10 Times WWE Tried Too Hard To Be REAL
Brock Lesnar busting Randy Orton's head open, the Brawl For All, and other REAL WWE fails...
It doesn't take much of a brain to see WWE's brand of professional wrestling for what it is, even if naysayers still think "it's fake" is a mic-dropping argument. The fact that sports entertainment may not be "real" in the traditional sense of a sport doesn't make it any less enjoyable to its fans. Still, WWE (and other promotions) have to take the extra step of suspending the viewer's disbelief to pass the product off as plausible.
To do so, WWE has gone out of its way to add small doses of realism to its product over the years. Not only does it give the presentation a bit of an edge, but it also reminds fans that the entertainers backstage are also real "tough guys and gals."
However, in an attempt to shake off the image of 'rasslers being "too soft" and present the product in a grittier, more realistic light, WWE has often taken things a bit too far. While some of these bits of "reality" created great entertainment, many others went down in infamy as some of the most regrettable decisions in WWE history...
10. Raw Underground
Said to be Shane McMahon's brainchild, WWE made a desperate attempt to improve third-hour viewership by introducing Raw Underground in August 2020. The last-hour segments boosted ratings during its debut but failed to retain fan interest within a few episodes.
The shoot-style fights were intended to add more realism to Raw but headed in the other direction instead. Big names from the MMA and wrestling worlds, especially Ken Shamrock, criticized the concept while also offering advice. Many thought it was a terrible idea, as it delegitimized pro-wrestling. Why would Dolph Ziggler lose every rasslin' match yet tear it up during "shoots"?
Aside from the clunky slugfests, the overall concept of Raw Underground was never truly established. First, there were the dancers straight from the Ruthless Aggression Era, and then they disappeared. McMahon originally announced there were no rules, although he ended up stopping the combatants (rather easily sometimes) when they "went too far." The only talent that benefitted from the ordeal was Dabba-Kato. Still, even he ended up being food for Braun Strowman's 1,000th push attempt.
Raw Underground was meant to improve ratings and introduce a grittier third hour, but it failed on both accounts. By the fall, the third-hour series disappeared amidst a COVID-19 outbreak and never came back. It was all thrown out within a few months and showed just how disorganized the company's creative had become.
9. Brawl For All
Toughman contests rose in popularity throughout the late 1990s, and WWE was there to try to get in on the act. Steered by infamous writer Vince Russo, the company launched a shoot-fight tournament called Brawl for All during the summer of '98.
Russo's idea was to have all the underutilized backstage brawlers in one tournament with big prize money as the payoff.
What ensued were a series of clunky bouts that made no one look good. Although the fans shared their displeasure with "boring" chants, the fights were more intense than they appeared. Overall, at least five performers sustained injuries due to WWE's poorly executed attempt at realism.
The tournament didn't play out how Russo promised either. 'Dr Death' Steve Williams was meant to be the star, but instead, he looked like a chump while Bart Gunn rose to the top and claimed the top prize.
Switching gears from pushing 'Dr Death' to Gunn shouldn't have been a huge deal, only it failed, too, when Butterbean knocked him out within 35 seconds at WrestleMania 15. And wouldn't you know it, he was fired rather promptly after the disgraceful performance. In essence, all the brawl did was destroy bodies and careers while, ironically, making wrestlers look even more like "fake tough guys."
8. Brock Lesnar Busts Randy Orton Up (SummerSlam 2016)
During the main event of SummerSlam 2016, WWE brass gave the green light to a brutal act so realistic it even caused a stir backstage.
As with many of 'The Beast's' matches, Brock Lesnar was largely dominant over Randy Orton, although both men did serious damage to each other ringside. After a flurry of big moves and F-5s, the former UFC Heavyweight Champion became frustrated with 'The Viper' and decided to go bare-knuckle, using unprotected elbow shots to split open Orton's skull.
A stomach-churning stream of blood poured out onto the mat as officials broke up the fight, declaring Lesnar the winner via TKO. Backstage, Chris Jericho confronted 'The Beast,' concerned that he had gone off-script.
Later on, Orton explained to FOX Sports that everything played out as planned, although he wished he could have been booked stronger. The only thing slightly off was the damage Lesnar's elbows caused. It should have been a clean-cut but ended up being a wide laceration.
