9. The Entire Royal Rumble 2011 Team
Cole wasn't so quick to notice something seven years earlier.
During the 2011 Royal Rumble, Alex Riley slipped during a spot with Cena and Kofi Kingston; the NXT protege failed to hold onto the ropes as planned and was thus eliminated from the match. Both Cena and Kingston stared at one another with a look that clearly said, 'Oh sh*t - what do we do now?'.
On commentary, Cole, Jerry Lawler, Matt Striker and guest announcer The Miz continued talking up Riley's cleverness as a reason why Miz had decided to mentor him the prior year. They did this for an alarming amount of time before someone finally spotted that Alex wasn't actually in the ring anymore.
Christ knows how the foursome missed Riley's accidental elimination. The Rumble ground to a halt when it happened, and Cena's facial expression alone told the world that the bout's format had just been f*cked. Pay attention, guys!