10 Times WWE Went Too Far
Disgusting Promotional Tactics.
Professional wrestling and Sports Entertainment aren't high art.
This should go without saying, though it needs to be reiterated from time to time. Shows like SmackDown and Raw are more akin to Die Hard than Citizen Kane. That isn't to say there's no room for nuance, detail, smarts, and intricacies but for the most part, this is popcorn entertainment and when it's bad, it's best to keep it at arm's length and laugh it off.
WWE's creative instability and penchant for pushing the envolve don't make this easy. Regardless, things like Sami Zayn mocking Bobby Lashley's "sisters," the disastrous Hell In A Cell 2019 main event, and cuckolding storylines aren't examples of the promotion going too far; just examples of the promotion telling terrible stories.
The examples discussed within are a lot more worthy of your scorn and bile, but note that these aren't necessarily the worst instances of WWE breaking the limits of taste, decency, and everything in between. History is peppered with many, many more, so go ahead and list your additions in the comments section below.
Let's run through some of the world's shadiest wrestling promotion's shadiest moments.
10. Jinder Mahal's Racism
Jinder Mahal had been WWE Champion for three months by the time he crossed paths with Shinsuke Nakamura. Having systematically failed to generate any meaningful heat after his sudden promotion from jobberdom, WWE attempted to get said heat by having 'The Modern Day Maharaja' resort to literal racism in the build to their Hell In A Cell pay-per-view bout, resulting in the year's most tasteless segment.
The 19 September 2017 episode of SmackDown saw Mahal and his henchmen, the Singh Brothers, hit the ring to cut a promo on Nakamura. Scripted to mock 'The King Of Strong Style's' facial expressions, Mahal said his opponent "always rooks the same." Then, to make matters worse, he claimed "they call you Mr. Miyagi," prompting chants of "that's too far" from a disbelieving crowd.
The Washington Post would later carry a WWE statement in which the company claimed to be "committed to embracing and celebrating individuals from all backgrounds as demonstrated by the diversity of our employees, performers, and fans worldwide" amidst the backlash. This was them creating "programming with fictional personalities that incorporates real-world issues and sensitive subjects."
No. It was racist, and it still didn't get Jinder over.
9. Piggy James
Remember when Vince McMahon randomly decreed Mickie James overweight and decided to mock her on-air for it? 2009 was wild.
It began on an October episode of SmackDown, with Michelle McCool and Layla ripping into Mickie for her supposed weight problems. The first segment saw James flee the scene in tears. Fat suits, bad Photoshops, and LayCool trying to shove cake down Mickie's throat were incorporated as the creative department went all-in on a body-shaming storyline aimed at a woman whom anyone with a working set of eyes could see wasn't overweight. Complete nonsense, and quite hilarious considering WWE were just two years away from launching their Be A STAR anti-bullying initiative.
Talking to WrestlingNews.com in 2013, James claimed the storyline was "an attempt to address bullying and tell a story with it," adding that "you're going to have sympathy for the character and understand where she's coming from, impacted from the perils of bullying."
A fine explanation if that was what the feud achieved. It didn't, though. It put heat on the writers, not LayCool, and likely came straight from the mind of the WWE Chairman.
8. The Fabulous Moolah Battle Royal
With nine Women's Championship reigns across the NWA and WWE, a 1995 WWE Hall of Fame induction, and complete dominance of her field for much of the four decades she was active, the Fabulous Moolah's wrestling résumé is impeccable.
Her record away from the ring, however, is not.
Moolah's legacy is awful. Countless peers accused her of manipulating the business to ensure that she got all the recognition, not her peers, taking paycheques from her fellow wrestlers, and forcing the likes of Luna Vachon, Vivian Vachon, and Ann Casey to move territories to avoid her influence. Unfortunately, these stories are just the iceberg's tip. Penny Banner called Moolah a pimp who rented her trainees out for sex in return for money. Max Maxine said she was an "evil person" whose income came from sending other women "out to this guy in Arizona," and Luna Vachon, in 2002, alleged that she was sent out to have photos of her taken by an older man when she was just 16 years old. There are many, many more accounts like this too.
