10 Unlikeliest WWE WrestleMania Main-Eventers

Celebrating the wrestlers who went from the chorus line to the final bow.

Becky Lynch WrestleMania 35
WWE

Serendipity is very sweet.

We thought we were going to get Becky Lynch vs. Ronda Rousey at Survivor Series, but after an errant Punch from Nia Jax, WWE made the audible of all audibles due to The Man suffering a broken nose and concussion. Charlotte Flair took Becky's place this past Sunday, and now, according to Dave Meltzer, the ostensible plan for WrestleMania? Becky Lynch in the main event against Ronda Rousey - and possibly Charlotte as well.

This is quite astounding, as Rousey vs. Charlotte 1-on-1 has been pencilled in for months as the probable main event of WrestleMania 35.

Naturally, wrestling fandom as a whole is jumping for joy at this news, as 2018 has been an absolute barnburner of a year for the perennial favorite. If WWE don't pull a Dave Meltzer special (i.e. "plans change"), Becky will join a long line of people who were never thought to be big enough stars in wrestling to join the ranks of 'Mania main-eventer.

From midcarders to journeymen to non-wrestlers, there have been some surprising names to close out the show of shows.

10. Daniel Bryan

Daniel Bryan WrestleMania XXX
WWE

It's probably the best underdog story WWE ever told, and they did it completely begrudgingly.

WWE would like you to think that they listened to the fans and deliberately crafted a story where Daniel Bryan rode a wave of momentum in 2013, and with the help of the Yes Movement, overcame WWE management and main-evented WrestleMania XXX in a completely organic fashion.

In reality, WWE had no plans for Bryan to main-event, and basically gave zero craps about the Yes chants. However, after the Royal Rumble, when CM Punk walked out of the company discouraged about not main-eventing WrestleMania, WWE had to re-arrange the whole show. When they realized that Batista was not going to work as a babyface against Randy Orton, they decided to insert Bryan in the main event. It killed two birds with one stone: it saved the show, and it was a good way to spite Punk by giving his coveted main event to his personal and professional rival.

Of course, whatever cynical backstage chicanery there was, sometimes, fiction is more important than reality. The story of Daniel Bryan overcoming the odds and closing WrestleMania as WWE Champion is one that will be in WrestleMania video packages forever.


9. Sgt. Slaughter

Sgt Slaughter WrestleMania VII Camel Clutch
WWE

In the '80s, Sgt. Slaughter was one of the biggest stars in the AWA and WWE. With his ability to work as face and heel, and his likeness being a recurring character on the GI Joe animated series, Slaughter created a great legacy for himself that should be honored.

However, most modern WWE fans likely associate him with his early '90s run when, inexplicably, Sarge was turned heel and, to coincide with current events, turned into an Iraqi sympathizer who renounced his ties to America.

That in itself would be strange enough, but seemingly convinced of the hotness of the war in Iraq, Vinny Mac decided to capitalize by booking Slaughter to beat the Ultimate Warrior for the title at Royal Rumble 1991. He was then programmed with Hulk Hogan, with the two headlining WrestleMania VII.

Keep in mind, 'Mania VII was originally planned to be held in the massive LA Memorial Coliseum. With the advertised main event being Hogan and Slaughter, the pre-sale for the show ended up being a trickle. As such, WWE cut their losses and moved the show to the much smaller Sports Arena, citing "bomb threats" due to anger over Sgt. Slaughter.

Of course, it wasn't anger from fans that caused the move. It was indifference.


8. Chris Benoit

Chris Benoit Eddie Guerrero WrestleMania XX
WWE

Warning: Chris Benoit elephant in the room. Yadda-yadda, you know the drill.

Chris Benoit was never meant to be the a top guy in any capacity. He was relatively short, and on the mic, he had the presence of a tumbleweed. But through persistence, hard work, and perhaps just being in the right place at the right time, he earned the prestigious honor of closing out the 20th WrestleMania.

Benoit was always revered for his technical prowess. From his start in Stampede, to his runs in New Japan, Benoit combined the rough, Calgary style with innovative junior heavyweight offense, setting the bar for smaller wrestlers along with Jushin Liger and Brian Pillman. In WCW, he was a perennial upper-midcarder, but was never allowed to break the glass ceiling due to his size and the backstage politics of the time. As the company grew more chaotic, he realized he needed to hightail it out of there, and so he did with other WCW mid-carders. They were redubbed The Radicalz once they arrived in WWE.

