10 Things You Didn't Know About WWE In 1991
The Attitude Era predated the New Generation era... sort of.
What are your memories of the year 1991?
There's a good chance that you were young enough to remember it fondly, since you were likely young, naive, and basking in the glow of the spectacle of it all.
You will remember feeling pure elation as Randy Savage and Miss Elizabeth reunited at WrestleMania in one of the most powerful moments in the history of the company. The angle was so well-paced and performed with such warm emotion in and of itself that this writer, who had WrestleMania VII before most other Silver Vision tapes, bawled like a mewling infant with zero context of the Mega Powers Explode angle. Arguably, this was the very vision of sports entertainment perfected.
You will remember Bret Hart and Mr. Perfect's technical masterclass at SummerSlam, because that match set the very template of your fandom. You persisted with and fell in love with the form as a result of Hart's brilliance. He didn't flog many VHS covers, but he is responsible for the fraying tape caused by overuse.
You will remember Randy Savage's arm getting gnawed off by a shoot cobra - but you might not recall the sheer extent with which the WWF went heavy heat mad in one of its most controversial years ever...
10. A Sign Of The Times, An Omen For The Future
You might have wondered, on more than one occasion, why WrestleMania VIII was not headlined by Hulk Hogan Vs. Ric Flair.
It felt like the biggest match not just in the WWF, but in all of pro wrestling. Hogan and Flair were the respective Aces of the WWF and the NWA. It was inconceivable that they'd ever lock-up, since they embodied the values of each promotion. Hogan was the über-muscled broad superhero, Flair the elegant, technically immaculate cardio machine.
And yet, through Jim Herd's idiocy, the dream match was made possible - but the reality of 1991 explains why it did not happen in 1992.
In a trivia note, Hogan and Flair actually worked their first match, unadvertised, on an impromptu basis. In Dayton, Ohio, on October 22, Hogan replaced Roddy Piper. Hogan and Flair did the post-TV taping dark match on a whim, thinking it was a good idea to feel one another out in the ring before taking their show on the road.
You may have read that the programme didn’t, for whatever reason, connect with the public to the level anticipated - but you might be surprised at how early the thing failed to ignite.
The very first advertised Hogan Vs. Flair match took place on October 25, 1991 at the Oakland Coliseum. Their main event drew 13,400, but did not set a record for pro wrestling nor sell out the building's capacity.
9. WWE Experimented With Attitude Much Earlier Than You Thought
The WWF was - ironically - a squeaky clean fictional outfit that presented nice morality plays with an upstanding hero as the leading man.
That was until that business model failed, and since it was only ever a business model, a slice of Reagan's '80s superman theatre, Vince happened upon a new one (about five years later than broader pop culture and only when Paul Heyman revolutionised the tone of US pro wrestling).
In December 1997, Vince McMahon ushered in the era of Attitude, and for the next three and a half years or so, the WWF was swarming with exposed skin and misogyny.
Incredibly, given that the WWF of 1991 was a parody of the American hero's quest for justice, a premonition of Attitude unfolded on the house show circuit between the Royal Rumble and WrestleMania. As the Ultimate Warrior Vs. Sgt. Slaughter series was prolonged, to send the crowd home happy*, Warrior lost, but fans were granted "catharsis" when Sensational Sherri was hung upside down from a steel cage, exposing her bra and panties.
*Dave Meltzer attended one such show and reported that, while the lads loved it, horrified parents dragged their kids - the WWF's target audience - home immediately.
8. Something For Bret Hart To Smile About
To fast-forward to 1993 briefly, Yokozuna went over WWF champion Bret Hart in the main event of WrestleMania IX.
The f*ck finish - Mr. Fuji threw salt in Bret's eyes - acted as pretext for the controversial impromptu main event, in which Yoko was immediately dethroned by Hulk Hogan, who had made an extravagantly racist challenge to the winner earlier in the night.
