10 Times WWE Totally BOTCHED A New Title

Spoiler: Something goes awry more often than not, though some have recovered fine.

Mick Foley 24/7 Championship
WWE.com

The wrestling world has been abuzz with WWE’s creation of a “new” World title, resurrecting the World Heavyweight Championship to serve as a brand-specific top prize on Raw - the show Roman Reigns and his “Undisputed” WWE Universal Championship aren’t populating.

The news certainly didn’t come without controversy, as fans and critics alike immediately pointed to Reigns carrying two World title belts around for the past year-plus and wondered why WWE didn’t simply separate the two – whether that meant stripping Roman of one or having him defend one at WrestleMania 39 and lost that title to Cody Rhodes.

This list does not recount the pros and cons of creating ostensibly a third World title as the tournament careens toward a conclusion at Night of Champions because this isn’t the first time WWE has created or resurrected a major title. In fact, this has been a regular practice throughout the years, with titles coming and going, returning, being merged with other titles, and ultimately being retired for good.

It’s actually rarer that new and resurrected titles are brought into the fold without issue. There almost always is something that goes awry, whether it’s the initial champion, title lineage, presentation, or how it’s rolled out from the jump.

So, with the new World Heavyweight Championship tournament well underway, let’s look back at some of the biggest snafus new WWE titles have experienced...

10. WWE Universal Championship

Finn Balor WWE Universal Title
WWE.com

It’s hard to really fault WWE for everything that went wrong with the Universal Championship when it debuted in 2016. But its first few appearances seemed snakebitten.

First, the title belt itself was the source of criticism, looking nearly identical to the WWE World Heavyweight Championship – just with a red strap because it was exclusive to Raw. The name also was mocked in part because WWE had a “World” championship and now had a “Universal” title, and also because it was connected to WWE’s strange affection for calling their fans the WWE universe.”

Finn Balor would become the inaugural champion, defeating Seth Rollins in a hotly contested match at SummerSlam. But Balor was injured during the contest and was forced to surrender the title the next night on Raw, meaning that a brand-new title was vacated 24 hours into its existence.

The Universal Championship would eventually recover, with Roman Reigns turning it into the “A-championship” when he won it in 2020, but its initial moments looked rather dubious.


9. WWE Hardcore Championship

Mankind Hardcore Champion
WWE

Everyone remembers the WWE Hardcore Championship fondly for its crazy 24/7 defense rule that saw the title change hands numerous times in random places, with attacks mid-match, backstage, and even in an airport.

But fans might not realize that the 24/7 rule didn’t take effect until February 2000, a full 14 months after the Hardcore Championship debuted. Up until that point, it was treated like a regular title defended in plunder matches.

The Hardcore title being awarded to Mankind in November 1998 was a cute little tribute, but it would become a hot potato passed around lower-card wrestlers after a strange stint with each of the New Age Outlaws holding the championship.

Even the 24/7 gimmick would run its course after a while, as the title would change hands literally hundreds of times, mainly at house shows, traded back and forth between wrestlers.

As a title, this probably could have been a Mick Foley tribute title for him to defend and then quietly retire it. The championship never had any prestige, and a lot of the weapons shots in those matches make you cringe today. But WWE and the superstars never took it too seriously, hence the very low ranking here.


8. ECW Championship

Rob Van Dam ECW and WWE Champion 2006
WWE.com

The idea of restarting ECW as a third brand under the WWE umbrella was always fraught with risk, but the first step seemed like a smart one.

At ECW One Night Stand in 2006, Rob Van Dam successfully cashed in his Money in the Bank briefcase, defeating John Cena for the WWE Championship. He was immediately awarded the resurrected ECW title and became a dual World titleholder - quite the distinction for a guy who never had reached the mountaintop in either company.

But it all fell apart a few weeks later.

Van Dam was arrested for drug possession, which led to him losing both World titles on back-to-back days, with Big Show capturing the ECW Championship in Philadelphia, of all places. Bobby Lashley would finally dethrone Show to end that period, but Mr. McMahon would take the title off Lashley about five months later, effectively making the title a joke and solidifying the notion that ECW and its title was a tier below Raw and SmackDown.

The ECW title would suffer another hit when it was defended for the first time at WrestleMania 24, only for Kane to defeat Chavo Guerrero Jr. in 11 seconds, turning what was hyped as a momentous occasion into another cruel joke. The title would be deactivated less than two years later when ECW ended as a brand, making way for NXT.


