10 Times Shane McMahon's Ego Ran Wild In WWE

Being the boss' son certainly has its benefits.

Shane McMahon Underground Dancers
WWE

Whatever you think of Shane McMahon, it would be fair to say that he’s given a lot to the wrestling business. Build a tall structure and he’ll happily hurl himself off it. Show him a pane of glass and he’ll allow Kurt Angle to chuck him through it. A glorified stuntman he may be, but he has put his body on the line for some unforgettable spots and surprisingly great matches.

And then there are the less commendable parts of his career. The times when being the boss’ son has clearly paid off, and he has clearly shucked and jived to find himself in some positions he has had no right to be in.

It’s genetic - Vince and Stephanie have similarly gold-laden careers - but no one seems to lack self awareness quite like Shane. He has a tendency to let his ego run wild, and fails to countenance the idea that audiences don’t want to see more Shane.

For all the good he’s done, these are the times he has gotten carried away, let the power go to his head, and basically used the family business to live out his fantasies.

10. AJ Styles At WrestleMania

AJ Styles Shane McMahon
WWE.com

It’s worth noting up top here that Shane McMahon vs. AJ Styles at WrestleMania 33 was actually a really decent match. Shane turns up with a point to prove and gives perhaps his best in-ring performance. While much of the quality is down to a superstar of Styles’ incredible skill shepherding the lesser McMahon through the bout, it’s one of the better matches on the card.

What’s less easy to swallow is the booking. Shane pretty much goes hold for hold with Styles, even taking control for decent portions of the match. He has been studying MMA holds and is as eager as a kid at show and tell to demonstrate them.

The lead up to the match was pretty flimsy, too, with the “beef” between Styles and the then-Smackdown commissioner difficult to believe. It’s pretty obvious that McMahon wanted a match against someone as reliably great as AJ to ride that wave of acclaim.

And the thing is, it worked! Judging the match on its own merits, it’s good, fun pro wrestling. Really it’s only the behind the scenes stuff that can leave a bit of a bad taste.


9. Raw Underground

Shayna Baszler RAW Underground
WWE.com

Raw’s ratings have never been worse, and while it can be explained away to a degree by the empty arenas necessitated by the pandemic, the fact is the creative side of WWE is in a pretty stale state. Plenty of the matches are still good to great, but with a few exceptions the angles are undercooked, stories started and dropped at random.

Shane McMahon believes he has the answer to this, though. It seems Shane recently watched the 1999 film Fight Club, and concluded that a no holds barred street fighting division held in the basement is just the shot in the arm the flagship wrestling show needs.

Raw Underground is devised and hosted by Shane (the irony of the man with the worst worked punches in the business anchoring the segment is not lost), and has so far consisted of superstars with little else to do battering no name spectators.

It’s different if nothing else, and whether this will do anything for the ratings remains to be seen. What it certainly has achieved is to give Shane a lot of screentime, though.


8. Feuding With Kane

Shane McMahon Kane
WWE Network

The removal of Kane’s mask was a story seven years in the making. The execution of the angle perhaps wasn’t what it could have been, stymied by some lame makeup and a lack of forward thinking, but in freshening up the character, WWE immediately had a new top monster on their hands. There were so many angles they could have launched with this terrifying, reinvigorated character. It couldn’t have been hotter.

Somewhat bizarrely, one of the first things WWE creative did was to book the big red maskless monster into a multi-PPV angle with the boss’ son. Shane McMahon vs. Kane was triggered by the latter tombstoning Shane’s mother Linda, so there was a certain amount of sense to it, but there were surely more exciting things we could have done with the character.

Instead we were given a couple of gimmick matches, a spot involving Shane’s testicles getting electrocuted, and Kane eventually destroying the kid. The seven foot beast’s dominance over a diminutive non-wrestler did nothing for either character, but served only to dilute the immediate impact of what should have been a huge moment.


7. Six Months Kevin Owen Will Never Get Back

Shane McMahon Kevin Owens
WWE.com

In late 2017, Shane McMahon began a feud with Kevin Owens. This started out alright enough, and fans assumed it would be blown off fairly quickly to allow for an actual professional wrestler to embark on an actual professional wrestling angle.

Then it went on, and on, and on, Multiple pay per views saw the two locking up or otherwise exchanging hostilities. The feud went all the way up to WrestleMania 34 (making this Shane’s third in-ring performance in a row at the company’s biggest event), with McMahon going over.

This would be the end of the feud for any sane booker, as the fans (and probably Kevin Owens) had grown more than tired of the angle. For just over a year, there was peace. Then, the angle resumed, culminating in a match at SummerSlam, i.e the company’s second biggest event.

Owens won, the crowd liked it fine, but boy did this storyline ever stagnate quickly. It’s safe to assume Shane believed he was elevating the status of one of the company’s best workers, and it’s easy to see how he’d think this, but the primary result of this angle was far more Shane McMahon on our TV screens.


6. Beating The Miz

WWE Money In The Bank 2019 Shane McMahon The Miz
WWE.com

In between chunks of his feud with KO, Shane decided he needed something else to keep him on TV, and began a programme with The Miz. In fairness, this made a little more sense, as Miz didn’t have a lot else to do, and the two bounced well off each other. But unsurprisingly, this led to yet another WrestleMania match for McMahon (making this four in a row).

What’s more - Shane actually won this match! It was a perfectly fine falls count anywhere brawl, with Shane taking the win by pure happenstance, landing atop his downed opponent after a Miz superplex from some scaffolding, but it’s hard to see the sense in this.