The decision was made to revert to the easy shortcut that was Hulk Hogan because, while his act was tired, he was a bigger name. Bret was a great custodian of the WWF, the man who drew WWF fans deeper beyond the superficial fad level, but he was not a crossover name capable of leading the company into a new boom period.
The thing is, Bret had replaced Hogan for a good reason: the fire had gone out, and Hogan's box office magic had waned.
It was a desperately upsetting night for Hart, less than a 4/10, but as disastrous as WrestleMania IX was in general, it actually outdrew the night that Hogan became passé.
WrestleMania VII drew 400,000 buys on pay-per-view, with the medium well established by that point - 'Mania V drew a staggering 767,000 - where Mania IX drew 430,000. That incidentally was up 40,000 on the number Hogan drew for his main event against Sid Justice at 'Mania VIII in 1992.
This is not to state that Bret was a bigger draw overall than Hogan - but fans were more interested in seeing Bret reclaim his title than they were in the death rattle of Hulkamania.
7. It's Not Just AEW...
Recently, WWE announced the Bash In Berlin Premium Live Event, which is set to emanate from the Mercedez-Benz arena on Saturday, August 31, 2024.
Now, WWE has frequently promoted PLEs in international markets under Triple H and Nick Khan, and have a strong base of fans in Germany - but it would be naive to state that the timing of the show didn't have a tiny bit to do with the fact that German fans now have less incentive to travel to England to watch a major event promoted by a US company that does not tour Europe frequently.
Certainly, while low on the list of reasons to book it, the existence of All In 2 - and WWE's desire to undermine it somewhat - was in the "Pros" column.
WWE was doing this sort of thing decades before All Elite Wrestling existed. They were doing it long before 1991 - Survivor Series only ever existed as a means of throttling Jim Crockett Promotions as a viable concern on pay-per-view - but in 1991, Vince McMahon booked a stadium show out of pure spite.
Because the promoter of the St. Louis Arena had allowed WCW to run shows in the building, an aghast Vince McMahon decided to book Busch Stadium in retaliation. Knowing that the attendance would dwarf the crowd WCW would pull to the arena, he - and this was a ballsy move mere months after 'Mania VII was downsized - also knew that the arena promoter would see the WWF as the only viable wrestling racket in subsequent years.
It's this sort of cynical yet astute thinking with which Vince got to where he was.
6. WWF = Bigger Than MADONNA
Wrestling is a cyclical industry.
In a sobering parallel between AEW in 2023 and the WWF of 1992, each promotion drew an enormous crowd to Wembley Stadium as domestic business softened. The first trend actually started a year prior, which compelled Vince McMahon to run SummerSlam 1992 in London.
In October, the WWF toured the United Kingdom and Europe to staggering, record-breaking effect. In another parallel, the WWF caught ablaze in Great Britain, much as it had in the States years prior, through the rise of Sky Sports. The UK equivalent to cable TV took longer to reshape the landscape, but eventually, the WWF reaped the rewards for a second time. Kids in schools the land over annoyed their parents into forking out for an exorbitant subscription because the Fed was the talk of the playground. Vince McMahon and the Premier League drove Sky to households.
The WWF occupied a bizarre transatlantic space between turmoil and triumph.
Strange, but incandescent: the WWF was so hot over here that a Wembley Arena show on October 14 sold out in 56 minutes. At the time, this was the fastest sell-out in the history of the building - breaking the record set by Madonna.
That context is frankly insane: in 1991, Madonna was the talk of the tabloids, a figure of seismic controversy, and was touring the Immaculate Collection: the best-selling greatest hits album ever released by a solo artist. The WWF show was headlined by The Legion of Doom Vs. The Nasty Boys.
Brian Knobbs: bigger draw than Madonna confirmed.
5. WWF Brought The HEAT
Following the WrestleMania VII debacle, as evidenced by a further decline in the buys between SummerSlam 1990 and '91, business did not improve.
