10 Things WWE Suddenly Wanted You To Care About (After Programming You To Hate Them)

In which Hulk Hogan ages backwards.

Baron Corbin
WWE.com

Vince McMahon is a creature of impulse.

He operates on a week-to-week basis in accordance with his whims. He has absolutely no regard for continuity, and expects you to fall in line. Think back to every dropped development of 2019. It is the Ultimate Thrill Ride.

Mojo Rawley used to look into a mirror, before being told that his Two out of Three Falls match has been cancelled at the last minute. That's not fair. Let's give Vince some credit: he is professional and prepared enough to complete the final draft of Monday Night RAW four minutes before it airs live. The Revival were presented as humiliated pissants, until Shane McMahon needed a couple of heaters, and so they were dressed in suits. We have deduced from the Robert Roode reinvention that Vince really likes a moustache...

...for six days.

Kevin Owens likes Sami Zayn, every now and then, and simply does not. Zayn doesn't turn on Owens subsequently because he has no interior life. He is a character who hates wrestling fans and blames them for everything. It's your fault WWE sucks. And Baron Corbin's, obviously. Such terrible, ratings-killing work must be punished! With a lengthy Universal Title programme!

2019 has accelerated this old mentality to a chaotic and fascinating extent, but it is as old as the man himself...

10. Women's Wrestling

Jerry Lawler Sable
WWE Network

In the early 2000s, women's wrestling in WWE was essentially a platform on which to put Jerry Lawler over on commentary.

The work put in by the women was incidental to everything. The "matches" were secondary to Lawler's riffing; if one of the women dared perform something remotely athletic, Lawler graded the move on his ability to see more of her body.

"Impressive big boot from Stacey Keibler," Jim Ross would say, putting over her flexibility.

"Yeah, and you can make out the crevice of her labia too, JR!" Lawler would say in response, in the process of an over-sexed meltdown.

This all changed, in 2015, after AJ Lee called out Stephanie McMahon's hypocrisy on Twitter. The Chief Brand Officer, maintaining that hypocrisy, subsequently put herself over as the new spokeswoman of the Women's Revolution initiated by her husband, Triple H. The NXT to main roster adaptation was awful, at first, and indicative of systemic attitudes: the women were positioned in cliques for purely aesthetic reasons, but after a time, the content levelled up with - and merited - the rhetoric.

That rhetoric was insufferable - "Thank you for no longer being perverts, and giving women a chance!" - but WWE is undoubtedly better for this PR initiative; the women's matches are often the most physical and most over on pay-per-view cards.


9. WCW

Booker T Buff Bagwell
WWE.com

'Dubya See Dubya', in everything down to the elitist, condescending pronunciation, was framed by the WWF as a hopelessly derivative, practically evil product enjoyed by rednecks.

A retirement home for old fogeys, WCW was the enemy - to such a gotten-to extent that DX once invaded Nitro on what most remember as a tank. It wasn't a tank, but the Mandela Effect conditioned by the WWF's rhetoric put that image in the minds of its loyal fans, who perceived Triple H et al. as Putin-adjacent all-conquering strongmen.

And then the WWF won the Monday Night War in 2001, secured WCW's assets for a paltry sum, and asked the Tacoma, Washington audience in the Pacific Northwest to buy into the idea of a RAW main event performed by two stars of the Atlanta-based league.

Booker T Vs. Buff Bagwell was a return to the Omni only in that it was an omni-disaster: the fans revolted at the mere notion of the match, and the match itself was a deeply basic layout piss-poorly worked. Bagwell, visibly pissed off, was on another wavelength to Booker, and seemed to remonstrate with the crowd not as a heel but as a man who knew the WWF has tried to f*ck on him.


8. Jinder Mahal

Jinder Mahal
WWE.com

Jinder Mahal was A) a basic and limited worker, B) known to WWE fans as an undercard also-ran, C) an actual undercard also-ran, a role reinforced just weeks before his bizarre main event push, but D) of Indian heritage, which was the pretext for said, bizarre main event push.

The problem with that push was A) Mahal was not cut out for a role WWE fans were given no reason to take seriously, B) WWE pay-per-views were at that point included within the Sony TEN deal at no additional cost, C) broadband speeds were then so poor in India that streaming hadn't arrived in the culture, meaning WWE was unable to monetise the push, and D) Mahal proved so unpopular in his ancestral homeland that WWE had to cancel a date on his big "homecoming" tour.

