10 Times WWE IGNORED The Fans (... And Got It Right!)

Because the WWE Universe isn't always correct.

Lita Edge
WWE

Since WrestleMania 39, one constant amongst wrestling discourse is whether or not WWE should've had Cody Rhodes topple Roman Reigns to become the new Undisputed WWE Universal Champion at this year's Granddaddy of Them All.

Going into 'Mania 39, it seemed a shoe-in that the American Nightmare would finish his story and slay the Head of the Table, precuring himself the title that his father never won. Instead, Solo Sikoa interference saw Rhodes come up short, and he now finds himself in the midst of a rivalry with Brock Lesnar.

As per Paul Levesque in the post-WrestleMania 39 press conference, Cody's story isn't finished and instead has simply had further chapters added to it. From the Game, the 'Mania loss for Rhodes was all part of a greater plan. What that greater plan looks like remains to be seen, but WWE opting to ignore the huge support behind Cody at the Showcase of the Immortals was certainly a bold choice.

Of course, over the years WWE has never been afraid to go against what its fanbase wants. And in fairness to the market leader, there have been times when those seemingly odd, stubborn decisions have actually turned out to be correct.

With that in mind, then, here are ten times WWE was proved right by ignoring its audience.

10. The Undertaker And John Cena Keep It Short 'N' Sweet

WWE WrestleMania 34 Undertaker John Cena
WWE

Regardless of how John Cena goofily sat in the crowd supping beer, pondering whether the Undertaker was actually going to show up to answer Cena's challenge at WrestleMania 34, everyone watching knew full well that we would be seeing these two icons go one on one at the 2018 edition of WWE's Showcase of the Immortals.

Anticipation was high for an all-time classic between two of the biggest names in modern-day history, with us all expecting a 20-minute war much akin to the pair's usual 'Mania appearances. In fact, 'Taker told Chris Van Vliet earlier this year that he initially believed the contest would be at least half an hour.

Instead, New Orleans' Mercedes-Benz Superdome played host to a 'match' that lasted just two minutes and 45 seconds.

While fans didn't get what they were hoping for here, it was absolutely for the best. Rather than a lengthy back-and-forth between two titans, what was served up was a dominant greatest hits victory for the Phenom.

This brief encounter was fun for what it was, but most importantly it didn't expose an Undertaker who was in the endgame of his career by this point. The Deadman only wrestled seven more televised matches after WrestleMania 34, with two of those being horrendous half-hour offerings in Saudi Arabia. In fact, the only time the Undertaker had a genuinely good outing after 'Mania 34. was the final match of his career, which was of course the cinematic Boneyard showcase with AJ Styles at WrestleMania 36.


9. Hollywood Hulk Hogan's WrestleMania X8 Opponent

The Rock Hulk Hogan Mike Chioda
WWE.com

It's not so much that fans were against seeing the Rock vs. Hollywood Hulk Hogan at WrestleMania X8, but more the majority of wrestling fans were hoping instead to see 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin be the one to challenge the nWo man at 2002's Showcase of the Immortals.

In terms of billing, Hogan vs. Austin would've been one of the biggest matches in history, featuring a pair of talent who many view as the two biggest names the industry has ever seen. Yes, the Rock was a huge star in his own right, but truth be told, the Texas Rattlesnake was always just ahead of his long-time rival when it came to the popularity stakes and to piercing the mainstream back then.

Rumours persist to this day that Austin vetoed any such Hogan match during this time, but one has to imagine the then-WWF could've forced the issue if they really wanted to. Whether that involved merely throwing a bunch more money the Bionic Redneck's way or not, this is a contest that would've happened if the promotion was adamant on the matter.

Instead, the market leader decided to pair Hollywood up with the Great One, and the rest is history. Would the Toronto crowd have reacted the same way to Austin as they did to Rock? If so, would Stone Cold have been happy to heel it up in the same way Rock did on that night? Regardless, the People's Champion proved to be the perfect foil for Hulk at WrestleMania X8.


