10 Things WWE Stole From The Indies

The Summer Of Punk was great, but it wasn't WWE's creation.

CM Punk ROH Title
ROH

WWE's relationship with independent wrestling promotions has never been as interesting as it is today.

While Vince McMahon's promotion still go out of their way to no-sell many of their competitors' existences ('sup, Impact?), they've spent the last few years developing working relationships with several smaller companies. Former Ring Of Honor man Gabe Sapolsky's EVOLVE have provided WWE with a regular conveyor belt of talent since 2015, while British promotions ICW and PROGRESS continue working closely with the company, to the point where we may see both on the Network someday.

Despite this, WWE have always taken more from wrestling's lower reaches than they've given back, such is the nature of the business. WWE's indomitable market share means they're free to pilfer these promotions as they please, with no fear of repercussion, and they're as ruthless as ever in 2017.

While much of what happens on the sport's smaller stages isn't suited to mainstream audiences, plenty of it is. If WWE see something they like, they'll snatch it without second thought, and nothing's safe, whether it's a gimmick, storyline, or an entire promotion-wide concept.

Here are the fruits of their plundering.

10. The Usos' Gimmick

Briscoes Ring of Honor
rohwrestling.com

The Usos are one of the best things in WWE at the moment.

Turning heel in 2016 has transformed them from one of the promotion's stalest acts into company-wide highlights, with their new personalities absolutely pivotal to the resurgence. Once a set of bland, smiley babyfaces, they've been reborn through menace, violence, and unpredictability, with their manic call-and-response promo style unlike anything else in the company.

As unique as this is within WWE, however, the act should be more than a little familiar to anyone with their eye on the independent circuit. It's not a total ripoff, but there are plenty of similarities between The Usos' current personas and what Ring Of Honor legends The Briscoe Brothers were doing many moons ago, particularly when it comes to promos.

Jimmy & Jey obviously lack Jay & Mark's country-fried drawl, but there are times when it sounds like they're reading from an old Briscoes script, particularly when they get frenzied. Their attire, too, is remarkably similar to the Briscoes, though the ROH duo have undergone several image transformations since they last decked out in black tank tops.

This shouldn't detract from your enjoyment of The Usos, but their influences are clear.


9. CM Punk Vs. Raven

There are countless parallels between CM Punk's Ring Of Honor run and his late-career work in WWE. As great as he was on wrestling's biggest stage, WWE spent much of Punk's time there regurgitating old material from his independent days, including the feud with Raven that effectively launched the straight-edger to the top of the independent pile.

Kicking off in 2003, it saw Punk clash with the ECW veteran in a long series of bitter, violent encounters focused primarily on Raven's lifestyle. Punk was at his absolute preachiest, ripping into his foe's well documented history with drug and alcohol abuse, and ruthlessly belittling his every mistake. Things went well beyond PG too, with Punk going as far as crucifying Raven on a straight edge 'X' symbol after losing a bloody 30-minute cage match.

The feud eventually found its way to WWE television in 2009, when the company retold it with the troubled Jeff Hardy as the subject of Punk's rage. The story drew swathes of critical acclaim, and while its more personal elements had to be toned down for mainstream audiences, it remains one of WWE's greatest modern feuds.

Just remember where it came from.


8. Zayn & Owens: Trolls

Sami Zayn Kevin Owens
WWE

There's no more enjoyable act on WWE SmackDown than Sami Zayn and Kevin Owens at the moment.

The former's Hell In A Cell heel turn was a complete success, repositioning him as a slimy, sarcastic heel after years as a go-nowhere babyface, and his partner has been as compelling as ever. They're dynamite together, and while Zayn and Owens have only been reunited for a few weeks, their rebirth as SmackDown's alpha trolls should guarantee months of quality programming.

Zayn has been particularly trolly since the duo were put back together. He has become WWE's clown prince, sarcastically skipping, smiling, and dancing his way to the ring while his impossibly chirpy ska theme plays out, then constantly teasing opponents throughout the ensuing match. It's great, but it's nothing new.