7. WWE Million Dollar Championship (2010, 2021)

Virgil, Ted DiBiase
WWE.com

When Ted DiBiase couldn’t win the WWF Championship, he went out and made his own title, a perfect melding of his excessive wealth and vanity. He would briefly bestow it upon his protégé, the Ringmaster, but that guy didn’t quite pan out.

But when the title resurfaced more than a decade later, it was around DiBiase’s son’s waist. Ted DiBiase Jr. even briefly had Virgil seconding him, as he looked more like a poor copy of his father than a second-generation wrestler who could stand on his own. Literally none of this worked. The Million Dollar Man was a main event-level wrestler who was a reviled heel, while Ted Jr. was barely a midcarder who looked like he was playing dress-up while carrying the title, which would only last for about seven months before it disappeared again.

The title would pop up once more in NXT in 2021 as part of Cameron Grimes’ evolution into the wealthiest man on the brand. He and LA Knight would feud over the title, which again would disappear after only a few months.

What worked once hasn’t worked since, so maybe WWE should just stick this one in a trophy case and leave it there.


6. WWE Divas Championship

michelle mccool divas champion
WWE.com

It’s strange to say that a title was doomed from the jump because of the name and design, but that’s kind of the case with the WWE Divas Championship.

Created in 2008 as a SmackDown exclusive title for the blue brand divas, the championship was meant to be a counterweight to Raw’s WWE Women’s Championship. But really, the Women’s Championship had more than 50 years of history to it (off and on), while the Divas title was this butterfly design with a silly name.

Just two years later, it would become the only title for a women’s division that would see its TV time shrink, match time evaporate, and storylines fall far short of expectations. The Divas Championship would be ushered out of WWE in 2016, less than a year after the “Women’s Revolution” reshaped the company’s women’s division.

Bad name, bad design, bad memories. This is one title that wasn’t entirely terrible, but also has a lot going against it in the aftermath.


5. WWE/NXT Cruiserweight Championship

enzo amore cruiserweight title
WWE.com

When fans learned that WWE was resurrecting the Cruiserweight Championship, surely, they thought, the company would avoid the pitfalls that befell the title before, when a little person was the last man to hold the strap?

And then… purple happened.

The 2016 Cruiserweight Classic was a highly regarded, critically acclaimed event that gave immediate credibility to the newly resurrected (though not linear) Cruiserweight title. But once the tournament ended, some of the major names who participated went back to the independent circuit, while WWE signed several of the other wrestlers.

The title initially would be defended on Raw in a strange, parallel universe where the ropes, turnbuckle pads and lighting were purple and no one interacted with anyone else from Raw. With no connection to WWE proper, no major storylines and little context to fans who missed the WWE Network tournament, matches were not really well-received in the arenas.

Later that fall, the cruiserweights got their own show, 205 Live, on the WWE Network, which reduced the visibility of the title even further. It was mostly relegated to that program before being shunted off to NXT, where it ultimately would be retired in 2022, less than six years after it debuted.

But really, the title was destined for second-class citizenship almost immediately.


4. WWE Women’s Tag Team Championship

The IIconics Billie Kay Peyton Royce
WWE.com

This currently active title shouldn’t really be a surprise to anyone who’s paid attention.

When WWE finally created the Women’s Tag Team Championship, it was a dream come true for Bayley and Sasha Banks, who basically willed them into existence. Fittingly, the duo won the inaugural title match at Elimination Chamber 2019 in a titular match…

...and then lost them seven weeks later at WrestleMania 35 to the IIconics.

That’s not meant to be a knock on Billie Kay and Peyton Royce themselves, but the Aussie tag team weren’t known for their in-ring prowess, and worse, they almost immediately disappeared from WWE programming (as did Sasha, who went on hiatus for a few months), and with them, so did the championship’s credibility.

The women’s tag titles have been little more than a prop during most of their four-year existence, with makeshift teams holding the straps more often than not, and there never being a consistent focus on the women’s tag division.

Sure, they’ll have their moment periodically on television, but this championship was horribly botched shortly after its debut and suffered as a result.


