10 Things WWE Wants You To Forget About Kaitlyn
Hey, remember when NXT totally sucked? Kaitlyn does...
After a four year stint away from the promotion, former WWE Divas Champion Celeste "Kaitlyn" Bonin will return to the spotlight as part of the second Mae Young Classic tournament this August. She's a more important addition to the Network special than you might think.
Not only did she boast perhaps the most Diva-riffic entrance theme of all time (admit it, you're jamming along), but Kaitlyn also held the Divas Title for 153 days. To put that into perspective, her reign is the seventh longest in the belt's lineage, and even means Kaitlyn beats out higher-profile women like Kelly Kelly, Paige and Mickie James on the list.
Why then is Kaitlyn's career one WWE would probably like newer fans doing a quick Google search to skip on?
Three words: NXT, romance and addiction. All of those have played a major role in Kaitlyn's wrestling career and life away from the ring. Bikini contests, a relic from WWE's fascination with using women as mere eye candy, storylines they couldn't even be bothered to show and the up-and-down lifestyle of Celeste Bonin all mean she's a rather controversial subject.
This comeback is about redemption, both personal and professional...
10. Her 2010 Debut Was A Bikini Contest
Time for a quick game of "Spot The Star".
Pictured above, we have current SmackDown star Naomi, ex-WWE Women's Champ Melina, Brandi Rhodes, AJ Lee and other assorted Divas. Amidst all the fun is Kaitlyn, and she's fresh off flaunting her body for FCW fans during one of those WWE bikini contests typical of the time.
This one actually took place in 2011, but Kaitlyn's grand WWE debut the prior year had been under similar circumstances. Yes, WWE were less concerned with how sound a female worker's in-ring skills were and more impressed by how they looked in itsy-bitsy swimwear. That was a Divas lot seven or eight years ago.
The fact Kaitlyn's first role in the promotion was to cavort around in her smalls is unlikely to come up when WWE discuss her history pre-match at the Mae Young Classic.
9. Kaitlyn Was Part Of NXT Season Three...
The original concept for NXT was rather solid (assuming one could stomach the flawed mentor idea, unnecessary reality TV elements or Michael Cole's counter-productive commentary). It was a platform to introduce fresh faces in bulk, and it gave those newcomers the chance to work in front of larger crowds.
It's just a shame the wheels had fallen off the wagon come Season Three. In fact, scratch that. The wheels had come off, and the wagon had tumbled down a nearby cliff before catching fire and exploding into a scorching blaze. In other words, NXT Season Three flat out sucked.
Kaitlyn, along with future favourites AJ Lee and Naomi, was unfortunately part of it despite having more talent than the show suggested.
Forced to engage in embarrassing skits, like kissing Hornswoggle, and generally looking like she had no idea what she was doing, Kaitlyn also wasn't helped by WWE's decision to move the season from SyFy to WWE.com mid-way through. It seems even they knew it was tanking hard.
8. ... And She Wasn't Even First Choice
Making things worse, Kaitlyn wasn't actually supposed to be part of NXT's third season at first.
No, near seven foot giant Aloisia was originally earmarked as Vickie Guerrero's "Rookie Diva" for the show, and she would've become the tallest woman ever to work for WWE. When apparent nude photos surfaced of her online, the company pulled Aloisia from the gig and replaced her with, you guessed it, Kaitlyn.
The main problem here was that WWE had already announced Aloisia on TV and spent time building her up as a firm favourite for the competition. Kaitlyn, by comparison, stood around 5'5" and didn't quite have the unique appeal her predecessor did. At the time, her arrival was treated like a disappointment.
To recap, poor Kaitlyn was part of a dying concept, had to deal with audiences who neither cared about the faux-reality game show vibe or her character, and she wasn't presented as Vickie's first choice for the role anyway.
No wonder this sh*t flopped.
7. That NXT Match With Maxine
If you've never clapped eyes on the 19 October 2010 episode of NXT, then now is the time to see why Kaitlyn vs. Maxine must be considered one of the worst WWE matches of all time.
Firstly, someone had the bright idea that "Pros" Vickie Guerrero and Alicia Fox should have microphones, allowing them to talk incessantly during the match. That rendered Michael Cole and Josh Mathews meaningless at ringside, and it led to asinine lines like Vickie crying out that Maxine's attacks would ruin Kaitlyn's sweatshirt.
It (somehow) got worse. A mind-numbing series of rest holds were hilariously accompanied by WWE's decision to run a reminder for that Sunday's Bragging Rights pay-per-view on the bottom of the screen. Meanwhile, the live crowd sat on their hands wondering what the hell was going on.
Seriously, this is essential viewing for anyone who gets a kick out of awkward silences, WWE shooting themselves in the foot or bad wrestling. The whole ordeal was a horrible five-minute reminder that neither woman was properly trained, the show was a dud and women's wrestling was, internally at least, viewed as pointless.
6. "The Chickbusters" Weren't Over At All
Following her hollow NXT Season Three triumph, Kaitlyn was moved to SmackDown and formed an alliance with fellow rookie AJ Lee. The pair were managed by Natalya, dubbed "The Chickbusters" and were notable only for smiling during entrances and appearing out of their depth against seasoned veterans like Beth Phoenix.