From then on, Benoit maintained his upper-midcard status, never quite reaching the level of top main-eventer. That is, until 2004, when, perhaps just out of a desire to get an underdog story over for WrestleMania, Benoit won the Royal Rumble, and he went on to beat Triple H and Shawn Michaels for the big gold belt.

Say what you will about what happened afterward, but after an entire career working hard, Benoit earned the spotlight and took it for all it was worth.


7. The Miz

The Miz WrestleMania XXVII
WWE

At this point, The Miz is a WWE institution. One of the more active mainstream ambassadors for the company, Mike Mizanin has earned his spot as one of the more respected veterans on the roster, as well as a pretty sweet gig as the perennial star of the Marine franchise (although, spoiler alert: in Marine 6, Miz's Jake Carter character is killed by Becky Lynch, so that run has come to an end). Given how he started, however, you'd think he wouldn't have lasted a year in the company, let alone headline their biggest show.

The Miz's rise to the top is basically WWE lore nowadays. Emerging on a season of The Real World in 2001, Miz made it known that he had aspirations of becoming a professional wrestler. He used this exposure to get on WWE's Tough Enough series, where he earned a developmental contract. For years afterwards, Miz had to endure disrespect from the fans and the locker room for his reality TV roots, despite being a lifelong fan of the business. Even by the time he won the WWE Championship in 2010, it was seen as a joke by most watching.

Although Miz's true creative renaissance didn't come until after his lone WrestleMania main event against John Cena, the fact that it happened so relatively early in his career shows what he was capable of when given the opportunity.


6. Bret Hart And Shawn Michaels

Shawn Michaels Bret Hart Wrestlemania
WWE.com

The Hitman and HBK are on the same entry because the two were inseparably linked during the mid-'90s era of WWE known as the New Generation. In a time after Hulk Hogan, but before Steve Austin, Bret and Shawn were the story of WWE, and one of their most important chapters came at WrestleMania XII. There, the two competed in an iconic main event: a 60-minute iron man match for the WWE Championship.

While Bret had main-evented a couple of WrestleManias prior to this, the 'Mania XII headliner was the ultimate vindication of him, Shawn, and what they meant for the future of WWE. Here were two former tag specialists who were considered undersized in the towering '80s. In the absence of Hulkamania, Bret and Shawn rose through the ranks and, for a time, replaced the WWE's priority on physiques and spectacle with an emphasis on in-ring work. It was their innovations that proved to be the foundation of what we consider modern mainstream wrestling.

It was the precedent of Bret Hart and Shawn Michaels that allowed superstars like Chris Benoit, Kurt Angle, and Daniel Bryan to main event the Show of Shows. And none of them would have been seen as main-eventers beforehand.


5. Mick Foley

The Rock Mick Foley WrestleMania 2000
WWE

When Mick Foley had his sole WrestleMania main event in 2000, he had already accomplished almost everything in WWE. Heck, he was already retired, and he only wrestled the match because Vince McMahon wanted him to have a WrestleMania main event just once. The fact that the boss of the company personally requested him to participate shows how much respect Mick Foley had earned from the big man.

It wasn't always like this, though. During his career, Foley was anything but the superstar you'd expect to be... well, a superstar. With his rough look and even rougher hardcore wrestling, Foley certainly carved a fine niche for himself and earned a cult following, but the glitzy, showbiz-centered WWE didn't want to touch him, at least not until prodding and convincing from those inside. Even then, Vince McMahon only took on Mick begrudgingly, and insisted that his face be covered. With the Leatherface-esque Mankind gimmick, Foley was more monster than man.

But even with that start, the man still got over. He was just too good in ring and too engaging of a personality not to earn the opportunities he got. By the time he got his swan song main event at WrestleMania 2000, he was already a bonafide legend who was on many fans' Mount Rushmore. Sometimes, try as a company might, they can't deny someone's talent forever, even if they don't fit a certain mold.


4. Seth Rollins

Seth Rollins WrestleMania 31
WWE

Here was one literally no one saw coming, because it came completely without warning. In one of the most iconic WrestleMania moments, at the 31st edition, Seth Rollins interrupted the main event between Roman Reigns and Brock Lesnar, and cashed in his money in the bank briefcase. He won the impromptu three-way match, and ended the show holding aloft the WWE Championship with Michael Cole proclaiming Seth had pulled off "the heist of the century."

