10 Underused WWE Superstars (And How They Should Be Booked)
The WWE creative team needs to maximise the usage of the current roster.
WWE has the biggest roster in the wrestling industry right now, with over 200 Superstars signed with the company. The organization has five brands now, namely RAW, SmackDown, NXT, NXT UK, and 205 Live. The fact that Vince McMahon released a bunch of wrestlers recently and still none of the shows are short on talent highlights that.
The most prominent sports entertainment firm has created several new stars in the wrestling world like Roman Reigns, Dolph Ziggler, Bray Wyatt, Big E, Charlotte Flair, and many others. They have even picked up the hot commodities from the independent circuit, a move that has helped the business gain more popularity. Since the creative team has a massive roster in its hands, they often underutilise the talent they have by keeping them off the TV or assigning them lesser roles.
While not every Superstar can hold the world championship, the underused stars at least deserve a proper direction, which could help in improving their on-screen characters. Here's a list of ten Superstars who are not receiving credible booking decisions from the writers and how they should be used.
10. Robert Roode
After a forgettable run on the main roster, it seemed like things would change for Bobby Roode when he transformed himself into Robert Roode and then picked up the tag team titles with Dolph Ziggler. Unfortunately, the former United States Champion could not continue his momentum as he soon found himself in a sidekick role. For no reason, he aligned himself with King Corbin and assisted him in his rivalries.
Given that his tag team partner 'The Showoff' has ignored him for Mandy Rose's attention, the writers should book Roode to come back and confront him for his change in attitude. Another thing which could motivate 'The Glorious One' to turn on his partner would be the fact that Ziggler featured in a singles match at WrestleMania 36, whereas he could not even find a place on the kickoff show.
This angle could help WWE get Roode over with the fans once again. Since there is a dearth of proper face wrestlers on the Blue brand, the Canadian Superstar can gain a respectable place on the roster.
9. Mojo Rawley
Very few wrestlers have the skills that Mojo Rawley possesses. The former 24/7 champion can cut a good promo and, if booked consistently in one direction, can become a proper heel or face. Many have hated the way the creative team has used Dean Muhtadi since the day he earned a promotion to the main roster.
WWE had an opportunity to establish him as a credible mid-card heel when he turned on his tag team partner Zack Ryder, but didn't take that route and instead created confusion in the minds of the fans. One day, Rawley acted as if he was a broken man, and the next day he was back to his old character. No reasons were given for these changes.
Looking at the options available on SmackDown, they could align him with King Corbin. The duo of Corbin and Rawley would receive antagonistic reactions from the audience, meaning that the tag team division would get a new heel unit. Not everyone likes to boo The Miz and John Morrison because of JoMo's moves.
The SmackDown tag team division needs a heel alliance that can challenge the New Day. Thus, the writers should consider inserting the two NXT graduates in this picture.
8. Cesaro
It is disheartening to see the multi-time tag team champion Cesaro work under the likes of Sami Zayn and now Baron Corbin on WWE TV. 'The Swiss Cyborg' has the talent to become the face of the company, but the higher-ups have never liked him. Given that he has stayed loyal to the organisation, the writers should give him a mid-card push soon.
The best way to push him would be to turn his character face and insert him in the Intercontinental Championship picture. The reigning champ, Zayn has been absent from SmackDown after he retained his title against Daniel Bryan at WrestleMania 36. There could be an angle where 'The Swiss Superman' would say that he is tired of being under the Canadian wrestler's shadow, and now, he wants to win the gold.
The matches between 'The Liberator' and the European star would take the ratings to the next level. The wrestling community has always been behind the former United States Champion. Thus, if Cesaro wins the Intercontinental title, it would not only freshen up things on Friday nights but also give him a prominent place on the show.
7. Bo Dallas
Former NXT Champion Bo Dallas has lost his prominence in the last few years. From being a top guy in the developmental territory, the Superstar has become a jobber now. It seemed like his career would be back on track when he joined forces with Curtis Axel, and the duo aligned themselves with the Miz.
However, when WWE moved Bray Wyatt's brother to SmackDown along with his partner, they lost their credibility once again. The creative team recently made Drew Gulak relevant on the TV by booking him in an angle with Daniel Bryan. They could do the same with Dallas as he can benefit a lot by joining Bryan and Gulak. The three-person faction can have rivalries with The Forgotten Sons, Lucha House Party, or the New Day. Besides that, the writers could also book Dallas and Gulak to compete in the tag team division while the former world champion would try to achieve success in the singles division.
This way, they can keep the former RAW Tag Team Champion busy on Friday nights, thereby even maximizing the use of talent that they possess.
6. Shelton Benjamin
Given that the singles division on RAW is stacked up right now, there is no place for the former Intercontinental Champion, Shelton Benjamin. Forming a tag team with an upcoming star is the only way he can make a place for himself on the show. Hence, it would be great if the creative team uses him in that division. 'The Gold Standard' can benefit a lot by joining the group of Seth Rollins. Just like 'The Architect' and Murphy, Benjamin is an in-ring technician.
