10 Times The Competition Totally Embarrassed WWE

In which the CZW garbage boys do a better version of an angle than Steve Austin and Undertaker...

Steve Austin Samoa Joe
WWE/ROH/CZW

WWE is arrogant. It just is.

Look at the structure of the company - NXT in particular - and what it even means for there to be an NXT.

NXT exists because WWE values the wider wrestling world with such patronising disdain that it is felt a finishing school is necessary. This, incidentally, renders the recent talk of cross-promotion very fanciful. Throughout the latter part of the 2010s, WWE signed countless incredible talents from the independent scene and didn't dream of putting a single one of them, beyond AJ Styles, on the main roster. They hadn't yet learned the "playbook" of which Triple H spoke on the eve of NXT Arrival.

And you think because Daniel Bryan thinks Otis would bang in the G1 that Vince McMahon is going to throw open the Forbidden Door and let Shingo Takagi explode through it? He doesn't even know how to look shocked when somebody kicks out of Made In Japan. This process takes at least three years.

NXT is perceived as developmental internally because virtually every talent is dispatched there to "develop". This happens because WWE by default is "better" than the competition, irrespective of how significant or otherwise the competition is.

Except, on more occasions than you'd think, it decidedly is not.

10. The CZW/ROH Inter-Promotional Feud

Steve Austin WCW WWE Champion 2001 Invasion
WWE.com

In 2001, WWE promoted the "Invasion" angle in which ECW and WCW - gutted, bastardised versions obviously - waged war with the WWF.

It was a painful disaster. Nobody bought Stone Cold Steve Austin as a WCW guy because he in effect became Stone Cold Steve Austin by savaging his original WCW run in ECW. Stephanie McMahon in a Kangol hat was a cursed image. The WWF did next to nothing - less than nothing, in fact - to build the invaders as a legit threat. It was just more bullsh*t McMahon melodrama that didn't even bother to masquerade as anything else.

Historically, WWE has looked at (or down upon) independent wrestling as a series of exhibition matches worked by guys who get too much sh*t in. This is why they are dispatched to the PC: to learn how to talk and how to unlearn bad in-ring habits. Triple H is on record, in 2014, saying that indie guys have "zero ability" to talk.

That's funny, because the ROH Vs. CZW feud of 2006 accomplished everything that the Invasion did not.

An unpredictable war between two evenly positioned companies, the programme extracted every glorious story beat from a bottomless narrative: set against a backdrop of ultra-heated tribalism, this bloody, philosophical war incorporated uneasy and unholy alliances alike as individual ambition undermined the united front in ROH, and the united front in CZW was only finalised through a shocking, temporary truce.

It was amazing - literally as great as the ECWCW Invasion was atrocious.


9. AEW's Wednesday Night War Victory

Kenny Omega Face
AEW

Remember, it's a marathon, not a one night sprint!

If the idea wasn't to beat AEW, but to siphon the audience well enough to stave off RAW-level numbers - and it was - the defeat to the tawdry competitor was still an embarrassment with major, long-term repercussions.

NXT developed an air of off-putting desperation - essentially turning heel through spite in the minds of the exact audience it targeted - and is now watched predominantly by old dudes who were fans of the WWWF. NXT was and is meant to be the cool, hip brand. WWE sacrificed that, and has lost any "street" credibility it once had in doing so.

WWE threw almost everything at this war: TakeOver main events as TV openers; a revisit of its longest and most successful programme; title unification matches; Ladder matches to earn the advantage for WarGames matches; the headlining star of WrestleMania...

Nothing worked. AEW won, and won a $174M rights fee. AEW encouraged its key assets to get over using their own expression, built future key assets by encouraging them to get over using their own expression, and got these assets over by carefully and steadily building intricate long-term storylines that hooked the bigger audience over the long term.

When people are embarrassed, they project to the contrary. Triple H was a giant piss baby in the aftermath, which says it all.

"The war-uh was only-uh imaginary-uh!"


8. ROH Take Madison Square Garden

WWE MSG Vince McMahon
WWE/MSG

In 2018, Ring Of Honor, red-hot through the meteoric rise of the Elite stable, negotiated with Madison Square Garden officials. They wanted the venue for WrestleMania 35 weekend.

This shouldn't have been a problem; after all, WWE had opted in recent years to run the cheaper Barclays Center in Brooklyn, old traditions be damned.

Only, because Vince McMahon literally has more in common with a toddler than an adult - he likes toilet humour, is incredibly irrational, and gets bad-tempered before a feed - he decided that it was his toy first, pal. Leveraging an old exclusivity arrangement in an attempt to thwart the show, it looked like it wasn't going to happen. But then it did, because when MSG pulled the date under the threat, Sinclair - the group that owns ROH - threatened him right back in the form of legal action. Vince relented in fear of annoying FOX, affiliates of which are owned by Sinclair, only one month after striking the deal to air SmackDown.

