10 Times WWE Forced It Down Our Throats
WWE is going to force feed you, and you're damn sure going to like it.
WWE doesn’t have a great track record when it comes to subtlety.
Actually, scratch that, WWE doesn’t have a track record when it comes to the lost art of delicacy, preferring instead to smash its audience over the head with a hammer until the minutiae of its storylines are as apparent as the sky, the moon, the sun and the stars. Leave nothing to chance, that’s the company motto when it comes to layered storytelling.
Sifting through the history books for the most egregious examples of this is an exercise in wasting ink and paper; the examples are just too numerous. Not a year goes by without Vince McMahon and co. (largely just Vince McMahon, really) picking something that must be rammed home, a buzzword, or a character, but more often than not an unstoppable babyface. In 2020, it has become a self-parody.
The largest wrestling promotion on the planet seems to have forgotten that people don’t like being told what to like. Maybe they never knew? Either way, WWE has a tendency to shove things down the collective throat of its audience, stubbornly sticking to its ideas whether you like it or not.
10. Lex Luger
There is a parallel universe out there, a world where Lex Luger is the biggest, most popular professional wrestler of all time. Luger’s career was one of false starts and erroneous dawns, of championship wins cut off at the legs by the rotten shadow of pro wrestling politics. Luger could have been the NWA’s new hope in the late ‘80s, and a decade later he gave WCW one of its all-time biggest pops in beating ‘Hollywood’ Hulk Hogan. It just never worked out.
Luger was brought into WWE in 1993 as ‘The Narcissist’, a heel who was more interested in his own physique than his matches. Judging by the quality of WWE’s in-ring product in 1993, he may have had a point.
But Luger’s mega-push came once the heel experiment ended, when Vince McMahon needed another bodybuilder to take over from the red and yellow-shaped hole left by Hulk Hogan. ‘The Narcissist’ became an All-American Hero, draped in the stars and stripes and given an actual bus in which to tour the country. No, not a Mike Awesome type of bus; this was the Lex Express.
What’s more, Luger was given the honour of being the first to bodyslam Yokozuna, doing so on an actual American warship no less. On July 4. Possibly while eating a hot dog and chugging beer, although that can neither be confirmed nor denied. It was all a little too much, which is code for "it was way, way, way too much," and the fans predictably rejected Lex Luger as their new American saviour.
9. Johnny Gargano Vs. Tommaso Ciampa
'Steve Austin vs. The Rock.
Kevin Owens vs. Sami Zayn.
Ric Flair vs. Sting.
Shawn Michaels vs. Bret Hart.
Professional wrestling is built on rivalries that span years, decades, generations. These are the pillars on which an entire industry rests, where icons are made and nostalgia formed. WWE’s problem (well, one of WWE’s problems) is that the mass of content that the modern world demands leads to any potential modern versions of these feuds being oversaturated almost immediately.
The Johnny Gargano/Tomasso Ciampa rivalry is the best example of this. The feud has spanned five years, but WWE’s insistence on returning to it means it feels like it has lasted a lifetime.
Injuries have played their part. While Gargano has stayed largely injury-free and thus had feuds with other people (Andrade and Aleister Black, most notably), Tommaso Ciampa’s bad luck on the medical front means his NXT run has been almost entirely taken up with Gargano-related things, be they with or against. Who else has Ciampa feuded with over his time in NXT?
WWE has done all that it can to make the fans believe that this is the greatest rivalry in NXT, that these two former best friends are forever entangled in a dance with death. All of that may well be true, but boy oh boy are some fans sick of it.
8. Sheamus
In 2020, Sheamus is a hard-working staple of WWE’s midcard, a consistent guy who can have decent matches with anyone and everyone, and one of the promotion's most reliable tag wrestlers. He is all sorts of underrated, and his advancing years mean the dream of an NJPW run (Sheamus vs. Ishii? Sheamus vs. Suzuki? Sheamus vs. EVIL?!) diminishes all the time.
2009 Sheamus was the most over-pushed guy in the business, an out-of-nowhere story that went from 0 to 60 in no time. Sheamus made his ECW debut that summer, and a couple of cups of coffee later he found himself putting John Cena through a table (sort of) and becoming WWE Champion. It all happened in a blur, a pasty, ginger blur that may or may not have been Triple H’s workout partner at the time. Who knows?
