10 Totally Underrated WWE Championship Reigns

Mankind's first WWE title reign wasn't just about his unlikely title win!

The history of any wrestling Championship is bound to be a bumpy one, replete with scripted swerves, real-life screwjobs and backstabbing politics... Great, legendary heroes stand astride their respective eras like titans, relinquishing their belts only for storyline purposes, or else as a ceremonial rite of passage to make the next big star. Some would-be WWE Champs never quite transition to the big time (usually a mixture of bad booking, audience reaction, or both) and others still have had the world handed to them on a plate, but simply lacked the knowledge or wrestling ability to take full advantage of what was on offer... Every once in a while, though, a WWE superstar becomes truly deserving of that title and embarks on a journey into the annals of legend. These greats; men like €˜Stone Cold€™ Steve Austin, Hulk Hogan, The Rock and Bruno Sammartino will forever be indelibly linked with their respective eras, their names becoming synonymous with greatness. In the eyes of their fans, they become Gods of the squared circle, akin to the gladiators of Rome... If you€™ve been a WWE fan for any period of time, you€™ll almost certainly have seen a couple of title runs that thrilled (or infuriated) you enough to keep you tuned in, week after week, event after event. You€™ve probably seen your fair share of duff, uninspired reigns as well (especially if you€™ve been a fan over the last decade or so). However, it is also entirely possible that there were some cracking title runs that, for one reason or another, we all missed out on. In this list, I€™ll be looking at 10 of the most underrated World Championship runs in WWE€™s history and (hopefully) making the case for why they deserve to be better remembered... Here goes...

10. Dolph Ziggler €“ World Heavyweight Champion (08/04/13 €“ 16/06/13)

Yes, it is a weird choice to start with, I know. However, Ziggler€™s WHC win was a huge moment for his many fans and demonstrated that €˜The Show Off€™ could hold the €˜Big Belt€™ as well as anyone else in the company. Having said that, what followed was by no means a great title run... Ziggler began by cashing in his €˜Money in the Bank€™ briefcase and dethroning Alberto Del Rio in a way that put neither man over as a particularly impressive champion. Ziggler then dropped the belt back to Del Rio a little over two months later and has since plummeted down the card (to the point where a lot of newer fans are wondering why he still gets a surprisingly healthy crowd pop whenever he enters the ring). ...But for one shining, golden moment, it looked like WWE was going to give Dolph the push he so obviously deserves. It seemed that Dolph Ziggler was going to get a chance to compete at the very top echelons of the company and thus, the world. Go back and HYPERLINK "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MKqtFqpRLEk" watch it again on YouTube, listen to the crowd, feel their reactions and take a swig of just how over Ziggler could be if the WWE marketing machine truly got behind him. With a fraction of the effort they put into burying Ziggler, they could easily turn him into a megastar overnight. Readers of UK wrestling mag Power Slam actually voted the moment of Ziggler€™s title victory as €˜Angle/Segment of the Year€™ for 2013 and it goes without saying that the IWC went crazy as well. However, the mainstream fan reaction is what ultimately matters and, by that yardstick, Ziggler STILL has all the makings of a great champion. We need to remember that title run, not for what it was, but for what it could have been, i.e. the start of something very big indeed.

