10 Times WWE Wrestlers Escaped Booking Hell

How The Rock, JBL, and New Age Outlaws escaped WWE booking hell!

The Rock transformation
WWE

Like a steel cage match, bad booking not only traps a wrestler but leaves them vulnerable to a serious beating - and while escape is possible, it's one hell of a climb away. If you’re fortunate, you could be launched through the cage to the other side (à la Steve Austin at St. Valentine's Day Massacre), yet this is extremely rare.

WWE’s creative machine often seems like a fantastical ancient god prior to a sanitised Disney reinterpretation. An out-of-reach power playing with wrestlers like toy soldiers, crushing and burning them with the change of seasons. The system wears its own set of Firefly Funhouse gloves – reading Success and Slaughter: for those who can escape the wringing grasp of scripted restrictions, there is a second chance at Success, for the rest, “Hurt” and “Pain” would be preferable.

Faith in WWE's booking is often blind and really, you only discover whether it was worth it at the end. Will a wrestler be a Hall of Famer or an obscure trivia question?

As Virgil (not that one) and Dante escaped the nine circles of Hell, these lucky superstars escaped the squared circle’s own brand of purgatory…

10. Mercedes Martinez

Mercedes Martinez
WWE.com

RETRIBUTION, while mocked for their presentation, could have redeemed themselves if booked as a dominant force. With repeated losses the group has become a cross between The Ascension and Kai En Tai left to play in Lucha Underground’s leftover assets.

The supremely talented Mia Yim is still trapped under the guise of Reckoning, Mercedes Martinez (quietly) shed her Retaliation identity, throwing out her membership card, bumper sticker, and insignia coffee cup.

Martinez took a stand and expressed her dissatisfaction with her role in RETRIBUTION. This alone is admirable knowing the precarious nature of WWE backstage politics. While she was grateful for the opportunity, the stage in her career and her age forced Martinez to be more selective, weighing up how her decisions will ultimately shape her legacy. Martinez said of her time in the stable; “it’s not a hidden fact that it was me. I don’t hide the fact, I don’t mention it, only because it was just a small part of what the bigger picture is”.

Martinez returned to NXT on 23 December 2020, annihilating Women’s Champion Io Shirai. She soon earned a shot at the championship on the yellow brand’s Vengeance Day special.


9. John 'Bradshaw' Layfield

JBL WWE
WWE.com

John ‘Bradshaw’ Layfield was notable for escaping constricting gimmicks. He debuted on 27 January 1996 as Justin ‘Hawk’ Bradshaw - a heel draped in fringe who wielded a bullwhip. He had the toothless tactic of branding fallen opponents with “JB”, using ink rather than traditional searing. Later, was paired alongside Kayfabe cousin Barry Windham as The New Blackjacks. The team fell victim to wrestling’s “New” curse and achieved little of note.

Bradshaw’s character was reinvented when he teamed with Faarooq as Hell’s Henchmen. After their manager, The Jackyl, left the company, the two were coopted into the Ministry of Darkness becoming The Acolytes. Backstage workings again sent the team on a tangent when Ministry leader The Undertaker took time away from the business. Bradshaw and Faarooq founded the Acolytes Protection Agency, a couple of mercenaries who’d beat-down anybody for beer money. The act saw the duo strike a balance between rough wrestling and comedy.

When the APA split during the 2002 Draft, Bradshaw was limited to the midcard. When he nudged his gimmick closer to his true self, he became JBL - a rich, swanky, Texan heel – a change which boosted him to win the WWE Championship.


8. The Rock

WWE Royal Rumble 2000 The Rock
WWE.com

In retrospect, Rocky Maivia is easy to mock.

He debuted looking like an over-oiled stripper who’d survived a string of baby boy gender reveals. His dead eyes and fixed smile furthered this comparison. That said, he made history as WWE’s first third-generation superstar (his ring name in honour of his father and grandfather) and was the sole survivor in his debut elimination match (Survivor Series 1996). He also captured the Intercontinental Championship just three months into his tenure.

The fans’ reaction to the character makes the backlash faced by Roman Reigns look tempered, as he was regularly welcomed to boos, jeers, and “Die, Rocky, Die” chants. Dwayne Johnson played the role to the best of his abilities but much of the hatred was predetermined. Johnson was cast in the mould of a “New Generation” babyface, after WCW had already changed the face of Western professional wrestling and WWE was moving towards the Attitude Era.

