10 Things WWE Wants You To Forget About 2023

Triple H learned everything he knows from Vince McMahon...

Austin Theory fail
WWE

Cast your mind back to the summer of 2019.

Roman Reigns had been "brutally" attacked backstage by somebody who bore a striking resemblance to Erick Rowan. Daniel Bryan, assuring Roman that this was not the case, declared that an Erick Rowan doppelgänger was responsible. What a terrible babyface Roman was. By not immediately kicking the tar out of Bryan, Rowan and his body double, the implication was that he entertained the most convenient explanation imaginable.

Fast-forward to this year's Backlash, and the most internationally famous musical artist in the world, the cool and critically adored Bad Bunny, arrived for his match to the sounds of his own song 'Chambea'. In Puerto Rico, on May 6, 2023, WWE felt like the most spectacular, on-trend entertainment medium on the globe.

That about sums up the drastic, inconceivable transformation WWE underwent between the exit of Vince McMahon and installation of Triple H as head booker in 2022.

WWE is selling out almost everywhere they go. The ratings defy wider TV trends. And, after a long while even under Triple H, the enthused fans in those buildings have re-learned how to make noise.

But how drastic was that transformation really?

10. The Boring B-Level PLEs

LA Knight The Miz
WWE.com

WWE has developed a rule in this 'Papa H' era: the international B-level Premium Live Events are outstanding or at least elevated by an intoxicating atmosphere, and the domestic editions are solid in the most uninspiring, missable way.

The Payback and Fastlane two-punch combo didn't rock anybody. The shows acted as confirmation that a certain annual Vince McMahon tradition will be maintained under Paul Levesque: WWE will enter a bland period of syndication between SummerSlam and Survivor Series.

Because wrestling is by default generically good in 2023 - you'll rarely see anything that is actively terrible, often in a very amusing way - neither show was technically "bad". Each boasted a cracking Undisputed Tag Team title match, complete with a title change, but that was the extent of the true quality and real importance. Actually, Becky Lynch and Trish Stratus over-delivered at Payback, even if their inspired Steel Cage match didn't need such a long, miserable build.

Elsewhere, the bell rang on LA Knight, Raquel Rodriguez bombed so hard that only a turn might save her, and while Fastlane was moderately better, it offered little new nor must-see. It was a WWE TV show without the ads.

Even Money In The Bank - which somehow contrived to promote a merely fine GUNTHER match - was rescued by the white-hot last 10 minutes of the all-Bloodline tag team headliner.


9. The Launch Of The World Heavyweight Title

Triple H
WWE.com

Triple H had a great year in 2023 - he was right to be smug and defiant in the aftermath of WrestleMania 39 - but he had a nightmare when introducing the World Heavyweight title back in April.

A few weeks after shaking the hand of Roman Reigns on the Raw after WrestleMania - a visual endorsement - Triple H explained that the Undisputed WWE Universal title situation was good for Roman Reigns, who he had endorsed, but not "good for WWE". Roman had taken WWE for a ride, in effect, and since nobody was good enough to beat him, the also-rans needed something to fight over. This was the actual canonical thought process behind launching the new title.

Moreover, Triple H's explanation also posed questions over WWE's creative process in retrospect. If WWE did not endorse Roman's conduct as champion, and indeed resented his chokehold over the title scene in his capacity as a part-time attraction, why didn't the company take measures - fair measures - to prevent that from happening?

Surely, WWE should have stipulated - at some point over the prior year - that Roman were to lose the belts in the event that the Bloodline interfered in his matches.

WWE, in order to get that logo front and centre, didn't score the easy tap-in by bringing back the 'Big Gold Belt' nor its worthy enough 2000s lineage. The new design was ugly, like somebody had taken a big embossed dump on an elegant design, which hardly helped.

If nothing else, HHH set the tone...


8. The World Heavyweight Title, General

Seth Rollins
WWE.com

WWE established that the World Heavyweight title was the lesser World title in its own canon, which was suboptimal.

Even less than ideal was the fact that the attempt to establish a prominent title defended regularly in matches that aimed for greatness was undermined - and that is because GUNTHER perfected that role as the Intercontinental champion.

His reign was incredible. Balancing invincibility and vulnerability, he was the perfect champion; capable of retaining his aura and generating rich drama at the same time, his outstanding matches against Chad Gable, Kevin Owens, and Drew McIntyre and Sheamus absolutely smoked Seth Rollins' body of work.

Seth hardly worked bad matches, but not one of his World Heavyweight title defences will remotely trouble any Match of the Year lists. That was the aim, too. Rollins was better as a bit of an obnoxious, extravagantly-dressed clown. His transformation into an earnest "workhorse" type was a regression back to 2019. Back then, he worked some of the best matches in WWE, but was outclassed by his peers on the international stage.

