10 Times Wrestling Recklessly Abused Kayfabe On-Air
"It's Still Real To Me, Dammit!"
Though not an entirely lost art, the act of protecting kayfabe in 2017 is no longer considered the high priority it once was within the industry.
Amongst other things in the modern era, social media has had a particularly damaging impact on the suspension of disbelief required to aid enjoyment of a pretend fight between two foes.
During WWE's mid-2017 European tour, Titus O'Neil's Instagram showed then-rivals Braun Strowman and Roman Reigns soaking up some history together on a tour of Rome. Enzo Amore used the same medium to share a selfie with Ric Flair hours before he made a 'surprise' appearance on SmackDown Live! to celebrate his daughter Charlotte's maiden blue brand title victory.
Whilst not acceptable to ask work colleagues and friends not to spend time together during long, arduous tours within their long, arduous profession, it's is reasonable to request that jovial snaps are not shared through such a public medium.
The plaster was long ripped off for adults, but there's a magic in pro wrestling for younger fans that disappears with the same rapidity of a Santa Claus/Tooth Fairy revelation, and incidents such as these effectively render some of that sparkle all but moot.
Though these may be different times, this sort of thing has been going on for decades. In the 1990s, certain creative minds felt that a peer behind the curtain equalled a surge in ratings, forcing the dreaded 'worked shoot' into wrestling's big box of tropes for generations to come. Some were successful. Some were utterly inexcusable.
10. TakeOver Makeover
Triple H loves being the ultimate babyface on NXT.
At the point in which he sensed just how popular his pet project became, he did what every other promoter with similarly delicate self-esteem has done when times are good, and put himself right at the very front of it.
Regardless of who the big stars have been during any individual TakeOver special, or what history was being made as attendances soared and the brand grew, 'The Game' made sure to remind fans that he was the architect of it all.
And this is not an argument against that. Since stepping into his current role in 2012, 'The Game' has been a revelation in ploughing forward with his grand plan to revolutionise talent development in a company that looked determined to repeatedly fail at it, but his love of taking public credit for the fact did absolutely no good for the divisve talent he was allegedly trying to elevate over the top on the main roster.
Wracked with rage following a cheap TLC WWE Title pay-per-view loss to Sheamus in December 2015, Roman Reigns sought vengeance on his oppressor Triple H, brutalising him to rapturous cheers previously unheard by the 'Big Dog'. It was an explosive segment designed to build tension for The Game's return and their WrestleMania match.
Triple H stubbed that out just three days later by opening NXT TakeOver: London with his usualy hyperbolic spotlit introduction. It was a pointless and destructive ego-driven decision that completely undermined the gravitas of the violent assault.
9. Character Assassination
There's a lot to unpack with this one, but it's the Attitude Era, so of course there is.
In mid-1998, The Undertaker revealed an alliance with his brother Kane after months of fighting, that was in-part to relieve Stone Cold Steve Austin of the WWE Title. Which helped Vince McMahon deal with his biggest problem, making them allies. Until McMahon got a little too cocky about their relationship and had his leg smashed to pieces by the Brothers of Destruction.
Ultimately their fragile relationship crumbled, allowing Kane to turn face and Undertaker to go full heel and form an evil 'Ministry of Darkness' alongside Paul Bearer and a host of pretty useless midcarders. It was within this group that he went off the deep end, committing atrocities under the leadership of a mysterious 'Greater Power' and attempting a hostile takeover of McMahon's entire company.
This in turn actually turned Vince quasi-face. Despite his unending war with Austin, he looked sympathetic on his knees as Undertaker set fire to his daughter's childhood teddy bear.
McMahon bit back, suggesting on television that 'Mark Calaway' was maybe taking his gimmick a little too seriously, suggesting that he really believed he was actually The Undertaker. Because actually trying to be the person you play on television is a...bad...thing?
It was a ludicrous assertion within pro wrestling's complex universe, but was forgotten weeks later anyway, when Vince himself was revealed as the Greater Power after all! All to get to Stone Cold Steve Austin. Massive buyrates. Huge ratings. Zero sense.
8. No Sale
Mankind and The Rock's on-off relationship was emblematic of the chaotic Attitude Era main event scene, with reigns as beloved tag team champions coming just months after 'The Great One' came close to murdering Foley with a hideous series of unprotected chairshots to the head.
Shortly before their rivalry really heated up following Rock's November '98 heel turn though, the pair were two thirds of a steel cage triple threat match to determine the Number One contender to the WWE Title that Rock would eventually scoop a month later.
Alongside third man Ken Shamrock, the triumvirate had been physically and verbally abusive to one another for weeks in the run up to the huge semi-main event of September 1998's Breakdown: In Your House pay-per-view.
Given separate promo time as the old blue bar cage was being assembled, they all let loose with a final barrage, but it was surprisingly a scathing Mankind that left the biggest impression with his near-the-knuckle onslaught.
