10 Times WWE Survivor Series Decisions Backfired

The November classic has dealt with backlash and meaninglessness.

Sheamus WWE Title
WWE.com

WWE's Survivor Series remains a part of the "Classic Four" pay-per-views, but due to its gradual devaluation over the years, it's hard to call the quartet the "Big Four" any longer. WrestleMania remains the king, while SummerSlam and Royal Rumble maintain their top-shelf relevance, but the same can't be said for Survivor Series.

When you look at the past decade of Survivor Series events, there are very few moments that stand out. Sure, there's Sting's debut in 2014, The Shield's debut in 2012, and The Rock's 2011 performance that served as his first match in close to eight years, but beyond those occurrences, Survivor Series has mostly been throwaway. If there weren't elimination matches that honor the event's original concept, you could hardly distinguish a modern Survivor Series from a Fastlane or a Battleground.

In other ways, Survivor Series is historic, albeit sometimes for the wrong reasons. Moments like The Undertaker's 1990 debut, the Hulk-Andre pseudo-rematch in 1987, and (of course) Montreal resonate through time, but there are times where the company's plans simply flop. With the thirtieth incarnation of Survivor Series forthcoming, the event understandably has a history rife with infamous occurrences.

NOTE: The Montreal Screwjob was intentionally omitted from the list. Many still disagree with it, but it certainly cast more eyes on a WWE product that needed it, and Vince McMahon certainly used its notoriety to alter the company in amazing ways.

10. The Gobbledy Gooker (1990)

The Gobbledy Gooker
WWE

Well, you figured this atrocity had to make the cut. Eddie Guerrero's older brother Hector was shoehorned into a plumage-adorned turkey costume, and hatched from a jumbo-sized egg at the 1990 Survivor Series. That egg appeared at TV tapings for months prior to the pay-per-view, with the promise of some major surprise hatching from it on Thanksgiving night.

Not only was the Gooker overshadowed by the other surprise of the evening (a debuting Undertaker, who had the role down pat from day one), but the negative reaction to an anthropomorphic turkey that danced with Mean Gene Okerlund led to Gooker being shelved very quickly. All of the hype was for nothing, except providing WrestleCrap with its eventual patron saint.


9. Turning Survivor Series Into A Commercial (1991)

Survivor Series 1991 Hulk Hogan The Undertaker Ric Flair
WWE.com

In 1991, WWE experimented with the idea of running weekly pay-per-views down the line (a decade before TNA did so out of necessity) by airing an event six nights following Survivor Series called This Tuesday in Texas. The excuse for running the card was to give Randy Savage an outlet to exact revenge on Jake Roberts, and to hold the immediately-instituted Hulk Hogan/Undertaker WWE Championship rematch.

To the fans at home, Savage seemed like a logical choice to replace an injured Sid Justice in his Survivor Series match (Roberts captained the other team), and it wasn't until the PPV began that President Jack Tunney announced that neither Savage or Roberts would wrestle that night. It was bait-and-switch through implication, and most of Survivor Series was spent hyping another pay-per-view, making the event-in-progress feel secondary. This Tuesday in Texas bombed, doing half the buyrate of the established Survivor Series, and the weekly idea was scrapped.


8. Shawn Michaels And His, Uh, Knights? (1993)

Shawn Michaels Knights Survivor Series '93
WWE

WWE's hottest feud of 1993 pitted Bret Hart against the antagonistic Jerry Lawler, who had made a number of over-the-line insults toward Hart's family. The blowoff to five months of acrimony was to slot Hart and three of his brothers (Owen, Bruce, and Keith) against Lawler and three masked hired guns, known as his "knights".

Then real life intervened. Lawler was charged with statutory rape just days before the pay-per-view, and bowed out of WWE matters for four months while the case was resolved. Michaels (coming off of a suspension) was slotted into Lawler's spot, but the Knights remained, even though their and Michaels' motifs didn't jive. You can't fault WWE for their hasty improv job here, but the year's most notable angle went up in smoke. It was weird, though, to hear the announcers claim that Michaels was the antagonist all along, while nary mentioning Lawler once during the show. Most focus went toward the early makings of Owen's heel turn following the match, so Michaels teaming with three 'knights' is largely forgotten.


7. New York Hates Michaels (1996)

Sid Shawn Michaels Survivor Series 1996
WWE.com

This was less a Survivor Series idea and more a long-running WWE campaign that opened many eyes. Although Michaels hadn't been the strongest draw since becoming WWE Champion eight months earlier, the company still pushed forward with him as their billboard. Repackaging him as a smiling do-gooder, while shaving away the edge that made him such a hard-to-hate villain, didn't help either.

A year's worth of questionable presentation plowed into a sharp curve when the fans inside Madison Square Garden gave babyface Michaels an especially hostile reaction, the forefather of the kinds of responses John Cena and Roman Reigns would one day get. The match's story saw Michaels get distracted when Sid assaulted his mentor, Jose Lothario. Even when Michaels showed compassion for his fallen mentor, the crowd continued cheering Sid, especially when he cracked the champion with a TV camera. The attempt at garnering sympathy simply wasn't going to work.