8. The Architect Causes The Shield To Crumble

Shield Break Up
WWE.com

It was always going to be just a matter of time before the Shield went their separate ways. Simply put, Seth Rollins, Dean Ambrose, and Roman Reigns were all on their way to superstardom - it was just a case of who would get to the mountain top first.

When that split came in June 2014, it was somewhat surprisingly Rollins who WWE chose to orchestrate this demise.

For fans, they were largely wanting Ambrose to be the one behind the faction's downfall. After all, the Lunatic Fringe was the one often butting heads with his teammates during the trio's final months together, and Dean was likewise the one who was often pinned in any tag matches featuring the group. On top of that, die-hard fans knew just how vicious a villain Ambrose could be due to his Jon Moxley days prior to arriving in WWE.

Throughout their run together, the future AEW World Champion was often the most underhand and sly of the Shield, and he similarly was the stable's best talker. If picking a breakout singles heel from the triumvirate, Dean Ambrose seemed the natural choice; particularly due to Rollins' high energy babyface moveset, and the fact that WWE clearly viewed Reigns as the future face of the company.

WWE's decision ultimately proved correct, though, with the heel turn springboarding Seth Rollins into a made man under the watch of the Authority. As a result, this turn provided Ambrose with the motivation to showcase his babyface fire, and Roman clearly ended up doing okay for himself once the dust settled.


7. "Demoting" Finn Balor

Finn Balor NXT
WWE.com

When Finn Balor returned to NXT in October 2019 - two months after being squashed by the Fiend at that year's SummerSlam - many groaned at seeing the ridiculously talented one-time Universal Champion back in WWE's developmental arm.

To those naysayers, this was, at worst, a demotion, or at best a mild ratings ploy as NXT found itself going head-to-head with AEW Dynamite. Either way, it was viewed as a backwards step for someone as skilled and tested as the Bullet Club co-founder.

In hindsight, WWE was absolutely right to switch Balor back to NXT. The star himself has since talked about how he was burned out on the main roster, and in reality he had grown stale as a middle-of-the-road babyface. Even an Intercontinental Championship win - the Irishman's second reign with that title - at WrestleMania 35 earlier in the year did nothing of note for a Finn who was merely treading water on the main roster.

During that second stint in NXT, Balor was able to revitalise his character, combining the edge of his Prince Devitt NJPW days with a sprinkling of what made Finn so popular during his initial NXT run.

In addition to memorably turning heel on Johnny Gargano as part of this NXT return, Finn also put on absolute bangers with Gargano, Tommaso Ciampa, Matt Riddle, Keith Lee, Karrion Kross, Damian Priest, Velveteen Dream, Timothy Thatcher, Kyle O'Reilly, Pete Dunne, Roderick Strong, and of course Adam Cole - who Balor defeated to become NXT Champion once again.

By the time Finn returned to the main roster in 2021, he was immediately paired up with Universal Champion Roman Reigns, and he's subsequently found himself a fantastic fit on Raw as part of the Judgment Day nowadays.


6. Daniel Bryan's 2015 Royal Rumble

WWE Royal Rumble 2015 Daniel Bryan
WWE

With fans clamouring for Daniel Bryan to win the 2014 Royal Rumble, should the Yes! Man have emerged victorious in that bout? Absolutely. With fans clamouring for Daniel Bryan to win the 2015 Royal Rumble, should the Yes! Man have emerged victorious in that bout? Absolutely not.

In an ideal world, D-Bry winning the 2015 Rumble would've been great. It would've been Bryan standing tall at the end of that over-the-top extravaganza rather than Roman Reigns, and the real-life Bryan Danielson would have landed himself a WrestleMania 31 shot against Brock Lesnar and the WWE Championship.

Regardless of what fans wanted, Reigns won the Rumble, and Bryan had to settle for a ladder match for the Intercontinental Title at WrestleMania 31; a match in which the Washington native was victorious.