The outrage generated when WWE tried to name WrestleMania 34's women's battle royal after Moolah was therefore earned. Immediate backlash from fans and critics followed, with WWE only budging when sponsors got involved a few days later.
7. Exploiting Reid Flair's Death
Ric Flair's youngest son, Reid, passed away in March 2013. He was just 25 years old when his body was found in a Charlotte, North Carolina hotel room, with an autopsy revealing he'd died of a heroin overdose, with traces of prescription tranquilizers, clonazepam, and alprazolam also present in his system.
WWE decided to incorporate this into Reid's sister Charlotte's Divas Championship feud with Paige ahead of Survivor Series 2015. A pre-match promo saw the champ dedicate the bout to her departed sibling. Paige's comeback? "Your little baby brother, he didn't have much fight in him, did he?"
Tasteless. Utterly tasteless.
Paige was a picture of extreme discomfort as she forced this terrible scripted line out, and as for the Flairs? They weren't even asked. Reports revealed that WWE hadn't asked the family for permission ahead of time and hadn't even warned the parents, with Ric claiming her burst into tears upon hearing it, stating that the only reason he didn't speak out at the time was that he didn't want to harm Charlotte's career.
Wrestling Observer Newsletter readers would rightly vote this 2015's Most Disgusting Promotional Tactic.
6. "Roman Has To Answer To The Man Upstairs"
More an old-school scorched earth shoot interview than a podcast, Jon Moxley's May 2019 appearance on Talk Is Jericho hit the wrestling world like a mortar blast, with the former Dean Ambrose shedding new light on WWE's broken creative process in the Such Good Sh*t era.
One of Moxley's most pointed complaints revolved around Vince McMahon insisting he spit multiple lines on Roman Reigns' leukaemia diagnosis after turning heel in late 2018. Having already taken the emotional rawness of Reigns' announcement to spark the heel turn, Mox didn't reveal exactly what the Chairman wanted him to say, but called it "so bad it would have lost [WWE] sponsors."
The one instance of WWE capitalising on Reigns' illness to generate heat for Ambrose was bad, but not "losing sponsors" bad. It went down on the 19 November episode of Raw. "We're all gonna get what we deserve," 'The Lunatic Fringe' said, referring to The Shield's past kayfabe sins. "I mean, look at Roman. For Roman's part and what Roman did in The Shield, he has to answer to the man upstairs."
He has to answer to the main upstairs.
Stay classy, WWE.
5. Exploiting Hawk's Alcoholism
Substance abuse and alcoholism plagued Road Warrior Hawk's life for years before his October 2003 passing, when the tag wrestling legend suffered a heart attack in his Floridian home.
WWE turned Hawk's problems into a storyline five years prior. It was the Attitude Era, and the promotion was still transitioning towards a more adult-themed product. Harder, edgier storylines led Vince McMahon's new list of demands, and forcing Hawk to work this programme (despite his and partner Animal's protestations) was part of the agenda.
A storyline saw an intoxicated Hawk shambling his way through matches and segments escalated when he edged towards suicidal tendencies. The Legion of Doom's new member, Puke, was then the catalyst in an angle in which Hawk scaled the Titan Tron and attempted to kill himself by leaping from the top. Later, it was revealed that Puke had been plying him with intoxicants all along. His endgame? Killing Hawk and taking his place in LOD. Grim.
Things got so bad that Hawk and Animal quit the company shortly after, only returning for a one-off appearance six years later (though Animal had a later run with Heidenreich as his partner).
4. The Melanie Pillman Interview
Brian Pillman passed away the day he was supposed to wrestle Dude Love at In Your House 18: Badd Blood. It was an awful situation, with the 35-year-old suffering a heart attack in his hotel room.
He was survived by his wife Melanie. The duo were going through divorce proceedings at the time, though Melanie claimed that it was supposed to be a wake-up call her husband, who'd been living in the family basement. Regardless, that WWE put this grieving widow on WWE television the night after Brian's passing was nothing short of heartless.
