10 Times AEW Turned Trash Into Treasure

In All Elite Wrestling, you can trust the process. Eventually...

Penta Oscuro Julia Hart
AEW/Twitter, @TheJuliaHart

In his famous, incredible promo of November 8, 2019, then-All Elite Wrestling EVP Cody Rhodes took pride in AEW's willingness and ability to "listen".

This verbal segment wasn't all talk.

The early, mostly well-received phase of AEW Dynamite was not without flaw, and certainly not without criticism. AEW's "change the world" promotional bluster was off-putting to some, and those critics let AEW have it. Time management was one such early issue. Several matches worked by the less experienced members of the roster went too long to the detriment of the episodic TV experience. The matches and angles were red-hot, but where were those interview segments? Hadn't wrestling fans wanted down-the-lens fire for almost two decades? Wasn't AEW meant to bring back what wrestling fans wanted?

Promo time was at a premium on the wrestling-centric early shows. People were mystified and unhappy that MJF and Jon Moxley hadn't brought that fire. Now, they, Hangman Page, Chris Jericho et al. have brought back a level of unscripted mic brilliance not witnessed consistently in the U.S. mainstream in decades.

Since 2019, AEW has refined itself - and solved far more pressing issues - to even more profound an extent...

10. NJPW X AEW Forbidden Door

Will Ospreay Orange Cassidy
AEW

The build to NJPW x AEW Forbidden Door was dire.

It was also cursed; CM Punk Vs. Hiroshi Tanahashi and Bryan Danielson Vs. Zack Sabre, Jr. were scrapped through injury. The level of detail and craft across those matches would have been sublime, but even if the latter match had happened, the build would have faltered.

As alluded to in Bryan Danielson's bizarre "I can't make the show and I'm making you wait 48 hours to reveal this crushing news" promo, Chris Jericho had paid off ZSJ, mercenary, to take Danielson out of Blood & Guts before a legitimate concussion had ruled him out.

Why did this need a North American TV-style build? Wasn't the idea behind a co-promoted show a collaboration of each company's booking principles?

Why couldn't ZSJ - winner of almost as many Bryan Danielson awards as Bryan Danielson - have issued a challenge to determine who once and for all was the best technical wrestler alive?

Why was Hiroshi Tanahashi programmed opposite the JAS in a pseudo-can they co-exist? deal with Jon Moxley? Why did Tony Khan plot some convoluted business with FTR, Will Ospreay and Best Friends to arrive at Ospreay Vs. Orange Cassidy? Couldn't Ospreay have told Cassidy he was a joke?

There were few personal issues heading into Forbidden Door, and, somehow, even fewer instances in which the representatives of each promotion were fuelled by a desire to prove that their home was the premiere destination for professional wrestling.

The pay-per-view itself was magic. Almost every match ranged from crazed fun to world-class action. The shot of Sting's silhouette before he dove onto the Young Bucks from atop an entrance tunnel! Orange Cassidy planning five defensive moves ahead! Tana making you beg out loud that he could stay in the match!

SHOOTER!

The whole thing was a masterpiece, one of the best PPVs ever. Hopefully, this year, the hype equals the quality.


9. The Butcher & The Blade

Butcher Blade Bunny Cody Rhodes AEW Dynamite
AEW.com

The Butcher and the Blade debuted on the 27 November 2019 Dynamite by, in the style of a supernatural WWE monster, emerging from a hole underneath the ring to attack Cody.

Jim Ross was mystified. Excalibur knew of their identity, and so he told us. He told us several times without really telling us anything. He just rattled off their names over and over again. Cody a week later styled the terrible entrance as the Butcher and the Blade's attempt to make a unique, theatrical impact, but it scanned as an apology. He didn't really explain the story beat.

MJF did - he hired the team to take Cody out - but the wonky audio left fans clueless. Happily, one of the weirdest match graphics in AEW's short history manifested as an inconceivable triumph. Cody and QT Marshall Vs. Butcher and Blade was a terrific TV match built around the idea that QT was far better than he looked losing tune-up matches on Dark.