The angle is a direct retread of the 'Troll Boyz' arc that recently played out in EVOLVE - one of WWE's closest independent allies. Much like Zayn and Owens, EVOLVE's Ethan Page and ACH were united through mistreatment from authority figures, dedicating their existence to disrupting shows, ruining everyone's fun, and straight up piss-taking. It came to a premature end when Page left the promotion last month, but the similarities are too numerous to be coincidental.


7. Stylistic Elements

Styles Cena Handshake
WWE.com

WWE are the most restrictive wrestling promotion on the planet. Their in-ring regulations are legion, and while many argue that this has created an overly homogenised environment that isn't conducive to producing great matches, it's all done in the name of safety.

This is at odds with the stereotypical spot-heavy indie style, which many still misinterpret as a psychology-less mess of high spots and big bumps, yet WWE have 'borrowed' countless independent tropes over the years, particularly in their main event scene.

WWE's standard 'epic match' format draws heavily from the independent bouts of old, with many now identical in their structure. Those John Cena vs. AJ Styles matches were incredible, but each concluded with an impossibly long sequence of finisher kickouts, with little transitional work in-between. Such layouts aren't alien to WWE, but they've definitely grown in prominence over the past few years, with this particular series standing among wrestling's greatest modern spotfests.

It goes deeper, though. NXT's TakeOver specials are almost entirely comprised of workrate-centric indie style matches, and so were tournaments like the Cruiserweight and Mae Young Classic. The indies' influence is growing, and while pure wrestling will never conquer the world of Sports Entertainment, WWE's stylistic shift is undeniable.


6. TJ Perkins' Gamer Gimmick

TJ Perkins Entrance
WWE Network

Few WWE Superstars have been as poorly used as TJ Perkins, who felt like a money-making babyface in the making after winning last summer's Cruiserweight Classic, but whose career went off a cliff as soon as he hit the main roster.

Much of this was down to the company's widescale burial of the 205lb division as a whole, but TJP was brutalised on a micro level too. Instead of letting Perkins be himself, WWE saddled him with a godawful gamer gimmick that saw him dress garishly, enter to what sounded like an old Sega Master System theme, and talk only in 'gamerspeak,' reciting lines like "you gotta level up, dude!" on a weekly basis.

The act was extremely similar to Kenny Omega's old gimmick. Long before he became the Bullet Club's 'Cleaner,' Omega himself was a 16-bit uber-geek who drew more influences from Mega Man and Street Fighter than his fellow wrestlers, but there's a key difference: Kenny made it work.

Omega's gamer persona was a perfect fit in Japan, where he made his name for promotions like DDT and AJPW while also building a sizeable cult following in the US, and he retains elements of it today. Perkins? He's lucky if he makes it to TV most weeks.


5. The Club

styles gallows anderson
WWE.com

Bullet Club are professional wrestling's hottest stable, so it's no surprise they caught WWE's attention a long time ago. They're a global phenomenon, and while it's unlikely that Vince McMahon's promotion will ever be able to bring the authentic BC to Raw and SmackDown, they've constantly tried to recreate the group's themes and motifs over the past few years.

It started in NXT, where 'Balor Club' came into existence soon after former BC leader Finn Balor joined the company, though the idea has never been another more than a t-shirt design. WWE took things a step further soon after signing AJ Styles, Karl Anderson, and Luke Gallows in January 2016, though. The ex-NJPW wrestlers were put together as 'The Club' soon after joining, and while their union was brief, it was a clear throwback to their days in wrestling's most popular stable.

Bullet Club is one of the sport's biggest brands. In constantly flirting with the stable, WWE are attempting to grab a slice of the hype for themselves, though it's unlikely they'll ever bring BC's full ensemble cast to the company. That won't stop them from cashing in, though.


4. Hordes Of Talent

bobby fish adam cole kyle o'reilly
WWE.com

WWE's signing policies have shifted dramatically over the past few years. The company still hire handfuls of inexperienced fitness models and former college football players, but in far smaller numbers. Now, the focus is on performers who've already built reputations and sharpened their skills on the sport's smaller stage, with much of their roster comprised of ex-indie stars.