When Johnson took time away due to injury, he returned as The Rock, a member of The Nation of Domination. The former hatred fuelled a star heel turn. Once given a microphone and freedom, The Rock took the industry, and all of pop culture, by storm.


7. Kane

Kane WWE
WWE.com

Glenn Jacobs’ transition from a sinister pyromaniac monster to the Mayor of Knox County, Tennessee may be his most impressive, but his wrestling career saw its fair share of dramatic turns.

During a time when career gimmicks were popular, Jacobs debuted as Jerry Lawler’s dentist Isaac Yankem, DDS. If wrestling is a desired skill in your dentist, hit up Britt Baker. Yankem, despite keeping Lawler’s sh*t-eating-grin shining, had a smile that would be excluded from The Big Book of British Smiles for its graphicness. With teeth so yellow that if you looked closely enough, you’d find phone numbers for local handymen, Yankem was initially involved in memorable feuds before descending into a cycle of jobbing.

The less said about Jacobs’ portrayal as “Fake” Diesel the better. He unfortunately made it to the final three at Royal Rumble 1997, forever linking the character to the classic Steve Austin-Bret Hart finish. While accounting for hindsight, it is ludicrous to think that anybody believed Kevin Nash could simply be recast.

As Kane, Jacobs had one of the best debuts WWE has ever orchestrated. Though the nuances of Kane have changed over time, the gimmick gave Jacobs the success he deserved.


6. Bray Wyatt

The Fiend WWE
WWE.com

Windham Rotunda, a third-generation superstar and one of the most creative minds to turn their attention to the squared circle, began his WWE career steeped in genericism. He debuted on the reality show incarnation of NXT under the name Husky Harris. As a member of both The Nexus and The New Nexus, Rotunda gained exposure but was often overshadowed. A Randy Orton punt kick wrote him off TV, and the dregs of this period live on as Huskus Pig.

He re-emerged as the menacing backwater cult leader Bray Wyatt. Whether giving poetic and esoteric sermons on the mic or beating down opponents displaying a misplaced giddy joy, Wyatt commanded attention. He reached World Champion heights, but his time with the belt was repeatedly fleeting and his character was dulled by losses at crucial points in his career.

After time off-screen, he returned as a new Bray Wyatt. In one of the most surreal but affective gimmick tweaks, he debuted as a split personality – a child-friendly TV host who becomes the demonic entity ‘The Fiend’. As we wait for Wyatt to return from the flames, debate is still out as to whether this new gimmick is following the same old path.


5. The Hurt Business

Hurt Business WWE
WWE

The Hurt Business are currently the most dominant and decorated stable on the main roster, albeit in a time of low competition. Nevertheless, the boost to the careers of each member has been immense.

The group’s leader, Ruthless Aggression mainstay Montel Vontavious Porter, was assumed retired and his appearance at Royal Rumble 2020 a one-off. He quickly got back to in-ring competition on the Raw brand. When he transitioned to a managerial role, on top of being a backstage producer, MVP saved Bobby Lashley from his pairing with Lana - a leftover storyline from the pitiful spaghetti junction of kayfabe lust and love also involving Rusev and Liv Morgan. MVP picked Lashley up and guided him to the United States Championship.

MVP and his CEO recruited Shelton Benjamin and Cedric Alexander. Benjamin’s last memorable act was being swiftly ejected from the Rumble by long-term friend Brock Lesnar. Alexander, other than his thrown together teaming with Ricochet, had been directionless since his days as Cruiserweight Champion. It would be generous calling either a mid-carder. The duo quickly captured the Raw Tag Team Championships and are one of the company’s most gifted pairings.


4. Bayley

Bayley Referee
WWE.com

Bayley’s path to booking hell had a lot of memorable matches and considerable title accolades. She is one of NXT’s greatest success stories - an organic babyface created in the WWE Performance Center. As ‘The Hugger’, she was a lovable underdog, with a child-like innocence that made fans protective of her. Her merch was a best seller and she almost made Wacky Waving Inflatable Tube Guys look fun, but as with all Lawful Good babyfaces, the act eventually became grating and one-note.

