10 Totally Dumb Booking Tropes Wrestling Is OBSESSED With

When Kevin Owens hates WWE more than Dave Meltzer...

Finn Balor
WWE

Is wrestling inherently and irredeemably stupid?

Advertisers certainly seem to think so. If you ever wondered why it took so long for an alternative to air on major cable - despite WWE's concurrent impressive viewership and savage critical reception, which indicated that there was a market for it - it is because advertisers, for decades, even during WWE's mainstream visibility, deemed wrestling fans too stupid and poor. And, because they were apparently too stupid and poor, it was pointless selling ads in the slot.

Why sell cars to people too uneducated to get a good enough job to afford one?

This is how the advertising industry perceived you, the reader. They probably still would, if you weren't among the only people left actually watching television shows in 2023.

After all, you'd have to be as thick as hell to watch wrestling, with its puerile humour, unrealistic combat, and dire melodramatic acting. Do you even know it's fake? Of course you do, but advertisers thought you were that stupid (which they conflate with being poor).

Wrestling is tremendous at its best. Kenny Omega's dense storytelling. GUNTHER's ability to make his opponents struggle for everything. Kazuchika Okada's new pissed off veteran phase.

On the following evidence, however, the advertisers may have a point...

10. The Subplot In The Background

Nikki Cross Candice LeRae
WWE

"And the Emmy for Outstanding Drama Series goes to..."

"Wait!"

A member of the panel sprints towards the stage. They have just watched an entry submitted at the eleventh hour. They whisper in the celebrity presenter's ear before darting back to their seat.

"Breaking news, guys. The Emmy was going to be awarded to Succession, but I've just been informed that Nikki Cross has been lurking in the background of some interview segments with Candice LeRae, and as such, your winner is WWE Monday Night Raw!"

Triple H is besotted with this trope, which sometimes isn't too dumb in and of itself. The idea is to use TV time economically and tease a mystery.

It is however dumb for how clever he thinks it is. Triple H thinks it's a hard-to-spot easter egg, a subtle flex of his incredible booking prowess. The other unfortunate reality of the trope is that it never goes anywhere...ever.

Cross and LeRae barely appear on Raw at the time of writing. Additionally, Triple H teased a similar alignment between Finn Bálor and JD McDonagh recently. The idea that Finn was hiding in the background, already a stretch, was rendered all the more daft when he was bathed in the purple light of his Judgment Day stable. McDonagh went 50/50 on Main Event with Apollo Crews across July.

Hardly subtly brilliant storytelling, is it?


9. Contracts

Matt Hardy Sad
AEW

An incredibly tiresome debate has raged across the online space throughout 2023: what is storytelling in pro wrestling?

The answer is literally anything that elicits an emotional response from the crowd and elevates a talent, whether that is a long drawn-out episodic plot, a daft backstage skit, or an actual wrestling match.

Some feel that the last bit, the wrestling part of wrestling, is not a story unto itself but rather the thing that can only happen, and is only worth watching, at the end of a long story.

When were Private Party hotter: immediately following a 14-minute match with the Young Bucks on the second episode of AEW Dynamite, or after three full years of an association with Matt Hardy and his contractual meddling?

The idea that a talent can own another talent's contract is fake and tedious bull. It's a ridiculous premise for a story, and the story itself is never strong enough to justify it. Winning a match to "get out of" a contract has never drawn money, a rating, a loud emotional response, anything.

Was anybody excited, upon AEW's launch, about the administration-oriented presentation? Why does AEW do this? Can you even keep track of the whole saga?

It's not particularly complicated, it's just that nobody cares. Hardy owned Private Party's contracts before merging the HFO with Andrade to create a NewCo named the AHFO. Upon Rush's arrival in AEW, Andrade stopped caring about his business so much, and when he left, Rush didn't give a damn about it at all, leading to the Firm purchasing the old HFO's contracts. What happened with TH2, the Butcher and the Blade and Jora Johl?

You don't give a single damn, which is funny, because "focusing a little more on storytelling" is apparently the answer to AEW's prayers!


8. Lampshade Hanging

Kevin Owens
WWE.com

Lampshade hanging happens in virtually every storytelling medium, and wrestling is no different.

It's basically a means of telling the audience that what they are watching is far-fetched or a bit dumb, but that's okay, because the author agrees. It's a cheeky way of getting away with some rubbish or other, basically.

It's necessary sometimes, but there is a good and bad version of everything.

