10 Times AEW Took It Too Far
AEW once had a stated mission: we won't be WWE. Channelling Vince Russo is not the way to do that...
All Elite Wrestling is a promotion designed for the millennial wrestling fans who wondered whatever happened to the wrestling they grew up on.
Where's the blood? Where are the stables? Where are the screaming promos cut straight down the lens? Why does every show start with a 20 minute rehearsed talking segment? Where's the energy? Why does everything feel so predictable and drab? Where are the sets?
AEW sought to answer those questions in a quest for far-ranging fan service.
While AEW at its best is a magnificent, creative promotion - Anarchy In The Arena was so great that, this time next year, fans will fantasy book the next big stable war into that attraction just as happily as they will Blood & Guts, which is truly impressive - the byproduct of this mentality isn't ideal...
...at all.
At times, AEW is rather too inspired by the 1990s.
Of course, Tony Khan isn't directly responsible for some of the questionable incidents on this list - but since part of his philosophy is to extend creative latitude to his talent, it's all AEW in the end...
10. Jake Roberts Terrorises Brandi Rhodes
Eurgh, the state of that image. It is repulsive.
The Cody Rhodes Vs. Lance Archer programme was so close to being an unqualified success. Not only was it mostly fantastic, it was stunningly resourceful. Operating with a 29% capacity skeleton roster in Atlanta in the first phase of the pandemic, Tony Khan crafted a TNT title tournament into which an awesome grudge programme was folded. On one side of the bracket, Cody narrowly eked out wins against the men, Shawn Spears and Darby Allin, who had given him his sternest tests. On the other, Archer, who looked like a mutated skyscraper in the context of QT Marshall's training school, ripped Marko Stunt to f*cking shreds and left a pool of blood under Cody's brother's head in a fantastic match that had no right to be as dramatic as it was.
Jake Roberts was great in the role of Archer's manager, in sinister pre-taped promos that didn't rely on him projecting his shattered voice in arenas, but in the live environment, it was difficult to ascertain what he was saying. This wasn't ideal, and it wasn't helped by that time, ahead of Double Or Nothing, that he crawled over Brandi Rhodes, adopted the missionary position as a taunt, and allowed a phallic snake to crawl all over her.
An unsettling artefact of a heat angle, this was just gross.
9. Sammy Guevara Brains Matt Hardy
In the interest of balance, it should probably be noted that Sammy Guevara has otherwise enjoyed a stellar breakthrough run in AEW thus far - because he's the focal point of much of this list.
He was piss funny as the heartthrob brat of the Inner Circle, and his smarmy face was so detestable that he could get away with working an electrifying, crazed ring style. He set the standard of how a mainstream unknown could get over on national TV by latching onto every opportunity, even those that he seemed locked out from. Most wrestlers do very little in picture-and-picture; where they allow your eyes to glaze over, Guevara made you pay attention and squint with his creative cue cards schtick.
He's also prone to moments of idiocy - like that time he couldn't find the planted prop chair and thought "F*ck it, I'll just grab whatever's handy and hope for the best".
In August 2020, in a cursed moment in a cursed timeline, Guevara stitched Hardy up proper by launching an actual steel chair with some speed into Hardy's temple. Hardy juiced a gusher and quite understandably read the riot act to Guevara backstage, per Bryan Alvarez on Wrestling Observer Live.
Reckless behaviour, it was also unnecessary; the show was taped, and Guevara could have yelled cut instead of actually cutting Hardy disgustingly deep.
8. Sammy Guevara Endangers Himself This Time
Wrestling is all about escalation, which often isn't ideal, since it never bloody stops and the accepted standard for insane stunts was set all the way back in 1998. Even as pure wrestling is restored in parallel with the stunt show - look at how little CM Punk and Dax Harwood did, but how much they got out of it - doing something outrageous is a guaranteed pop.
And now, somewhat unhelpfully, a guaranteed GIF in the Twitter era. More people are going to GIF a 630 senton off a ladder than Punk just barely feigning to sweep the leg as Dax withdraws just as quickly as he steams ahead.
Sammy Guevara lit up the internet with his perfectly timed cutter to Cody Rhodes at Beach Break in January. The jump from turnbuckle to ladder to ladder was both supernaturally impressive and a spot of strategic quick-thinking in a match that nailed the intent-to-win tone. Guevara felt he had to out-do himself, and subverting the spot by taking a mid-air cutter wasn't enough for him, and so, at the midway point, he attempted a 630 senton off the top of the ladder.
