10 Times The Past Buried WWE's Future

WWE's stars of tomorrow hindered by its stars of the past.

Kevin Nash Triple H Cm Punk
WWE.com

There's always room for nostalgia in WWE. The warm glow of past glories is celebrated on almost every broadcast, as fans everywhere are reminded of the landmark moments that helped mould WWE into the wrestling behemoth that it is today. The unfortunate downside to this train of thought, though, is that sometimes the past comes back to stomp WWE's current crop of stars with all of the force of Godzilla's size 98 foot.

This particular problem ran rampant under Vince McMahon's stewardship. Nobody was safe from WWE's geriatric past, as the sight of decrepit old bastards beating wrestlers in their prime would happen with infuriating regularity. Fans were routinely trained to expect their current group of superstars to be brutalized by Vinnie Mac's legends of the past, both in small TV segments and occasionally in the biggest matches of the year.

These moments where nostalgia went off the deep end would include the company's biggest championships changing hands, and even the Royal Rumble wasn't safe from the heroes of WWE's past burying the company's present and future stars. The following are some of the most extreme cases of WWE's past ruining WWE's future.

10. The Rock Defeats CM Punk At Royal Rumble 2013

Rock Punk
WWE.com

CM Punk's 434-day run with the WWE Championship was heralded as one of the greatest triumphs of the 2010s. During an era when it felt as though booking decisions were intentionally made to make fans apoplectic, Punk enjoying arguably this period's greatest championship reign felt so good because it felt like an exception to this rule.

Taking that on board, it's no surprise that CM Punk's reign came to an end in the most infuriating way possible. The Rock returned and declared himself number one contender for Punk's championship at the 2013 Royal Rumble because he'd beaten John Cena at the previous year's WrestleMania. The legend with a part-time schedule then defeated the new era's greatest superstar for the title at the Rumble, despite being cooked like a Sunday dinner roast chicken by Punk's "your arms are too short to box with God" promo in the build to the event itself.

Because that wasn't quite enough to annoy fans who'd seen CM Punk discarded like a snotty tissue, The Rock then beat him again at the following month's Elimination Chamber. The message was clear: your indie darling has just been crushed by the Tooth Fairy, and there's nothing you can do about it. This was compounded by Punk being beaten by more part-timers in quick succession, losing to The Undertaker at WrestleMania 29 and Brock Lesnar at SummerSlam 2013.


9. JBL Buries The Ascension

JBL Ascension
WWE.com

NXT had never seen a tag-team blitz through the brand's competition quite like The Ascension. Booked like absolute monsters, Konnor and Viktor routinely dominated teams in devastating fashion. Showcasing a look that echoed Demolition and The Road Warriors, this team may have lacked originality, but they definitely had a style that was useful in an era where tag teams lacked personality and individuality.

Enter, JBL. 

The WWE's color commentator would regularly side with the company's heels, but he took one look at The Ascension's bad guy antics and was having none of them. Verbally assasinating the pair for their contrived look and for being fed lowly competition after they hit the main roster, JBL would tell audiences that Konnor and Viktor couldn't hold a candle to the teams they were echoing on a weekly basis.

In JBL's defence, he always felt like the mouthpiece for Vince McMahon's thoughts, and Konnor and Viktor being ran through by the nWo and other veteran acts with alarming regularity suggests that this was the case with The Ascension. Nevertheless, Bradshaw's treatment of one of NXT's top tag-teams of all time was so brutal that it's something he's still flamed for to this day.


8. Goldberg Defeats Kevin Owens For The Universal Championship

Goldberg Kevin Owens
WWE.com

Kevin Owens is an all-time great talent. Superb as both a babyface and a monster heel, he has indie credibility, shone like a diamond in NXT, has multiple WrestleMania main events under his belt, and was able to thrive under the most difficult of WWE circumstances: Vince McMahon's creative. 

Arguably, Owens' greatest moment on WWE's main roster came when he won a fatal four-way on the 29th August, 2016 episode of Monday Night Raw to win the Universal Championship.

Coming after Finn Balor's unfortunate injury stopped him from having a run with that new title, Kevin Owens defeated Roman Reigns, Seth Rollins, and Big Cass(!) to be given the task of establishing the championship as one of WWE's premier titles. Owens managed that with ease, showing exactly why he deserved to compete at the top of the company. He went through Seth Rollins in a Hell in a Cell war and racked up multiple wins over both Rollins and Roman Reigns during an impressive 188-day run with the Universal Championship.

