10 Times Wrestling Fans Turned On Internet Darlings

Fickle, or stale?

Mr Kennedy SummerSlam 2007
WWE.com

*Professional wrestler endures slump in form, fails to do anything new or interesting for several years, has simply "molecules" in common with the performer who was once so over or promising*

r/SquaredCircle: "God, wrestling fans are so fickle! You liked him when was good!"

Dr. Dre told Kendrick Lamar that anybody can get it; the hard part is keeping it, motherf*cker. Staying over is hard, particularly within a system that functions to make getting over incredibly difficult. There are pratfalls everywhere.

Look out - there's Vince McMahon, and he's unscrewing a lightbulb and motioning you towards a darkened room. Oh no - there's a WWE creative writer, and he's asking you to repeat a key word over and over and over again because "the thick tw*t marks won't understand, otherwise". And oh man - there's a road agent, and he's telling you you don't know how to work, which is funny, because you're not convinced Billy Kidman wrestled like Randy Orton in 1998 WCW, but he's in the bubble just like you're in the bubble now. You're all Stamford Wives in a fundamentally broken system.

So good luck staying over, pal...

10. Damien Sandow

Damien Sandow Money In The Bank Valise
WWE

Damien Sandow was tremendous value as the Intellectual Saviour of the Masses; nobody likes to be told they are dumb, and Sandow was very good at telling people they were dumb.

He held the microphone like a glass of red, wore a delectably smug expression, and his entire disposition was perfectly affected in the way he executed his arsenal. With a classic, guaranteed heat-seeker of an act stripped of any problematic connotations, he was destined for a top heel run.

It didn't happen, of course, since the apparent genius couldn't work out when best to cash in his Money In The Bank briefcase. Christ, even Jack Swagger managed it, and he didn't even know how to unhook the f*cker.

Sandow was subsequently demoted following his burial, but retained the support of the crowd through the endearingly naff (but admirably committed) Damien Mizdow schtick and its much-needed comedic relief amid a period during which belief in real systemic change had started to erode. Sandow left as most WWE wrestlers do - as a squandered would-be megastar - in 2016.

He shored up in Impact Wresting, in which he was the Fonz to the Pipebomb's shark-jump. The hollow rhetoric wasn't substantiated - it was a disaster of a run - and for years, Aron Rex contrived to subvert the most ingrained narrative there is.


9. TJP

TJP WWE
WWE.com

TJP has this tremendous gift on social media that proves incredibly helpful in this age of profound information overload: his posts are invariably dumb. The longer the dumber, in fact, which saves a lot of scrolling. If TJP has spent that long discussing something, it is assured that he has lapped himself, as he proved recently when warning of the dangers of groupthink and the echo chamber...

...in a post shared only between certain people of his choosing.

It wasn't always like this.

In 2016, TJP stole the hearts of the hardcore WWE fan by opening himself up about his tough upbringing and winning the superb Cruiserweight Classic following a string of emotive and incredibly accomplished performances. And yeah he got booed a bit and did f*ck all on the main roster, but then again who does?

TJP ruined this goodwill, variously, by no-selling the ongoing global health crisis and revealing to the world who the real racists are, and get a load of this, man, if your imprisoned mind is open enough to grasp it: it's actually the people who profess not to be racist.

Whoa.

Get a load of Neo over here!


8. Chris Jericho

Chris Jericho WrestleMania 33
WWE.com

Do you know why Chris Jericho is so great at this?

In addition to being a tremendous, versatile professional wrestler who is charismatic, keenly intelligent, and genuinely piss funny, not just wrestling funny?

It's because he knows precisely when to put himself over. He knows then that his words have far more weight. He wasn't banging on about being the master of reinvention in 2016, certainly, when he rocked back into WWE as the basic thrust of the Y2J character complete with new - and not particularly good - patter in the form of "rooty tooty booty", three immature words that rhymed in a row. That was the height of the patter, and if you think "turned on" is strong, type them into Google. The first result you'll see is a self-titled r/SquaredCircle thread in which the OP wishes "Jeridad" would "go home".

Jericho was defiant on his podcast in the aftermath of a wave of criticism, but he must have taken it to heart.