In 2023, he didn't even work the best matches in WWE - his first PLE matches with Finn Bálor and Shinsuke Nakamura were unacceptably "mid" - which undermined the prestige of the belt he carried.


7. SummerSlam

WWE SummerSlam 2023 The Usos Jimmy Jey
WWE.com

SummerSlam was a disappointing major show with a brutally dull main event - an event to forget for both WWE and its fanbase, since they'd rather you fill stadiums at least three times per year.

A major stadium show is meant to feel epic, spectacular, bold. A major stadium show is meant to make you curse the fact that you didn't buy a ticket or even fork out for an expensive travel package.

SummerSlam 2023 was not that.

Two attractions while very good to great - Seth Rollins Vs. Finn Bálor and Cody Rhodes Vs. Brock Lesnar - were rematches from B-level PLEs, lending the show a familiar vibe. Shayna Baszler didn't get much of a rub from a departing Ronda Rousey in a miscalculated 'MMA Rules' match, which was a poor idea for the broad stadium setting under ideal circumstances. The match was a boring version of a style that the WWE base isn't enthusiastic about.

GUNTHER Vs. Drew McIntyre was good, but disappointing. It wasn't dissimilar in quality to a televised GUNTHER match. The GUNTHER TV match is very good at a minimum, but on a Big 4 show, true greatness is the ceiling. Logan Paul Vs. Ricochet and Asuka Vs. Bianca Belair Vs. Charlotte Flair were good, but also felt a bit long.

The main event was an interminable parody of a big Roman Reigns match - a whole load of absolutely nothing for 25 whole minutes before the obligatory shenanigans. Jimmy Uso turned on his brother, and before he displayed some decent comedic chops in October, it felt for a while like the cherished 'Saga' had become 1999 nWo.


6. The Lack Of A Youth Movement

LA Knight Roman Reigns
WWE.com

Roman Reigns is 38. Cody Rhodes is also 38. Roman might never return in a full-time capacity, and while Cody no longer speaks in absolutes, he is more capricious than his top WWE guy predecessors.

Seth Rollins is 37, has done everything there is to do in WWE, and isn't the physical specimen he once was. LA Knight is 41. He's over to an absurd degree, but he's not going to get much better in the ring at this point. Damian Priest won the Money In The Bank briefcase, ostensibly casting him as the next WWE main event hope. He's 41, too. Judgment Day stablemate Finn Bálor is a year older. Drew McIntyre is 38. Sheamus is 45. Bobby Lashley is (an albeit inexplicable) 47. AJ Styles, if he's even a top star these days, is 46.

Charlotte Flair is 37. Becky Lynch is 36. Bianca Belair, at 34, has just entered her wrestler's prime.

That realistically leaves just Rhea Ripley, at 27, who has a decade of a top run ahead of her. Every other prominent WWE star is closer to the end than the beginning. This is when the wrestler masters the full range of the form, generally - but it's also when the injuries start to pile up.

Solo Sikoa and Dominik Mysterio haven't done enough to suggest they truly have the stuff to headline consistently. WWE don't seem to know what they have with Montez Ford.

NXT is intent on telling you that Bron Breakker and Carmelo Hayes are the next two recurring WrestleMania headliners, but they don't have amazing hit rates. Their chemistry together is weak, too, undermining the idea of an Austin Vs. Rock-style legacy feud.

WWE is popping bottles in the present. The future however could be a lot brighter.

The women in NXT are the crack of light in a greying sky - Tiffany Stratton and Lola Vice are both tremendous for their level of experience - and the Creeds are proof of concept that the NIL programme could see WWE finally make the Performance Center worthwhile. It's a bit early to tell still.

Austin Theory is just 26...but...


5. The Failed Austin Theory Push

Austin Theory
WWE.com

WWE is a strange promotion still. Their idea to build a new star is to have old stars kick the hell out of them and call them worse than dirt.

This was the "arc" of Austin Theory in 2023, and it did not go well.

He defeated John Cena at WrestleMania 39 in a lifeless anti-rub of a match. Imagine the exact opposite of Mick Foley's hard, selfless work in putting Triple H, Randy Orton and Edge over, and you are still not close to how apathetic it all was.

Theory continued his endless programme with Bobby Lashley in the spring, which was inessential filler that just existed. Tasked with getting himself over on commentary, he was a bland automaton completely lost without the scripts he can orate well enough. None of his TV matches met the standard of the 2023 back-and-forth, and he offered nothing new, either. He worked his three-star special - mechanically tight, utterly soulless - against Rey Mysterio at Payback. Theory's push in general was anti-show, don't tell. He just didn't captivate people or do anything that got them in the gut.

He was better when paired with Grayson Waller deeper in the year, but doing obnoxious prelim heel work is hardly something that positions him as the next face of the company.


4. Gable Steveson Being Rubbish

Gable Steveson
WWE

As mentioned, the Creed Brothers are proof of concept for the NIL programme. They are absolute studs, monster hybrid athletes, and they radiate an intense meathead charm.