9. Bret €˜Hitman€™ Hart - WWF Champion (03/07/97 €“ 09/11/97)

The Hitman€™s 5th (and final) WWF title reign will forever be overshadowed by the way it ended. Now, myself and every other wrestling correspondent that ever lived have analyzed the events known as €˜The Montreal Screwjob€™ to death. Books have been written, films have been made and numerous interviews have been given. There is even a small contingent of fans that genuinely believe, despite all evidence to the contrary, that The Screwjob itself was a work. So, whatever your thoughts on it may or may not be, we aren€™t going to go there this time out... The point is that, the 1997 model Hitman was absolutely at the peak of his powers. He had fully transitioned from flawless technician and respected mid carder to being THE bona-fide star of any WWF show. The Hitman was now a great all-rounder, beloved entertainer, respected in-ring worker and bankable drawing card. Hart had stepped out of the shadow of Hogan; he had beaten Ric Flair at his own game and he had enough experience at the Main Event level to qualify as a locker room general. In addition, despite the fact that it was obviously thrust upon him to lower his market value within the wrestling industry, Bret Hart embraced his newfound US-hating heel character with zeal and guts. Attacking the USA breathed new life into the Hitman character and gave Bret Hart a new angle to play up. As any longtime fan knows, the most beloved heroes will always make the most hated heels. Bret Hart€™s heel work was actually very polished as well, both in the ring and on the mic - and he was able to polarize fans in the same way that John Cena does today. His inflammatory, US hating promos led fans to get extra hot in the same way that old school fans used to when somebody cheated the hometown hero. Don€™t believe me? Re-watch the crowd interviews from Wrestling With Shadows. Those guys are almost ready to riot. A feud with the masked €˜Patriot€™ character (an instance of a very good wrestler saddled with a crap gimmick) unravelled his momentum a bit, but even still, by the time of the Screwjob, Bret Hart was the hottest heel in the business and his title run up to that point should be considered as some of the best work of his career.

8. Kurt Angle €“ WWF Champion (22/10/00 €“ 25/2/01)

If I decided to write a book called €˜How to Make a Pro Wrestling Star€™, chapter one would probably be called €˜Kurt Angle€™. The 2000-era Kurt Angle was a bright, good looking former Olympian who was motivated, eager to learn and as American as apple pie. In the hands of a lesser promoter, Angle would simply have been packaged as €œhe€™s an Olympic Gold Medal winner, he€™s an American sporting hero and he looks like G.I Joe. Start cheering, people€ (the way TNA books him today, in fact) €“ But Vinny Mac isn€™t just any promoter... Contrary to all expectations, the Kurt Angle character of the 2000€™s was arrogant, cowardly and deceitful. He ran away from challengers, cheated like it was a bodily function and generally acted as an irritating pr!ck at every opportunity. However, despite all that, Angle was rarely, if ever, booked to look weak. Once he got in the ring and started using his array of beautiful, textbook suplexes (his belly-to-belly and German suplexes are utterly definitive and never less than breathtaking), or his masterful holds and reversals, the fans were always allowed to see a master ring technician in action. In short, Angle was legit and the fans knew it. Following a superb feud with Chris Jericho, Angle was pronounced €˜Inter-Euro Champion€™ (meaning that he now held both the Intercontinental Championship and the European Championship simultaneously). The major wins continued and Angle capped off his rookie year by winning The Big One, in a meteoric rise that WWE has attempted a few more times since, but never quite as successfully (Randy Orton probably being the closest comparison I can think of right now). Today, with Angle€™s place as the best wrestler of his generation pretty much assured, people often forget that his first, damn-near year long title run as a despicable heel character granted him pinfalls over the era€™s biggest stars and saw him become one of the most recognizable faces in professional wrestling, practically overnight. Had his first reign been booked like Eddie Guerrero€™s one and only reign, or even Ziggler€™s WHC run detailed earlier, he might never have become the 11-time World Champion and massive star that he is today.