3. WWF Light Heavyweight Championship

Gillberg 600
WWE

During the Monday Night War, WCW might have had the tagline, “Where the big boys play,” but the company excelled at giving cruiserweights a tremendous platform. Their Cruiserweight Championship would become a staple of the company, so much so that WWF/E would retain it after buying out WCW.

But before then, WWF tried to establish its own title for smaller wrestlers: the Light Heavyweight Championship. Whereas WCW’s cruiserweight division was stocked with wrestlers like Rey Mysterio Jr., Psicosis, Chris Jericho, Dean Malenko, Eddie Guerrero, Juventud Guerrero, Billy Kidman and Ultimo Dragon, WWF’s light division was… different.

Sure, they had Taka Michinoku, but others included members of Kaientai, Scott Taylor, Brian Christopher and Christian – not exactly the same pedigree or international flavor of wrestlers. The matches weren’t presented in the same manner, and the division never really materialized as a focal point for WWF programming like it did in WCW.

Within a year, the title was around the waist of Duane Gill, a joke champion who would hold the title for nearly 15 months without defending it on WWF programming for 14 of those months. The title would resurface in early 2000 as Gillberg would lose the title to Essa Rios, who was outshone by his valet, Lita.

By then, the title was little more than a prop. When WWF bought out WCW in early 2001, it was pretty clear which of the two titles carried more prestige and would survive. The Light Heavyweight Championship was quietly deactivated in 2002.


2. WWE World Heavyweight Championship (2002)

Triple H Eric Bischoff World Heavyweight Championship Award
WWE.com

Let’s be honest: WWE hasn’t really had the best track record when it comes to introducing new World titles in recent years. The Universal Championship and ECW Championships have already been covered, but this fumble preceded them.

Brock Lesnar won the Undisputed WWE Championship at SummerSlam 2002, but shortly after, he became exclusive to SmackDown, leaving Raw without a world champion (sound familiar?). Raw GM Eric Bischoff’s solution was to reestablish the World Heavyweight Championship. But rather than hold a tournament among all the Raw superstars, he simply awarded it to Triple H. That alone was a near-unforgivable offense.

Apologists will say that Triple H was a heel, and this just made him even more hated, but there’s a reason the World Heavyweight Championship of that era was often regarded as the B-title of the two. It’s hard to establish credibility for a title when it literally was pulled out of a briefcase and handed to a guy.

Sure, the title would be held by several future WWE Hall-of-Famers like Shawn Michaels, Kurt Angle and Goldberg, but that misstep out of the gate was a pretty notable setback.


1. WWE 24/7 Championship

Titus O'Neil 24/7
WWE

When fans actively boo and jeer at the unveiling of a new title, you might be in trouble. When the actual debut championship match for the title elicits fierce criticism and even outright derision, you know it’s a huge problem.

Mick Foley had the dubious duty of introducing WWE fans to the new 24/7 Championship in May 2019. Speculation had centered on the company possibly reintroducing the Hardcore Championship, a title that also was defended 24/7. But rather than resurrecting a title that also was synonymous with unprotected chairshots and some gratuitous attacks that didn’t quite fit today’s WWE, they rolled out the green-strapped title to a chorus of boos.

But it got worse.

Foley announced that the title would be up for grabs immediately, with the first person to claim the title becoming the initial champion. This led to a mad scramble amongst the lower-carder wrestlers on the roster, with Titus O’Neil securing it, only to lose it moments later backstage to Robert Roode, who then got rolled up in the parking lot by R-Truth.

From there, the title was little more than a joke, with title changes taking place via simple rollup and various celebrities taking turns holding the championship for a few minutes. Superstars such as R-Truth, Jinder Mahal and Drake Maverick actually made it an entertaining comedy title, but by the time Reggie was flipping around parks with the title, it had jumped the shark.

The ignominious – but somehow fitting – end to the 24/7 Championship came in November 2022 when Nikki Cross defeated Dana Brooke, then dropped the title into a refuse bin.


Contributor
Contributor

Scott is a former journalist and longtime wrestling fan who was smart enough to abandon WCW during the Monday Night Wars the same time as the Radicalz. He fondly remembers watching WrestleMania III, IV, V and VI and Saturday Night's Main Event, came back to wrestling during the Attitude Era, and has been a consumer of sports entertainment since then. He's written for WhatCulture since 2014, establishing the Ups and Downs articles for WWE Raw and WWE PPVs/PLEs and composing pieces on a variety of topics.