Unfortunately, WWE's concerns over Bryan's health proved to be well founded, with the American Dragon forced to vacate the IC Title shortly after 'Mania 31, which was eventually followed by the star's enforced retirement due to concussion issues. Thankfully, Daniel was able to return to in-ring action several years later, but it's hard to argue that WWE didn't get it right here.

Also, one has to wonder whether we'd have got Seth Rollins' iconic Heist of the Century at WrestleMania 31 should it have been Bryan vs. Lesnar rather than Reigns vs. Lesnar.


5. Logan Paul, PLE Main Eventer

Logan Paul vs Roman Reigns - Crown Jewel 2022
wwe.com

With just two matches under his belt - teaming with the Miz against the Mysterios at WrestleMania 38, then defeating Miz at SummerSlam 2022 - many scoffed when it was announced that Logan Paul would be headlining last year's Crown Jewel PLE against Undisputed WWE Universal Champion Roman Reigns.

Paul hadn't looked out of place in his prior two in-ring outings, and he'd nailed some nice spots in those matches, but surely the YouTube sensation was a million miles away from being able to perform at the level required to main event a Premium Live Event.

Love him or hate him, it's becoming clearer with each subsequent outing that Logan Paul is extremely good at WWE's particular brand of sports entertainment. Yes, the Crown Jewel bout was designed to accentuate Paul's strengths, and yes, the match did spend a little too much time outside the ring without paying attention to the standard ten-count, but Logan very much hung with the biggest star in the industry.

Since Crown Jewel, the 28-year-old had a hugely memorable appearance at this year's Royal Rumble, and then put on another top level performance against Seth Rollins at WrestleMania 39. Obviously being between the ropes with incredible hands like Rollins and Reigns is always going to make for an easier ride, but Logan Paul has absolutely delivered to a phenomenal level in his WWE career so far.


4. Holding Off On Bron Breakker's Main Roster Move

Bron Breakker
WWE

Ahead of this year's WWE Draft, many fans presumed Bron Breakker was nailed-on to make the jump from NXT to the main roster. After all, Bron had dropped the NXT Title to Carmelo Hayes, and it looked for all the world as if there was nothing more for the second generation star to do down in WWE's developmental arm.

While there were several NXT talents who did make the jump to Raw or SmackDown as part of the Draft, Breakker was surprisingly not one of them - and that has proven to be the correct call.

Right now, Bron Breakker is tearing it up in NXT with a new vicious, violent persona. Sure, Steiner Jr. has always shown the same badass, roughhouse aggression as his father and uncle since arriving in what was then NXT 2.0, but that has been taken to an entirely new level since Bron turned heel by attacking Hayes shortly after that title loss.

If Breakker had moved to Raw or SmackDown in his prior NXT guise, he'd have been perfectly fine and would still be viewed as a can't-miss prospect. But by allowing the 25-year-old to hone his heel craft in NXT for a little while longer, that should position Bron to make an even bigger impact when he inevitably lands on the main roster.

Should WWE get it right, this villainous, brutal Bron Breakker could legitimately make the same sort of impression that Brock Lesnar made when the Beast debuted on the main roster back in 2002.


3. Not Firing Edge

Lita Edge
WWE

Not only did a certain section of the WWE fanbase want Edge fired in 2005, but Triple H was even reportedly pushing for the market leader to sever ties with the Canadian. Of course, this was after it become public knowledge that Edge - himself married at that time - had been having an affair with Amy 'Lita' Dumas, who was dating Matt Hardy back then.

While Matt was clearly the wronged party in all of this, it was actually he himself who would end up fired during this period, with WWE management taking umbrage with how Hardy publicised this affair and publicly lambasted his ex-girlfriend and his former friend.

If anyone deserved to benefit from this awful situation in a wrestling sense, it was Matt Hardy. It remains unknown whether the groundswell of fan support generated for the Hardy Boy during this time would've been enough to cement him as a bona fide main event player, but WWE did end up with one genuine top, top star as a result of this very real drama: Edge.