Hurrah!

WWE has finally worked out a way of building their own talent in-house through the scouting and recruitment of unreal collegiate specimens.

The thing is, Gable Steveson's pitiful debut at the Great American Bash underscored the other side of the high-level athlete. These people have spent every waking hour of their lives in the pursuit of achievement. They train relentlessly. They sacrifice their social lives to this end, and many are pushed into it by their guardians from a frighteningly young age.

The byproduct of this is a Gable Steveson: a man so utterly tedious and devoid of personality that, were you ever trapped in conversation with him, you'd pinch your thigh through your pocket just to feel anything other than the searingly intense feeling of wanderlust into literally any other room on the planet.

Steveson was both piss-poor investment and, potentially, a bad omen of the type of person WWE is almost exclusively scouting. The Creeds are great, but most precocious athletes are Michael Owen.

Gable Steveson can throw a suplex, but he was an amateur wrestler: that's like praising a baker for their ability to knead dough.


3. The Women's World Tag Team Title Scene

WWE Money in the Bank 2023 Liv Morgan Raquel Rodriguez
WWE.com

The Women's World Tag Team titles have never once developed an aura of prestige. Creative cares nothing for them, and this attitude filters down to the fandom. They simply exist.

While Chelsea Green is an entertaining act with an excellent grasp of her lightweight material, her Honky Tonk Man-adjacent run with the titles is a vehicle for her character. This development is far more interesting than watching a pair of babyfaces suddenly become best friends ecstatic to be in one another's presence, but it will further stigmatise the titles as a joke. That's not really a fair point; the rot set in a long, long time ago. At least Chelsea and Piper Niven offer a different dynamic than Rodriguez, who has more random mates than 90% of the AEW roster.

Has WWE ever promoted one memorably great match for the belts?

There's an easy solution to this; WWE should permanently transfer the titles to NXT, which promotes more women's wrestling than either main roster brand.

Parity and representation are good things, but the belts are a hollow exercise in optics that drastically undermine the point WWE is pretending to make.


2. How Uninteresting Much Of It Was

The Judgment Day Raw
WWE.com

One more quick note on the Creeds: their main roster debut was incredible in and of itself, but it worked also as a result of WWE's discipline elsewhere.

After learning the lesson of his rehiring spree - in which multiple wrestlers, few of them interesting, were brought back in late 2022 to diminishing returns - Triple H instead set about working with what he had, mostly.

The Creeds, Dragon Lee, Zoey Stark, Cameron Grimes, Grayson Waller and JD McDonagh were promoted from NXT, and Bad Bunny, Logan Paul and Brock Lesnar worked part-time (as did the Undisputed WWE Universal champion), but each debut was spaced out. An impact was made at least half the time.

The effect of this disciplined approach was felt on multiple episodes of WWE Raw, since it seemed like members of the Judgment Day wrestled combinations of Cody Rhodes, Kevin Owens and Sami Zayn every single week. That wasn't even a feeling, or hyperbole: it was literally true for months and months on end.

WWE was coherent, popular, and on top in 2023 - but it was never the most exciting promotion, and rarely did it generate much discussion. They didn't do much in the way of radical booking. The in-ring style was still a bit homogenised.

Triple H does not do water cooler television, and this, more than any single catastrophic error, could prove to be the undoing of this era of resurgence over time.


1. Padding It All Out

Becky Lynch Trish Stratus
WWE.com

Triple H was defiant and adamant, at the post-WrestleMania press conference, that the story is never finished and that the next chapter was worth sticking around for.

He was right.

While the Bloodline saga would have been more dramatically effective had Roman lost the top belt - suddenly deciding to be the tag team specialist would have made more sense of his split from Jey Uso - Paul Heyman et al. plotted the thing out beautifully until SummerSlam. Cody proved his staying power throughout the year, too. Subjectively, he should have won the title at WrestleMania - but when a company as massive as WWE elects its next top babyface, they need to be absolutely sure.

Still, the finish in Los Angeles was very poorly received, and it echoed the cynicism of the old regime. The same thing happened at SummerSlam; the twang of realisation that WWE would rather pad things out than move storylines forward with a bold sense of momentum.

The Cody Rhodes Vs. Brock Lesnar programme was a very good version of WWE's boilerplate trilogy, in which the first two matches don't count. Seth Rollins worked his two main rivals twice on major shows. Becky Lynch and Trish Stratus feuded endlessly.

WWE was a bit...bare minimum and brazen with it in 2023, suggesting that this period is propelled by the relief of Vince McMahon's departure than something wholly captivating on its own terms.

Can it last, is the question.

WWE isn't doing something that seems destined to date - Triple H is doing the basics, and doing them very well - but if the promotion needs a jolt of electricity next year, is he the man to provide it?


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!