7. Andre The Giant €“ WWF Champion (05/02/88)

This title €˜reign€™ lasted less than a day and was really less of a belt change and more of a storyline or angle, but I find it interesting as a good example of professional wrestling storytelling. The truth is that, for the most part, title belts don€™t actually mean that much in pro wrestling. Of course, every wrestler wants to be the champ (who wouldn€™t?) €“ and some title reigns genuinely qualify as historic moments - but the reality is that title belts are really just built up in the minds of the fans to mean much more than they actually do. Originally, Championships only existed so that something would be at stake in the matches. A lot of wrestlers, such as The Undertaker, Bruiser Brody, The Original Sheik, Abdullah The Butcher and others never really needed a championship belt around their waist in order to earn credibility with the fans. Neither did Andre. By the time he was feuding with Hulk Hogan and The Ultimate Warrior in the late 1980€™s and early 1990€™s, health problems related to gigantism had taken their toll on The Giant. A genuinely great worker in his prime, Andre had been a star all over the world and he was booked as a kind-hearted and gentle giant, as well as a one-of-a-kind attraction. Now, however, his career was winding down and his ring work was, for the most part, sloppy and a little bit sad to watch. Still, Andre knew better than anyone how to use his size in order to appeal to a crowd and how to work a main event matchup like no one else. It was these skills, as well as his genuinely larger-than-life charisma that Andre used to credibly defeat Hulk Hogan for the belt (together with some help from Earl Hebner€™s €˜evil€™ twin Dave). Immediately after winning his first ever World Championship, Andre €˜sold€™ the belt to WWF€™s biggest heel, €˜The Million Dollar Man€™ Ted BiBiase. Sadly, DiBiase was not allowed a run with the belt at this time (the heat on The MDM would have been unbelievable) and the title ended up in the - wholly deserving - hands of superworker €˜Macho Man€™ Randy Savage instead. However, as an example of €˜shock & awe€™ storytelling, in my view, at least, this odd little title change is right up there. Surprises can be good in pro wrestling €“ and this one certainly sold tickets. You€™d never see something like this in a €˜legitimate€™ sport, which is part of pro wrestling€™s appeal, as far as most fans are concerned.

6. Billy Graham - WWWF Champion (30/04/77 €“ 20/02/78)

I know what you€™re thinking; €˜can€™t this guy write an article about wrestling that DOESN€™T go on and on about the genius of €˜The Superstar€™?€™ Well, no. Apparently I can€™t. 1977 was a year of great change all around the world. Star Wars: A New Hope was a hit at the cinema, punk rock was smashing down musical barriers all over the Western world and The Cold War was heating up and scaring the crap out of anyone lucid enough to be paying attention. According to Scottish author Iain Spence€™s Sekhmet Hypothesis, every 11 years, solar cycles effectively re-wire young minds, sending them into a frenzy, typified either by long hair, baggy clothing and trippy music (1966, 1988) or short hair, tight clothing and brief, aggressive music (1955, 1977). Well, 1977 was a year of change, as the zeitgeist shifted around to a tougher, harder scene. It was time, then, for the WWWF to crown its first true rebel champion. Imagine the attitude of €˜98-era Steve Austin, with the look of Hulk Hogan circa €˜84, or Triple H in €™02. Now imagine seeing all those guys for the first ever time. The €˜Superstar€™ (as he called himself) was the ruthless narcissism of the male ego given flawless physical form. Before Randy Orton was even born, The Superstar made it cool to be a douchebag. He was also the first, long-term WWWF heel Champion. Beforehand, heel champs had always been used as €˜transitional€™ title holders (i.e. a safe way of moving the Big Belt away from an older star without embarrassing the incumbent babyface hero). However, when Graham unseated the legendary Bruno Sammartino for the Big Belt €“ and then kept it for almost a year, it was as if the entire world had turned upside down. There had been long-term heel champions before, of course, but it was a new concept to the WWWF at the time. Graham€™s title reign became the prototype for all heel runs €“ a blueprint that is still being used today. Apparently, Superstar wanted eventually to be turned into a rebellious, edgy fan-favourite, but Vinny Mac Sr insisted that he drop his belt to clean cut nice guy Bob Backlund instead. He obviously didn€™t think that a rule breaking, ill-mannered anti-hero would be a draw as a champion. Ah, hindsight.