Ultimately, ROH embarrassed itself on the night by strapping up Matt Taven in a heat stunt, indulging Bully Ray, and - in a an angle that never gets credit for being plausible, at least - having Enzo Amore invade.

The NJPW part of the show was fantastic, mind.


7. Developmental In General

Pwg Logo
PWG

The global scene and the independent circuit created more WWE stars than WWE's in-house talent developmental system, and, were it not for Jim Cornette's stint in Ohio Valley Wrestling, this would be a Sid Vicious Vs. Marko Stunt squash match of a W.

When Cornette left WWE in 2005, so too did any remote semblance of sense. OVW continued as a star vehicle for CM Punk - who didn't exactly need it, since he was such a sensation in ROH - before Paul Heyman's exit torpedoed an operation that WWE severed ties with in 2008.

In the meantime, an agreement was struck with Jody Hamilton to oversee Deep South Wrestling. The feeder promotion was such a disaster that the students actively preferred humiliation over training, choosing to eat jelly donuts from an a**hole acting as a plate than endure Bill DeMott's torture.

FCW produced more name acts than DSW - Roman Reigns and Big E were developed under the respected learning trees of Dusty Rhodes and Dr. Tom Prichard - but it drew flies, imposed the same style, and most of those who did emerge from the territory as stars took several years to get over. Drew McIntyre had to leave.

NJPW, ROH and PWG, primarily, created the headlining stars of the modern era.

Kenny Omega; Adam Cole; Kevin Owens; Kyle O'Reilly; AJ Styles; the Young Bucks; several others: all emerged from the expressive playground of Reseda and/or the work-embracing confines of PWG's more serious counterparts. Where range and creativity was valued, top stars emerged. Where style and persona was imposed, stars had to get over in spite of it.

Even, in Drew's case, in storyline.


6. The Presentation Of Jon Moxley

Jon Moxley
AEW

Hell, even Combat Zone Wrestling - a promotion meme'd to death for its hysterical macho bullsh*t - gave Moxley his shot. CZW was better and more versatile than the JAYSUS memes, of course, but that's not part of the narrative.

The narrative is that CZW was no-selling mud show garbage wrestling.

And yet, Mox emerged from it as the wrestling headliner so cool, and so admirable as a human being, that he rescued 2020 for fans mired in a pandemic and disenchanted with the worst sleazes of an historically disgusting industry.

But not before WWE almost ruined him entirely.

He was great in the Shield. The Shield were great. Not great was the Mountie cosplaying, condiment-spraying prankster who had to be wacky because he had great comedic timing. As is so often the case, the comedian became the punchline.

In NJPW and AEW, Mox was reborn as an hilarious hard-case who swaggered his way through the brutal rhythms of strong style and got over as the whip-smart one-man wrecking machine overcoming the odds of a gang of bastards. He is the best John Carpenter lead this side of Kurt Russell.

He got all the way over by bringing back a level of danger and selling it with a promo game as witty as it is incendiary.

On the subject of which...


5. Promos

MJF AEW
AEW

"We don't trust you yet."

Those were the words of Brian 'Road Dogg' James, who spoke on After The Bell with Corey Graves last year about WWE's creative process. Promos are "scripted word for word," he said, under the belief that WWE contracts a group of "loose cannons" - as opposed to generations of talent too sh*t-scared to approach Vince McMahon's office - who might do something too "wrasslin'" on national television. You know, like get over as artists.

For two decades, the scripted model has persisted. For those two decades, WWE has created fewer stars than it has throughout its history. The correlation is obvious to all but the performative positivity accounts and the undiscerning brainwashed that follow them.

And, yes, AEW has illuminated how dumb and arrogant this approach is.

MJF effectively promoted a successful pay-per-view main event, ahead of All Out 2020, by adding a genius wrinkle to his heel persona. The only person worse than MJF is a politician. So he evolved into one. MJF, who cuts piss funny promos utterly convincing in his self-belief and the hatred he holds for his opponents, just scored AEW's first-ever #1 cable ranking.

WWE's approach can't even begin to grasp what AEW has done with Darby Allin - the new quarter hour demo god - whose ominous short films effectively create an atmosphere of danger around his matches. If he was on RAW, he'd say the word "relentless" about 80 times in every 10 minute promo.

You need a lot of words to fill those three atrocious hours.


4. The Presentation Of Sting

Sting AEW
AEW

Circling back to the contrast in how WWE presents a performer versus AEW's vision - an exercise worthy of a list in itself - Sting is the most striking example.

In AEW, Tony Schiavone erupted in nostalgic euphoria and roared "It's Stiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiing!"

In WWE, Triple H was gotten-to and roared "F*ck Stiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiing!

WWE wanted Sting, in what was more entrapment than promotion, to remind everybody that WCW was f*cking sh*t and that they lost. The losers. Sting was a loser. And he lost at WrestleMania 31. Just like WCW lost the Monday Night Wars! JBL said, nearly tearing his c*ck off in delight before remembering that it was a perfectly serviceable hazing instrument.