Then Kevin ran into Goldberg at Fastlane 2017. Losing his title to a 50-year-old man was questionable, but the manner of KO's defeat flushed months of hard work down the toilet of establishing him as a top-tier talent. Like he was some kind of local enhancement talent, Owens was beaten in just 22 seconds.

This was just one of a billion reasons why new stars were unable to break through Vince McMahon's glass ceiling during McMahon's last decade in charge of WWE creative.


7. Hulk Hogan At WrestleMania IX

hulk hogan wrestlemania 9
WWE.com

Among seasoned wrestling fans, Hulk Hogan is as known for his backstage politicking as he is for his numerous in-ring achievements. "That doesn't work for me, brother" is as synonymous with the red-and-yellow superstar as "whatcha gonna do..." and encouraging fans to say their prayers and take their vitamins. His magnum opus of political s**thousery came at WrestleMania IX.

During an era where WWE was trying to find its way as a business after the glory days of the Golden Era, Vince McMahon was moving towards superstars who were younger and more impressive in the ring. Bret Hart fit every criteria you could ask for in this regard, and Yokozuna was the perfect monster heel champion walking into WrestleMania IX.

The stage was set for Bret's glorious coronation, until The Hulkster reemerged. WrestleMania IX has one of the worst endings to any PPV in wrestling history, with Hogan ending the night as WWE Champion in a match he wasn't even in. Yokozuna beat 'The Hitman', and Mr. Fuji offered an open challenge to the WWE locker room for absolutely no good reason.

Enter, Hulk Hogan. 

Bret Hart encouraged Hogan to take the match, making Hart look like nothing more than a pink-and-black-clad Hulkamaniac, and Hulk won the title in 21 seconds. This debacle took WWE years to recover from, as their world title lost all credibility, all in the name of one more shining moment for Hulk Hogan.


6. Brock Lesnar Destroys Riccochet

WWE Super ShowDown 2020 Brock Lesnar Ricochet
WWE.com

When he was on the indies, Ricochet was a phenomenon. Clips of his superhuman athleticism would spread like wildfire in an era when more of a spotlight was being shone on the global independent scene than ever before. NXT did a great job of signing standout talent, and when Ricochet joined the rising brand, it felt like a match made in heaven.

Ricochet did great work in NXT, but his mic skills and Vince McMahon's love for bigger, meatier men always made it questionable how much impact Ricochet could have on WWE's main roster. His talent was undeniable, but his booking left a lot to be desired, as the company didn't really know how to lean into his death-defying ring work to increase his popularity.

Things hit an all-time low when Ricochet was booked to face Brock Lesnar at Super Showdown 2020 in Saudi Arabia. Lesnar swatted Ricochet's opening dropkick like he was a bug, and proceeded to decimate the flexible superstar in a 90-second victory. It showed that WWE's booking team didn't value Ricochet's skillset and saw him as nothing more than an enhancement talent. Try to remember this humiliation the next time you see Ricochet's Twitter fingers having a moment online.


5. Kane Ends Zack Ryder

Kane Zack Ryder
WWE.com

Matt Cardona spent several successful years on the indies, launched many great wrestling-related products for fans, and eventually fulfilled his wish to make his way back to WWE after being released in April 2020. It's been a hell of a ride, but his initial run as Zack Ryder remains a damning indictment of WWE's inability to listen to fans in this particular era.

Ryder's internet TV show, Z! True Long Island Story, was revolutionary, as he built a bond with fans on YouTube and got his "bro" persona over outside his allotted TV time. It seemed as if WWE higher-ups had taken notice of this, as Zack was given stories that included a blossoming friendship with John Cena, an endearing relationship with Eve Torres, and putting the US Title on him at TLC 2011.

We should have known better, as within 12 months, Cena kissed Eve in front of Ryder (while he sat injured in a wheelchair holding roses), and Kane went full Attitude Era on poor Zack. The Big Red Machine launched one of the most heinous attacks of his career by hurling Zack Ryder off the Monday Night Raw stage while Ryder was still in his wheelchair on the January 16th, 2012 episode. 

WWE's lovable 'Broski' didn't get his revenge on Kane in any meaningful way, Eve Torres shrugged as her former boyfriend was yeeted from a great height, and Ryder would flounder in WWE's lower midcard from this moment on. 


4. DX Bury The Revival

hhh revival
wwe

FTR are quite rightly considered one of the greatest tag teams of this (or any) generation. Their no-nonsense brand of hard-hitting, smash-mouth technical wrestling has been a joy since the pair rose to prominence in NXT as The Revival. The former Dawson and Dash were never quite as revered as they should have been on WWE's main roster, and they were yet another victim of WWE's old boys club.