He took it too far and very nearly badly hurt himself; with so little room to properly rotate, and moving too quickly for a smooth catch, he was lucky enough to land on his shoulder and not the crown of his head.
7. Dan Lambert Gets Homophobic
Dan Lambert is AEW's fictionalised version of Jim Cornette: a ranting, out-of-touch parody of an old school critic who can't sanction the new generation of wrestlers and their flippy sh*t and such. He's the supposed man's man who, deep down, is a coward. That's the heat.
It never worked as well as it should have, given how much Cornette is a massive heel in the eyes of the AEW audience. Was the character too meta? Was Lambert's slick-tongued, red-faced delivery too good?
Or did AEW miss the actual point, all this time?
The parallels are almost too uncanny; many of Cornette's ugly opinions shouldn't be fictionalised, and the specifically venomous way in which he describes Kenny Omega is one of them.
Back in October 2021, when building the American Top Team Vs. Inner Circle programme, the latter's Sammy Guevara faced Ethan Page of the former in a TNT Title match. They shared a verbal segment on the 23rd, a typically eye-rolling exchange in which edgy sh*t was slung over the dreaded invisible wall. Lambert claimed, with a certain cadence, that Sammy "sucked on the stick". Obviously, Lambert wasn't criticising Guevara's promo ability; with openly gay wrestlers backstage working for the promotion that is for "everybody," Lambert suggested that a gay sex act is something worth mocking.
Lambert was the heel, but that justifies precisely nothing; this was lame bro sh*t from a company that should be above this.
6. Cop A Load Of Tay Conti's Arse, Lads!
Tay Conti has - how to put this delicately? - a posterior that Jim Ross is guaranteed to have liked on Twitter at some point or other.
This physical attribute has driven storylines in AEW in a way that, for example, Bryan Danielson's bulge has not. Nobody has said that Danielson is so full of himself that he flaunts his huge cack around because his character is a sadistic technical expert. Also, he is a man.
Conti isn't afforded this luxury. On no less than two occasions, those bloody jealous, superficial women have made it known that Conti is defined by what she sits on.
At Full Gear '21, Conti challenged for Dr. Britt Baker's AEW Women's World title. In the build, Baker buried Conti. "All you've done since coming to AEW is show everybody your ass," Baker said, and months later, Paige VanZant signed her AEW deal on it, the implication of which was similar: Conti's personality, as a woman, is defined by her looks.
Now, this wouldn't be particularly "on" even if the idea was to convey that Conti had been underestimated, and that there was a real, credible threat underneath the marketable facade (she lost the match at Full Gear, which wasn't ideal in this regard).
Her portrayal is significantly worse now...
5. Tay Conti Gets Slut-Shamed
Tay Conti is involved in a monogamous relationship with Sammy Guevara.
Even if she weren't, and she was having it off on a consensual basis with multiple partners, that's absolutely more than fine. It's her body, it's her life, and she would be no less of a human being if this is how she chose to spend her time.
She's barely even a valet at this point; on AEW television, she plays a slut-shamed accessory of Sammy Guevara and is defined by their relationship.
For several months now, she has been targeted by Dan Lambert, who has nicknamed her "Whorehausen" and "Luchawhoreus". Again, some tedious d*ckhead who has the capacity to just purchase the WWE Network and watch the Attitude Era in full on a loop if they're so inclined might counter with something to the effect of "Relax soy boy, he's a heel".
Lambert was still coming out with this ancient sh*t when he played de facto babyface against Guevara, on whom the AEW base had turned by April. The misogyny was so rife in this Russo-pilled programme that it was difficult to determine who the heels were; at one point, Scorpio Sky was effectively positioned as the babyface as a result of burying Conti's sex life. The implication was that you couldn't have Conti, and you were to resent her for that.
When AEW announced itself as the promotion "for everybody," did this have to include incels?
4. AEW Goes Carny
Disclaimer: Chris Jericho and Jon Moxley are close, and if Mox didn't want Jericho to bring up his issues with substance abuse, this wouldn't have happened. The segment in which the Anarchy In The Arena match was announced was agreed upon by all parties, was clearly not a reflection of Jericho's real feelings on his storyline rival, and was scripted to heat up a worked professional wrestling match.