This wasn't the first time he had returned as simply "Y2J", feeling more civic center than stadium-sized, and he took to working on new material that very year, embarking on a renaissance from which he hasn't looked back - nor stopped reminding us of, to never, ever again relinquish the narrative.


7. Mr. Kennedy

Ken Kennedy Money in the Bank
WWE.com

The world was his, and then he dropped it at a dangerous angle with a back suplex.

People loved Mr. Kennedy - your writer included - because he pre-dated the workrate era and carried himself like a megastar at a time when WWE could actually build them, or at least persisted after three weeks.

Hi Ricochet Shayna Baszler Bianca Belair Brendan Vink Humberto Carrillo - how ya doin'?

A gifted mic man, Kennedy's booming proclamations of his own greatness were enough to convince us all of his main event credentials. The confidence he radiated was infectious, and the booking matched it: there was nothing remotely over-ambitious about Kennedy's pledge to cash in his Money In The Bank briefcase at WrestleMania XXIV: he belonged on that stage, and his assurance of that fact was consistent with a character WWE were very committed to putting all the way over.

It was at this point that a plague of rotten luck threatened to babyface a natural heel, which wasn't ideal, but his inner dumbass surfaced to save the day, restoring his heel aura via disastrous media handling.

WWE however didn't have the appetite anymore - he was stigmatised as a sh*t disturber - and when he left, he never did find a set of clothes.


6. Triple H

Triple H
WWE.com

The Big Show has turned heel far more often, but never has he straddled such extreme ends of the spectrum, with Motörhead on full blast, as Triple H.

The man has shifted from the destroyer to the saviour of U.S. professional wrestling over the course of a divisive career defined by euphoric highs, catastrophic lows, and mid 25 minute matches playing out to removed silence.

He first earned the ire of the hardcore set by being very bland, less over than his valet, and draping his craven shoulder around the arm of Shawn Michaels, but won them over with his á la mode lowbrow jock antics in 1998. He practised *Lionel Hutz vioce* heel work 101! in 2000 before practising *Lionel Hutz voice* heel work 101 in 2003, a year so awful that his fictional work in the form of a villainous quasi-combat athlete was compared to that of a terrorist.

But he won them back, following a babyface performance he could never hope to replicate in the ring, with his unbelievably great and even wholesome stewardship of NXT, with its heartwarming underdog stories and scintillating in-ring action divorced from the patterned, dull main roster in-house mode.

Then NJPW gained traction in the west, to which he responded by fighting critically acclaimed fire with critically acclaimed fire, reimagining NXT as a glorified banger exhibition league lacking in soul, killing several Indies by thieving their soldiers for the fight.


5. Becky Lynch

Becky Lynch Truck Entrance
WWE.com

The woman so immune to WWE's scripting that she became a superstar in spite of it, Becky Lynch succumbed to it in the end. Nearly.

After a great run ahead of WrestleMania 35, all that slowly ebbed away when WWE do-declared Lacey Ehhh-vens as #1 contender to her RAW Women's Title, resulting in a series of poor matches. Lynch was dragged down to Lacey's level - which, since she was nowhere near for the role, was sub-developmental - and she cooled off significantly, not helped by an onscreen association with real-life partner Seth Rollins tempered by palpable awkwardness.

Her standing improved following a belting programme opposite Sasha Banks, but then the van came around ahead of WrestleMania 36 as Lynch took to driving an articulated lorry with her face emblazoned all over it. The implication that she had gone to the effort of customising a geet big truck for herself depicted her as a try-hard, and if this was part of a pride-comes-before-a-fall character development, that was rather undermined by the fact that she handily defeated Shayna Baszler inside 10 minutes.

The cosplay Conor McGregor had fulfilled the prophesy, but before some mouth-breather first attached the 'Super' prefix to her good name, she got the hell out.


4. Dolph Ziggler

Dolph Ziggler
WWE

Dolph Ziggler was a fabulous midcard talent it turns out was mistaken for a main event talent in an era just before the global standards of professional wrestling blew up.

Ziggler was incredibly "SquaredCircle over", praised for years as the most under-utilised talent in the WWE system. He could work excellent, lung-bursting TV matches and the bumps, fahgeddaboutit!

Seriously, forget about them. They knackered him, if anything.