Vince McMahon was always averse to a heavy heat angle. He was - and this of course developed an intense irony when he eventually monopolised the North American industry - a "send the fans home happy" promoter. Vince, after all, had positioned a babyface on top as WWF Champion for well over 90% of the time spanning January 23, 1984 to January 19, 1991. Only the scheming of Ted DiBiase in 1988, and a two month period in Randy Savage's reign, disrupted the long pattern of a babyface - Hulk Hogan, Savage, the Ultimate Warrior - operating as ultra-cartoonish purveyors of wish fulfilment.
In 1995, when Vince McMahon ceded creative power for a week, he couldn't cope, and re-cut the one thing Bill Watts was allowed to do: a heavy heat cliffhanger angle.
1991 was a different story. 1990 was hardly a great year - Warrior floundered on top - but in 1991, it really felt like the walls were closing in on the '80s pop culture behemoth. In response, to shock young fans back into caring, Vince decided to traumatise them.
He booked a psyche-scorcher of an angle in which Randy Savage was bitten in the arm by Jake Roberts' cobra. Watch it 32 years later, and you're still convinced that little bastard will dart his head through the screen. It was heavily implied, after an endless-feeling administration of CPR, that the Undertaker had suffocated the Warrior to death by trapping him inside of a casket. As was taped in 1991, Marty Jannetty would rather have smashed his face into glass than confront the end of his friendship with Shawn Michaels.
The WWF of 1991 was nightmarish for the young fans, as the bad vibes surrounding the promotion seemed to bleed through the camera lans...
4. The Real Reason Behind This Tuesday In Texas
If you're a millennial fan raised on the WWF, cast your mind back to the early 1990s when, with your Hasbro collection sprawled all over your living room carpet, you sit down with your sausage and smiley faces dinner to watch Survivor Series 1991 on Coliseum home video.
You sit there, thrilled, because you are not remotely discerning and have not yet realised that Virgil and the Berzerker are absolute dog dirt. They're big, wacky, and they have muscles!
Life is good, but oh boy - the Undertaker is out next, and before his t-shirt collection gave you a real reason to be horrified, through your childhood lens, he's real creepy. That ghostly make-up. The chilling gait. The dead eyes.
And, oh no - he's just beaten Hulk Hogan for the belt! Blast!
But!
Hulk Hogan might win it back at some show called This Tuesday In Texas?
"What the hell is This Tuesday In Texas, son?" your da asks.
It's another 20 quid at Woolworths, that's what it is. No chance.
Vince McMahon annoyed parents and left kids wanting, undermining the home video and PPV markets, with this cheap carny trick. Survivor Series and This Tuesday In Texas were two of the worst-performing WWF PPVs in years, and really only existed as a double-header to offset the start-up costs of the World Bodybuilding Federation.
They didn't even give you a proper finish at the show that "counted", either. It's no wonder the 1992 Royal Rumble buy number - just 260,000 - was so brutal.
3. Him?!
Sgt. Slaughter, to huge controversy, was repackaged as an Iraqi sympathiser in 1991.
The idea was to whip up a patriotic fervour amongst the public, who would get behind Hulk Hogan in huge numbers as he restored justice. You see, a wrestling match is a means of settling a complex and harrowing geopolitical conflict. America won when Hogan dropped the leg.
The theme of the match was a total farce, almost kitsch looking back on it now, but it was somehow almost worse.
Now, Bruce Prichard is what you call an "unreliable narrator". A trash-mouthed carny, he has defended the dirt-worst WWE booking and has a selective memory of his involvement in it. He once claimed that Vince McMahon devised the Muhammad Hassan character because he was saddened by the plight facing Arab-Americans following 9/11 - which is funny, since Vince failed to put his red pen through the line - "I see sand people" uttered by babyface Steve Austin.
Prichard claimed on his 'Something To Wrestle' pod that Tugboat was discussed internally to play the role of American turncoat and work Hogan in the main event of WrestleMania VII. Better yet - though this must have been a rib - Bruce contended that he would be named 'Sheik Tugboat'.
How.
How was that going to be the name.
An anthropomorphic boat that hated America nearly headlined WrestleMania.
