10 Times Ego Cost Wrestlers Everything

WWE and WCW stars who believed their own hype to the point that it ruined them.

Shane McMahon Riddle WWE Royal Rumble 2022
WWE

The pro wrestling biz is ego-driven.

It's not unfair to say that the likes of Steve Austin, John Cena, Becky Lynch and more wouldn't have reached the apex of the industry had they not believed in themselves. Of course, there's a fine line between self-belief and outright arrogance, but knowing when to play the ego card can be crucial to someone's career.

That perception can be the difference between continuing to struggle and dominating on top (Lynch). Or...it can wreck runs completely and end up costing workers everything rather quickly. It's the latter that's focused on here - so many wrestlers ("wrestlers" might be more accurate for one of them) have shot themselves in the foot because they were far too self-absorbed and wouldn't stop until it was too late.

There were extenuating circumstances for some that maybe justifies this to an extent. Wrestling, like any other business, is rarely simple. Nothing is really black and white here, but it's true that common sense did give way to ego and/or ignorance on these occasions.

Be careful who you p*ss off on the way up and down...

10. Buff Bagwell Throws His Weight Around

Buff Bagwell
WWE.com

WCW incomer Buff Bagwell's short 2001 WWF run was just ridiculous.

Jim Ross found himself fielding upset phone calls from Buff's mother Judy about the way her son was being treated. Meanwhile, said son was chucking his weight around in training sessions, getting into fights and generally acting like 'Billy Big B*llocks' for no reason whatsoever.

Apparently, Bagwell believed he'd be a made man when he joined Vince McMahon's league. He couldn't have been more wrong, but Buff might've stood a chance had he not acted like the WWF was super-lucky to have him. His behaviour, and his ego, proved troublesome from minute one.

The federation was never going to tolerate that long-term, especially not when Judy Bagwell was chewing JR's ear off over the phone like some irate mother phoning her kid's school. 'The Stuff' lasted a few short months, and it's perhaps amazing that he even got that long before being cast out.

So much for that.


9. Jean-Pierre LaFitte Won’t Do The Job

Jean Pierre Lafitte
WWE

There's a natural pecking order in wrestling - there always has been, and there always will be. World Champions, rightly or wrongly, exist above everybody else on the card. In WWE, they're closer to Vince McMahon than most others, and the promotion aims to protect them.

So, with that in mind, what the f*ck was Jean-Pierre LaFitte thinking in 1995?

The pirate refused to do the J.O.B for then-WWF Champion Diesel on a house show in Canada. According to LaFitte, the natives would riot if he lost to Kevin Nash. Shawn Michaels wholeheartedly disagreed, and warned his big buddy not to go easy on the former Quebecer.

Their first match went to a double count out, but Diesel got the win 24 hours later in Quebec City. This ludicrous refusal from LaFitte directly led to his departure from the WWF by November '95. He'd raised the ire of the Kliq, and ticked off the office by playing hardball with the champ.


8. Dr. Death Believes His Own Hype

WWE Brawl For All Quebecer Pierre Dr Death Steve Williams
WWE.com

File this one under, 'What the f*ck were they thinking?!' too.

Ageing veteran legend Steve Williams joined the WWF in 1998 and was immediately discussed in glowing terms. JR's buddy was renowned for being a wrasslin' hard man, and most figured he'd paste the rest of the entrants in a silly 'Brawl For All' shoot fighting tournament the promotion was trying on.

'Dr. Death' didn't. He squeezed past Quebecer Pierre (Jean-Pierre LaFitte) in the opening round, then got positively creamed by Bart Gunn in the second. Honestly, when Doc hit the mat, his run in Vinnie Mac's group was all-but-over. This was never going to end well, and it's baffling that Williams agreed to it.

Did he believe in his own tough reputation that much? This was a 16-year pro with bad knees, and he looked like a joke with the gloves on. The WWF instantly scrapped any plans for a proposed main event run vs. Steve Austin and looked elsewhere.


7. The Dynamite Kid Refuses To Relent

The Dynamite Kid
WWE.com

The Dynamite Kid wasn't well-liked backstage during his peak 1980s WWF run. His mean-spirited pranks and bullying ways made him a target for those willing to stand up for themselves, but supporters argued that Dynamite was, well, dynamite between the ropes.

That's a fair assessment - his big-bumping, high-flying style acted as a template for countless wrestlers who followed. Unfortunately, Kid's staunch refusal to mix up his game cost him big time in the end. Dynamite's injuries were severe, and he masked his pain by medicating. There was no way he was gonna change his ring style.

Long-term, that proved to be a huge mistake.

It was likely ego-driven too. Dynamite had earned rave reviews for his stunning matches, and he couldn't stand the thought of giving that acclaim up. By refusing to relent, Kid would eventually succumb to his injuries and end up wheelchair-bound.

He became even more bitter and twisted towards the end of his life, before sadly passing on in 2018.


6. Vince Russo Runs Wild

Vince Russo WCW
WWE Network

2000-era WCW TV was some laugh.

Seriously, fire up WWE Network/Peacock and watch some. It's car crash telly, sure, but so entertaining in retrospect. 22 years ago though, viewers were tuning out in their droves; Vince Russo's brand of WCW didn't cut it for the casuals, and once-proud flagships like Nitro started to tank.

