10 Times WWE Were Shamelessly Exploitative
This is not exploitation, no, this is just a 'tribute'.
The whole wrestling world united in paying tribute to the great 'Mean' Gene Okerlund following the legendary interviewer's passing in early January. Few stars of the business were as intimately associated with Okerlund than arguably its biggest of all time, Hulk Hogan. So it was only natural that The Hulkster led the eulogies.
What was less natural was WWE laying out the red carpet and diverting ten minutes of their flagship programming for him to do so. Appropriate - and deeply affecting - though Hogan's Monday Night Raw encomium towards his close personal friend was, it was difficult to ignore the reality that, once more, as they had with Crown Jewel, WWE had leveraged a real-life situation to sneak Hogan back onto their screens.
In Jeddah, the company hoped those chastising Hogan's comeback would be drowned out by the general tone of disgust. On this occasion, they knew laying into their exploitative practices would be erroneously confused and conflated as criticism towards Hogan's genuine sentiments about the beloved Okerlund.
In other words, they knew they would get away with it. Somehow, they always do.
10. Eddie Gilbert's Broken Neck
Eddie Gilbert was nothing more than a jobber during his early-'80s spell with WWF, but just as he was breaking into the mid-card, his career received an unusual, unexpected boost via the most bizarre of circumstances.
Gilbert was travelling home from a house show in Allentown, PA, when he was involved in a near-fatal car crash. The wreck wracked him with serious injuries. 'Hot Stuff' grew out his distinctive beard to conceal scars from reconstructive surgery, whilst he was left plagued by back and shoulder issues which for years encouraged his ultimately fatal painkiller addiction.
Worst of all, he broke his neck in the accident. But it wasn't all bad news - at least in the eyes of Gilbert's employers. When he had fully recuperated, he returned to WWF screens as Bob Backlund's new protégé ahead of a renewed push - with the neck injury fully publicised.
This being wrestling, it wasn't long before The Masked Superstar (Bill Eadie under a white hood), feared for his use of neckbreakers, cracked Gilbert's vertebrae afresh to the absolute horror of concerned fans. Backlund broke down in tears as his charge was hauled away in an ambulance.
Oddly, the whole scenario resulted in a programme for Backlund himself, not Gilbert, who shortly after left the company. At least his broken bones were worth something.
9. Hogan Returns
Apparently WWE had Jo Moore on the staff around the time the company was embroiled in their Crown Jewel disgrace in November 2018.
Vince McMahon's decision to push ahead with the proposed Saudi Arabia show, even once it had emerged that Washington Post journalist Jamal Khashoggi had likely been executed at the hands of government officials, was met with widespread, justifiable opprobrium. But apparently the cash-grab alone wasn't distasteful enough.
Aside from trying to palliate the palaver, WWE instead considered the desert a good place to bury the bad news of Hulk Hogan's return following his own racism-related scandal. The Hulkster was sneaked back on screen in Saudi Arabia, a soft relaunch on his WWE career whilst the world's media were distracted by the event's more substantial overcoat of enormity. It almost seemed like an act of spite.
8. The Warrior Award
When WWE chose to exploit the sudden death of The Ultimate Warrior shortly after his relationship with the company had finally thawed, they seemed to go out their way to make it as distasteful as possible.
During his Hall of Fame induction speech, Warrior had suggested a gong named for long-time WWE merchandiser Jimmy Miranda, with the company's unsung behind-the-scenes heroes in mind. Instead, they came up with an award taking his own name, to recognise those who have "exhibited unwavering strength and perseverance, and who live life with the indomitable spirit of The Warrior."
Which was all well and good - except for the name. Few could argue that those in receipt have deserved it - but should they have accepted it? If they'd stopped to reflect on The Warrior's "true spirit", which extended to telling the LGBT community that "queering don't work", instructing an Iranian student to "get a towel", and openly wishing for Bobby Heenan's death from cancer, then probably not. In reality, the 'Warrior Award' is nothing than faux philanthropy masked behind an exploited, lionised legacy.
