10 Totally Soul-Crushing WWE Title Changes
Glitters Like Gold.
'SummerSlam Comes Early' was the phrase used ad nauseam by WWE in a desperate attempt to heat up a tepid Monday Night Raw scene on the go-home show for the August spectacular.
Featuring two matches already booked for the card itself, as well as a face-to-face-to-face-to-face between four quasi-heels that not-so-subtly teased the likelihood of combat between the quartet of main eventers, the company again attempted to super-serve two masters in an effort to aid both their television ratings and Network subscribers primed for the weekend's blockbuster card.
In the case of Finn Bálor and Bray Wyatt, their listless affair created a reason for the former NXT Champion to unleash 'The Demon' this Sunday, as many had predicted. However, the Cruiserweight Division tune-up had substantially different far-reaching consequences.
Competing for the league's salvaged title less than a week before their SummerSlam encounter, Champion Neville and Challenger Akira Tozawa were dumped in the middle of the show to work a passable encounter for the 'King Of The Cruiserweight's beloved belt. Astonishingly, after 197 days of sheer dominance, the malevolent ruler was dethroned.
Though the match wasn't without charm, it was without notice, and without thought (more on that later).
For an industry built on a predilection that titles are everything, WWE has a bad habit of neglecting the reality that the same courtesy extends to fans too. When the gold is booked with such disregard, that indignity reaches the crowd, and can take an awful long time to recover.
10. Randy Orton Vs Triple H (Unforgiven 2004)
It was Randy Orton's legend being killed before even becoming fully established when WWE elected to have Triple H outsmart and outfight him less than a month after winning his first World Heavyweight Championship at SummerSlam 2004.
Steering into fan sentiment as they'd almost never do now, the company acknowledged the growing support for Evolution's young lion following his impassioned war with Mick Foley earlier that year, and elected to anoint him the youngest ever holder of Raw's top title with the August victory over Chris Benoit.
In storyline (and perhaps in reality too...) this didn't sit well with Triple H, who hadn't clung tightly to his beloved strap since dropping it to 'The Crippler' at March's WrestleMania 20. Orchestrating a turn alongside Batista and Ric Flair, HHH brutalised the new champion on his first night with the belt, leaving him alone beyond support Orton had garnered from the crowd.
In the two weeks that followed, the sentiment rapidly dwindled as Randy was booked to look like a coward and a lousy schemer, with it already being established that he couldn't hold on to friends.
The burial was complete when he couldn't hold on to the title. At the first attempt, and with only limited Evolution support, Triple H soundly beat 'The Legend Killer', returning Raw to its pre-WrestleMania status quo and quashing Orton's babyface momentum almost entirely.
9. Bayley Vs Alexa Bliss (Payback 2017)
You could feel it in the air.
Though not the constant many people assume it to be, WWE still have a nasty habit of humbling a performer in their hometown, dating back to days when what went down in -INSERT YOUR TOWN- would impact ticket sales ahead of the company's return there. From a televisual standpoint too, it was argued that the heel in question would benefit from additional heat at the expense of the local hero.
But like almost every decision made relating to the Raw Women's Title in the first half of 2016, it was the wrong move, in the wrong place, at the wrong time.
WWE had already given Bayley a false start with the prize, having her win and retain it against Charlotte Flair in less-than-perfect circumstances in a manner that derailed a potential WrestleMania feud and Flair's intriguing pay-per-view winning streak.
Her defence against Alexa was effectively her first leap outside the comfort zone of the vaunted 'Four Horsewomen' safety net, but the company perplexingly decided to let her fall flat on her face.
'Little Miss Bliss' went on to make an excellent Champion, restoring much-needed stability to the title and proving herself able to overcome woeful storylines, but the localised loss only accelerated Bayley's disparate descent. Now out injured, it's a slide she's unfortunately still failed to arrest.
8. Daniel Bryan Vs Sheamus (WrestleMania 28)
Though the company pounced on the moment in order to set a narrative for tear-jerking Daniel Bryan documentaries, his WrestleMania World Heavyweight Title squash from Sheamus wasn't ever intended to kick off a movement that would lead him back to the promised land two years later.
Latching on to his self-aggrandising 'YES!' chants as he entered for the evening's opener, the Miami crowd were beyond devastated when Bryan was struck with a single surprise Brogue Kick from the challenger to end his night and enjoyable reign after just 18 seconds.
Literally overnight, the murmurings of the monosyllabic call-to-arms throughout the remainder of WrestleMania turned into an out-and-out protest vote on the evening's typically rambunctious Monday Night Raw. In truth, the company were fortunate that it remained loud and strong enough for them to repurpose the following year in time for Bryan's push towards SummerSlam 2013 with John Cena.