The Butcher and the Blade became ancillary characters in the epic MJF vs. Cody saga, and, in 2020, became cult favourites with their amazing work in crazed plunder brawls. The Falls Count Anywhere match opposite the Young Bucks on the July 16 Dynamite was one of the most creative and relentlessly entertaining TV matches ever. All four men turned Daily's Place into a playground and battleground by working awesome spots across every square foot of it.

AEW learned from the initial fumble and refined the debut process across the board...


8. The Debut Process, General

Jeff Cobb Inner Circle
AEW

Tony Khan was a huge ECW fan, and used an old Paul Heyman trick on his very first show: at Double Or Nothing, the lights went out after Best Friends defeated The Hybrid 2.

The expectation was rampant, even if CM Punk was hardly going to make his debut running in after a midcard tag match - but that's what the lights out gimmick elicits. The Dark Order were revealed to blanket silence. It bordered on embarrassing. As mentioned, the Butcher and the Blade also debuted in less than auspicious circumstances. This felt like such an open goal of a booking flaw; Khan could nail an angle and sell the sh*t out of a pay-per-view. but he couldn't pen a vignette?

He did eventually - well, not pen a vignette, but refine the process.

On that subject, as a small aside: what has a vignette ever actually told the audience?

"Hi, I'm Razor Ramon. You may remember me from the film Scarface. Also I'm mean to wimps."

There's no ideal way to debut a brand new act, and if Tony Khan is yet to crack a code that doesn't really need to be solved, he has perfected the debut of the established star.

Sting's wintry introduction was majestic in the strictest definition; the viral marketing campaign that heralded CM Punk's introduction was so great that countless wrestling fans between them fantasy booked an infinite amount of programmes; the cryptic build of Mr. Brodie Lee made the Dark Order fascinating where they were once irredeemably atrocious.


7. The House Of Black

House Of Black
AEW

It's probably unfair to label the House of Black as "trash", on balance.

Well before they dethroned the Elite for the AEW World Trios titles at Revolution, they were nothing less than an awesome unit with a unique approach to getting over as an intimidating, invincible presence. Tremendous at isolating and surrounding opponents, they are fantastic at orchestrating a sense of plight before unleashing their awesome range of offence. Buddy Matthews has the warp speed snug strikes, Malakai Black is the more accomplished martial arts, Brody King the terrifying winged behemoth.

The act absolutely rules, and mostly always did, but the chintzy aspect of their presentation, mercifully, has been abandoned.

Though many have forgotten this, since the blow-off at Double Or Nothing was so tremendous, their feud with Death Triangle was risible. Alex Abrahantes looked like a child buzzing about Halloween in November and was much too desperate to do Goth Stuff. Penta Oscuro wasn't so much the dark alter-ego as Tony Khan's dismal attempt to feed the lore n*nces any old spooky sh*te. The television was Hot Topic-looking drivel, and the House's inscrutable babbling didn't help the Wish Bray Wyatt vibe.

It turned afterwards - the shot composition and body language in their programme with Sting, Darby Allin and Miro was so fantastic that Malakai actually felt like the presence he has always aspired to be - but all that was lost when he and AEW seemed to have a falling-out.

They're now a more permanent (and less corny) fixture on AEW programming, which is all the better for the House's black metal energy.


6. Miro

Miro AEW
AEW

In a rare example of AEW turning treasure into trash, the rankings system has been abandoned.

The principle behind it still exists, to an extent - Bryan Danielson recently had to defeat several names in a series of eclectic and sensational matches to earn a shot at World champion MJF at Revolution - but too often, the lazy Eliminator gimmick has replaced the compelling intricacy that once drove characters into major matches.

The old system was super effective when deployed thoughtfully. Consider the gauntlet match that determined the number one contenders to World Tag Team champions Kenny Omega and Hangman Page at All Out '20, and how it teased the prospect of a first-ever in-ring meeting between FTR and the Young Bucks. But it was not perfect. Miro's debut underscored its imperfections.