5. Rey Mysterio - World Heavyweight Champion (2/04/06 €“ 23/06/06)

At 5,6€ and 175lbs, Rey Mysterio was the last person that anybody expected to climb to the top of the WWE ladder. And yet he did. Winning a gobsmacking triple threat bout against Kurt Angle and Randy Orton at WrestleMania 22, Rey Mysterio€™s title run was the ultimate underdog triumph. If, to borrow a line from Germaine Greer €œrevolution is the festival of the oppressed€, then Rey Mysterio€™s first World Heavyweight Championship win was a full-on tattooed luchadore fiesta. In truth, Rey was always going to be a tough sell as a long-term World Champion, mainly because he is so slight in stature compared to the rest of the WWE€™s Main Event crowd. However, WWE recognized this and smartly booked Mysterio as €˜a little man with a big heart€™ who never gave up and never let his fans down, no matter what €“ and the fans responded. Naysayers tend to argue that Mysterio only got the belt that night as a tribute to the late, great Eddie Guerrero, Mysterio€™s close friend (and sometime rival) but I prefer to see it as a gesture of respect, given to Rey in recognition of his mould-breaking, trailblazing career in the squared circle. For some wrestlers, a Championship belt is more of a €˜lifetime achievement award€™ than a statement of intent from management €“ and that was definitely the case with Rey Mysterio. For longtime admirers of Mysterio€™s transcendent talents, seeing him finally recognized as a World Heavyweight Champion was a dream come true. We€™d watched him for years and any true fan respects the hell out of the man for his accomplishments and contributions to the sport, but most of us never actually believed he€™d get that far. To this day, if ever I fear that an obstacle is insurmountable, I re-watch Rey beating Kurt Angle and Randy Orton and I know in my heart that nothing is impossible.

4. Mankind - WWF Champion (29/12/98 €“ 24/01/99)

The first of Mick €˜Mankind€™ Foley€™s 4 World Championship runs actually lasted for less than a month, but it meant a hell of a lot to Foley€™s hardcore fanbase €“ and (probably) even more to the man himself... Mick Foley was a well-respected indie talent and ECW icon before being signed up to the WWF in the mid 1990€™s. Although he had been criminally underused in WCW, Mick Foley (who wrestled there as €˜Cactus Jack€™ €“ for the one guy reading this who didn€™t know that), had still engaged in a brutal, bloody and excellent feud with Vader and had memorably teamed with Abdullah The Butcher, as well as main eventing the occasional WCW Pay Per View. However, he was hardly a household name and was probably best known for putting his body on the line in all manner of gory stipulation matches with the likes of Sabu, Shoji Nakamaki, Tommy Dreamer and, of course, the legendary Terry Funk. Mick was never a prime physical specimen (although he was in much better shape than most people give him credit for) and the Mankind character, who appeared to have been modelled on Hannibal Lector at first, never seemed likely to become the poster boy for the clean cut, respectable WWF. However, with the change in tastes of the late 90€™s, a combination of Foley€™s innate charisma, ingenious promo work (he always was one of the best in the biz on the mic) and, of course, THAT Hell in a Cell bout at 1998€™s King of the Ring Pay Per View, made Mankind SUPER over with the WWF fanbase. He always had good chemistry with The Rock (both as friends and as rivals) and, from a booking standpoint; two thirds of Mankind€™s WWF Championships were aimed at enhancing The Rock€™s stature within the company. However, once again, it seems clear (to me, at least) that Vince McMahon wanted to acknowledge Foley€™s various sacrifices to the business and the company he loved. It seems that the decision to put the belt on Mankind was an acknowledgement to the fans, as well. It was as if the McMahons quietly looked up and realized just how much Mick Foley meant to us and just how many of us tuned in to WWF programming just to see Mick Foley do something crazy, or funny, or scary (often all three). Like Daniel Bryan in the run-up to WrestleMania XXX, Foley won over the fans, before he won over the McMahons. Mankind was a bona-fide WWF main eventer and one of the company€™s biggest stars, of course, but it was obvious that he was never getting his hands on that belt for any significant period of time. Still, Mick seems to have been fine with that... Honestly, I really think that all he ever wanted from the business was to be compensated well financially for the pain he put himself through and to be remembered as a guy that gave 150% of himself, every single night. Being a three-time WWF Champ is just the icing on the cake, really.