Keeping Daniel a heel and literally insisting he screamed 'NO!' in response to the crowd, the company tried and failed multiple times to break the inexorable connection between the performer and the fans, with the audience's stubbornness winning out once and for all shortly after the disastrous 2014 Royal Rumble. A flat-out refusal from the fanbase to tolerate his 18 second mistreatment started it all.
7. United States Championship 20-Man Battle Royal (WWE Raw, May 2014)
Heels do bad things to babyfaces, then get their comeuppance. Without this most simple premise, professional wrestling is virtually nothing. But this well-walked path cannot just be a justification or get-out for careless booking and lazy writing.
Shortly after WrestleMania 30, Triple H found himself locked in a war with The Shield after Dean Ambrose, Roman Reigns and Seth Rollins left The Authority's employ in the wake of condescending neglect from 'The Game'. Ahead of two spectacular wars against the 'Hounds Of Justice' alongside his Evolution buddies Randy Orton and Dave Batista, 'The Game' took the usual heel approach of stacking the deck against his former allies to weaken their resolve. It was at this point somebody remembered that Dean Ambrose had held on to the United States Title for a whopping 351 days.
It was (and still is) a record reign for the title since its 2003 WWE inception, but it had been a run assembled quietly in the background of the group's absorbing trios wars, thus rendering the longevity something of a moot point.
Short of a celebrating a year with the title, it felt cynical enough of the company to dethrone Dean anyway, not least without even giving him the dignity of losing with honour. Hurled into a 20-man battle royal, Ambrose lasted until the bitter end, only to be eliminated by Sheamus a tone deaf babyface 'push' for the 'Celtic Warrior'.
6. London & Kendrick Vs Deuce & Domino (WWE SmackDown, April 2007)
Another lengthy title reign carelessly thrown to the wolves, the WWE Tag Team straps were tossed back into the mixer when longstanding stalwarts Brian Kendrick and Paul London were undone by cartoon newcomers Deuce and Domino during a SmackDown taping desperate to match Raw's own shock title twist.
WWE's 2007 Italian viaggio had generated one of the biggest shocks in some time, with Santino Marella emerging as a humble crowd member on Monday's Milan Raw to dethrone Intercontinental Champion and 'Samoan Bulldozer' Umaga almost entirely thanks to the help of Bobby Lashley.
Keen to cling on to the frantic energy of Monday, the SmackDown taping the following night afforded the greasy 50s duo an unexpected victory following a spontaneous decision to punctuate London and Kendrick's impressive 331 day run.
The high flyers deserve more credit than they receive for stabilising the blue brand's chronic doubles division at the time, with MNM's 2006 collapse giving way to a rotten Legion of Doom retread and the makeshift pairing of Batista and Rey Mysterio before the Shawn Michaels trainees sunk their teeth in.
With the loss, brief interest in the division returned to stoic indifference as Deuce and Domino's act completely failed to inspire. Trapped in the doghouse with management, London and Kendrick were drafted to Monday Night Raw soon after, and controversially Pedigree'd by Triple H just seconds after running in to save him from a beatdown.
5. Eddie Guerrero Vs The Big Show (No Mercy 2003)
Ahead of his unthinkable WWE Title victory over Brock Lesnar at February's No Way Out 2004, Eddie Guerrero was on the babyface run of his life in 2003 after establishing a deep connection with the audience despite attempts to keep him a heel.
This was never more apparent that the company's last-ditch effort to make him a heel following a breakdown in relations between him and makeshift partner Tajiri. After losing the tag titles to the Worlds Greatest Tag Team, Eddie delivered a gutwrench powerbomb to the 'Japanese Buzzsaw' on his low-rider, but 'Latino Heat' only galvanised more support in the turn.
His 'lie, cheat, steal' mantra had just become too popular, and was a natural fit to lift the United States Title immediately upon it's reintroduction in July. So often guilty of neglecting the obvious option in their storytelling, it was encouraging for WWE to make a call so instantly rewarding to fans, but this perhaps triggered the factory reset mentality just three months later at the height of Eddie's popularity.
Lumbering and aggressively overweight at the time, Big Show was the ultimate WWE safety bet as a heel as a face, but his dominant displays over one of SmackDown's fastest rising megastar set Guerrero back months, and sapped all quality from the division ahead of John Cena's own 2004 ascension.
4. Neville Vs Akira Tozawa (WWE Raw, August 2017)
Perhaps the biggest victim of WWE's counter-productive efforts to nurture their struggling television ratings and raise stagnating Network subscriber numbers, Neville has been forced to jump through countless hoops off-screen and yet still maintained his phenomenal role in front of the camera.