Some fans would have hoped WWE learned from the past that performers don't need to suffer and take unnecessary risks for the sake of entertainment. What played out at SummerSlam was a blatant attempt to get a little color on a major PPV. It would have been almost better if Orton had broken the "no-blading" rule instead. Ultimately, Lesnar didn't need the bump from the stunt, and it did little to help a returning 'Viper's' momentum.
7. Brock Lesnar Busts Roman Reigns Up (WrestleMania 34)
The Universal Championship match between Brock Lesnar and Roman Reigns at WrestleMania 34 is nearly impossible to rewatch. 'The Beast' was wearing out his welcome with his strong-armed booking and repetitive match structures, and 'The Big Dog's' heat as a babyface was at an all-time high. Whether a series of suplexes or announce table spots, neither performer could do anything to win back the crowd, who at this point, chanted "this is boring," "this is awful," and "we want refunds."
Seen as an attempt to save the dumpster fire of 'Mania main event, Lesnar removed his gloves much like he did against Orton and started to drill his elbows into Reign's head until a similar crimson scene unfolded. During the match with 'The Viper,' fans were stunned by the sight. This time, the stunt had little effect, and the fans continued to boo the two men out of the building.
WWE had tried to use a little extra realism to build sympathy for their hated "hero" in Reigns, only for him to suffer the consequences for no real gain. Lesnar retained the belt in an anti-climatic finish, and 'The Guy' took a serious risk just to be left without gold and looking like he was completely out of 'The Beast Incarnate's' league.
6. Attitude Era Promos
The cat has been out of the bag for years in regards to whether professionally wrestling is "real" or not. Aside from children new to sports entertainment, most people recognize the fact that it's a bit of a cross between combat sports and vaudeville. Still, that has never seemed to stop the weak rhetoric of "it's fake" by critics of rasslin'
During the height of the Attitude Era, the fact that pro-wrestling wasn't completely on the up-and-up still stigmatized WWE's product, so the company felt the need to go out of the way to convince fans that it was actually real.
Starting with an ad during NFL's "Big Game," WWE ran a series of advertisements that showcased many of the top talents during the time. In each one of these videos, the wrestlers called out naysayers and provided their real-life accolades and list of injuries to demonstrate just how "real" sports entertainment was.
It might have been entertaining to hear the lists of accomplishments and downfalls from the performers themselves, but the hard push to convince people WWE consisted of "fake" pro-wrestling that was "real" was a bit uncanny when simply advertising the best of their content was another viable option. Sceptics weren't going to change their minds, and the promo pieces brought up the conversation of "wrestling is fake" rather than playing it down.
5. Big Show Vs Akebono In A Sumo Match (WrestleMania 21)
For a short period of time, whenever a celebrity wanted to step into the ring at 'The Grandest Stage of Them All,' they had to go through The Big Show. Before he would go on to be knocked out by Floyd Mayweather or rumors of a match against Shaq started, 'The Giant' went toe-to-toe with Akebono Tarō in a sumo wrestling match.
Relatively unknown to the general WWE audience, Tarō was fairly popular in Hawaii as a pro-wrestler. Moreover, he was the first American-Japanese grappler to reach "yokozuna," the highest rank in sumo. To top it off, he was skilled in both kickboxing and mixed martial arts.
On the surface, it seemed as though WWE tried to toss in a little more "real sport" into 'Mania by featuring a shoot-style sumo match between the two big men. However, the execution left fans wondering if the bout simply took place so Vince McMahon could cackle at the sight of Big Show in the traditional sumo regalia.
Big Show might have been WWE's 'World's Largest Athlete,' but Tarō outweighed The Giant at well over 500 pounds, despite giving up a few inches of height. Additionally, Show had never participated in a sumo match before. Needlessly to say, he ended up looking ridiculous as he picked out a wedgie moments after Tarō made short work of him, tossing him out of the ropeless ring.
4. Undertaker Puts Mankind Through Hell (King Of The Ring 1998)
WCW struggled toward the end of the 1990s, but WWE still needed some kind of Hail Mary play to fully overcome its competition and stabilize the company as the mecca of sports entertainment. What had worked best for the Attitude Era were darker storylines and visually violent stunts. However, fans never before witnessed what they were going to see during the Hell in a Cell match between The Undertaker and Mankind.
Within the first two minutes of the bout, the two men already battled on top of the giant steel structure. Of course, any fan of professional wrestling knows what ensued next. 'The Deadman' tossed Mick Foley over the edge of the cell, sending him crashing through the announce table far below.