The good: Kevin Owens doing a great impression of an apoplectic Seinfeld character ranting about how contrived Monday Night Raw is as a television show. The implication is weird, though: Kevin Owens is more angry with WWE television and the way in which it is formatted than any critic with an "AEW bias".

And, when the show isn't at its post-peak worst, Kenny Omega on Being The Elite explaining that he sometimes concocts risky plans on AEW Dynamite - which involve him nearly getting Pillmanised - for dramatic effect.

The bad: Almost every other BTE skit in 2023. When a wrestler makes reference to the fact that their backstage interview has been conveniently interrupted to set up a match on the next show. Matt Hardy promising not to do any more contract storylines before getting one more out of his system.

This really only works when it's funny.

Ultimately, if the product is bad or at least ripe for mockery, isn't it preferable to make a better product and get rid of the contrived stuff altogether?


7. The Heel Commentator

AEW Collision Nigel McGuinness Ian Riccaboni
AEW

It used to make sense when the wrestling commentator aligned as a heel or babyface.

In the golden era of the WWF, Bobby Heenan's deranged grasp of reality - in addition to being genuinely piss-funny - underscored the vile actions of the heel characters. Those actions were so unconscionable that there was zero justification for their conduct, and listening to Heenan scramble made that all the more apparent. Jim Ross in the Attitude Era was an inspired inversion. His pearl-clutching act underlined the heinous antics of Triple H, Vince McMahon et al. He was indignant, and his role was quietly crucial. He made it feel as if the WWF had a soul to save, and that Steve Austin was the man to do it.

This is another thing that happens in wrestling years and years later purely because it has always happened.

In 2023, all commentators should play it neutral with a moralistic bent, unless of course a heel is guesting. Corey Graves is an obnoxious d*ck for the sake of it. He does not operate in harmony with the characters. He just does a diluted version of Heenan's act purely because Heenan was such a genius.

Wrestling is a less cartoonish landscape than it once was, particularly in AEW, and it's very jarring to hear Nigel McGuinness play heel on Collision. He rarely drills into the strategy of the in-ring, which is where Taz and Excalibur are so valuable in deepening the tension and credibility of a match, instead just siding with the heels for no discernible reason.

There was a psychology to Heenan's schtick, and only Jerry Lawler came close to getting it.


6. The Babyface Coward

Cody Rhodes
WWE.com

"The babyface coward" is an oxymoron, but leave it to WWE to make it real.

In WWE, a babyface will win a match, with a legitimate wrestling hold that some godforsaken reason is sold as a lucky throw of the dice, and the commentator will say that that babyface "stole one".

As if they are a heel who has cheated, and not a babyface who has...triumphed using a snug, well-timed technique.

This is less prevalent now that Vince is only on the periphery of creative, but still: totally dumb. The idea is to like and "get behind" the babyfaces, not look upon them as little weaselly bastards who can't believe they've won a match and scarper out of the ring in fear the second they've done so. Imagine the British Bulldog running away at SummerSlam '92.

Even Cody Rhodes, otherwise booked as strongly as any top WWE star ever, got the hell out of dodge after sneaking past Brock Lesnar at Backlash. It's the worst device imaginable to make it seem as though a match in some way does not "count", and that a more decisive sequel is required. If you're going to do a carny finish, at least make the babyface not look like a buffoon.

Again, this isn't quite limited to WWE; Bandido celebrated like an idiot when he beat Rush on Rampage back in November.


5. The Entrance Music Cue

Becky Lynch
WWE.com

So what happens here?

Does the wrestler ask the sound technician to hit their music before they hit the ring? If the sound technician for whatever reason is slow to react, does the wrestler wait to hear their sting, even if their mate is getting their brains plastered onto the canvas?

Or, does the sound technician see the wrestler, full of fury and ready to go to war, and cue up their theme? And is the wrestler so taken by their music that they register the crowd reaction momentarily before saving the day?

These are facetious, rhetorical questions, obviously. Promoters do the entrance theme-backed run-in spot because it almost always gets a pop.

It doesn't matter that the contrivance ruins suspension of disbelief and makes the live broadcast feel like a staged show. The pop is apparently more important than making the show feel urgent and believable. AEW barely did this early in its run, but succumbed to the temptation more often than not within months.

Wrestling as a thing you're meant to buy often collides with the reality that it is a big, daft spectacle - but can't this sort of thing, admittedly a very cool moment, be reserved for truly special occasions?

Nobody would ever want to do away with that December '98 Austin Pop - but nobody wants wrestling to feel like an entirely staged, fake-feeling production, either.