7. Mocking Jerry Lawler's Heart Attack
On the 10 September 2012 episode of Monday Night Raw, Jerry Lawler suddenly fell silent whilst calling a routine tag team match between Team Hell No and The Prime Time Players. The audience looked on in stunned silence as a commotion began to fester around the announce table. 'The King' had suffered a massive heart attack.
Just ten minutes earlier, he'd been involved in a tag match against Dolph Ziggler. He now lay clinically dead backstage, as an ashen faced Michael Cole bravely fought through his own emotions to announce that this was a real-life situation.
Miraculously, Lawler pulled through, and returned to WWE screens just two months later. He was met with a heartfelt embrace by his announce colleague in one of the company's lesser-spotted moments of legitimate emotion.
Inevitably then, the whole story was immediately exploited for cheap heat. Later that same night, CM Punk mocked Lawler's near-death experience, whilst his advocate Paul Heyman coughed and spluttered by his side. Run-of-the-mill heatmongering for sure, but given how the situation had pulled at the heartstrings of so many, it came across as particularly tasteless.
In 2017, WWE returned to the well, as Dolph Ziggler goaded Lawler during an episode of SmackDown to the effect that it was his elbow drops to the chest which had caused his cardiac arrest. Five years after the fact - and without ruining a rare feelgood moment - it was fair game.
6. Using Roman Reign's Leaukemia For Heat
After finally toppling Brock Lesnar following years throwing pebbles at his metaphorical Goliath, Roman Reigns was cruelly blindsided by one of fate's ironies, when he was tragically forced to vacate his Universal title following a recurrence of leukemia.
Reigns' sobering announcement reminded everybody in attendance of the real man behind the mic, and the persistent boos which had dogged the The Big Dog instantly turned to cheers of appreciation. The raw emotion was tangible as Reign's Shield brothers joined him on the ramp, their faces bewashed by tears.
Grief-stricken fans had to compartmentalise their actual feelings later that same night, when Roman's illness was used to instigate a heel turn by Dean Ambrose. In an era where the curtain has long since been removed from the rail, nobody truly bought into Dean's dastardly deceit, and instead it just highlighted that WWE were more than happy to cash-in on real life tragedy.
That wasn't even the end of it. On the 20 November 2018 episode of Raw, Ambrose intimated that Reigns' was "answering to the man upstairs" for some unrevealed misdemeanour as part of The Shield. Not only was his cancer being used as a lazy shortcut for heat, but the implication was that every sufferer of the disease somehow deserved it.
5. Paige Crosses The Line
Though Ric Flair's tear ducts are generally poised to discharge at the slightest provocation, the way WWE provoked him to tears on the 16 November 2015 episode of Monday Night Raw was completely beyond contempt.
During the contract signing ahead of their big battle for the then-Divas' Championship at the upcoming Survivor Series pay-per-view, Paige levelled opponent Charlotte with the broadside that her younger brother Reid - who died of accidental overdose in 2013 - "didn't have much fight in him."
Outrage, inevitably - and justifiably - followed. WWE professed that the line had met with Charlotte's approval, with a company spokesman stating that "“Subject matter this personal is only approved as a result of the strong advocacy of the talent themselves."
However, they hadn't bothered to run the script past Reid's father Ric, a regular presence on WWE TV at the time. Who would ask a bereaved father such a question? Nobody - and if they had, the angle would never have played out. Nor should it have.
4. Muhammad Hassan
Marc Copani's Muhammad Hassan's character could have been a real positive for the industry at a time when xenophobic stereotypes were still depressingly rife. Rather than being booked to exploit the simmering racial prejudices of a society still recovering post 9/11, Hassan instead aired legitimate grievances about the treatment of American Muslims in the wake of the tragedy.
Apparently, this made him a heel.