Ziggler made absolutely everybody look like a beast flying around that ring, but it was an attribute that split the office and the fandom; they didn't see him as a believable main event-level threat, where we valued greatly the craft about which they couldn't really give a f*ck. Ziggler felt right on when he took to moaning about his spot and being that damn good, which he was, but then the North American landscape changed rapidly in 2014 - the year after his fans had exhausted the sort of ardent support a wrestler tends to draw only once. You can't maintain that energy.

Suddenly, Ziggler - the man who looked like Mr. Perfect in contrast to David Otunga - looked like Dolph Ziggler next to Sami Zayn, Neville et al.

He kept moaning, which didn't help, and after 2016, he seemed more or less stuck in a distant past.


3. Seth Rollins

Geek Seth Rollins
WWE.com

You know, if Seth Rollins had just shut the f*ck up, he'd have been all right.

The WWE machine is so fundamentally broken that the discourse of pro wrestling absolves the independent contractor of any responsibility in their downfall. It's perceived as the evil empire, and since they won't allow their talent to wear protective face masks behind the plexiglass - they are to look like fans, real fans, in this demented uncanny valley - it almost certainly is.

A wrestler could develop a beer gut and barely turn up, and all they'd have to do is "Like" a tweet complaining about their burial to convince the fandom that they are in fact being buried. The WWE sports entertainer is as protected by the fandom as they aren't by the office.

Seth Rollins missed that point and indeed all other points quite spectacularly on Stomping Grounds Eve ahead of a show that A) was headlined by Baron Corbin and B) was so poorly attended that a recent big US NJPW show had out-drawn it, making his bizarre "WWE is the best pro wrestling on the planet" flex wrong under at least two criteria.

He doubled down dawg, entered into a meltdown, and suddenly, the super-worker of 2015 had become the living, laughable embodiment of the Stand Up For WWE campaign.


2. Pete Dunne

Pete Dunne
WWE

In 15 years' time, when a suit-wearing Pete Dunne waltzes into shot on NXT UK, making a main event match for tonight, he will have earned the spot and you mustn't begrudge him. He's putting the hard work in now by assuming the role of British wrestling gatekeeper on Twitter, surfacing rarely - but with a stern authority, much like a Brummie Jack Tunney - to show errant UK talent "the way".

Or rather, what isn't "the way".

When a BritWres lad attempts alien concepts such as "banter" or "not staunchly defending WWE without irony", they earn a b*llocking from Dunne. WWE has helped the Independent scene, he reminds them, the evidence for which he appears to have eaten at the finger food buffet, Nigel!

There's a common misconception about Dunne's wrestling nickname of the 'Bruiserweight'. It's not a pun, but rather a portmanteau of "bootlicking cruiserweight," and this sort of behaviour has earned the ire of a home nation left without much of a scene to enjoy.

Pete Dunne is an absolutely fantastic professional wrestler, but the former PROGRESS World Champion is about as punk rock as Avril Lavigne, not that he'd profess to listening to anything of the sort.

"You like Motörhead? No way, me too!"


1. Kenny Omega

Kenny Omega Jon Moxley
AEW
"I see Kenny Omega is only working ****1/2 matches in America. He sucks now!"

- Wrestling fans.

The intense/insane scrutiny applied to AEW conspired to create a Kenny Omega backlash ahead of and into the early Dynamite era.

Even though it was made very clear by the messaging ahead of launch that the show would not resemble Being The Elite, the Wrestling Twitter mutants were appalled by Omega's unhinged, sniffing character, firmly expecting it to sh*t the bed on national television. He didn't play it, of course, instead playing a rocked version of his Best Bout Machine persona to allow the more famous Chris Jericho to establish the AEW World Heavyweight Title as the company's first Ace figure. But Omega - not pushed to that level by design - was no longer a star, apparently, even though he'd just shocked a wrestling world desensitised to violence in a genuine attraction that headlined a very successful pay-per-view.

Omega rebounded by design in 2020 by capping off the best episodic storyline on a wrestling TV show in years before working the greatest tag team match ever at Revolution.

Omega - never received as anything less than a star by live crowds - was in his post-Mellon Collie, Ava Adore transition from NJPW to U.S. TV, and that run should in time receive a similar critical reappraisal.


In this post: 
Mr Kennedy
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!