WWE had a chance to solidify both of these talents as World Champion contenders, though things ultimately didn't pan out like that for Matt. By opting not to fire Edge, though, that only amplified the heat the Rated-R Superstar was receiving from fans, which in turn made him the hottest villain in the promotion and started a run that saw the nowadays WWE Hall of Famer wrack up an impressive 11 World Championship reigns.


2. Maintaining The Stardust Gimmick

stardust cody rhodes
WWE.com

Right, this one is very much an entry reliant on Cody Rhodes' dogged determination, work ethic, and willingness to bet on himself - and it's also reliant on WWE not particularly playing a significant role in Rhodes' reinvention of himself - but in an extremely 'long-game' road laced with happenstance, WWE refusing to allow Cody to drop his Stardust gimmick has led to the market leader now having a white-hot megastar on their hands.

As Stardust, Cody went fully in on the gimmick, embracing the eccentricities of the character. Still, once Dusty Rhodes tragically passed away in 2015, many clamoured to see Cody return to his roots as, well, Cody Rhodes.

When any such gimmick change failed to happen, Rhodes ultimately asked for - and was granted - his WWE release in May 2016.

Would Cody Rhodes have become the Cody Rhodes of today if he'd have remained with WWE? That's an incredibly tough question. What we do know, however, is that Rhodes' decision to depart the market leader and take a chance on himself resulted in him nowadays being the biggest babyface in WWE and one of the biggest stars in the industry.

To get to where he is now, Cody spent time in IMPACT Wrestling, Ring of Honor, New Japan Pro-Wrestling, various independent promotions, and eventually co-founded AEW - all as he honed the American Nightmare act that now has him sat at WWE's top table.


1. Rocky Maivia Really Was Destined For Greatness

Rocky Maivia
WWE

In fairness, Dwayne Johnson himself deserves plentiful credit for realising that his Blue Chipper act wasn't working, and the then-WWF deserves credit for trusting Johnson and turning him heel, but wrestling fans in 1996 thought Rocky Maivia was more destined for a company exit than destined for greatness.

As Rocky Maivia, WWF did all it could to tell audiences that this was someone who would become a top player for the promotion in a few years. Playing up Maivia's athleticism, good looks, and family heritage, the programming of the time slapped you around the face with how Rocky was a can't-miss prospect with World Championships in his future.

Not just did fans outright reject Maivia, but the vast majority of those fans likewise thought the rookie had slim to no chance of carving out a decent career for himself.

It took a knee injury in a match against Mankind in 1997 to change the path of Rocky Maivia. Having received such a negative reaction to his babyface act, Maivia used this time out of action to plan a heel turn that would come into play when he returned in August of that year. Berating those who'd booed him and joining the Nation of Domination, the seeds were finally in place for Rocky Maivia to become the Rock, to become the Great One, to become the People's Champion, and to become one of the biggest stars the industry has ever seen.


Watch Next


Senior Writer
Senior Writer

Once described as the Swiss Army Knife of WhatCulture, Andrew can usually be found writing, editing, or presenting on a wide range of topics. As a lifelong wrestling fan, horror obsessive, and comic book nerd, he's been covering those topics professionally as far back as 2010. In addition to his current WhatCulture role of Senior Content Producer and Presenter, Andrew previously spent nearly a decade as Online Editor and Lead Writer for the world's longest-running genre publication, Starburst Magazine, and his work has also been featured on BBC, TechRadar, Tom's Guide, WhatToWatch, Sportkskeeda, and various other outlets, in addition to being a Rotten Tomatoes-approved film critic. Between his main day job, his role as lead panel host of Wales Comic Con, and his gig as a pre-match host for Wrexham AFC games, Andrew has also carried out a hugely varied amount of interviews, from the likes of Robert Englund and Eli Roth to Kevin Smith and the Russo Brothers, to Kevin Conroy and Frank Miller, to Bret Hart and Sting, to Mickey Thomas, Joey Jones, Phil Parkinson, and Brian Flynn, to many, many more. Where his beloved Wrexham AFC is concerned, Andrew is a long-standing season ticket holder and an FSA Award-winner for his time co-hosting the Fearless in Devotion podcast.