Considered one of WWE's most famous matches, the slaughter of a brawl tipped the company over the edge, cementing its position over WCW. By today's standards, though, the vicious fight would have never taken place. At least, it would have been stopped after the first major bump.
Although it will go on as the stuff of legends for decades, Foley chose to take unnecessary risks for the sake of improving ratings and viewership, and they weren't just stunts that could have injured him. Both falls from the top of the cell alone could have ultimately ended his career if not also his life. He might have been OK with taking the bumps, but WWE management should have never allowed them to occur.
3. Paul Bearer Gets Buried Alive In A Concrete Tomb (The Great American Bash 2004)
Production value is one of the biggest factors that sets WWE apart from competitors, so it's a wonder why many of their stunts come off unrealistic and a bit hokey, much like Randy Orton setting 'The Fiend' ablaze at TLC 2020.
However, WWE will go the extra mile to make something look "real" every so often. Sometimes it goes too far.
Such was the case leading up to the 2004 Great American Bash. Paul Heyman told The Dudley Boyz "to make an impact," which they did by abducting Paul Bearer. Their actions set up a handicap match at the PPV with a rather peculiar stipulation.
Bearer was locked inside of a glass tomb. If 'The Deadman' defeated The Dudleys, his longtime manager would be buried in concrete. The twist saw 'Taker bury his mentor himself, but it wasn't nearly as shocking as to how WWE pulled off the stunt.
In an interview, Bearer revealed that the glass was real, and so was the concrete (albeit mixed with oatmeal). Upstage, he held down a button. If he ever let go, the staff would come to his rescue.
The idea was to use a septic truck to suck out the concrete. It didn't work out, and Bearer was luckily rescued after by stagehands with axes. In the end, WWE used a combination of pre-taped and live footage to pull off the bit. Still, a ring veteran's livelihood was risked for the sake of verisimilitude and shock value.
2. The 'Loose Cannon' Brian Pillman (1996)
Before jumping to WWE, Brian Pillman ditched his 'Hollywood' look for a much grittier persona. Going off-script, cursing, and making extreme threats, 'The Loose Cannon' reestablished himself through a controversial approach to the "entertainment" side of the business.
His behavior transcended the ring, though, leading to issues with management in WCW. Shortly after he buried the company via ECW, WWE gave Pillman a call back, hoping his influence would propel Raw into an edgier future.
To mirror the times, WWE kicked off the era with a handful of ultra-violent acts, but none were more wicked than the 04 November 1996 episode of Raw. On this night, fans saw Steve Austin invade Pillman's home only for 'The Loose Cannon' to whip out a 9mm.
WWE pulled off some dubious stunts in the past but implied homicide was some next-level s***.
It also landed the company in hot water, especially when Pillman would utter phrases like "get the f*** out of the way" in the process. WWE got the push into the aggressive late-90s it wanted, but the Pillman stints certainly established the line in the sand.
Even though the era continued in a violent and realistic fashion, it noticeably lacked the use of firearms (that didn't pop out a cartoonish "Bang!" flag), which had probably had nothing to do with the sponsors and parents. Whether a low-brow attempt to save Raw from ratings death, it's hard to imagine the Attitude Era without the unpredictable actions of 'The Loose Cannon.'
1. Kurt Angle's 2004 Tough Enough "Shoot" Challenge
WWE tried to properly promote Tough Enough in 2004 by featuring the potential talent on episodes of its programming. By large, the competitors were put to the test in various challenges. One such challenge came at the hands of Kurt Angle, who perhaps assumed he could get away with a little hazing.
'The Olympic Hero' went out to the squared circle and challenged any of the Tough Enough performers to come out and enter a shoot-style wrestling match. Answering the call was MMA fighter Daniel Puder, who wasn't ready to be publically humiliated.
Whereas Angle was expected to make short work of Puder, he visibly struggled to maintain control. Once the Gold Medalist managed to wrestle the fighter down to the mat, he locked on a legitimate kimura lock that threatened to break Angle's arm.
Officials panicked as they searched for a way to abort. Still locked in the kimura, Angle rolled Puder over into a pin. Even though his shoulders weren't completely down, the referee made the quick three-count and declared the Olympic wrestler victorious.
After the match, Angle chewed Puder, yelling, "Are you f***ing stupid?" at his face. WWE might have frowned upon Angle's idea of challenging Tough Enough stars to shoots, but management didn't proactively stop it. They and the 'Olympic Hero' both risked injury and public embarrassment for the sake of adding a little realism to a sport that had been far from "real" for over 60 years.