Tony Khan argued that he couldn't push Miro as a serious threat immediately; Khan was nowhere near ready to have him lose, but if Miro won too often and too early, logically, he'd have to compete in a World title match. When the system was devised, Khan possibly hadn't thought through the implication of signing a free agent monster heel.

Still, this didn't justify Miro's first persona. A half-decent idea - as 'The Best Man', Miro was meant to be the best all-rounder in the promotion - but his feud with Best Friends was so wacky that his aura all but vanished. Arcade Anarchy was very fun, but the stakes were so low and the feud dragged on for ages. It was punishingly dull.

Miro was subsequently reinvented as a psychotic God-fearing monster bound to unleash the violence from on high. He was legitimately scary in the role, and the presentation of his Redeemer character was world-class. He also was the Best Man - a great hoss who measured his vulnerability to perfection, creating palpable drama in matches totally unique to AEW, and needed just 30 seconds to build his feuds with a screenwriter's panache.


5. "69 Me, Don!"

69 me don
AEW

The difference between AEW and WWE's biggest disasters is that WWE deemed those disasters a good idea.

Hell In A Cell 2019 Vs. Revolution 2021: both were excruciatingly humiliating for the respective companies, but at least the finish to the Exploding Barbed Wire Death match wasn't the actual idea. The idea was to have Eddie Kingston save Jon Moxley from a raging inferno and build what constituted as a mega-pop in the 50% capacity Daily's Place era when the new coolest tag team in the world made their heroic, badass return.

Instead, as a result of a horrendous production snafu, the odd sparkler rained a few puffs of pyro onto the two men. It was either heartbreaking or very funny, depending on your perspective, but AEW's response was so incredible that it was almost a good thing that a $50 pay-per-view was ruined.

Kenny Omega and Don Callis reenacted the scene on the subsequent Dynamite to take the piss out of Eddie; after Kenny implored Don to "69 me!", nothing happened. Kenny's "Did I blow up?" deadpan was outstanding. The idea was to revel in the humiliation, to fictionalise it and give the babyface team cause to assault the Elite in multiple piss-funny buddy movie action set-pieces.

Without the sh*tty Revolution finish, you wouldn't have been able to watch Nick Jackson squawk in fear, like a bird, at the threat of Mox and Eddie out for revenge:


4. The Commentary Team

Tony Schiavone
AEW

The original AEW broadcast team was not great. It was very poor, in fact.

The idea was thus: Excalibur was to call the in-ring action as a former pro with a studious and enthusiastic grasp of the modern style; the legendary Jim Ross was to provide the gravitas and authority; Alex Marvez was to fill a new audience in on the backstories of the unfamiliar talent, à la New Japan Pro Wrestling's Chris Charlton.

The problem, God bless his very nice-seeming heart, is that Marvez - a close friend of Tony Khan's hired through nepotism - was awful. Where his analogue Charlton is a true company expert who genuinely enriches the stories of NJPW epics, the happy-to-be-there Marvez interjected himself at awkward times with an easily-pleased, gee-whizz wonderment. He disrupted the flow of the matches, you could hear in the silence JR's contempt of him, and in general, the man sounded like he had won a competition.

It was untenable, unpopular, and AEW made the call to transition him to a backstage interviewer role and replace him with Tony Schiavone ahead of Dynamite's launch.

Schiavone is wonderful. There are few sounds as blessed as the man saying "That was an ass-kicking match, guys", he tempers JR's more abrasive qualities by popping over the dives on Rampage, and is simply a warm and wonderful presence.

Nearly four years in, his gee-whizz wonderment still doesn't feel carny. He sounds like he's having the time of his life.


3. The Perception Of The Elite (And Indeed All Elite Wrestling)

Jacksonville Elite
AEW/Lee South

Tony Khan was faced with a crisis over the 2019 holiday season.

His December 18 AEW Dynamite episode was a disaster; the awful supernatural Dark Order act - or more accurately, the "creeper" underlings - had battered Kenny Omega and Cody Rhodes and failed to batter Dustin Rhodes by a good foot and a half. The whiffed punches were isolated on social media as a video emblematic of the extent to which the promotion at large had missed the mark. The gothic am-dram vibe was nowhere near the exhilaration and deep emotion elicited at Double Or Nothing.

