10 Ultimate Wrestling Guilty Pleasures

The quality of these moments is up for debate. The joy they bring surely isn't.

Matt Hardy Hurricane
Impact Wrestling

In the pantheon of wrestling greatness, some moments stand the test of time, forever capable of enthralling fans and perhaps inspiring the next generation of talent. They not only captivate viewers but spark their emotions with all the precision of a well-crafted story.

And then there are moments notorious for all the wrong reasons. These infamous events and segments crash and burn like the Ultimate Warrior willing Hulk Hogan to take the controls of an airplane, but they sure entertain along the way. Perhaps these guilty pleasures push the absurdity of sports entertainment too far or were simply doomed to begin with, but why split hairs when the end result is this satisfying?

If loving these moments is wrong, well, we can accept that. It just won't change our feelings about them.

Here are 10 wrestling guilty pleasures that are hard to look away from...

10. WCW New Blood Rising

New Blood Rising
WWE.com

To call late-era WCW an acquired taste would be an understatement to say the least. By August 2000's New Blood Rising, the inmates were clearly running the asylum, putting together a product that baffled fans and scuttled ratings. Failing to replicate Vince Russo's success in restoring WWE's fortunes during the Attitude Era, WCW was increasingly staring oblivion and irrelevance square in the face. As WCW travelled north for their second Canadian pay-per-view in history, there was no reason to expect anything other than the company's recent track record of hot messes and weak finishes.

Which isn't to say that New Blood Rising broke this trend by any stretch. The event was named after a faction that no longer existed by August 2000, after all. Yet despite a litany of problems, New Blood Rising is oddly appealing from start to finish. The boy band-inspired 3 Count winning a ladder match for a gold record is a fun opener, while Buff Bagwell defeating Kanyon in the legendary Judy Bagwell on a Forklift match demands to be witnessed at least once.

On a less thrilling note, the Four Corners match for the WCW Tag Team Championship is such a complete dumpster fire that nobody could rightly call themselves the winner, although Kronik officially defended the gold. To make matters worse, WCW's roster was so thin by this point that Kronik were booked again that same night in a losing effort to Vampiro and The Great Muta. On top of all that, Sting squashed the Kiss-themed Demon and Lance Storm screwed Mike Awesome out of the WCW United States Championship in a Canadian Rules match that reeked of overbooking.

Then, in New Blood Rising's penultimate match, Goldberg turned up following a kayfabe motorcycle accident, only to refuse a powerbomb from Kevin Nash in a bizarre worked shoot that comes across to modern viewers as laughably arrogant. It wasn't enough for Russo to wink at his own audience, he had to belittle them by screaming "wrestling's fake" until blue in the face. And for one ridiculous night it almost worked. Almost.


9. The Broken Universe

Final Deletion Hologram
Impact Wrestling

Matt Hardy has accomplished just about everything in the ring, yet in 2016 he took his career to dizzying new heights and briefly revitalized TNA by debuting his radical new character, a man "Broken" by the loss of his world title. Speaking in an ambiguous accent and sporting a grey streak in his hair, Broken Matt Hardy blamed "Brother Nero" Jeff for his fall from grace, marking his longtime partner and occasional rival for deletion. Whatever the hell that meant.

Over the course of the coming weeks, Matt Hardy carved a niche for himself on TNA programming, creating the part-horror, part-mall goth Broken Universe and assembling a cast of characters that challenged the very nature of sports entertainment. It all culminated in "The Final Deletion", a TNA special where Matt defeated Jeff for the right to the Hardy brand. There were drone attacks, dilapidated boats, and extraordinary xylophones, not to Senor Benjamin preparing the battlefield for massacre. Some hated it, others couldn't get enough. And while any wrestling was secondary to the larger story, nobody can deny the Broken Universe stood out.

Sadly, efforts to recreate the magic of the Broken Universe in WWE following Matt's 2017 return didn't quite succeed, although it wasn't for lack of trying. Matt's "Woken" gimmick felt all too familiar by now, proving that sometimes lightning doesn't strike twice.