Monday Night Raw's 25th anniversary was a big deal, with D-Generation X getting back together for their usual schtick. Triple H, Shawn Michaels, Road Dogg, and Billy Gunn were even joined by Scott Hall, with Finn Balor, Luke Gallows, and Karl Anderson joining the party to throw up their Too Sweets for a seal of approval.

There was no such friendship for The Revival. Dawson and Dash were thrown to the old folks home, taking multiple finishers from all of the legends of yesteryear for nothing more than cheap cheers. This spot is fine if WWE used a comedy character or a team they have no plans for in this spot, but to feed The Revival to a bunch of old timers who were certain to leave our screens after one night of glory was an absolute travesty. 


3. Batista Wins the 2014 Royal Rumble

batista royal rumble
WWE.com

WWE and its fans have rarely been at odds with each other more than at the start of 2014. The company was gearing up for WrestleMania 30, and the popularity of Daniel Bryan's 'Yes Movement' was at an all-time high. So, naturally, Vince McMahon had Daniel Bryan booked for a midcard 'Mania showdown with Sheamus, instead opting for a returning Batista to main event the biggest show of the year against Randy Orton. 

Batista felt like the wrong guy in the wrong place at the wrong time as soon as vignettes started to build anticipation for his big comeback. Just one year on from WWE making their hardcore audience shake with rage at The Rock coming back to steal the WWE Championship from CM Punk before sodding off back to Hollywood, fans were determined not to see Daniel Bryan suffer the same fate.

Vince McMahon cared not one bit about this, of course. Batista entered the Rumble at number 28 and spent just over 13 minutes in the ring before winning the whole thing and punching his ticket to the main event of WrestleMania 30 to a chorus of boos from the Pittsburgh crowd. Even poor Rey Mysterio was greeted with a hail of jeers as he entered at number 30 for the crime of not being Daniel Bryan, with the leader of 'The Yes Movement' being left out of the match entirely.


2. Triple H Kills The Summer Of Punk

Triple H CM Punk Night of Champions
WWE

'The Summer of Punk' can mean two distinctly different things. In Ring of Honor terms, the summer of 2005 is heralded as one of the greatest periods in that company's history. Despite all rumors that he was leaving the promotion, Punk won the ROH Title from Austin Aries, unleashed one of the most unexpected and rapturously received heel turns of all time, put on a slew of great matches, and bowed out of the company for good to join WWE. And then there's the WWE's Summer of Punk.

After winning the WWE Championship from John Cena at Money in the Bank 2011, hot on the heels of his infamous Pipe Bomb, the expectation was that WWE would strap a rocket to the Straight-Edge Superstar and capitalize on the new eyes on their product. What they proceeded to do was the polar opposite of this, as Punk dropped his title to Alberto Del Rio at the next PLE, lost a number one contender's match to Cena, and got into a feud with Kevin Nash that made absolutely no sense whatsoever.

They weren't done there, though. Triple H would wrestle his only match in six months to defeat CM Punk at Night of Champions in a move that felt like a sledgehammer blow for many reasons. Firstly, it ensured that The Summer of Punk was a complete bust, but, crucially, it felt like Vince McMahon and his son-in-law rejected the WWE Universe's love of the 'Second City Saint' in no uncertain terms. Punk and the audience's call for change had been answered emphatically. No chance, that's what ya got.


1. Goldberg Embarrasses The Fiend

WWE Super ShowDown 2020 Goldberg Bray Wyatt
WWE.com

Bray Wyatt's struggles with WWE's creative department are well-documented. From his creepy backwater beginnings through the Firefly Funhouse to the sinister menace of 'The Fiend', Wyatt struggled to get his true vision across to WWE fans, as it was constantly being meddled with by people who didn't understand his characters or the horror genre that Bray drew influence from. 

Nevertheless, 'The Fiend' would overcome these odds and find popularity. It may have always been a Diet version of Bray's intentions, but 'The Fiend' is still revered by fans to this day. That is an unbelievable achievement when looking back at some of the abysmal booking Wyatt had to suffer, the worst of which came in Saudi Arabia at the hands of Bill Goldberg.

Taking on Goldberg at Super ShowDown 2020, Bray Wyatt's 119-reign with the Universal Championship came to a screeching halt. 'The Fiend' was hit by four Spears and one of the worst Jackhammers of all time, as he was destroyed in less than three minutes by the then-53-year-old. This felt even more insulting, as it came one year on from Goldberg's match at Super ShowDown 2019 with The Undertaker, which is comfortably one of the worst matches in The Phenom's long and illustrious career. It was an insult to 'The Fiend', Bray Wyatt, and fans everywhere.


Contributor

Terry Bezer hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.