Chastising Kevin Kelly for his stupid question, he talked about other stupid things in the world (including Bill Clinton's liaison with Monica Lewinsky), but noted that 'nothing rivalled The People's Elbow for sheer stupidity'.
Turning up the heat for his last blast, he followed up by insisting that 'If you think Mankind in a pay-per-view match inside a steel cage is gonna lay down and sell that abortion, you're even stupider than I look.' It was a caustic reduction of one of the most over spots in wrestling history.
7. Running Mates
After such a thoughtless destruction, it almost feels like The Nexus were never even that much of a threat to WWE's established roster, but for a small period in 2010, the NXT Season 1 group were absolutely unstoppable.
After their June Monday Night Raw arrival, weekly stand-offs between the group and WWE representatives were a highlight, with Wade Barrett's crew utilising their numeric advantage for calculated gang assault on the traditionally divided heel and babyface superstars.
Over the weeks this gradually changed, with uneasy alliances formed between locker room rivals, particularly during the electrifying build up to a blockbuster seven-on-seven SummerSlam main event. With a roster cautiously united, The Nexus were forced to hit and run, leading to an unintentionally cringeworthy moment on Monday Night Raw in which wrestling's fourth wall was hilariously smashed.
After the group targeted John Cena, the superstars showed unity in chasing Barrett and co right out of the building, but a rather over-enthusiastic 'Worlds Strongest Man' shattered the illusion by mistiming a cue and gingerly running alongside (and in some cases, in front of) half the departing gang!
In a subsequently absurd scene, Henry is overtaken by over half the heel field he calmly jogged ahead of, including a game Heath Slater who improvised a scuffle with the big man in an effort to keep the chase looking even remotely credible.
6. Buff Does His Job
Vince Russo's WCW was full of moments that annihilated the very concept of kayfabe in a flawed effort to mimic the times he'd strayed just close enough to the sun without burning during his lauded WWE tenure.
Under his leadership, Nitro became morbidly enjoyable but utterly impossible to watch as a television show designed to tell reasoned and well-threaded stories.
October 18th 1999 was his first night on the job (as viewers were informed on camera by Tony Schiavone and Bobby Heenan earlier in the broadcast, as if it remotely mattered), and Buff Bagwell became the first recipient of one of his most infamous 'edgy' plot devices.
Entering earlier in the night for an interview that 'wasn't on the format', Bagwell cut an enthusiastic promo about being 'the chosen one' by his 'new bosses', but looked thoroughly disinterested when he emerged for his match against La Parka later in the broadcast.
As the announcers alluded to him not looking his usual self, Buff cut a frustrated figure throughout the entire contest, basically mocking all his usual taunts and completely exposing the traditional rhythm of the match. Presenting himself for La Parka to kick him in the head, it later turned out that management had told him he wasn't their top guy after all, and that he was due to lose to the Mexican star. His display was thus entirely in protest, and completely contradicted the fundamental rules one has to accept about professional wrestling as a whole.
Again, it was Vince Russo's first Nitro.
5. Kliq Bait
The WWE experienced seismic changes between during 1997, but as highlighted in numerous reviews of the Attitude Era's embryonic stages, a host of intentional and accidental incidents during 1995 and 1996 led to so many of the historic moments that would occur in the years that drove the company back to the summit of the wrestling industry.
By October, D-Generation-X was just about fully formed in all but name, as Shawn Michaels and Triple H basked in the glory of 'HBK's Hell in a Cell victory over The Undertaker at the previous evening's Badd Blood: In Your House pay-per-view. The duo opened Raw (following a sombre ten-bell salute to Brian Pillman for which they remained backstage) with a rampaging worked shoot promo speaking mostly about their own brilliance whilst ripping to shreds much of the silliness the endured during WWE's troubled New Generation Era.
Michaels in particular was in rare form as he ruthlessly positioned himself above the entire roster in establishing his unwillingness to 'lay down for anybody' as a catchphrase just days after he'd said exactly that to Bret Hart for real backstage. It was then things turned goofy, as Shawn and Hunter replayed found footage of the infamous Madison Square Garden 'Curtain Call' that saw Helmsley demoted and Michaels demonised as the pair bid fond farewell to best friends Scott Hall and Kevin Nash.
In May 1996, it was an unacceptable and unthinkable contravention of kayfabe. Just over one year later, it was already a subversive grasp for ratings.
4. Tears Before Bedtime
Triple H went rogue yet on live television yet again, or more specifically didn't, with the 'Cerebral Assassin's icy temperament appearing to melt away as he enters his autumn years.
By January 2015, 'The Game' and wife Stephanie McMahon had reacquired control of Monday Night Raw less than a month after losing it 'forever' in November's Survivor Series main event, and were back to their usual tactics in attempting to cut down every major babyface for no hugely discernible reason.