It didn’t end there. Sheamus hung around the upper echelons after losing the title, but it wasn’t until his marvellous face turn autumn 2011 that the mega-push began, an incredible feat when you take into account the whole "166 days between debut and World Championship" thing. He won the Royal Rumble and the World Heavyweight Championship within months of each other as WWE tried once again to make the Irishman the face of SmackDown. It didn’t work.
Sheamus is one of those strange cases, a wrestler once overrated who is now under-appreciated. He may deserve better right now, but nobody needs a rerun of the hyper-pushes he received in 2009 and 2012.
7. Rocky Maivia
Dwayne Johnson can do whatever he likes. The former Flex Kavana is one of the biggest stars on the planet, a mainstream media icon who may have started in pro wrestling but will finish wherever he god damn pleases, be on the silver screen or even the poisoned chalice of the White House. It isn’t outside the realm of possibilities.
All of this was most certainly outside the realm of possibilities when a young Rocky Maivia was floundering in the face of Vince McMahon’s expectations. A rocket was strapped to the company’s first third-generation star from the get-go, a sole survivor debut followed up by Intercontinental Championship glory and all the attention one could want. It was sickening, in truth.
And the fans agreed. It didn’t take long for the audience to turn on Rocky, bringing about a heel turn and the development of one of the most important characters in the history of pro wrestling, further proof that Vince McMahon isn’t the creative genius many believe him to be. In his world, Rocky Maivia may have been the biggest babyface on planet wrestling by the end of 1997. Instead, we got The Rock, and everyone was better off for it.
6. The Fiend
It’s The Fiend! That’s The Fiend! The Fiend Bray Wyatt! That’s Bray Wyatt, The Fiend! The Fiend is here! The Fiend with the mandible claw! The Fiend!
The booking of Bray Wyatt since his return in the summer of 2019 will have its own chapter in the eventual ‘Death of WWE’ bestseller. It was a whirlwind of classic WWE tendencies, proof that the company has little patience and even less faith in its audience. It started with "spooky" toys in boxes, transitioned into the most intriguing vignettes the company had produced in years before degrading into mindless branding that nobody could see, because of those stupid, stupid red lights.
Many critics wondered how the Bray Wyatt character would play out once it moved into the ring. Wyatt didn’t have a reputation for being the most dynamic in the squared circle, but maybe this new, streamlined Bray would offer more? Critics needn’t have wasted their time, as WWE took all intrigue out of it all by spamming The Fiend in impossible-to-watch squash matches.
A slow build may have worked but this is WWE, "slow build" may as well be kryptonite. Wyatt was shoved down the throats of all and sundry ahead of winning the WWE Universal Championship, and you can make your own mandible claw joke there. You know, because The Fiend uses the mandible claw, and that involves fingers and throats and shoving. Get it? The Fiend! The Fiend Bray Wyatt!
5. Rey Mysterio, Doing It For Eddie
Eddie Guerrero's death is one of the saddest, most tragic events in pro wrestling history. His was a true redemption story, of a man who took himself to the brink only to drag himself back, overcoming the most pernicious of personal evils on his way to becoming the most beloved star of a generation. When Eddie died, pro wrestling lost something it could never regain.
Which makes it all the more frustrating and despicable that WWE has used his death as the metaphorical horse over the years, flogging and flogging until there’s no flogging left to do, only to continue with the aforementioned flogging. Rey Mysterio’s rise to the World Heavyweight Championship immediately after Eddie’s death came before all the flogging, but it may have been the most glaring example.
Even before Rey Mysterio won the Royal Rumble in 2006, the story was Eddie Guerrero. As Rey came out to celebrate on the next episode of SmackDown, Eddie was mentioned multiple times before Mysterio himself. In case you weren’t aware, Rey was doing this for his friend Eddie, his mentor, his brother. He’s doing it in an Eddie Guerrero shirt, copying Eddie’s poses, occasionally using the frog splash and driver away in a lowrider. Eddie! Eddie!
The story was so lacking in subtlety that as Rey pinned Randy Orton to win the World Heavyweight Championship at WrestleMania 22, boos were audible around the audience. Imagine that? Only the sledgehammer that is WWE could create such a scene.
4. Roman Reigns
WWE has tried and tried and tried with Roman Reigns, much to its detriment. Coronating the 'Big Dog' has been an annual tradition for half a decade now, and it took a health crisis to stop the same happening in 2020.