Melanie Pillman was subjected to an intense grilling from Vince McMahon, whose only intention was to absolve his company of any blame for his passing. "Have you had any opportunity to think of what you, as a single parent, will do to support your children?" he asked, live on TV, with Brian's body not yet cold, then prodded her on her husband's reported painkiller addiction. The message was simple: he was out to prove that Brian's death was on Brian, in the most tasteless manner imaginable.
Even worse is that WWE used this as a ratings grab, holding the interview in Raw's second hour after a night of near-nonstop promotion.
3. Continuing With Crown Jewel Post-Khashoggi
Dissident Saudi Arabian journalist Jamal Khashoggi was brutally murdered inside Istanbul's Saudi consulate on 2 October 2018, having previously fled his country of birth to go into exile. While the Saudi government initially denied the death, the country's attorney general confirmed the premeditated murder of a man never shy of sharing his criticising of King Salman and Prince Mohammad bin Salman, who, according to a CIA investigation, ordered the assassination.
These are the people WWE leapt into bed with when agreeing their multi-million dollar deal.
The backlash was swift. WWE were put under immense pressure to scrap their upcoming show in the wake of Khashoggi's death, though it'd mean missing out on a huge financial windfall. Ultimately, they chose cash over morales.
"Considering the heinous crime committed at the Saudi consulate in Istanbul, the company faced a very difficult decision as relates to its event," WWE's statement read. “Similar to other U.S.-based companies who plan to continue operations in Saudi Arabia, the Company has decided to uphold its contractual obligations to the General Sports Authority and stage the event."
Disappointing? Bitterly. Surprising? Absolutely not. As if WWE would actually be the company to turn down literal blood money.
2. The Greatest Propaganda Machine
The argument that politics shouldn't be brought into the discussion surrounding WWE's ongoing business in Saudi Arabia is invalid. The company made this political, not wrestling media, the fans, or anyone else. It's impossible to remove politics from the debate because this is a political debate.
Shows like Crown Jewel are part of an initiative commissioned by the Saudi royal family designed to rehabilitate the country's global image through big, attention-grabbing events. Saudi Vision 2030 is, in a nutshell, a transparent PR job engineered to paint a brutal regime in a positive light. That's why WWE are there. It has nothing to do with bringing Sports Entertainment to wrestling-deprived crowds and everything to do with propaganda.
Said propaganda was everywhere on the Greatest Royal Rumble broadcast, turning the event into what was effectively a five-hour Saudi infomercial. Vignettes on Mohammad bin Salman's supposed social progress, appeal as a tourist destination, and anti-Iran sentiment were spliced between every other match or segment. There were impossible to miss, making the anti-political argument untenable.
WWE fortunately dialled back on this at Crown Jewel 2018, but that they were so blatant in airing this propaganda was almost unbelievable.
1. NOT Stopping Over The Edge 1999
Owen Hart plummetting 70 feet to his death at Over The Edge 1999 should have brought the show to a halt. It didn't.
Though TV viewers were spared the grisly sight, they were informed of what had happened by a heartbroken Jim Ross an hour later later. "I have the unfortunate responsibility to let everyone know that Owen Hart has died," he said. "Owen Hart has tragically died from that accident here tonight."
15 minutes passed before Vince McMahon and his team made the call to keep the pay-per-view going. Poor Val Venis, Nicole Bass, Jeff Jarrett, and Debra emerged for a tag match shortly after the announcement. They, like the rest of their peers, were shell-shocked, but tasked with proceeding regardless. Cold-blooded and classless, it took the ridiculous "show must go on" mentality to a ridiculous new level.
Vince was tasked with making an incredibly difficult decision on the spot and in the moment, with information hitting him from all angles. Ultimately, he made the wrong one. It didn't matter that the pay-per-view was just getting started and refunds would've been issued - a man fell to his death. Nothing else should matter.