3. Randy Savage - WWF Champion (23/03/88 - 02/04/89)

€˜Macho Man€™ Randy Savage was the perfect World Champion. He had everything you needed. He could talk, he had bags of charisma, he could get over equally well as a heel or a face €“ and he could work. Good God almighty, that guy could work. The Macho Man€™s first reign was very well played out in the long term, with the character starting out as a trusted friend of the beloved Hulk Hogan and then slowly turning heel over time, all while he still had the WWF belt. In a 2013 interview with Fighting Spirit Magazine, Hogan said of Savage that, "You know, he's the only guy we could pass the belt to, and we wouldn't lose money. You gave the belt to The Ultimate Warrior - I don't want to drop a bunch of names - and right away the revenue went down. Give the belt to 'Macho Man', and things would stay the same, or get better." The bizarre love triangle angle between Hogan, Savage and Savage€™s manager (and real-life wife), Miss Elizabeth was relatable (who hasn€™t been there at least once?) and played off of Savage€™s legitimate jealousy towards Elizabeth. Hogan, an expert in milking sympathy from the crowd, was perfect as the misunderstood nice guy who watches his best friend slowly turn into a rotten apple and doesn€™t quite know what to do about it. The whole thing came to a head, of course, at WrestleMania V, when Hogan faced off against Savage and defeated him for the WWF Championship. Savage would go on to be WWF Champ once more (defeating Ric Flair), but eventually fell out of favour with Vince McMahon (and, if Bret Hart€™s book is to be believed, was treated abysmally in his final years within the company). He did go on to become a four-time WCW Champ, however. One day, when the WWE corrects its heinous mistake and FINALLY inducts The €˜Macho Man€™ into the Hall of Fame, I€™ll read this bit back to myself and smile. Your day is coming, Macho Man.

2. Bob Backlund €“ WWWF Heavyweight Champion (20/02/78 - 26/12/83)

Bob Backlund is arguably the most underrated and misunderstood wrestler in WWE history. A genuinely superb technical wrestler in his heyday, I tend to think of Backlund as the €˜last of the great old-school Champions€™. He was a man who (through absolutely no fault of his own) found himself surplus to requirements, as pro wrestling shifted gears in the mid-late 1980€™s and subsequently changed forever... The 1978-model Backlund was a far cry from the hypermanic nut job character of €˜Mr. Backlund€™ - as he is generally known by today€™s WWE fanbase. In fact, in the early part of his career, Backlund didn€™t really play a character; he was just a dedicated, serious athlete who lent believability and credibility to his ring work and promos. He didn€™t use catchphrases or anything like that; he just got in the ring and wowed the fans with his poise, skill and professionalism. He was the very definition of a €˜wrestler€™s wrestler€™. By the time he signed up to Vince Sr€™s WWWF promotion in 1977, Backlund had already tangled with greats such as Terry Funk, Harley Race and Jack Brisco in the NWA and was being groomed for even greater things. In fact, had the NWA continued to be the most recognized force in pro wrestling, then its safe to say that Bob Backlund would have eventually held the NWA World Heavyweight Championship before too long. In the WWWF, he was fast-tracked to the top and embarked on the second-longest title reign in WWE history, holding the Big Belt for around 5 years. He very briefly dropped the belt to Antonio Inoki €“ before quickly winning it back again- on a tour of Japan during this time, but WWE doesn€™t count that as official. If they did, Backlund would be considered a Three-time WWE Champion when all is said and done. Bob Backlund eventually dropped the belt at the very end of 1983. In a moment of beautiful, dramatic tension, Backlund€™s manager, Arnold Skaaland was forced to throw in the towel for his friend and client, who refused to submit to a gruelling Camel Clutch, being applied by The Iron Sheik. It was a sad, but fitting, end for both a character and an era. Less than one month later, Hulk Hogan roundly trounced The Iron Sheik and became the biggest star, first in wrestling, and then the world. In the era that ensued, Vince Jr€™s vision of a mainstream, family-friendly and entertainment-orientated wrestling product was brilliantly realized and Bob Backlund, with his amateur wrestling gear, serious demeanour and impressive array of complicated mat techniques, was suddenly obsolete. Backlund would return many times to the WWF/WWE over the years. In the 1990€™s, he inexplicably returned as a madcap heel to defeat Bret Hart for the belt and then pass it to Diesel (Kevin Nash) in a squash match soon after. Backlund€™s professionalism saw him sell Dielsel€™s powerbomb as if he€™d been skydiving without a chute and he literally crawled all the way out of the ring and up the ramp. Later, he had some memorable on-screen moments with Mick Foley and an up-and-coming Kurt Angle, which helped increase his profile with younger fans. The really interesting thing about his first title run is that, at the time, few could foresee the sweeping changes that were already on their way. Bob Backlund€™s first WWWF title reign would prove to be the last gasp of old school wrestling, before something bigger, bolder and more colourful took its place.

