10 Unique Pitches To Save Struggling AEW Stars

Some wrestlers in AEW are in desperate need of saving. Here's how to turn their careers around.

Kamille Mercedes Mone
AEW

All Elite Wrestling has no shortage of talent. If anything, the roster is arguably too bloated, with many wrestlers who would otherwise be bigger fish in a smaller pond now struggling to fight for their share of the limelight as others pass them by and become bigger, more notable names.

For every Will Ospreay who lives up to the hype, there are a handful of others who felt like a big deal at one point, only to now be enhancement talent or sidelined entirely. And while not everyone can be at the top of the card, being on the low end is never anyone's dream.

Some just need a sustained push from Tony Khan. A few could go a long way with a heel or face turn, or being paired in a new team. Others would require a massive reboot of their characters. Some may even be beyond saving, but it's worth trying anything at this point, because there's nothing else left to lose.

Let's take a look at 10 different AEW stars who are fading into obscurity or spiraling out of control - and toss out some ideas of how they can be saved and perhaps brought back into prominence.

10. Lio Rush

Lio Rush
AEW

Despite numerous attempts, Lio Rush has never quite clicked in AEW. He has fun matches, but it never goes anywhere beyond having him around as a good hand.

While AEW doesn't discriminate as much about height compared to Rush's time in WWE, it's still a hurdle that is hard to overcome, even for someone as gifted in high-flying maneuvers as The Man of the Hour.

One move that would help out not only Rush, but many others who are in a similar position, would be to create an AEW Cruiserweight Championship. AEW can replace one of its three midcard titles (TNT, International, and Continental) with this to open up a whole new field of competition and do something WWE hasn't done in several years at this point—another means for AEW to stand out and be an alternative, like it was originally intended to be.

On top of that, though it isn't the most unique idea, Rush should join The Hurt Syndicate, as has been teased. He has a natural arrogance that he cannot tap into as a babyface, and if this title were created, Shelton Benjamin, MVP, and Bobby Lashley wouldn't be able to compete for it, so Rush would fit in nicely as their representative of that division.


9. Matt Sydal

Matt sydal
AEW

Another wrestler who would greatly benefit from that AEW Cruiserweight Championship concept would be Matt Sydal. At this point, it's been clear for more than a few years that he's not going to be given a more prominent spot in even the midcard title scene. Currently, he's out of action after undergoing foot surgery, but prior to that, he still was only barely being used on television, and rarely ever winning when he was.

Sydal is a veteran who has some wisdom to impart, and it would be worth swapping him into Lio Rush's spot as an ally of Top Flight. Rush fits that team on paper for his style, but not his attitude, whereas Sydal has had some history teaming with Darius and Dante Martin, so there's a foundation to build from.

At 41, he's not going to be soaring the skies for another 20 years, but he can pass on what he's learned to the younger generation and be booked as an example of what they can all strive for. This could even set him up for his eventual retirement, where he can be touted as one of the best high-flyers of that generation, rather than being forgotten.


8. Wardlow

AEW Revolution 2024 Wardlow
AEW

Stepping away from the cruiserweights and shifting 180 degrees to a huge powerhouse, Wardlow is in a criminally bad situation in AEW given how much potential he had.

Injuries happen to everyone and are major albatrosses, but when someone is over enough, they come back having lost very little momentum, if any. Wardlow hasn't had that luck, as his comebacks continue to flounder.

This next time, AEW needs to not only avoid the temptation to give him another generic Powerbomb Symphony squash story, but also keep him far away from Adam Cole and the Undisputed crew, as that pairing never worked.

Truth be told, the real fix for Wardlow would be to go back in a time machine a few years ago and send him to the WWE Performance Center, as he might have had better luck there. But, since that's impossible...

Instead, Wardlow should be spending his time out taking acting classes, studying new moves to add to his repertoire, and brainstorming aspects of his true self that can be sympathetic. Fans need to care about him beyond just his size and strength.

Take inspiration from someone like Batista, who grew past just being the muscle, and let us see who Michael Wardlow is behind the scenes. Otherwise, he's just another Brian Cage who isn't around as much.