Either dragged out for meaningless spots on Monday Night Raw or hidden away in the purple badlands of 205 Live, the 'King Of The Cruiserweights' has epitomised the company's internal philosophy of 'maximising the minutes', gobbling up every second of screen time with his sensational portrayal as demonic heel.
His matches have routinely stolen shows, even in only receiving scant promotion. Forced onto kickoff shows, (and in the case of his WrestleMania curtain raiser with Austin Aries, off the DVD release), some of his best work has been criminally overlooked by the company despite maintaining the attention and support of the fanbase at large.
WWE may hotshot the title back on to the former champion at SummerSlam, but in defeat, he loses more than just a Championship. Such is the subverted nature of the present day product, his loss may be a reward for his hard work in the form of a promotion back to the main roster. If not, the company should prepare for a rebuilt Cruiserweight kingdom to burn yet again.
3. Shawn Michaels Vs Triple H (Armageddon 2002)
Shawn Michaels' unexpected World Title victory at November 2002's Survivor Series led some to decry a reliance on nostalgia on a night where The Big Show delivered Brock Lesnar's first defeat in dethroning 'The Beast', but a contemporary 'HBK' title reign did at least promise the potential of some great matches over the beleaguered title that had been besmirched by some rotten Triple H bouts throughout the Autumn.
It wasn't to be.
After a lone Monday Night Raw defence against Rob Van Dam in something of a dream match for the time, the miserable nose of familiarity crept back in to contention immediately, necessitating their 'Three Stages Of Hell' clash at December's Armageddon.
Engaging in a Street Fight, Steel Cage and finally a Ladder Match, 'The Game's victory over three falls reset the flagship show to its unsatisfying default, and concluded Shawn's fairytale story long before most fans soaked in the return of an icon.
Ultimately, it was deemed impossible to justify keeping the title on the part-timer Michaels still was at the time, but a reversion to Triple H in particularly convoluted circumstances left a deeply sour taste that wasn't going to be combatted by the next eight months of headline dominance by the 'King of Kings'.
2. Six-Man Cruiserweight Open (Great American Bash 2007)
Though hardly the top priority of WWE at any point during the near-two decades a variation of the lightweight division has existed, the company's Cruiserweight Title hit rock bottom in 2007 when a record-breaking Gregory Helms tenure and choice Chavo Guerrero spell were followed up by a victory for Hornswoggle that literally murdered the league.
The Great American Bash had hosted the type of multi-person spotfest the division had become a dumping ground for by 2007, but when Guerrero put the gold up for grabs against Shannon Moore, Funaki, Jamie Noble and Jimmy Wang Yang it at least assured audiences that the gold's prestige would be in good hands.
As usual, Hornswoggle was the punchline to a joke nobody was telling.
Emerging from underneath the ring as he was wont to do, the former 'Little B*stard' hit his Tadpole Splash on an unsuspecting Jamie Noble, rolling the former Ring Of Honor World Champion up to land his first and only singles title with the organisation.
After repeatedly getting the better of Noble on television in the aftermath, the diminutive star was then settled upon as the panicked outcome of the 'Mr McMahon's Illegitimate Son' storyline, forcing his surrender of the title for no adequately explained reason. It was mothballed completely, returning only last year in the 205-and-under format following the summer's Cruiserweight Classic.
1. Yokozuna Vs Hulk Hogan (WrestleMania 9)
Burying both main event talents having already dominated the middle of the broadcast his own, pre-arranged, title match, Hulk Hogan played an absolute blinder in his utter decimation of WWE's topline following his controversial early-1993 return to the company.
Slotted into best friend Brutus Beefcake's rivalry with Money Inc, it was a pleasingly understated spot Hogan would occupy at April's WrestleMania 9, especially as new WWE Champion and company figurehead Bret Hart required space away from the old guard to flourish against top new heel Yokozuna in their titanic clash.
'The Hulkster' had other plans. Falling short of tag title glory via disqualification, Hogan made a nuisance of himself following the screwy finish to the title match that saw Yoko rob Hart thanks to Mr Fuji throwing salt in the champion's eyes.
Idiotically challenging the comparatively fresh Hogan on behalf of his sumo behemoth, Fuji's mouth wrote a check his new champion couldn't cash. Hulk left 'The Hitman' to blindly stagger to the back, hit the ring and won his fifth WWE Title in just 22 seconds.
Other than the Vegas car park attendees drunk on nostalgia, just about everybody suffered from the decision. That included Vince McMahon, who lost a visual champion for two months thanks to Hogan's external commitments keeping him off television outside of one return at June's King Of The Ring. There, he dropped it right back to Yokozuna and departed the company for good.