Or, the writers could book him to reunite with Shorty G. The team of Chad Gable and Benjamin had received a positive response from the wrestling universe when they performed together on SmackDown Live! Unfortunately, the organisation disintegrated the unit and tried to launch Gable as a singles star. Since they could not achieve their targets, the backstage officials could move the former SmackDown Tag Team Champion to the red brand and allow him to work with Benjamin.
The 44-year-old veteran deserves a better stage to showcase his talent than the company's 'C' show, Main Event. The tag team division of the flagship show would benefit a lot with this addition.
5. Natalya
'The Queen of Hearts' Natalya has lost her credibility on RAW because of the 50/50 booking nature of the creative team. They have randomly turned her character heel or face, a move that has confused the fans. The Canadian wrestler had teamed up with Liv Morgan to battle the Kabuki Warriors on 9th March, yet just a few weeks later, she battled the former Riott Squad member in a random bout on the kickoff show of WrestleMania 36.
The above highlights the inconsistency of the former SmackDown Women's Champion's persona. Since she is so experienced, it would be great if the writers turn her heel and include her in the tag team division. The reigning women's tag champs, Alexa Bliss and Nikki Cross, need new challengers. Natalya can unite forces with another directionless female pro wrestler, Ruby Riott, to chase the gold.
Through this manner, Vince McMahon and co. can keep the two talented females engaged in a meaningful title feud.
4. Murphy
Murphy has proven himself as a talented wrestler who can wow the audience with his moves inside the squared circle. Unfortunately, he has always played second fiddle to Seth Rollins on the TV. He ate a Claymore kick for his master this week on the red brand. Since 'The Monday Night Messiah' will likely fail to dethrone Drew McIntyre as the WWE Champion next Sunday, the creative team should not extend that rivalry, and instead, give the pair a new direction.
A switch to NXT could be game-changing for Rollins and Murphy, as both the wrestlers had achieved a lot of success in the Black and Gold brand. Also, the former Shield member has mentioned that his goal is to save the Vince McMahon-owned company and the universe for the greater good.
Since the tertiary brand of the company is facing competition from AEW Dynamite right now, the creative team could pull this move off. They recently shifted Charlotte there and, Rollins and Murphy could light up the tag team division on Wednesday nights.
3. Humberto Carrillo
Humberto Carrillo has failed to succeed as a face superstar on RAW. The writers tried to get him over with the fans by booking him in the United States title picture. Unfortunately, he could not win the hearts of the fans as he finds himself wrestling on WWE Main Event now. Since he is young and talented, the creative team should soon turn his character heel and give him another opportunity to prove himself.
After turning heel, he could join the faction of Zelina Vega. The group has got a lot of screen time on Monday nights recently with Andrade, Austin Theory, and Angel Garza showcasing their talent in the ring. Since Garza is Carrillo's cousin, there could be an angle where he would try to recruit Humberto in their team. Since his career is going nowhere, the wrestler would have no option but to say yes.
Vega has been doing the job precisely on the mic. With the terrific in-ring skills that he possesses, Humberto can prove to be a substantial addition to the mid-card.
2. Bobby Lashley
Bobby Lashley has the caliber to become the next WWE Champion of the company. Unfortunately, the creative team believes that he is only good enough to be Lana's fake husband and flip tires on RAW. When the former Intercontinental Champion defeated Roman Reigns at Extreme Rules two years ago, it seemed like he would dethrone Brock Lesnar at SummerSlam.
As the fans know, the same did not happen as 'The All Mighty' soon became a joke. His alliances with Lio Rush and 'The Ravishing Russian' have further diminished his credibility. Since he is distancing himself from his on-screen wife now, the writers still have a chance of reviving his character by giving him a monster push. Paul Heyman can involve him in the world title picture after Money in the Bank, by booking him to win a #1 contender's match.
Even though he would not pick up the crown, he could become an essential name on the red brand, whose only aim is to destroy his opponents.
1. Shinsuke Nakamura
'The Artist' Shinsuke Nakamura has struggled to keep his character relevant since the day he arrived on the main roster. He had a stellar run in the developmental territory, where he held the NXT Championship two times. Unfortunately, things did not get going for Nakamura on the blue brand. After winning the Royal Rumble in 2018, he had a dull rivalry with AJ Styles.
The creative team turned him heel and even gave him the mid-card belts multiple times. Still, somehow, his gimmick did not connect with the fans. Unfortunately, he finds himself directionless on Friday nights, wrestling in random matches. It would be great if WWE would allow him to switch brands now. It has been a long time since he has been on SmackDown.
A move to RAW could revive his character and help him become a credible name on the main roster. Apollo Crews benefited a lot with this switch. The writers can easily say that the draft pick expired. Hence, the USA officials could sign Nakamura from FOX. He can then have feuds with the likes of Kevin Owens, Rey Mysterio, and even Drew McIntyre.
With the Extreme Rules pay-per-view event approaching, it would be great if the company allows him to revert to his 'King of Strong Style' gimmick instead of booking him as an artist on the TV. As he possesses an immense amount of experience, a few solid rivalries would establish him as a leading name on the flagship show.