That week, it was the turn of John Cena, who took an absolute kicking at the hands of The Big Show, Seth Rollins and Kane as The Authority took aim at the 'Leader of the Cenation'. Naturally this upset many of those very supporters, including one young boy sat front row right next to where the malevolent 'King of Kings' had placed himself to watch the action.
The child burst into tears at his hero taking such a thrashing, but rather than playing up to the drama, Triple H immediately broke character to console the lad and arrange for him and his father to go backstage and meet the wrestlers.
It was an astonishingly public reversion of old habits, especially considering that the kid's emotional manipulation effectively proved how good a job they were doing at re-visiting the tired old trope.
3. Beach Balls-up
Probably the most infamous Vince Russo moment from his incident-filled time in WCW occurred at July 2000's Bash at the Beach pay-per-view.
Four years earlier, the company transformed the entire industry within the very same building as Hulk Hogan turned heel, forming the New World Order alongside Kevin Nash and Scott Hall to run roughshod on the WCW roster in a long-running angle that would briefly propel the Atlanta outfit above Vince McMahon's monolithic WWE.
Russo's mere presence represented the desperation of the company by the time the show rolled around in 2000, having been poached from McMahon in an effort to revive the promotion after it began it's terminal collapse in 1999.
Hogan was again at the centre of controversy, but the twist ending this time took a very real, and expensive turn.
A planned WCW Title contest between 'Hollywood' and Jeff Jarrett failed to materialise, as 'Double J' hit the ring and lay down flat at the behest of authority figure Russo, allowing Hulk to cover him with one foot and win the Championship. Hogan snarled at Russo and cut a scathing promo, before leaving for the night with the belt.
Later on in the broadcast, Russo the character returned to explain his actions, but the work became a shoot as he spat bile at 'The Hulkster' for his 'bullsh*t politics' and pledged that fans would never see that 'big bald son of a b*tch' again. It proved true. Incensed and planning legal action as a result, Hogan and WCW severed ties completely, rendering the whole mess costly as well as inherently stupid.
2. Jamaican Him Crazy
To call Randy Orton's behaviour unpredictable would something of an understatement, with WWE attempting to foster his rather complex attitude problems into the model version of a 'superstar built from the ground up', as John Bradshaw Layfield incessantly chirps on about.
Guilty of a host of backstage misdemeanours, 'The Viper' has let his frayed temper get the better of him under WWE's bright lights on more than one occasion, but his most infamous tantrum came at the conclusion of a Triple Threat match with John Cena and Kofi Kingston.
Battling for a shot at Sheamus' WWE Title, Cena was engaged with Orton's Legacy subordinate Cody Rhodes, leaving Randy and Kofi alone to resume a conflict that had almost elevated Kingston to the upper echelon before Orton's senseless victory at December's TLC pay-per-view.
With Cena displaced, Kofi performed his trademark leap onto Orton in the corner, but completed his 10-punch attack before Ted Dibiase has interfered, forcing them to unconvincingly redo the spot and slightly undermine the eventual Dibiase intervention.
Orton was visibly livid. Shoving Kingston to the ground, he callously pawed at him before RKOing him and audibly screaming 'STUPID' in his face before forgetting to celebrate the victory in anger. Incandescent with rage, he screamed 'STUPID, GODF**KINGDAMN IT' again on camera before the shot finally shifted to a confused WWE Champion Sheamus, who was stationed on the ramp observing the entire charade.
1. The Professionals
A slightly forgotten moment of madness from WCW's final days saw Bill Goldberg positioned as a real life heel as well as an on-screen one he was badly miscast as.
It started in July when the heel character Goldberg defeated Kevin Nash to cheaply deny Scott Hall's return to the company. 'Big Sexy' then mentioned in a spurious worked shoot sitdown interview with Scott Hudson, in which he indignantly inferred that if he fought Big Bill, he'd 'go over'.
This insanity was to build tension for a match featuring both men and Scott Steiner at WCW's disastrous New Blood Rising pay-per-view later that month.
The three way dance wasn't particularly engaging until the final third, when Nash set Goldberg up for the Jackknife. Bill slipped out, briefly stared Nash down, then marched off to the back.
He was met half way by Vince Russo, who ostensibly instructed him to get back in the ring before being left alone courtesy of a middle finger and a 'f**k you' from one of WCW's greatest ever homegrown creations.
As commentators waffled nonsense about 'improvising', Nash polished off Steiner with his finisher, as Mark Madden cynically uttered 'at least he went up for it Goldberg', attempting to aid the useless facade.
The wrestling business may have been relatively well exposed by 2000, but such senseless objectification of the parameters undercut literally everything else a viewer had seen before or after the broadcast, draining what little credibility WCW still had left.