If it isn't becoming crystal clear just by reading that, then let's spell it out: this was a very poor period for women's wrestling in WWE.
The Chickbusters gimmick wasn't one fans particularly cared about; everyone could see that Natalya was going to ditch her proteges ASAP, and the eventual turn was greeted with cheers because people were happy to see Nattie and Phoenix align as the "Divas Of Doom". They were more popular, and fans were chuffed to see deserving workers get more screen time.
On the flip side, Kaitlyn and AJ continued to drown in mediocrity, and it'd be a while before either woman was taken seriously by creative as more than a smiling newbie. They just weren't over.
5. Her Heel Turn Was Cut By WWE
AJ Lee came into her own in 2012 as a vindictive so-and-so who used the roster's sense of male entitlement against them. It was a killer gimmick, one she played to the hilt. Things would have been extremely different though had WWE stuck to their guns and rolled with early plans to have Kaitlyn turn heel on AJ.
The company even went so far as to tape the turn (on 6 December) for the 9 December 2011 episode of SmackDown.
Following another loss, Kaitlyn flipped on Lee, beat her up and then joined forces with Natalya and Beth Phoenix. That segment was never shown on TV, either because WWE believed it sucked or due to time constraints, and WWE didn't bother to try again. They just scrapped the idea completely and moved on.
When fans next saw Kaitlyn, she was back on NXT as part of the show's fifth season (Redemption) and rekindling her feud with Maxine. Later, she restarted the rivalry against AJ, but there was a twist: Lee was the heel, not Kaitlyn.
4. Her Run Was Bogged Down By Romantic Nonsense
As bad as the current angle between Bayley and Sasha Banks is on Raw today, at least they're feuding with each other and not warring over some dude. In ye olden times, WWE's Divas weren't quite so lucky. Nah, they had to suffer through endless romantic storylines that had them playing damsel in distress or cheating harlot.
Kaitlyn was no different. Her natural role as a strong, independent body-builder who didn't need men to complete her life was constantly undermined by WWE's own over-reliance on lovey-dovey soap opera stories. In just four years on the roster, Kaitlyn was romantically linked with Derrick Bateman, Cody Rhodes (briefly) and Big E.
Exactly none of those relationships helped get her over.
The Big E one, in particular, was the pits. After being suckered in by E's advances as a "secret admirer", only to find out that ex-pal AJ Lee was behind the ruse, Kaitlyn looked like a moron rather than a lovestruck heroine. This is one WWE trope everybody should be glad to see the back of these days.
3. The Diva Era Killed Her In-Ring Potential
Watch Kaitlyn's effort against Maxine on NXT in 2010 and then her blistering match with AJ Lee at Payback 2013 back-to-back and it's night and day. In less than three years, she had gone from awkward rookie to self-assured ass-kicker, and her match against AJ still stands the test of time five years on.
It's every bit as valid as anything WWE's "female revolution" throws up in 2018.
Kaitlyn and AJ obviously had something to prove with the match. They were handed over 10 minutes (an abnormal decision for WWE back then), had an intriguing story going in and believably pasted the crap out of one another come bell time. It was a total winner, had the crowd invested and remains the best match of Kaitlyn's entire career.
Revisiting it makes one wonder how much more she could have done without the distracting Diva nonsense, short multi-woman matches or focus on looks over in-ring work. Perhaps that's something Kaitlyn herself wants to prove during her WWE comeback this August.
2. She Walked Away From WWE On Her Own Terms
When Kaitlyn left WWE behind in January 2014, it wasn't the promotion's decision.
Keen to see what else was out there, return to the fitness industry and launch her own clothing line, Kaitlyn made the call to terminate her WWE deal and walk away. In short, she left pro wrestling's biggest company on her own terms, not because the writing team had nothing for her or due to WWE's willingness to move on.
Kaitlyn must also be proud that she (professionally, at least) hasn't suffered since stepping out of the WWE spotlight. Her clothing company, Celestial Bodiez, became a passion, and she's also ventured into other businesses like motivational speaking and running a smoothie bar with her ex-husband.
Now her life has led her back to wrestling, Kaitlyn is once again in charge. She didn't necessarily need a WWE comeback in 2018, but a renewed desire to return to the ring has re-opened old doors. It's on her own terms, and that's something Kaitlyn must be satisfied with.
1. Drug & Alcohol Addictions Almost Killed Her
That WWE comeback nearly never happened.
In late-2016, Kaitlyn's life had spiralled into a mess of drugs and alcohol. She entered rehab to kick old habits, only to find that booze was an easy way to deal with depression and anxiety. In an interview with The Sun, she admitted that she "wanted to die" when celebrating her 30th birthday.
This isn't something WWE will want to openly discuss when hyping up her imminent return for the second Mae Young Classic special. The promotion consider themselves a family friendly outfit who bend over backwards to appease major shareholders and corporate sponsors. Talk of talent almost dying due to rampant drug abuse is hardly fun.
Thankfully, Kaitlyn is in a much better place mentally than she was a few years ago. It's brave of somebody in the public limelight to be so candid about their problems too, especially when they're about to make a grand return to WWE.
Go get 'em, girl.
-
What else do you think WWE would want people to forget about Kaitlyn? Let us know down in the comments section below!