4. Impromptu Matches

Kevin Owens Turnbuckle
WWE.com

A lot of people don't mind the impromptu match. A lot of young people raised exclusively on WWE just think it's the norm, and have never questioned its logic gap.

Some hate the idea that the promoter slash authority figure shambles into an arena, having not booked a main event, but as luck would have it, their talent have argued in the show-opening segment 95% of the time for 25 bloody years.

It is convenient storytelling so laughably stupid, when used to excess, that Kevin Owens has a new bit in which he savagely mocks the stupidity of the trope and is apoplectic, on a weekly basis, that it happens all of the time. The impromptu match, through rampant overuse, has made every WWE show feel fake.

Does AEW have to follow that direction?

The impromptu match has happened more than once in 2023, which is alarming. Nobody needs to watch another promotion patterned after WWE. Of course, AEW is absolutely nowhere near that yet, but the comparison is going to get made.

AEW could make the device less awful by, for example, having the commentators make it clear that Tony Khan expects tensions to boil over - on certain weeks, a handful per year - and has allocated time on the show accordingly, with a standby match in place in case his suspicions are unfounded.

A small concession to reality is a huge reason to invest.


3. The Invisible Camera

Jey Uso Sami Zayn
WWE

Whenever AEW films a skit that doesn't take place in the arena, almost invariably, the camera is acknowledged.

In the recent MJF Vs. Adam Cole programme, the two frenemies have participated in "bro sessions" as a means of building chemistry. On each occasion, even if it's simply a drunk Cole asking the camera operator how they're doing, or MJF looking down the lens in disgust at the prospect of dining out at an establishment frequented by "poors", it is made abundantly clear that the camera is not invisible.

This is done because the existence of an invisible camera in the live arena of professional wrestling - which WWE has folded into its storytelling for well over a quarter of a century - is inexcusably stupid.

The characters in wrestling occupy the same world as the audience. You can't concoct some sort of evil scheme away from the prying eyes of those in the dressing room because the babyfaces in the dressing room have the ability to watch the same product as the people whose sympathy they beg for in the ring.

The invisible camera cannot logically co-exist with pro wrestling as a live, interactive, televised performance because it renders every character, automatically, a complete moron.


2. Inconsistent Safeguarding

Pull Apart Brawl Raw
WWE.com

The pull-apart brawl is a great device on its own terms.

This happens because a booker, early into a programme and particularly one that is highly anticipated, wants you to wish the characters could rip one another into shreds there and then. This doesn't happen because it is a means of building the anticipation. You have to watch next week - or ideally shell out for the pay-per-view! - to see the big show-down.

WWE is particularly fond of this trope when Brock Lesnar begins a rivalry with his next opponent. The idea is that he is capable of inflicting serious harm and therefore must be separated from his target, but as the weeks progress, he'll simply beat the hell out of him. The entire roster is conspicuous by their absence at this point because it's time for the beat-down heat angle.

The implication is funny - that the booker stops giving a damn about the wellbeing of their talent after about a week. There are tickets to be sold, after all!

While fundamentally a bit stupid, this is the sort of dumb wrestling trope that even the most cynical and pedantic fans don't complain about too much. They accept that a grudge must escalate, and that the booker can't give everything away immediately.

Unlike...


1. Selective Application Of Company Principles

The Outcasts
AEW

On the July 22 edition of AEW Collision, Andrade el Idolo was escorted out of the building. Commentator Ian Riccaboni explained that he was ejected because he was likely to interfere in and ruin the integrity of the World Trios title match. AEW wanted a clean contest.

Why, then, are the Outcasts allowed to interfere in almost every single match involving one of their members? They sometimes get thrown out, but they are always stationed at ringside to begin with - even though Tony Khan should know exactly what to expect by now. Do they have a manager's license? If so, why hasn't this been revoked?

Andrade hasn't yet interfered in a single match on Collision, and yet he was ejected from ringside for potentially doing something that repeat offenders actually do without impunity.

What?

Perhaps this is a philosophical difference between Dynamite and Collision that will become more pronounced over subsequent weeks, but what sense does that make? Khan books and is the storyline, mostly offscreen General Manager of each show.

Wrestling bookers tend to book storylines with a very convenient application of their "values" depending on where each programmes needs to go next. This isn't an isolated incident; Jeff Jarrett's stable was sometimes prevented from seconding their members to the ring earlier this year, because Tony Khan presumably knew what they were like, before simply being allowed to come back out the next week.

That's enough. It's time for a steel cage match to prevent outside interference...in this feud and this feud alone, my undercard babyface can get his head kicked off for all I care.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!