Bayley and Sasha Banks teased reigniting their acclaimed NXT rivalry on the main roster. Most naturally assumed Bayley would be cast as the face, with Banks already a proven heel. Bayley chopped off her signature ponytail, burst her Bayley Buddies, and turned on her fans. Her 380-day run as SmackDown Women’s Champion greatly benefited from the new persona. ‘The Huggable One’ couldn’t carry an extended championship reign while keeping fan’s interest piqued, and the realignment made the feud with Banks one of the hottest rivalries of 2020.

Even away from the title picture, she is an entertaining and witty heel, who isn’t afraid to play up the goofiness inherent in professional wrestling.


3. Dolph Ziggler

Dolph Ziggler
WWE.com

The character Dolph Ziggler is sanctuary for Nick Nemeth after escaping booking hell twice.

Nemeth debuted on WWE C-show Sunday Night Heat on 19 September 2005. He was cast as a golf caddie for Chavo Guerrero Jr.’s cringe-inducing Kerwin White persona, though the whitewashed gimmick was axed in the wake of Eddie Guerrero’s death.

When he returned to TV (Raw, 23 January 2006), ‘Nicky’ was a member of The Spirit Squad. The male cheerleaders were a group of goons who recalled the Mean Street Posse with the irritability factor cranked up and were inserted into the rivalry between Vince McMahon and Shawn Michaels, cheering the boss on, and both dishing and taking beatings in his honour. The Squad’s only achievement was winning the World Tag Team Championships, splitting the honour five ways under the Freebird Rule.

Before the year’s end, DX launched all five members into a crate addressed to “OVW - Louisville, Kentucky” - an embarrassing way of sending them back to development.

Dolph Ziggler’s overall success is debatable, but he is a solid mid-carder, able to put a decent match on with any opponent. As a caddie or a cheerleader, he would never have become a two-time World Heavyweight Champion.


2. Umaga

Umaga Promo Pic
WWE.com

Eddie Fatu, a member of the Anoa'i wrestling family, was not always booked in line with his legendary lineage.

Fatu joined WWE alongside his cousin Matt Anoa'i in 1996 for the initial purpose of having them feud with their relative Solofa Fatu. Eddie and Matt portrayed silent gangsters seemingly set up to be foils to Solofa’s “Make A Difference” Fatu gimmick. When this was nixed, the team were sent to the Heartland Wrestling Association to improve.

Upon their return, they were repackaged as Jamal (Eddie) and Rosey (Matt) forming 3-Minute Warning, the muscle for Raw General Manager Eric Bischoff. The cousins served as the consequence for anybody who failed to interest Bischoff in a three-minute time limit.

3MW’s enduring legacy is as the violent component of WWE’s most cringe-worthy LGBTQI+ moments; beating down two women whose “Hot Lesbian Action” failed to amuse Bischoff, and derailing Billy and Chuck’s fake gay wedding. In WWE, the team was aptly short-lived.

Eddie Fatu’s luck changed when he returned as Umaga: a savage, ruthless monster. He gained credibility via a destructive rampage, beating, and sometimes outright squashing, the Raw brand’s best and brightest.


1. The New Age Outlaws

New Age Outlaws 1997
WWE.com

The time between the New Generation Era surpassing its expiry date and the Attitude Era beginning with a bang was a revolutionary reset. The benefits were widely advantageous, however, Brian James and Monty "Kip" Sopp gained even more than most.

When James debuted in WWE, he was Country musician Jeff Jarrett’s roadie. The Roadie and Jarrett’s run lasted mere months before the pair left the company. The Roadie, now Jesse James, returned as a star. He called himself "The Real Double J" and took credit as the voice behind the other ‘Double J’s’ music.

His future partner Sopp followed a similar path. After capturing the Tag Team Championships as a member of The Smoking Gunns, Billy Gunn became Rockabilly – the prodigy of The Honky Tonk Man. He found himself between the egos of James and Honky, ultimately siding with James and smashing a guitar over his mentor.

They teamed up as The New Age Outlaws – now going by ‘Road Dogg’ Jesse James and ‘Badd Ass’ Billy Gunn. In leaving their Country routes, they became exciting prospects. Their absorption into DX increased their popularity further. The Outlaws were the third-best merch sellers during the hugely profitable Attitude Era.


Watch Next


Contributor

An English Lit. MA Grad trying to validate my student debt by writing literary fiction and alternative non-fiction.