Mahal captured the WWE Heavyweight Championship under the thinnest of storytelling logic: SmackDown was the 'Land of Opportunity', and his lackeys enabled him to grasp his - but the storyline alienated domestic fans and didn't much excite the targeted demographic, the targeting of which wasn't thought through at all.

???????

Profit.


7. Curtis Axel

Curtis Axel Intercontinental Title
WWE.com

May 20, 2013, was the moment.

Starting that moment, from now, from that moment on, that was the moment, starting then, of the genesis of Curtis Axel, who WWE very ambitiously asked you to receive as a main event act from out of nowhere.

But you see, at that moment, the performer had changed his name. He was a new man, starting from that moment on, a man who, by adopting variations of his father and grandfather's names, was suddenly as good as they were!

Perfect!

Except it wasn't perfect, because the pitch so sudden and inelegant and insulting that nobody bought it. In a real careful-what-you-wish-for indictment of fan-casting, simply 'make Paul Heyman his mouthpiece!' did not work, in part because Triple H did such a sh*tty job of putting him over. Triple H had endured such a pounding at the hands of Brock Lesnar that he really shouldn't have taken the match. But, by God, you don't just chickensh*t out of a predetermined match. And it doesn't matter if your knee hurts so much that it has reduced you to tears. Triple H fought through a pec tear in Saudi Arabia, so you'll take that year on the shelf and f*cking like it. And trust Triple H to frame an uncommitted act of politicking as something heroic, Jesus wept.

The guy looked like he'd suffered sunstroke, which was the closest thing the dud Axel character ever got to heat.


6. Baron Corbin

Baron Corbin Raw Roster
WWE.com
"Under your leadership, Monday Night RAW has sucked. It has sucked because of you. That roster, that locker room back there, that is some of the most talented men and women that Monday Night RAW has ever seen, and you've got no idea what to do with it. This whole Baron Corbin experience has been an abject failure."

Seth Rollins, Monday Night RAW, December 10, 2018

The message was just about coded: Yes, we've pushed Baron Corbin well beyond whatever connection he may have with the audience, his featured role has proved very unpopular, and this is our (deeply weird) way of conveying that to you all.

Rollins captured the Universal Title from Brock Lesnar a few months later at WrestleMania 35. Which talented man or woman in that locker room did WWE have an idea of as Rollins' major rival in the late spring months?

Baron Corbin.

Predictably, the programme was met with derision or at best apathy, as was WWE's decision to have Corbin retire Kurt Angle at WrestleMania. Chronically ineffective heel heat - Corbin was the embodiment of the Lionel Hutz 'There's heat, and there's heat' meme - this cooled Rollins as a babyface to such an extent that he misinterpreted the online reaction and turned himself heel.

Hey, little buddy! That was presumptuous of you.


5. Survivor Series

survivor series 2016
WWE.com

"We think Survivor Series is obsolete," Vince McMahon told investors on a 2010 conference call. "It worked many, many years ago. It was one of the original four, but it's outlasted its usage," he said, justifying its year-to-year plunge of 26.3%.

Vince only hastily dreamed up the concept (imported from Japan) as a last-ditch measure to remove Jim Crockett Promotions from the pay-per-view arena. And he was right: the event had lost its lustre. The episodic TV model had weakened the novelty of seeing name stars collide without stakes, and many of the traditional tag matches were glorified exhibitions that were not elevated by careful, shared universe storytelling nor any sequential purpose. WWE aimed to phase the event out, but the failure of Bragging Rights put paid to it.

WWE is still asking the public to care about the retooled version of the pay-per-view that is indebted to the Bragging Rights brand warfare concept. Every November, all of a sudden, the stars of each show begin to show a bit of pride. The stars of RAW and SmackDown compete head-to-head every week in 2019, but an October draft may yet ask a great deal of the Universe.

"I've only been on SmackDown for a month, but let me tell ya: it's way better than RAW, which sucks!"


4. Goldberg

Goldberg's RAW Return
WWE.com

WWE ruthlessly re-conditioned the audience when debuting Goldberg in 2003.

The intense, smash-mouth destroyer of WCW was gone, replaced by a wrestler who sold and sold before the comeback in a betrayal of his essence as a performer. The old Goldberg was such a wrecking machine that he didn't even need to mount a comeback; there was no coming back after being broken in half after his spear.