Rather than allowing Miz to take a dominant win, give himself a little boost, and put this feud to bed, this was another tick in Shane’s wins column. They’d go on to fight at Money In The Bank where, once again, Shane picked up the victory.

In both instances, the matches are allowed to go for some while (in MITB’s case, their match is almost as long as both women’s world title bouts). It’s not hard to work out why.


5. The Mean Street Posse

The Mean Street Posse
WWE.com

This was a case of nepotism piled upon nepotism. For all his good qualities and genuine talents, it’s undeniable that, were his last name not McMahon, Shane would have had at least a harder time breaking into WWE. And if their best pal’s last name weren’t McMahon, then you’d definitely never have heard of Pete Gas and Rodney.

The Mean Street Posse - two of Shane’s real life childhood pals plus ringer Joey Abs - were hired as backup for the prodigal son, and by sheer luck managed to rack up a hefty number of TV appearances. They interfered in some prominent events, and each have a Hardcore Championship win to their name (albiet an extremely brief one in every case).

None of them were totally inept - Abs especially had a solid career behind him - but once their association with Shane was over, they were shown the door quickly enough.

If we had the chance to get our close mates cushy jobs we’d probably do it too, but most of us don’t have the sway to get our childhood pals on an actual WrestleMania card.


4. His Record

Shane McMahon Drew McIntyre
WWE

You’re on thin ice when you’re talking about win/loss records in professional wrestling because, ultimately, it doesn’t really matter. Politics and the basic nature of the business means that your stats don’t necessarily reflect your quality as a performer - they’re not the metric by which a wrestler should be judged.

Still, when you take a look at some of the names Shane McMahon has victories over, it does boggle the mind somewhat. Mankind, X-Pac, Roman Reigns, Dolph Ziggler, Steve Blackman, and The Big Show have all done the job for the boss’ son. That’s a collection of world champions, main eventers, Royal Rumble winners, and Steve Blackman.

Naturally many of these wins involve shenanigans, but that’s par for the course in pro wrestling no matter who you are. A win’s a win, foul play or otherwise.

When your last name happens to be McMahon, there’s no getting around the sense that the boy wonder pulled a string or two to line up a hearty W column for his legacy. Then again, he is the best in the world. Talking of which...


3. Best In The World

Shane McMahon Crown Jewel
WWE

Trying to figure out who thought this was a good idea, and why, is a fool’s errand. Crown Jewel 2018 was centred around a tournament to crown the Best In The World (said tournament was populated entirely by American wrestlers, but let’s not go there). After a series of perfectly fine heats, it came down to Miz vs. Dolph Ziggler in the final. Two quality workers - what can go wrong?

Well, Miz could (kayfabe) blow his knee out. Following that, Shane McMahon could insert himself into the final of a three-legged tournament, and then beat a 14 year veteran of the company in under three minutes. That’s pretty wrong, alright!

If this was supposed to bring heat on Shane, it didn’t, not in a good way at any rate. Fans knew that they were going to get plenty more of McMahon at his smuggest as a result, which precisely no one tunes in for. It didn’t lead to a good angle, or a comeuppance.

It’s hard to see this in any way other than: Shane McMahon fancied calling himself the Best In The World, and manufactured a tournament in order to make it so.


2. An Epic With The Undertaker

Shane mcmahon undertaker
WWE Network

Shane McMahon’s 2016 return to WWE was a feel good moment, a genuine nice surprise for the fans. That almost immediately turned sour, because the first thing he did was enter into a dreadfully lazily set up Hell In A Cell match against the Undertaker at WrestleMania 32.

From the off, there are so many problems with that. The execution was dreadful - Undertaker was brought in to do Vince McMahon’s bidding, for some reason. Beyond kayfabe, though, Undertaker was on his last legs here. He’s one of the biggest stars the industry has ever known with a handful of WrestleMania matches left, and you’re wasting one on the boss’ son?

Then, there’s the match itself. Like with AJ, Shane goes blow for blow with ‘Taker for much of the bout. It’s far more egregious here, though, because it runs 30 minutes and is almost entirely dull.

Props must go to Shane for plummeting off the cell at age 46, but if that’s all he really wanted to do, could he not have just shown up for this spot, allowing Undertaker to have a better match with someone else? No - because he’s Shane McMahon.


1. Retiring The European Championship

Shane McMahon European Champion
WWE

When Shane McMahon first stepped into active competition, many heads unsurprisingly began to shake, but he more than exceeded audiences’ low expectations. While he was no A grade performer, he worked far better than expected. Giving him the European championship was going a bit too far, but his matches were far from unwatchable, so no one really cared too much.

Then, 43 days into his reign, he decided to vacate the title, wanting to retire as an undefeated champion. The title was declared vacant, and nearly three months later Mideon happened upon the belt in Shane’s bag, with the boss’ son declaring the former pig farmer the new champ, because why not.

It’s impossible to see who this helped. Shane looked like a spoiled brat, not a dastardly heel. Mideon was given nothing from the angle. Most of all, the European championship was made out to be a plaything. If a McMahon didn’t care about it, why should we?

This was Shane acting out just because he could, undoing his decent work to this point. It did nothing but harm to the belt and his brand.


Contributor
Contributor

Yorkshire-based writer of screenplays, essays, and fiction. Big fan of having a laugh. Read more of my stuff @ www.twotownsover.com (if you want!)