On May 18 of this year, in an inspired tease, Jericho threatened to challenge Eddie Kingston et al. to a Stadium Stampede match; AEW, knowing that the second wasn't anywhere near as charming as the first, had a bit of self-awareness here. "I'm not doing that sh*t," Mox said. It was a great deadpan line. Jericho's cheap heat?
Not so much.
He called Danielson a "nerd," which while lame worked, because that's the exact attitude the sports entertainment juggernaut extended to him in 2010. Jericho then said that Danielson should live a little, but not too much. He doesn't want to end up in the "clinic like Mox". Yes, Jericho is a heel, but it was genuinely lovely to see Punk empathise with Moxley when the news first broke. It felt, naively, like wrestling had moved on from its bullsh*t. It hadn't.
Wrestling, even at the Elite level, just can't help but expose itself as an unpleasant and cheap carny racket.
3. Tony Khan: Message Board Poster
Tony Khan is a genuinely endearing feller, and he's a billionaire. That takes some doing.
In addition to financing and booking the best U.S. territory of the century, and being a so-bad-it's-funny promo wise enough to contain his warbling lunacy to post-show thank yous, Khan has a "one of us" vibe to him because he is. Well, he's a billionaire, but as far as billionaires go, he's an extremely online message board poster who is so good at booking for the aspirational hipster because he is one. He also has no filter.
This can yield brilliance. He thought nothing of burying WWE's propaganda of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia nor suggesting that the worst people on Wrestling Twitter are bots who may have been programmed by the Fed.
He also took it much too far on, of all days, New Year's Eve. He forgot the auld acquaintance with Big Swole by calling her dog sh*t in the ring. That's paraphrasing, but he was equally cruel, and it didn't matter at all that Swole wasn't particularly good between the ropes or showing signs of improvement. It was callous, removed entirely from a far more pertinent issue, and it was hypocritical; Khan had praised Swole's work previously, which badly affected his credibility.
His catchphrase is "X has been great for us," but in the wake of his meltdown, he can appear far more like a carny than an agent of change.
2. Max Caster's Raps
Allowing a great promo artist to go out there and advance a story in their own words is one thing. It's actually crucial to fan investment, to getting over, to everything.
Allowing an entertaining guy with no clue where the line is free rein to say what he wants is quite another.
In a "Heartbreaking: The Worst Person You Know Just Made A Great Point" deal, Road Dogg, when explaining WWE's scripted promo model, said to Corey Graves on the After The Bell podcast in 2020 that fans can't "fathom" the idea that a guy might be a "loose cannon" who says a "cuss word or something".
"So we script his promo word for word now because we don't trust you yet".
While this scanned as hysterical WWE arrogance at the time, AEW's Max Caster has proven him right - somehow, on more than one occasion. After drawing outrage for stating that PRC tests were "fake", insinuating that the deadly pandemic was overstated, Max in the next breath made a horrendous rape joke. Caster was suspended for this 2021 promo, and Tony Khan promised to tightly edit Dark in future, where he hadn't previously - but Caster continues to say ill-advised sh*t well into 2022.
Mocking Hunter Biden's addiction issues and "dunking" on Amber Heard in particular is big yikes sh*t. The indirect ramifications of the reaction to that case (without saying anything of it on its own terms) are the opposite of escapist showbiz b*llocks.
1. A Mockery Of WWE Too Far
A good, astute wrestling promoter plays to their audience. "Telling the fans who to like and if they don't like them, tough t*tties" isn't the norm. This is the nihilism-generating philosophy of a mad old king.
AEW fans tend to pop for the various digs aimed at WWE's expense, so AEW will proceed with doing it. Subjectively, what was once earned and amusing is starting to really wear thin - unless CM Punk is in full furious "F*ck off" mode doing his incredible "buy one get four three extravaganza" bit - and it does frame AEW as the #2 organisation. Regardless, it's fan service, it always generates a reaction, and until it doesn't, AEW won't stop.
They should probably start thinking about it in the wake of the Jeff Hardy news. The scope for a self-own is too vast, and has now been realised.
Even before Jeff debuted, Matt parodied Jeff's exit by hopping the guardrail when abandoning Private Party; on commentary, with a wink, this was described as "pretty erratic behaviour". Jeff has recently behaved in a manner far more sinister than "erratic", by endangering the lives of drivers, and this scene (in addition to Jeff's own parody at Double Or Nothing) scans as deeply, deeply ill-advised stone-throwing. Booking Jeff Hardy on this specific run was a dishonourable mention unto itself.
If you want to get over on the heel, it's best to play babyface.