As the years receded from 2004, company rhetoric painted Goldberg as a one hit wonder. Triple H, speaking to SBNation on the WrestleMania XXVII hype train, referred to him as a "hodge-podge" guy. He wasn't even asked about Goldberg; he was asked who he enjoyed working with, and claimed Goldberg was somebody he couldn't have a "classic" with, and it's strange. Goldberg has a nice, hardened ass. It's almost as if Trips provides different, contradictory reasons for burying guys that threaten his spot!

"Bill's trying to get into the Hall of Fame," Triple H continued. "If there's a rumour about him coming back, he probably started it."

As those years receded, and WWE failed to replace the top stars, Goldberg was welcomed back into the fold in 2016. WWE reimagined him as a Hall of Fame headliner by...

...booking him as the intense, smash-mouth destroyer of WCW.


3. Hulk Hogan

Hulk Hogan Wrestlemania 30
WWE.com

Hulk Hogan: an old, incontinent, dementia-riddled bastard in 1996, but a timeless legend in 2002.

Did he age backwards? Or is Vince McMahon full of sh*t?

Hogan was crucified in those infamous Billionaire Ted skits. For a modern analogy, were Hogan to sign with AEW in 2019, WWE would Photoshop his head in a Klan hood and broadcast it on the Titantron. Hogan was a guy who no longer had to worry about passing a piss test for steroids, and yet his steroid-fuelled body still couldn't pull off a move as "extremely impressive" as the Razor's Edge. This bit them on the ass a few months later, at which point Scott Hall suddenly aged by a decade and a half.

This farcical, rotten PR drive didn't inform the marketing of Hogan's babyface run six years later, but it was immaculate, all the same: Hogan was reimagined as a living fixture on wrestling's Mount Rushmore, an actual legend we were privileged to see on his last ride.

It was an expert strike of the iron, but it wasn't necessary: the nostalgic euphoria that swept through the SkyDome confirmed that the skits never did work: Hogan wasn't just the right gay-guy, at the right time.


2. Ultimate Warrior

The Self-Destruction of the Ultimate Warrior
WWE

The Self-Destruction of the Ultimate Warrior DVD was an outrageous exercise in burying the legacy of a former talent. Usually, the BioDVD was aimed at the fans of a performer who wished to celebrate the triumphs of their career. This was instead catered to everybody who thought the Warrior was a callous piece of sh*t.

A long-form Vice article adapted to video, the content was astonishing.

Warrior was essentially framed as a demented, inarticulate egotist who was impossible to work with. He only hailed from Parts Unknown, said a very much justified Bobby Heenan, because "he was too stupid to remember where he was from". Heenan and Ted DiBiase claimed Warrior didn't appreciate the business. Triple H said Warrior "ruined the experience" of his first WrestleMania, which might have inspired him to go long against all reason virtually every subsequent time.

Reduced, Warrior's career was a total aberration that you, I, we were all as crazy as he was for enjoying. He couldn't work and his promos were asinine. Warrior only got over because little kids - each and every one of you - are stupid and undiscerning.

Until there was money to be made from his Hall of Fame induction, at which point Warrior was suddenly an electric, energetic megastar once again.


1. Independent Wrestling

ROH Ring of Honor Final Battle
www.rohwrestling.com

When WWE debuted Daniel Bryan in WWE, in 2010, his background was used as a shovel with which to bury him.

The monopoly, historically adverse to putting over anything created beyond itself, referred to Ring Of Honor et al. under the amorphous "Indy" pejorative, instructing the audience that Bryan had performed for "50" people in "high school gyms", and the only people interested in him were his fellow "tweetin', bloggin'" dirtsheet-obsessed nerds.

Meanwhile, everybody was left to infer that Wade Barrett et al. had simply arrived, fully-formed and WWE-ready, from some sort of laboratory. That laboratory was Florida Championship Wrestling, a sub-company that was essentially kept secret in WWE canon, and with sound reasoning: high school gyms at least have bleachers. The glorified warehouse of FCW was all empty seats and WWE-lite action, but the students were learning the 'WWE way', and that was paramount.

Until the model ceased to function effectively, and WWE was forced to acknowledge a strong Indy background as a reason to take the stars of the retooled NXT seriously. When the latest star recruits were captured on camera at TakeOver events, WWE couldn't exactly bury them. '[X] is from Japan!' commentary would state emphatically, as if that mattered all of a sudden.

Now, the tedious grapple-f*ck stylings of EVOLVE is presented as a proving ground, hilariously, because it was used to counter-programme AEW.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!