Kevin Owens, Seth Rollins, AJ Styles, Sami Zayn, Dean Ambrose: they're all among WWE's major players, and each cut their teeth on the independent circuit before jumping into the mainstream. A huge portion of NXT's talent pool is comprised of independent veterans as well, with the likes of Adam Cole and Aleister Black poised to join WWE's next generation of main eventers.

The days when WWE's roster largely comprised of wrestlers built from scratch in the company's developmental system are dead and gone. Recent years have seen them 'steal' dozens of the indie scene's biggest names, and the practice continues, with former standouts Donovan Dijak and Lio Rush recently joining the company. Fortunately, wrestling's smaller stages have never been so stacked with talent, making it easy to rebuild when WWE inevitably swoop in and snag their top stars.


3. The Summer Of Punk

CM Punk's Pipe Bomb
WWE

Ask a pool of WWE fans about their favourite modern wrestling angles and most will mention the Summer Of Punk. It ended in Triple H-induced infamy, but the program's genesis felt like a real paradigm shift, with the protagonist's legendary 'Pipe Bomb' living on as one of wrestling's most memorable worked shoots. The Money In The Bank 2011 main event is a certified classic, and it's tragic that WWE decided to slay the angle with 'The Game' and Kevin Nash.

It felt fresh, new, and revolutionary, but it wasn't. The Summer Of Punk was not a unique storyline, but a retread of one that had already played out in Ring Of Honor six years prior, with WWE aping everything from the name to the overarching theme.

Much like the WWE version, the ROH story had Punk threatening to bring the promotion's top championship with him when he left the company. He spent weeks mocking his employers, and even went so far as to sign his WWE contract on the physical belt, and the company eventually brought Mick Foley in to show Punk the error of his ways.

The key difference is that Punk didn't actually leave with the ROH World Title, and instead dropped it to James Gibson on his way out. Still, WWE's version was the sequel, not the original.


2. Generation Nexus

Generation Next ROH
ROHWrestling.com

In May 2004, a rogue group of young, hungry wrestlers came together as a villainous faction, declaring war on Ring Of Honor's pre-existing hierarchy. The gang featured future WWE stars Austin Aries and Roderick Strong, and christened themselves 'Generation Next.' They attacked indiscriminately, destroying everyone from company staples in The Briscoe Brothers and Jimmy Rave to a bona fide wrestling legend in Ricky Steamboat as they took ROH over, quickly becoming the promotion's foremost heel force.

Sound familiar? It should, because Generation Next's rise was almost identical to that which The Nexus would experience in 2010.

The Nexus' arrival was more startling, and their methods more extreme, but the core idea was the same. Both groups were comprised of relative rookies unwilling to sit around and wait for a chance in their respective promotions, though their fortunes differed greatly.

John Cena eviscerated The Nexus at SummerSlam 2010, and killed leader Wade Barrett's hopes of ever becoming a true main eventer with a series of late-year burials. Meanwhile, Generation Next's Austin Aries had the honour of ending Samoa Joe's 21-month ROH Title reign in December 2004, and his group stayed strong throughout their run, before mutually disbanding in June 2006.


1. NXT

NXT Full Sail
WWE.com

WWE have rewritten the developmental rulebook with NXT.

No longer a mere finishing school, the system is now a viable brand in its own right, and a wrestling-centric island away from the main roster's tedious Sports Entertainment. NXT is the source of much of WWE's most visceral and exciting output. Its TakeOver events are always among the year's strongest, but while radically different from the rest of the company's output, NXT is little more than WWE's attempt at a super indie.

With few over-the-top stories, straightforward promos, an all-star cast, and a focus on wrestling above all else, NXT is presented almost exactly like prime ROH or PWG. It's Triple H's fantasy booking dream come to life, and while considerably glossier than any independent promotion could ever hope to be, WWE have largely succeeded in capturing the smaller stages' spirit with NXT.

This is nothing like the developmental territories of old. NXT is still a training ground, but putting on a good show is just as essential now. WWE have succeeded not by aping Raw and SmackDown, but successfully adapting dozens of indie traits for a wider audience, creating a product perfectly tailored to their hardcore fans' needs.


Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.