Little by little, the Islamophobic leanings of the character gradually ramped up. His questioning of American attitudes earned him a "sand people" rebuke from none other than Steve Austin, whose casual racism was met with a babyface reaction. Likewise, Hassan earned the ire of American hero Hulk Hogan - prejudice which makes more sense with the passing of time.
The distasteful arc reached its nadir with a devastatingly timed angle during which Hassan and a posse of masked men - terrorists, in other words - kidnapped and subsequently garroted The Undertaker, before the 'martyr' was carried away on their shoulders.
Just one day before the awful taped angle was scheduled to air, London was hit with a terrorist attack which left 56 dead and many hundreds more injured. Yet unbelievably, the SmackDown segment aired as intended on UPN. The TV network were not happy, and immediately ordered an end to the Hassan character. For once, WWE let sense prevail over sensationalism, and dropped the whole storyline. Poor Copani was out of a job because of his employer's own lack of sensitivity.
3. Paul Bearer's Death
In April 2013, to build up their blowoff match at the upcoming WrestleMania XXIX, CM Punk decanted the entire contents of The Undertaker's urn all over his opponent, before lathering himself in ash. Implicitly, they were the remains of 'Takers deceased manager, Paul Bearer.
Fans had seen the Bearer character die on screen - more than once - but this had nothing to do with that. William Moody - the man behind the Bearer persona - had actually died just a month earlier.
Paul Heyman, made up in ghoulish pancake to resemble Bearer, looked on as Punk supposedly soaked himself in Bearer's residuum. Even though Moody himself, as committed to the industry as anyone, probably would have approved of the angle, it felt more like cheap exploitation than a tribute.
After the stunt, Moody's family, whilst confirming they had signed off on WWE's intentions, were disappointed with how things had transpired on screen. It was an uncomfortable watch for Moody's sons, and just as uncomfortable for fans, as the angle itself became the talking point, rather than the upcoming match.
2. Eddiesploitation
On 13 November 2005, just one day prior to a scheduled World Heavyweight Championship victory on SmackDown, Eddie Guerrero was found dead in his hotel room. He was 38 years old.
What followed was an outpouring of grief from all facets of the industry for one of its best-loved performers. WWE led the tributes for their fallen superstar, with both episodes of the week's Raw and SmackDown given over to his honour. The entire roster, many of them overcome by tears, stood on the entrance ramp in silence as a ten bell salute sounded for Guerrero.
WWE's touching tribute was soon rendered meaningless when Eddie's death was incorporated into Rey Mysterio's long-running tilt at the World Heavyweight Championship. At first, Mysterio vowing to win the Royal Rumble for his close friend seemed reasonable. What wasn't was rival Randy Orton getting in on the act, callously claiming that "Eddie ain't in heaven... he's in hell!" Vince McMahon - and according to a group of ex-writers, the idea was entirely his - had stopped honouring Eddie's death, and was simply milking it.
1. The Melanie Pillman Interview
WWE's reaction to Brian Pillman's sudden passing just hours before he was due to compete at the Badd Blood pay-per-view was bizarre, to say the least.
On the night, a stony-faced Vince McMahon imparted the tragic news, but it was billed more like an apology to disappointed viewers than an announcement of an employee's death. To make up for Pillman's match being necessarily cut from the card, out trotted Mexican minis Mosaic and Tarantula to compete a totally tone-deaf comedy match.
An understandably shaken Vince was in a bind, so perhaps the bungled handling could be excused. What couldn't, was his decision to subject Pillman's griefing wife Melanie to a live grilling the very next night on Monday Night Raw as though it was simply the next beat in a wrestling angle.
McMahon turned Martin Bashir for the night with the implicit objective of absolving WWE from any responsibility for Pillman's death, the widow badgered into admitting her late husband did not abuse steroids. But it also served another purpose: McMahon gradually ratcheted the screw throughout the interview, cranking up Melanie's emotions - and, he hoped, the ratings.
The sordid stunt attracted widespread criticism, but McMahon refused to repent, insisting the grief-stricken exposure had benefited the family. How, he did not mention.