Has the Roman Reigns push been as bad as fans believe? Like most things in the world, the answer to that is both yes and no. Sure, Reigns has been given ample opportunities to establish himself as this generation’s transcendental star, but he is a great example of the company’s failings as opposed to his own. Reigns has consistently had great matches with opponents as varied as AJ Styles and Braun Strowman, but he has done so in an era where fans are wise to the inner-workings of the game. He never stood a chance.
Reigns also had the misfortune of coming into prominence while the Daniel Bryan phenomenon was in full flight, and the audience had no interest in cheering for a company-anointed hero over their own champion. Reigns breaking Kane’s Royal Rumble eliminations record was very well done, and if Reigns had won that match then his present may have been different. But he didn’t, and it isn’t.
WWE has spent half a decade obsessively trying to make Roman Reigns the biggest star in the company, oblivious to the damage caused by such a strategy.
3. John Cena
John Cena doesn’t get the respect he deserves. There, that wasn’t so hard, was it?
'Big Match John' is the last of a dying breed: a transcendental talent who outgrew the company that made him. WWE has had performers who may have grown to the same level of popularity, but it has learnt its lesson from years of making stars. WWE is the attraction, not its individuals. This will eventually lead to the death of the company as we know it, but that’s another story for another time.
Somehow, someway, being shoved down the throats of the WWE Universe didn’t lead to the death of John Cena as a top babyface star. "Cena" and "Overcoming the Odds" might just be the most iconic couple in modern WWE, but fans today may never really understand the visceral hatred Cena inspired in the audience, vitriol that came about as the company tried to make him the most loved man in the industry.
Nobody in the modern age was as all-conquering as John Cena. He won, he always won, even when faced with seemingly insurmountable odds. It was boring, but it kept happening. By the time Cena no-sold a DDT on the concrete floor and single-handedly vanquished The Nexus, a convincing argument could be made that it was Wade Barrett and co who were at a disadvantage.
Cena isn’t deserving of the criticism that has been thrown his way over the years. WWE’s relentless approach to booking him should take all the flack.
2. Hulkamania
Nostalgia is a powerful beast. Aside from coating the past in a comforting glow, it renders the present rotten. Everything was better in the good old days, especially in professional wrestling. As John Cena and Roman Reigns enjoyed monster pushes, fans clamoured for the days of yore, simpler times, better times.
If you think the pushes handed to Cena and Reigns were excessive, you should finish work on that time machine and head back to the 1980s, but you better build a resistance to all things red and yellow before you do. Hulkamania was everywhere as Hulk Hogan took the then-WWF on his back and ran it into the stratosphere, taking wrestling into the mainstream. For many, Hulk Hogan is and was professional wrestling.
Announcers spoke of Hogan with awe usually reserved for the immortal as opposed to The Immortal™, while the heels made dastardly plans to end Hulkamania, once and for all. WWF was full of larger than life characters but there was only one top guy, a balding moustachioed man who was the image of all that is good with the world. He was also the image of every single bit of merchandise the company could devise.
Hogan main-evented seven of the first nine WrestleManias but was left standing tall at the climax of all nine. Even as colleagues such as Randy Savage and Bret Hart were given a little more attention, it was Hogan that remained the be-all and end-all of good guys in McMahon-World.
1. The McMahon Family
Vince McMahon may make a good argument for being the greatest single performer in WWE history, but the discovery of that fact has done more damage to the company's creativity than most events of the last 25 years. Yes, it gave us the biggest drawing character in company history (Steve Austin), but it also gave us a lifetime of the McMahon Family being all over the product, at all times.
Vince is the be-all and end-all here, the final say, the big bad of WWE booking. How many times has he used that position to position Stephanie McMahon as the saviour of women’s wrestling? How many times has he used it to put Shane McMahon in matches he had no place being in? The McMahons have been positioned as both wrestling’s salvation and its damnation, and only one of those is true.
You don’t need to make a song and dance about the WrestleMania 2000 main event, but it doesn’t hurt. "A McMahon in Every Corner" was the tagline, but the show was more like a bad dream, one where the ruling dynasty was everywhere and anywhere. Fast forward to the present day and they are never that far away, ready to swoop in when ratings fall (ratings always fall) and act as the most important humans on the planet.