Still would have better than Triple H Vs. Randy Orton at 25.
2. It Was Actually Class
The WWF was rightly savaged for exploiting the Gulf War as the key selling point of WrestleMania VII, and karma gave them the old ten punches on the top turnbuckle: the show was downsized from a stadium to an arena and drew a pitiful 400,000 buys because Hulk Hogan wasn't the man anymore, the theme was ugly and transparent and desperate, and the WWF fad did what fads do: died.
The thing is, the period between Royal Rumble and WrestleMania was strong, ignoring all that, and since hundreds of horrific world events have unfolded since 1991, a dim, calloused memory, it's a lot easier to watch it all - and admire the narrative dexterity of the booking - in retrospect.
Randy Savage entered an incredible heel performance at the Rumble, which, in collaboration with Pat Patterson's superb knack of booking finishes, linked together the two main attractions at 'Mania VII brilliantly. Savage almost tripped over Warrior, he was so intense and desperate to mess him up, and he absolutely nailed him with the sceptre shot to hand Sgt. Slaughter the title. You've seen a million interference finishes, but Savage made it feel like a brutal, unconscionable injustice.
This set up both Slaughter Vs. Hulk Hogan, which was serviceable, a bit long, but very, very loud, and Savage Vs. Warrior - hefty, unique, super-dramatic, an indelible spectacle in and of itself and a backdrop to one of the most moving angles in wrestling history.
WrestleMania VII in general was the best 'Mania up 'til that point, and wasn't bettered until X. The Warlord and British Bulldog was an improbably great, resourceful undercard match, the Jake Roberts Vs. Rick Martel Blindfold match was as silly as it was deafening, and, in the Rockers Vs. Haku & the Barbarian and Hart Foundation Vs. Nasty Boys, the WWF delivered what was then the best pair of tags in 'Mania history.
The former was a dynamic spot of escapology on the part of Shawn Michaels and Marty Jannetty, where the latter was a blinding way of getting heat on the heels. You're probably sick of hearing a commentator say "They stole one!", but the Nastys really did do an awesome smash and grab.
1. The Dave Meltzer Vs. WWF Blow-Up
In 1991, the year of war in the WWF, a battle broke out between the promotion and Dave Meltzer of the Wrestling Observer Newsletter.
A letter was written to Dave's then editor, Frank Deford of The National, concerning a story Meltzer had written.
Meltzer reported that Hulk Hogan was sent by the WWF to visit troops in Saudi Arabia in a bid to strengthen his public image, before the tour was throttled by the US Defense Department. The WWF vehemently denied that, claiming it was all at the behest of the USO. In response, Meltzer noted that somebody within the WWF had told him, prior to the letter being sent, that WrestleMania VII was set to be the biggest ever. Sgt. Slaughter was set to burn the flag, which would position Hogan as the ultimate babyface patriot. As part of the push to to build interest in the event, Meltzer was told, Hogan was going to Saudi.
This sparked something of an existential crisis within Meltzer, who dedicated the entire February 4 WON to a treatise on journalistic ethics. In this issue, Dave revealed that he once worked for the WWF as a consultant on the Japanese scene - tour dates, bookings, the way things played out in general. So, if you believe that Dave shouldn't report on something he's never been involved in, you'd be wrong.
The WWF made further accusations that Dave specialised in "inaccurate, bias (sic) writing", the irony of which is that you can comb through virtually any edition of the Observer from 1991 and notice that Meltzer was on the money. So prescient and knowledgeable as to be an oracle, Meltzer obviously didn't have the benefit of hindsight.
And yet, in the September 30 issue, he correctly reported that "the latest speculation is that they'll be asking Ultimate Warrior back", and he indeed returned months later. It was a bold one, given the events of SummerSlam '91, at which Warrior extorted Vince McMahon for Hulk Hogan money. The relationship was deemed dead.
In the same issue, Meltzer reported that the Rockers had handed in their notice but were unlikely to join WCW since the promotion was not strong enough at the negotiating table.
Dave was correct on both counts.