8. Any Time Ahmed Johnson Opened His Mouth

ahmed johnson michael hayes
WWE.com

When Ahmed Johnson became WWE's first African American Intercontinental Champion, he accomplished a long overdue milestone worthy of sincere admiration. Paired as an ally of WWE Champion Shawn Michaels in a feud with Camp Cornette, Johnson seemed poised to become a future main event player, yet his skills on the microphone leaved more than a little to be desired. Twice awarded "Worst On Interviews" by the Wrestling Observer Newsletter, Johnson's mush-mouth is the stuff of legend and just as addictive now as it was then.

Just take a look at Johnson's ominous promo describing Stone Cold Steve Austin entering his "zone," which he refers to as "kind of like an end zone." Whatever you say, pal. Johnson then keeps the homoerotic train rolling by threatening to score on Austin. You see, Austin had already scored on him, so it was only fair Johnson return the favour. I suppose none of this should come as a shock from someone who confessed to stiffing Goldust. The whole sordid affair then ends with Johnson screaming hysterically that he's coming to get Austin.

Or watch Johnson yelling about Jeff Jarrett committing a drive-by shooting in attacking him. Johnson works himself into such a frenzy you'll think "Double J" gunned him down for real. I guess we all have our limits.

Examples like these are just the tip of the iceberg. Most of Johnson's promos start calmly enough then take a Pearl River Plunge right off a cliff, but we wouldn't want it any other way.


7. Sid Justice At The WrestleMania VIII Press Conference

Sycho Sid Vicious
WWE.com

The devil's in the details on this one. When WWE President Jack Tunney held a press to conference to announce who would challenge Ric Flair for the world title at WrestleMania VIII, five potential contenders were up for consideration: The Undertaker, "Rowdy" Roddy Piper, Hulk Hogan, Macho Man Randy Savage, and Sid Justice, whose commitment to his performance is nothing short of astonishing - and a gift that just keeps on giving with repeated viewings.

As Tunney announces Flair's opponent, Justice is seen grinning from ear to ear, clutching what appears to be some sort of victory speech. He even rises from his chair in anticipation, only to look on in shock as Tunney names Hogan the number one contender. His shock soon turns to melodramatic rage, with Justice gritting his teeth and tearing up his speech in violent convulsions. It was the role of a lifetime.

Justice then blames Hogan for costing him the world title at the Royal Rumble before launching into a tirade against Tunney, accusing the WWE president of committing a bogus act. It's all rather silly yet Justice's conviction makes Tunney's bogus act sound like high treason.

Of course, these elaborate proceedings were all to set up a match between Hogan and Justice at WrestleMania, which looked fine on paper, although we all know how that turned out. At least we'll always have Justice's brilliant acting turn at this press conference.


6. Big Boss Man Crashing The Big Show's Father's Funeral

big boss man big show
WWE Network

Grief is an abyss - a dark portal of oblivion that'll bury you alive faster than a buried alive match if you let it. But most of us are at least afforded a chance to grieve in dignity when the moment comes to say goodbye to our loved ones. Not in the WWE Universe, though. And for that we should all be grateful.

When WWE decided to incorporate the death of Big Show Paul Wight's father years earlier into a feud with the Big Boss Man, the first casualty was any lingering shred of the company's dignity. It all started tastefully enough, with Big Show, clad entirely in black leather, bidding his father a fond farewell. Big Show's remarks that his father taught him everything in life are genuinely touching until this humble funeral is interrupted by the Big Boss Man arriving in a police cruiser and shouting into a megaphone.

While the Big Boss Man claims he's only there to pay his respects like everyone else, his condolences go sideways when he propositions Big Show's mother, Big Widow. Show tries to defend his mother's honour but is run down by the Big Boss Man, who chains the casket to his car and speeds away. Absconding with human remains? That's one way to get heat.