The thing is, episodic wrestling doesn't end. He had to keep going, but how?

He had nearly ruined more than one top star and formed part of a booking committee with them.

Khan made the decision to oversee the creative process and restore the vibe, and did so with a booking masterstroke. He penned a happy ending and a cliffhanger on the same show: the incredible, instant return to form that was the unopposed January 1 Homecoming special. Khan recognised the perception of the Elite, in a bid to reassure fans that he knew what they were thinking of and fretting over, and posed a question at the start of the broadcast:

Are the Elite still the Elite?

He answered it by having Cody Rhodes go over Darby Allin and Kenny Omega and the Young Bucks go over PAC and the Lucha Bros. in two awesome bookends. He reminded the audience that the Elite were incredible wrestlers and winners. This was necessary, but it didn't compel fans into watching the week after.

Hangman Page is the main character of AEW, and the protagonist rode into and saved the show: shunted to commentary, he entered a comedic meme-friendly masterclass of a performance that drove the power of the cliffhanger.

The Elite were still elite wrestlers, but the faction wasn't whole: Hanger's potential exit from the stable was a tremendous cliffhanger that ultimately led to the greatest tag team match ever.


2. The Dark Order

Dynamite Dark Order
Twitter (@AEWrestling)

Supernatural wrestling wasn't always so horrendous - Kevin Sullivan had some presence, and it helped rather a lot that he was a quality brawler - and if AEW was to offer a "buffet" to fans bored by WWE's one-dimensional approach, you can see why a spot of spooky b*llocks was pitched in the experimental phase of the promotion.

Not the best idea to base one of the biggest storylines in the promotion around it, mind, Jesus Christ.

The Dark Order act was unfathomably awful in 2019. The "creepers" were the least intimidating act in major league wrestling history, and while the idea was to convey that they only had "strength in numbers," it wouldn't have mattered if there were 5,000 of them. They looked like trash.

The idea (as reported by Dave Meltzer but denied by Matt Jackson) was for a debuting Marty Scurll to have been revealed to have formed the Dark Order, in the shadows, as he waited to avenge being left behind by the Elite. They dodged a bullet with an idea that wasn't half-bad in 2019, but even then, the presentation of the act was pathetic. As small-time as it gets.

It was all saved by a much better and less problematic 'Exalted One': Mr. Brodie Lee, who, after an inspired red herring-strewn marketing campaign and less inspired Mr. McMahon impression, devised a genius bit.

His conniption fits at his moronic underlings were priceless. He struck a tremendous balance between being terrifying and entertaining and, in a less cruel world, built an unreal match with John Silver in particular. That David Vs. Goliath attraction remains pro wrestling's elusive masterpiece of a dream match.

Rest in peace.


1. The Role Of Hangman Page

Hangman Page
AEW

Hangman Page was never bad, but his early role felt miscast.

Page was hardly helped by MJF, whose charisma dwarfed his at Double Or Nothing. Nor was he helped by the enforced change in booking plans; Page, originally meant to wrestle PAC to earn a title shot at All Out, instead won the Casino Battle Royale, the comedic overtones of which undermined the achievement. His promo work in the build was stellar - he ripped the bandages from his face to get himself over as a classic babyface - but the match with Chris Jericho didn't get over as a proper main event because he went 50/50 with Kip Sabian at Fight For The Fallen in a match that attempted to do too much at once. Getting the time limit draw over was not the priority (and was a waste of time, since AEW has now abandoned a promising narrative device).

In the early phase of Dynamite, Page got over in an excellent series with PAC, but the Elite dissolution angle really got him over as the most popular act in the company. His genuinely funny comedic instincts connected him with the fans. Scrutinised closely, that pitcher of beer pictured above making its way into his hand was impossible, but the bold-faced absurdity of the bit, and the timing of the reveal, got it over.

This entry might be a reach, because this arc was likely the plan from the jump. You were meant to lose faith in him just as he was meant to lose faith in himself.

Maybe AEW has been burying some of that treasure all along.


In this post: 
Jake Hager
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!