6. Lesnar's Streak Ends (2002)

Big Show Survivor Series 2002
WWE.com

With ratings freefalling in 2002, and no Stone Cold or The Rock to keep the casual fan tuned in, WWE desperately needed to build a new mega-star. Unrepentant killing machine Brock Lesnar held limitless potential as an evolutionary Goldberg-type. As such, he was not booked to be pinned or made to submit for a lengthy period of time, and for good reason.

It seemed like a stale, unmotivated Big Show would be just another colossal victim for Lesnar come Survivor Series, but it wasn't to be. In an ironic twist, Lesnar needed time off because of a rib injury caused by Show during a live event match, so they had Lesnar put Show over after Paul Heyman turned on his client. Instead of saving that first loss for some truly-heroic conqueror, it was wasted on a giant with no mystique. And Lesnar didn't even miss that much time!


5. Hardy's Hotel Escapades (2008)

Jeff Hardy
WWE.com

Jeff Hardy was scheduled to take part in a triple threat match for the WWE Championship at the 2008 pay-per-view. The popular star had flirted with the gold all throughout the year, and Hardy was being accepted as a legitimate main event star. Leave it to WWE to cause a panicked uproar after presenting a worked news story as potentially real.

To build the idea that Hardy had been attacked before the show by an unknown assailant, WWE.com published a breaking news story that claimed Hardy had been found unconscious in a Boston hotel stairwell at 3 AM.

Given Hardy's history of wellness troubles, and the number of wrestlers that had been found dead in hotel rooms over the years, the story alarmed many folks who thought it was legitimate, and feared the worst. It wasn't the best way to re-introduce Edge after an injury layoff.


4. Roman Looks Strong (2013)

Roman Reigns Survivor Series 2013.jpg
WWE.com

Nobody at the time would've guessed that Roman Reigns would one day draw reactions ten times more caustic than anything John Cena's ever heard. In 2013, Reigns was the irresistible force that complimented The Shield's gamesmanship (Seth Rollins) and bravado (Dean Ambrose). He was also the greenest of the trio inside the ring, but his menacing look and hard-hitting potential promised greater days ahead.

In a five-on-five elimination match, Reigns and Rollins lost their three partners (Ambrose, Cesaro, and Jack Swagger), and had to fight against long odds to survive. No problem for Reigns, who pinned four of the five opponents by himself, looking like a one-man army all the while. Reigns came off great as the sole survivor, but you can point to matches like this as reasons why WWE imbued Reigns with their faith, and for some reason feeling he'd come off better as Cena-Lite, without the verbal energy. The cliched Roman Empire kicked into high gear beginning here.


3. No For Show (2013)

Big Show Authority Survivor Series 2013
WWE.com

By the time Reigns' spotlight began to turn many shades brighter, most fans believed Big Show was standing in the beam belonging to Daniel Bryan. When Bryan's quest to overthrow The Authority and win the WWE Championship failed in the fall of 2013, Show was inserted as Randy Orton's Survivor Series challenger.

Show even co-opted Bryan's "YES!" arm-thrusts for himself, trying to curry the same electric response that organic-crowd favorite Bryan was finding it easy to come by. Not the case for Show at Survivor Series, who found himself serenaded with chants of "boring" and "we want Bryan". The vitriol would only increase when Bryan remained out in the cold (though not for much longer) in favor of Batista in 2014, but Show was such a lame choice that he couldn't even draw wittier chants such as "Bluetista" or the like.


2. Authority's Christmas Vacation (2014)

dolph ziggler survivor series 2014
WWE.com

We get it: forever is a joke in wrestling. Retirements don't last, stipulations mean jack, and continuity is highly negotiable. That's part of a major problem, as fans have been conditioned to not take high stakes seriously, and thus would-be marquee match-ups have less appeal.

Therefore, when you get a transcendent moment like Sting arriving to save WWE's babyfaces by wiping out The Authority at Survivor Series, it's amazing when fans buy into it. Sting's debut (and Dolph Ziggler's dramatic victory) made fans a few shades less jaded on the basis of the amazing execution by everyone involved. Six weeks later, The Authority was back, rendering the entire historical occurrence moot. And WWE continues to wonder why fans don't take their grandiose plans all that seriously.


1. The Road To Ratings Ruin (2015)

Sheamus Cash-in Survivor Series 2015
WWE.com

WWE's TV ratings had been in free-fall for much of 2015, and they would only get worse come the end of the calendar year. The original Survivor Series plan was for Roman Reigns to end Seth Rollins' eight-month WWE Championship reign, which went out the window when Rollins blew his knee out earlier in the month. Acting quickly, WWE threw together an elimination tournament, doing all they could under the circumstances to salvage things.

Reigns winning was less than ideal for much of the audience, but the subsequent Money in the Bank cash-in by Sheamus only punctuated the disaster. Ratings slipped further and further with Reigns/Sheamus as the headline feud, alarming everybody with a dismal 2.16 the night after Survivor Series, and trumping it with a 2.15 for the TLC go-home Raw just weeks later.


Contributor
Contributor

Justin has been a wrestling fan since 1989, and has been writing about it since 2009. Since 2014, Justin has been a features writer and interviewer for Fighting Spirit Magazine. Justin also writes for History of Wrestling, and is a contributing author to James Dixon's Titan series.