Sure, the entire segment's vulgar in the extreme, yet watching Big Show desperately cling to his father's casket is a special kind of hilarious. The kind that makes you worry about the Undertaker dragging you straight to hell.


5. Sting Vs. Jeff Hardy At TNA Victory Road

Jeff Hardy Victory Road
TNA

When Jeff Hardy challenged Sting for the TNA World Championship at 2011's Victory Road, fans rightly expected a decent match. After all, each competitor boasted an incredible list of accomplishments. Instead pay-per-view audiences were subjected to a main event car crash rarely witnessed before or since. What a treat.

Concerns over Hardy's intoxicated condition began backstage. Try as he might, Hardy's slow, staggered walk to the ring did little to ease these fears. Executive Producer Eric Bischoff changed the match's stipulation and finish on the fly, making it No Disqualification and instructing Sting to take Hardy out. To Bischoff's credit, he managed to shoehorn these abrupt changes into the existing Immortal storyline, but nothing could save the resulting match from being anything other than a disaster of the highest magnitude.

Before the bell Hardy stalls by pretending to toss his for shirt into the crowd for ages, but there was no stay of execution to be had. His fate was sealed. A few awkward strikes, a Scorpion Death Drop, and it was all over. Sting then forcefully pins a confused Hardy, who tries to kick out to no avail. While the crowd reacted with understandable shock and anger at this atrocious main event, a guilty pleasure for the ages was born. Long may it be so.

It was wrong of Hardy to wrestle and equally wrong for viewers to laugh, but life works in funny ways sometimes. Bullsh*t, yes. Unwatchable, no.


4. Hulk Hogan Promoting The Yappapi Strap Match

Hulk Hogan Ric Flair
WWE.com

Cultural appropriation meets midlife crisis, Hulk Hogan's impassioned promos in the buildup to his Yappapi Indian Strap match with Ric Flair at 2000's WCW Uncensored are like watching a Renaissance sculptor shaping a giant turd. Despite Hogan's best efforts, the finished product was never going to look quite right.

Supposedly inspired by a Native American tribe, the Yappapi Indian Strap match was Hogan's ticket to ending his blood feud with Flair following "The Nature Boy" sending longtime Hulkamania ally Jimmy Hart to the hospital. Really, it was nothing more than a regular strap match repackaged and cloaked in phony Native American lore. You know something's off when the vast majority of search results for "Yappapi" point to this dumb match.

Still, Hogan throws himself into the moment, treating audiences to absurd levels of detail in describing the Yappapi Indian Strap match and his meticulous plan for victory. Hogan outlines how his main priority is to ensure "flexibility of the wrist" and "to get the body in the prime position for the strapation, dudes." Is he talking about a wrestling match or a Tinder date? Hogan then takes his 50 Shades of Grey fan fiction even further by describing how "Strapmaster" Jimmy Hart's presence at ringside and possession of multiple Yappapi Indian punishment straps would make all the difference in winning the day and whipping the flesh off Flair's back. But victory or defeat, there was no glory in this contest.

It's all rather embarrassing, which is why Hogan's conviction is so remarkable. He comes across as your best mate's dad discovering BDSM after the divorce. "Let me tell you about the birds and the bees - and my leather, son."


3. Brian Pillman Pulling A Gun On Stone Cold Steve Austin

Brian Pillman Gun
WWE.com

The Attitude Era gifted WWE fans with many vulgar moments, ranging from Mae Young birthing a hand to Val Venis almost losing his piledriver, but perhaps none rivals Brian Pillman kayfabe pulling a gun on Stone Cold Steve Austin during the November 4, 1996 broadcast of Monday Night Raw.

