10 Times WWE Repeated History

Dumb luck or careful planning? These historic WWE moments had a familiar feeling...

Becky Lynch Asuka
WWE

What is "wrestling history", exactly?

As fans, we hear about it all the time. So and so could "make history" by doing such a thing. Wrestler X is was the first in "history" to win Prize Y from Wrestler Z. "History" will piss itself laughing if it ever revisits "Slapjack". And so on.

What we do know - and this is less than ideal - is that it's unreliable. The only facts are in the stats, and they're often the preserve of the boring, the bored or worse, the manipulative. In wrestling history, there's lots of implication, but increasingly less verification. The vaunted (and only occasionally literal) history books are written by the winners of wars, resulting in generations of fans buying into a monopolised narrative with such conviction that the prospect of seeing it challenged brings about civil unrest the likes of which hasn't been seen since the mid-1990s.

It's subsequently got less gravitas than the promoters and performers themselves would have you believe. It can be rewritten, or reimagined. Wrestlers or bookers can use the present to repurpose somebody's past, or mine that past to inform the future.

Back when he was more enlightening than lightning rod, Jim Cornette used to say you had to wait seven years to rebadge something old. Like his temper and range of influence, that has gotten much shorter in recent years...

10. The Ultimate Opportunist

Edge Undertaker
WWE

It was harder to fail than succeed with the original Money In The Bank cash-in. Bona fide firsts in wrestling are always so cool, holder Edge had never worn the company's top prize, and John Cena was becoming a figure of such disdain that f*cking 2001 X-Pac would have got a pop for beating him.

The responsibility of the shock-and-awe moment being given back to the original perpetrator was a tremendous solution to an unexpected problem when the third 'Mr Money In The Bank' Mr Kennedy was shelved for a period everybody believed would take him past the expiry date.

The less said about his Unlucky Alf year the better (suffice to say, Kennedy was back less than two months after an injury that had initially been thought to take him out for a year), but 'The Rated-R Superstar' was a sublime sh*thouse choice to take his place.

A beaten and battered Undertaker was a long way from the loathed Cena, too - everything about Edge's sensational second bite was crueler than the first.


9. The Golden Role Models Go On A Two-Woman Power Trip

Sasha Banks Bayley
WWE.com

Stone Cold Steve Austin and Triple H going belt collecting in 2001 is fondly remembered because a) it was fairly short-lived and b) if you wear rose-coloured glasses all the time, red flags just look like flags.

WrestleMania X-Seven was the end of WWE's mainstream boom, with the Two-Man Power Trip's feud with The Undertaker and Kane there to distract and delay a decline that felt inevitable. But - and this question is less flippant than it sounds - who doesn't love it when wrestlers win loads of belts at once?

Seeing them holding the World, Intercontinental and Tag Team Titles all at once was stark at first and then maddening after the fact. It was a visual people wanted for the time it took to soak in, followed by a thirst for some babyface or another to break it up.

The same could be said for Bayley and Sasha Banks in 2020. Midway through their own slow build story, the duo regained the Tag Team Titles and snared the Raw Women's Championship for Banks as part of deferring her inevitable challenge for her best friend's SmackDown belt.

They looked cool as f*ck holding all the gold, and deserved the plaudits that came with it. Even if it meant grim finishes aplenty to get the belt off Asuka just to eventually give her it back.


8. His Name Is Earl

Earl Hebner The Rock
WWE

An oddity from the era, WWE somehow found their way into booking near-identical finishes to Backlash main events in 1999 and 2000. Both, unsurprisingly by the time, were devoured whole by Attitude Era audiences in total adoration of an organisation that could do no wrong.

For '99's headliner, the company ran back an exhilirating WrestleMania main event between Stone Cold Steve Austin and The Rock, but with more bells, whistles and bullsh*t. Shane McMahon had taken over The Corporation from his distracted Dad, babyfacing Vince in the process. Playing corrupt referee, he repeatedly tried to rob 'The Rattlesnake' before the Father atoned for the sins of the son by punching him in the face and handing over control to Earl Hebner.