7. Jay Lethal

Jay Lethal
ROH

There's something to be said about not punching above your weight class, which is what AEW does to Jay Lethal any time he's in the ring with core talent that the company is built around.

As great as Lethal is, he's just not going to be scoring victories left and right over people like Jon Moxley, Adam Page, Swerve Strickland, and others that are considered the main characters of this promotion. From the onset, he wasn't brought on to be in their league, and was quickly put in a big faction with Jeff Jarrett, Satnam Singh, and Sonjay Dutt, where he was ultimately relegated to a midcard spot.

Ring of Honor could use him as a roster stalwart. He's never been as big of a deal in any other promotion compared to his legacy in ROH. He has legend status surrounding those titles and could be one of the top stars of that brand on any given day, provided he just gets frequent victories to prove it.

Lethal should separate from Jarrett's crew, stick to ROH, possibly mentor someone like EJ Nduka and/or Lee Johnson, feud with people who fly in the face of what the company stands for like Chris Jericho, and focus on being an asset there, rather than making sporadic appearances in random AEW matches as a guy to fill in a losing spot.


6. Miro

AEW Collision Miro
AEW

Is Miro still even employed by AEW?! He supposedly asked for his release, but nothing of the sort has been confirmed by any parties. As fans and spectators on the outside, we're left to just guess if he's sitting out the remainder of his contract before going back to WWE, wants to go elsewhere, doesn't want to wrestle for anyone anymore, or is simply hanging around with nothing to do like he's largely done for the bulk of his AEW run.

If it is a case of business is usual, where Tony Khan still wants to potentially use him, he still wants to be a part of this company in return, and it's just a matter of not agreeing on making him a big enough star, that's where Ring of Honor once again comes into play.

Clearly, if Khan saw Miro as a true top-tier main-eventer in AEW, he'd have been in a spot similar to Samoa Joe. Since that didn't happen, his Redeemer character and the TNT Championship run is all we have to go by, but that's still more than enough legacy, combined with his WWE career, to put him as the top guy in ROH.

Have Miro win the ROH World Championship and steamroll opponents for a year. It'll make him happy, he'll finally be a world champion, and it will freshen up that roster. It's that simple.


5. Boulder & Bronson: The Iron Savages

AEW Collision The Acclaimed Daddy Ass Iron Savages Jacked Jameson
AEW

The Iron Savages, Boulder and Bronson, have had a few different tweaks to their gimmick since joining AEW, but have overall stayed in a position of sometimes comedic, sometimes physically imposing, but ultimately still enhancement talent who have a variety of different allegiances and friends they partner with whenever they're needed to be inserted into a situation.

Short of randomly just winning matches out of nowhere, they won't be taken seriously unless they're given a new purpose, and that's where the ROH champion Miro comes into play again.

"Big meaty men slapping meat" was a Big E creation, but was adopted by people like Miro. If he's going to be a dominant powerhouse, why not pair him up with the former Bear Country's Bulk and Beefcake as his henchmen?

Those two can act as his subordinates and the nigh-impenetrable wall surrounding him who are galvanized to use their strength in a more effective way under his leadership. They can be reshaped into tag team title contenders, but also straddle the line of losing to No. 1 contenders who are feuding with Miro.


4. Deonna Purrazzo, Taya Valkyrie, and Serena Deeb

Deonna Purrazzo AEW
AEW

When Deonna Purrazzo was brought into AEW, she felt like she could be the leader of the women's division. After falling short of capturing the AEW Women's World Championship and not even bouncing back with a TBS title win or anything else of note, her level of importance has diminished drastically in just a few months.

Pairing her up with Taya Valkyrie to create The Vendetta is the most recent attempt to fix things, but that quickly hasn't worked out well for them. The name is generic, they don't have an enthusiastic chemistry together, and winning one match against some no-names on Rampage, of all places, isn't a good sign of things to come.