WWE did not really like nor even respect Sting as an ageless mythical legend. AEW promotes him as one.

The presentation is not perfect. AEW is limited in what they can do with a man who can only take a limited number of bumps, but because he's f*cking Sting, he's there a lot and sometimes engages in pointless, repetitive brawls.

But the presentation is faithful and stunningly effective at it best.

The sight of Sting in full reckoning mode, coming back from a terrifying bump to bring an end to Team Taz tyranny, was as brilliantly timeless as the Icon's appeal.


3. Being The Elite > WWE RAW

BTE Kenny Omega
Being The Elite

Being The Elite isn't the show it once was - it's still fun, but it's d*ck joke fun, not actually great episodic storytelling fun - and one can make a convincing argument that it's still a better pro wrestling show than WWE Monday Night RAW.

But that's because virtually anything is, even being buried alive.

In 2017, before a bad RAW show descended into this atrocity of a thing, Being The Elite was still far superior to the flagship as an entertaining show that effectively promoted star acts and kept viewers on the hook with various mysteries.

In 2017, on RAW, the Bayley character was killed off when she was repackaged as a timid, feckless wallflower.

On BTE, Adam Cole was killed off to get Marty Scurll over as the new 'Villain' of the Bullet Club. Scurll's horrific, confessed sexual misconduct has of course tainted those old memories, but he was undeniably over as a result of the twisting, well-crafted plot.

In 2017, on RAW, WWE teased a mystery centred on Kurt Angle's shameful secret. It was revealed that Jason Jordan was his son, in a development that nobody bought and didn't even make for perversely entertaining TV. Why didn't he cheat and get over as a d*ckwad heel knowing his General Manager da was going to overlook it?

On BTE, the Elite teased a mystery centred on Kenny Omega's penis. This resulted in an hilarious rib at the expense of Seth Rollins, further getting the Elite over as sh*t disturbers.

In 2017, on RAW, WWE was so bad at building stables that the Miztourage turned into the weirdest rogue's gallery ever at TLC.

In 2017, on BTE, the Elite got so over that the fractured dynamic of the group resulted, at Supercard of Honor XII, in ROH's biggest ever house.


2. WCW Throughout The Monday Night Wars

Eric Bischoff being a bit of an arsehole
WWE Network

Trace back the history of WWE, and the extent to which Vince McMahon almost got in his own way really is striking.

He saw little in the Undertaker and less in Steve Austin. Thought Tom Magee was such good sh*t, instead of merely sh*t. Thought the Royal Rumble was dumb. Didn't think Bret working Owen Hart was a good - or even relatable! - idea.

He was a master at eventually marketing that which he did eventually grasp, but it took a long old time for him to grasp the shifting landscape of the mid 1990s.

For 83 weeks, his self-aggrandising "recognised market leader in global sports entertainment" patter was exposed, calculably, as bullsh*t. He was battered, frequently, as WCW developed an awesome formula of workrate range, twisting mystery, and the ability to market the stars of the 1980s with a 1990s aesthetic.

The New Generation was great, insofar as its intricate storytelling and peak in-ring. Wildly, Vince's product at its best was the purest form of great technical wrestling and rugged brawls. WWF was more JCP than WCW in 1995, bar Vince's age-old aversion to the heavy heat angle.

This embarrassment, once again, was sold by a transparent attempt to no-sell it via those wretched War Room skits.

I'm not owned, I'm not owned, Vince continued to insist as he slowly shrank and transformed into a corncob.


1. AEW Convincing Shaq To Work A Proper Match

Shaq AEW
AEW

WWE tried for years to convince Shaq to work a proper match with the Big Show.

It was teased via a showdown during the Andre the Giant Memorial Battle Royal at WrestleMania 32 with the idea of promoting it at next year's Orlando-held event.

It never happened, rendering the mewling cries of "You'd have hated that Shaq match if it was in WWE [cry-laugh emoji x7]" utterly irrelevant. WWE couldn't get his name on the contract. "If," "if," "if". It's always "ifs" with some people.

Sadly, nobody will ever know!

Shaq revealed back in 2017 that WWE "kept playing" and ultimately "messed it up". And wouldn't you just know it, Vince McMahon's trademark tinkering pissed him off enough to end negotiations. Shaq was first told that he'd work Show one-on-one. This changed to a three on three. Then, according to Shaq, it was cancelled outright.

AEW of course did secure the signature, and after a drawn-out build throughout which he didn't seem particularly up for it, he over-delivered on the night. Mauling Austin Gunn; fancy footwork as a great heel taunt; unleashing a better powerbomb, legitimately, than many actual wrestlers who used it as a finish: Shaq was awesome in the strictest definition, and he ate two tables to get a shockingly great celebrity match all the way over.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Jon Moxley
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!