One year on and both of them were back being b*stards, this time to The Rock in his own battle for the belt against Triple H. This time it was Linda who was bringing Hebner in, after a returning Steve Austin had wiped out every breathing heel with a steel chair.


7. The Crowds Get As Loud As The Yes Movement, But WrestleMania Never Falls On Rusev Day

Rusev Day
WWE

To compare Daniel Bryan's Yes Movement and the Rusev Day chants would be a little generous to current AEW star Miro's biggest WWE success story. But the company's attempted - and in the latter case, victorious - burials were worryingly identical.

Bryan's 2013/14 arc was cynically documented by WWE as they tried to reclaim it as if the whole shoddy affair was by design. In the years that followed it, Rusev's own road to run was given no such attention, because there was no happy ending to spin it.

By December 2017, "Rusev Day" was the closest thing WWE had to a phenomenon. Chants dominated shows, including matches that didn't even feature 'The Bulgarian Brute'. His unit with sidekick Aiden English was the hottest thing on the show, audiences splashed the drab SmackDown spotlights with the the whites, greens and reds of the Bulgarian flag and calendars with 365 identical days were top sellers on WWEShop.com.

As later revealed by Miro himself, Vince McMahon thought that the adoring public were simply mocking the gimmick. Though not beaten down into the dirt as Daniel Bryan had been, Rusev never won the big one, nor received shots or opportunities that reflected his sudden popularity.

The ramifications from it are still being felt today, with a very understandable "why try?" mentality emerging from those that have seen too many internal failures to keep on keeping on.


6. No More, No Less, It's The Magic Number

Wrestlemania XIX Austin Rocky 19
WWE.com

Stone Cold Steve Austin's epic-feeling 2001 "Desire" video found 'The Rattlesnake' in contemplative mood about how much of a career he could still have on what was very clearly borrowed time.

He made it apparent that when he couldn't quickly get back up, he'd stop falling down, and that he never wanted to be the guy slipping into opening match obscurity after years going on last. This couldn't be any more obvious watching his WrestleMania XIX exit, even if the company and the man himself weren't explicit about it in 2003.

That the match was against The Rock ensured the bittersweet moment would have lashings of the latter. It had surely been the happiest of accidents that the pair had gone to war at WrestleMania once every two years for six of the business' best ever, but 'The Great One' was precisely the right man for Austin to look at the lights for on his way out. He owed him more than one, and it paid nice tribute to The Rock's own incredible rise from the man Austin wouldn't (and couldn't) lose to when they'd first feuded in 1997.


5. Double Trouble At Two Royal Rumbles

John Cena Batista Royal Rumble vince mcmahon quads
WWE

Vince McMahon has almost never felt the cruel hand of karma on his shoulder, so it was quite nice that he was made to sit the f*ck down by it when he thought his pay-per-view had gone the way of his quads in 2005.

It really wasn't worth his rage. Batista and John Cena had tumbled over the top at the same time in a spot that looked familiar to the finish from 1994 between Bret Hart and Lex Luger. There, the move had been orchestrated to take the audience's temperature on just exactly who it was they wanted to go to WrestleMania. Here...it was a flub.

In the most astonishing bit of fortune (not least in that neither sustained any injuries), the pair hit the deck at the exact same time. Planned winner Batista hadn't won, but he hadn't lost either. This could have made for quite the angle, but a panicked Vince rushed out with more fury than his legs could cope with. Infamously restarting the match with one blown quad before walking to the back unaided and blowing the other, McMahon could have saved himself months of painful rehab if he'd just had a better memory.


4. The Survivor Series Screwjob

Rock Vince McMahon Shane
WWE.com

When Vince McMahon screwed Bret Hart at the 1997 Survivor Series, even he couldn't have predicted how well the aftermath would go for him. Post-punch in the face, anyway.