This was not a coincidence. Many reasons have been given for WCW's fall, but Russo has to take some of the blame. His incoherent product, decision to book himself as World Champion and laundry list of excuses for sagging ratings remains unbelievably arrogant to this day.

Rather than realising that what he was doing wasn't working, Russo hid behind the idea that Turner execs put a leash on him creatively by disallowing the same raunchy content Raw was producing. That was just one part of the story, and nowhere near the full tale.

Nah, ego definitely got in the road here. Russo booked himself like the world's worst combination of Mr. McMahon and The Rock.


5. Ted DiBiase Lives The Gimmick

Million Dollar Man
WWE.com

WWE's 2009 book on Ted DiBiase's life and career flies under the radar as an essential read. Some skimmed-over sections do hurt it, but there's enough meat on the bone to make it worth your time. Plus, Ted declines the chance to shy away from controversial moments or attempt to cover himself in glory.

He admits that his womanising, drinking and general behaviour as the high-rolling 'Million Dollar Man' cost him his marriage. DiBiase lived that gimmick in the late-80s and early-90s. Then, he was horrified when his wife found out the full extent of his cheating and threatened to leave him.

Ted believed he was untouchable as a top heel - in short, he lost touch with reality.

1993 was a tipping point. Desperate to save his marriage and banged-up anyway, Ted quit full-time wrestling and returned home for a spell. In the book, he lays out how egotistical he'd been during his prime, and how poorly he treated so many people.

That caught up with him.


4. Chyna Wants “Stone Cold Money”

Chyna Steve Austin
WWE.com

This is a little bit different, and there are two sides to the story.

Chyna's personal life was rocked by revelations that Triple H and Stephanie McMahon had been seeing one another behind her back. This would clearly have a massive impact on anyone's mental health, but something else notable happened right before that in 1999/early-2000: Chyna asked for a pay rise.

Or, more accurately, she told Jim Ross that Vince McMahon should pay her "Stone Cold money". Steve Austin, as the biggest box office attraction in the industry at the time, was the company's biggest earner. JR scoffed at the suggestion, and said he could ask for more cash but couldn't demand the same as Austin.

Jim revealed, via his podcast, that this 100% worked against Chyna in the long run. Further, her aloofness around other women as the head of that particular division in 2001 didn't do much for Vince either. Everything fell apart for someone who once seemed to have it all.


3. Bret Hart = Superhero

Bret Hart Montreal Screwjob
WWE.com

No, there's nothing new to say about ye olde screwjob.

Stick with this though, 'cause it really is quite fascinating to think about. Everybody blames Vince McMahon, Shawn Michaels, Earl Hebner and others for conspiring to f*ck Bret Hart over at Survivor Series 1997 - that's fair, and they bloody did, but...what about Bret's part in things?

Refusing to drop the WWF Title in Canada was a strange power play from somebody who claimed to lead by example. Nobody's defending what McMahon, HBK etc did, and yet Hart definitely contributed to his own WWF empire crumbling by being so egocentric right before a major pay-per-view.

He looked upon himself as a real-life superhero, and contested that his home nation would be crushed if he lost. Really? That's doubtful. Life would've marched on no bother had Michaels bagged the belt in Montreal on 9 November '97.

The 'Hitman' got into his own head here. That shoved him closer to the exit door, and towards a quite miserable run in WCW.


2. The Ultimate Warrior Thinks He Is The Business

Ultimate Warrior Vince McMahon 1996
WWE.com

One could launch into a deep dive on multiple dramas from The Ultimate Warrior's career. He spat the dummy back at SummerSlam 1991 by demanding more money, and had become well-known for being a tough customer to deal with by the time a second stint rolled around in '96.

Then, the comic books. Oh boy, the comic books!

The ins and outs of Warrior's follow-up falling out with Vinnie Mac are complex. The boss was peeved that the wrestler skipped some house shows in June/July; Warrior explained that he was grieving his father's death, but McMahon pointed out that he'd been estranged from his dad for years.

Whilst all of that was going on, Warrior claimed the WWF sold merch without giving him a cut and tried to get them to buy a boatload of his comics in return. JR said on his pod that Vince wasn't interested, but was willing to do business. Sadly, Warrior wanted everything his own way and wouldn't meet in the middle.

He pretty much no-showed bookings then said, 'Hey, buy a crap ton of my merch off of me or else!'.


1. Shane McMahon Rebooks The Rumble

Shane McMahon
WWE.com

Welcome to the latest example of ego running wild.

Recent reports reveal that Shane McMahon tried to rebook the 2022 Royal Rumble match at the last possible second. This, no-one will be surprised to learn, upset a fair few WWE agents and creative team members behind the scenes. Shane supposedly didn't care - he was going to get his way.

McMahon entered at the #28 spot and did the following: Shane battered ex-UFC man Riddle with rabbit punches, threw Kevin Owens out of the match, then went after Brock Lesnar before eventually being eliminated. His five minutes in the match proved to be some ego trip.

What more did he want?! Did Shane honestly think that winning the Rumble, or being one of the final two with Brock, was the way to go? Whatever his plan was, it'd cost him. Vince "quietly released" his son from contract a few days after the pay-per-view.

Oops.

When else has ego cost wrestlers everything? For more like this, check out 10 New Directions For WWE After Royal Rumble 2022 and 10 Totally Unnecessary WWE Gimmick Changes!


Watch Next


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.