1. Pedro Morales - WWWF Heavyweight Champion (08/02/71 €“01/12/73)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ggk5ZQU1_hk A classic WWWF Champion, Morales broke new ground at every opportunity and was genuinely beloved by fans of the era. Watch their reaction as he wins the WWWF Championship from Ivan Koloff in the above clip and judge for yourself. Pedro Morales was built like a tank, had a great look and connected well with fans. His wrestling style was basic, not particularly showy and he mainly relied on fan interaction and ring psychology rather than powerful feats of athletic derring-do. Morales€™ detractors often note that, like Bruno Sammartino, he was mainly popular with €˜ethnic€™ audiences (in this case, Puerto Rican/Latino crowds) and that he wouldn€™t have gotten over in the Southern territories as well as he did in New York, where these markets were at their strongest. However, whilst there is undeniably some truth to that, it still doesn€™t detract from the fact that Pedro Morales was over with pretty much everyone in his WWWF heyday, regardless of their race or ancestry. Pedro Morales was born on the small Puerto Rican island of Culebra, which was home to about 600 people (an estimated 300 of which are apparently related to Morales in some way). When Pedro was a boy, the island only made use of electricity between 4 and 11PM. He left for Brooklyn, New York in order and attend High School (because there wasn€™t one in Culebra) where he learned to wrestle and eventually became a two-time World Champion with the WWA in 1965. However, since the NWA didn€™t recognize the WWA at all, Morales€™ single WWWF title run is remembered as making him the first Latin American to win a recognized World Heavyweight Championship. History should celebrate that, if nothing else. He wasn€™t a flash in the pan, either. Pedro Morales remained WWWF Champion for 1,027 days (almost three years) and, even today, is remembered as the 5th longest-reigning WWE Champion in history. He is also the longest reigning Intercontinental Champion in WWE History. During his groundbreaking reign, Morales went up against stars of the era like Blackjack Mulligan, Stan €˜The Man€™ Stasiak, €˜Classy€™ Freddie Blassie, Blue Demon and, of course, the great Bruno Sammartino. In 1995, Morales became the first Latin American to be inducted into the WWE Hall of Fame. If Pedro Morales hadn€™t had this hugely successful run as WWWF Champion, then it is likely that other Latin stars, such as Eddie Guerrero, Rey Mysterio or Alberto Del Rio would have had a much harder climb to the top of the mountain. In short, Pedro Morales was a pioneer and an icon of the sport and he deserves to be remembered that way. ...And that, as they say, is that. 10 WWE World Championship reigns that, for one reason or another, don€™t quite get the respect that they are due. Do you have any other, better suggestions? A forgotten, overshadowed, or underrated title reign that you want to shine a little light on? Go on, then. Pop your suggestions in the €˜comments€™ section... - CQ

In this post: 
Mankind
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

I am a professional author and lifelong comic books/pro wrestling fan. I also work as a journalist as well as writing comic books (I also draw), screenplays, stage plays, songs and prose fiction. I don't generally read or reply to comments here on What Culture (too many trolls!), but if you follow my Twitter (@heyquicksilver), I'll talk to you all day long! If you are interested in reading more of my stuff, you can find it on http://quicksilverstories.weebly.com/ (my personal site, which has other wrestling/comics/pop culture stuff on it). I also write for FLiCK http://www.flickonline.co.uk/flicktion, which is the best place to read my fiction work. Oh yeah - I'm about to become a Dad for the first time, so if my stuff seems more sentimental than usual - blame it on that! Finally, I sincerely appreciate every single read I get. So if you're reading this, thank you, you've made me feel like Shakespeare for a day! (see what I mean?) Latcho Drom, - CQ