On that fateful night an injured Pillman was being interviewed by Kevin Kelly and nursing an ankle injury at his Walton, Kentucky home when Austin trespassed onto "The Loose Cannon's" property and fought off a pack of goons. "The Texas Rattlesnake" then invaded Pillman's home, only to discover that Austin 3:16 was poised for a fateful showdown with Pillman: 9mm Glock. Viewers watched as "The Loose Cannon" aimed at Austin before the screen cut to black and returned moments later to chaotic footage of Pillman's friends trying to wrestle the gun away. Kelly's reassurances that nobody had been shot did little to make up for the preceding slew of bad choices. Yet it remains a landmark piece of Attitude Era history that almost everyone and their dog vividly remembers. And that's the bottom line.

WWE later apologized for the entire segment, and in the wake of the "Pillman's Got a Gun" angle, the Attitude Era would never quite push the boundaries of sports entertainment in the same way. And that's probably for the best. Jim Ross screaming "that killed him" was always meant as hyperbole, after all. Enjoy this one while it lasts because there'll never be anything like it again.

Often lost in the shuffle of Austin's home invasion and Kelly's interview with "The Loose Cannon" is Pillman claiming he has an "excellent prognosis for '97," the year that sadly took his life. Knowing Pillman's ultimate fate less than a year later makes this moment one of wrestling's most tragic guilty pleasures.


2. Bray Wyatt's WrestleMania 33 Ring Projections

WWE WrestleMania 33 Bray Wyatt Randy Orton Maggots
WWE.com

When Bray Wyatt finally captured the WWE Championship at 2017's Elimination Chamber, fans hoped he would enjoy a lengthy title run worthy of his exceptional charisma and indisputable presence. It's a shame he had to cross paths with "The Viper" Randy Orton at that year's WrestleMania, in a bout that saw Wyatt stoop to ridiculous depths in his futile quest to retain the belt.

The match's opening moments are nothing out of the ordinary, that is until Wyatt bends over backwards and summons the first in a series of bizarre ring projections designed to terrorize Orton. From maggots to worms and insects, this was one idea that ran out of gas quick. In fact, the Orlando crowd turns from initial enthusiasm for the gimmick to outright hostility in only a matter of minutes. When Wyatt's last batch of mind games fails to distract "The Viper" and results in an abrupt RKO and anticlimactic finish, the whole match comes across as an abject failure and a moment unique in WrestleMania history that never bears repeating. Once was enough.

A few years removed from Wyatt's abortive inaugural run with the WWE Championship, it's easier to look on this awful experiment with a more forgiving eye. Sure, it'll never go down as a five-star classic, but that was hardly the intent. Enjoy it now for what it is: a spooktacular Halloween reject designed solely to entertain.


1. The Undertaker Vs. Goldberg At Super ShowDown

Royal Rumble 2017 Goldberg Undertaker
WWE

Almost no pairing in wrestling history spelled dream match quite like The Undertaker facing off against Goldberg. Two titans of their respective companies, both in their prime during a true golden age of sports entertainment. Granted, this 2019 matchup at Super ShowDown was 20 years too late, but nobody could've predicted the near-fatal consequences that followed.

After a promising start, the match goes south when Goldberg busts his head open hitting the ring post. From that point on, virtually nothing goes right. Goldberg looks out on his feet, turning an attempted Jackhammer into a shoot brainbuster that just about kills The Deadman. Good thing he's already dead. However, the real pièce de résistance is a botched reverse Tombstone spot that doesn't even belong in a bingo hall, never mind a pay-per-view main event. From there, The Undertaker mercifully puts Goldberg down with the lowest chokeslam ever recorded. Saudi Arabia never knew what hit it.

While a colossal disappointment, there's something so addictive about bearing witness to this abomination. The entire match feels like a metaphor for the looming specter of mortality. It's only a matter of time before death claims all of us. Try as we might, there's no reversing our own tombstone. Maybe that's the real takeaway from all this.

Some dreams are just meant to die. It's a miracle everyone escaped this one alive.


Contributor

Investigator and writer based in Vancouver, Canada. Fond of history, professional wrestling, and rock hubris. Once co-directed a Star Trek fan film with a budget of less than $200.