One year on from being floored by an excellently executed fist, McMahon was atop the wrestling world thanks to the success of his on-screen feud with Stone Cold Steve Austin. Survivor Series 1998 was to be the night he unveiled his most fiendish plan yet, revealing that nascent fan favourite The Rock was his protected bet when 'The Great One' applied the Sharpshooter to Mankind in the final of the WWE Championship tournament. Insisting that the timekeeper ring the bell in a kayfabe riff on his cruelest act, McMahon yet again gifted somebody the belt. This time, he could luxuriate in it

Even the most ardent 'Hitman' fan - of which your writer was and is - had to nod approvingly at its spellbinding creativity, finish included. WWE loved it so much that they persisted with the idea of people getting "screwed" at the Survivor Series in subsequent years. None of them had the spice and shock factor of that glorious original homage.


3. Twice The Effort On The Grandest Stage

Daniel Bryan Wrestlemania 30
WWE.com

Vince McMahon's penchant for giants is the worst kept secret in wrestling, but a quick scan of some of his landmark events reveals an unlikely coincidence about just how and when he showcases somebody new.

WrestleMania X was a night designed to apologise to Bret Hart for going with Hulk Hogan at his expense a year prior. Hart wrestled a beautiful opener against his brother Owen then dethroned Yokozuna in more of a moment than a match in the main event.

A decade on and in the same building, Chris Benoit overcame company lifers and main event veterans Triple H and Shawn Michaels to win his first and only top title in WWE, with the theme being that only the steepest climb would yield such satisfction.

10 years after that, and Daniel Bryan did both. He worked twice, like Bret, and worked a triple threat main event against the WWE favourites (as opposed to the fan ones) to become the Champion in unlikely circumstances.

All three were deemed too small, too boring or too technical to be the star attraction in McMahon's one-ring circus, yet they made it. Perhaps Chad Gable should at least persist until for WrestleMania 40, just in case.


2. Becky Lynch And Asuka Share Titles And Respect

Becky Lynch Asuka
WWE

A touching photo of Becky Lynch and Asuka embracing after a 2016 Tokyo house show match between the pair did the rounds on reddit when the similarities between something entirely different were suddenly crystal clear.

Then, the unbeatable 'Empress Of Tomorrow' successfully defended her NXT Championship against an 'Irish Lass Kicker' struggling to settle somewhat on a main roster that hadn't yet been divided back in two.

Their respectful hug trapped between it the ultra-prestigious original NXT Women's Championship. Another tender embrace would carry similar power four years later.

It was in one of the only genuinely touching moments of a dumpster fire year in WWE that the two again came together again. Having won Money In The Bank one night earlier, Asuka came to claim formal ownership of the briefcase, only to be given the belt itself from 'The Man' as she prepared to take maternity leave. Again, the prize between the prizefighters was captured as the two reached unique crossroads' in their respective careers.


1. Cometh The Hour, Cometh The Man

Steve Austin, Becky Lynch
WWE

Blood in WWE has always been better when it's been outlawed. That's not to say that the current policy of permitting Brock Lesnar to scoop open people's brains is better than the odd use of blade, but red's always equalled the most green when it shouldn't have been seen.

This was the case in both 1997 and 2018 as two performers ironically went from red to white hot thanks to the fire in their eyes and a little bit of claret.

As Stone Cold Steve Austin refused to quit in Bret Hart's Sharpshooter at WrestleMania 13, his crimson mask told a story just as captivating as the arch of his back or committed call from the commentators. He was an unapologetic piece of sh*t, but he became property of the people in that very moment. As did Lynch, literally, when she basked in the afterglow of an attack on Ronda Rousey and a stiff punch in the face from Nia Jax.

In both cases, the two were going to have to face injury layoffs that could have impacted lesser pushes. But these were not those wrestlers, nor those pushes. WrestleMania main events were waiting - and they'd literally spilled blood to make it happen.


In this post: 
Asuka
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.