Purrazzo's Virtuosa gimmick would pair much better with Serena Deeb, aka The Professor. They would easily make for a tag team of technical wrestling specialists, whereas having Valkyrie with Purrazzo feels like an Odd Couple pairing without the silliness that makes those work. Image the combinations Purrazzo and Deeb could conjure up for their maneuvers!

Valkyrie, meanwhile, can join the alliance of MxM Collection alongside Mansoor, Mason Madden, and her husband, Johnny TV. Having a female representative of that group would add another dynamic to it, and allow Valkyrie to be as flamboyant as she wants.


3. Abadon, Danhusen, and The Dark Order

Abadon AEW
AEW

Speaking of silliness, The Dark Order was at its best during the COVID-19 lockdown when they transformed from a laughably uncool heel group that wasn't the slightest bit imposing to a collection of loveable losers who might as well been named The Dork Order.

Even at their peak, though, Tony Khan must have never felt it necessary to give them a tag team or trios title reign, so they eventually just lost steam and became less and less featured, to the point that they now only fill in the blank here and there and wrestle mostly on Ring of Honor.

Being heels for a bit didn't rejuvenate them, and it seems they're back to their "endearing" ways, but without a firm commitment to that on AEW television. While it won't likely lead to them reaching new heights, it's better to turn into the skid and go back to what works.

But they need new members to freshen it up and replace the ones who are gone. Why not throw in Danhausen and Abadon, who aren't doing anything that would stop them from trying this out?

Abadon's lost all her mystique. Let's see if she can be funny. Danhausen just isn't doing anything at all anymore. 


2. Colt Cabana

AEW Colt Cabana
AEW

Let's be honest, Colt Cabana isn't going to be the guy to take down The Death Riders. But when you've done nothing for two years but lose in dark matches to Satnam Singh and The Dark Order, going back to being on television as an enhancement talent would still be a significant upgrade! Yikes!

Since QT Marshall isn't leading up The Factory anymore and rounding up all the losers into his group, maybe Cabana is the right man to spearhead the next incarnation of The J.O.B. Squad under whatever name they decide to go with?

Everyone who is in no better standing might as well go into the same group. That ranges from Aaron Solo to Zak Knight.

Fans already know who is on the bottom rung of the roster, and AEW already winks at meta-commentary as it is. Why not just embrace it and play into the fun of having a group that is basically a wrestlers' union sticking together because they wouldn't be able to get booked otherwise since they keep losing all the time?

Cabana is funny and likable where fans wouldn't get tired of him being the figurehead, especially if he reasserted his leadership by getting a few wins here and there. Others (like Peter Avalon, Luther, Angelico, etc) can be cycled in and out as needed. If anyone ever gets a push, that in and of itself is already a story in watching them break free from those chains.


1. Kamille

AEW Dynamite Mercedes Mone Kamille
AEW

How is Kamille already worthy of being on this list?! She just debuted in July and has wrestled a whopping six matches for the company, but has people like Konnan calling out how terribly she's been booked so far.

From the onset, something was wrong. AEW sat on her for months after she had signed and finally put her on television to be paired with Mercedes Moné, but somehow, the most basic "enforcer for a heel" storyline was botched almost immediately.

It's a simple formula when done correctly, but you can't have a weasel heel get help from a bodyguard if you book the bodyguard to fail at their job and Moné is out there winning matches on her own. That, plus Kamille's injury and quick loss to Kris Statlander, neutered The Brickhouse as a completely ineffective henchwoman.

Everything was rushed, as if Tony Khan wanted to start the angle and skip straight to the finish without letting it build, so nobody could grow to care about Kamille, let alone be invested enough to salivate at the thought of her getting revenge on the TBS champion.

At this point, with her injury already a talking point and this total dud of a false start, the only way to rehab Kamille is to wait a while, play into the idea of her quitting, and have her come back months from now, pretending like nothing happened and try again from scratch not as anyone's bodyguard, but as a dominant former NWA women's champion.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Founder of pro wrestling site Smark Out Moment (https://www.smarkoutmoment.com) and geek culture site Fanboys Anonymous (https://www.fanboysanonymous.com).