It was quite the moment for someone who, years earlier, was pelted with "future jobber" chants.

The man once known as Tyler Black was a skinny, indie-riffic wrestler who didn't really have much of a personality. Fans of ROH thought he would be eaten alive in the world of giants. It seemed like that, even when he was made part of The Shield. The company saw more star potential in Dean Ambrose and Roman Reigns. Thus, Seth at first was the group's fall guy, eating pins to protect Roman and Dean.

However, those in the company saw how hard Seth worked, how good he made others look, and how amazing his moveset was. Once the time came to split the Shield, Rollins got the rub of the heel turn and alliance with Triple H, and from there, he was set for stardom. And when he was in the right place and the right time, he was called on to give WrestleMania 31 a happy ending.


3. Lawrence Taylor

Lawrence Taylor, Bam Bam Bigelow
WWE.com

Sometimes, you just need to look at an image and say, "Oh, 1995."

Things were desperate in the mid '90s for WWE. Attendance was at an all time low, ratings were down, and their stars just weren't connecting like they were during Hulkamania. It makes sense that Vince McMahon would want to reach out to the mainstream in order to get media exposure. It even makes sense to involve Lawrence Taylor in a high-profile angle. Fresh off retirement, LT was (and still is) considered by many to be the greatest American footballer of all time. As a spectacle, having him wrestle against someone like Bam Bam Bigelow is the kind of nifty, novel attraction you want for a show like WrestleMania.

But as the main event? When Taylor had never worked a match before? What were they thinking?

The match itself was fine, and Taylor looked perfectly competent, but when you're struggling as is to create stars, having them play second fiddle to a football player just made the problem worse.

In addition, the boys in the back were not happy about the billing, most especially Shawn Michaels, who resented Bigelow for getting the spot he felt he and Diesel deserved. Using their political leverage, HBK and the Kliq completely killed Bigelow's push in 1995, and he was gone from the company by the end of the year.

Not to say any of that is Taylor's fault, but hey, it's what happened.


2. Triple H

Triple H Stephanie Wrestlemania 2000
WWE.com

Triple H, heir apparent to WWE, has more power in WWE than anyone who isn't Vinny Mac himself. On his way up in the corporate hierarchy, the King of Kings absolutely dominated the main event scene in the 2000s, closing multiple WrestleManias, the latest at 'Mania 32.

However, such a track record would not be expected for someone who was fed to the Ultimate Warrior in less than two minutes at WrestleMania XII.

Triple H debuted in the garish cartoon world of 1995. As such, his persona was ripped straight from a Richie Rich comic, and he came out as a snooty aristocrat. This put him in the same pecking order as guys like "Spark Plug" Bob Holly, Duke "The Dumpster" Droese, and other animated New Generation gimmicks. Folks in creative such as Jim Cornette and Vince McMahon saw this svelte, technically-focused worker with the weird face and said "That's a mid-carder."

Of course, through Hunter's hard work, and his buddying up with the likes of Shawn Michaels, Vince Russo, and Vinny Mac himself, Helmsley was able to get over, transform into The Game, and main event several WrestleManias. And now, he's set to inherit the company.

Ultimately, Triple H is the prime example of how Vince's first impression of does not determine your future.


1. Steve Austin

Steve Austin WrestleMania XIV
WWE

Yep. At one point, even the hottest star wrestling has ever produced was seen as disposable. By several companies.

In late 1995, Steve Austin was a WCW reject who was pushed to the side by Eric Bischoff because he didn't have the "star quality" of a Hulk Hogan or Randy Savage. There were people in the industry like Paul Heyman who saw what he was capable of, but Paul Heyman wasn't the one writing the big cheques and making the important decisions. Nor were Bruce Prichard and Jim Cornette when they pitched Austin to Vince McMahon. They saw him as the next big thing, but VInce? He saw a guy who couldn't get over because he had "a Texas accent."

When Austin made his PPV debut for the company at Royal Rumble 1996, no one could have foreseen that he would win the match the following two years. No one could have imagined that he'd bring WWE back to relevance and kickstart the hottest era in company history. It seemed to all happen so quickly.

Whether or not Becky Lynch does indeed get that main event at WrestleMania 35, there will always be a lineage of people who were never groomed for that spot, but they earned it regardless.


In this post: 
Becky Lynch
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

A mystery wrapped in an enigma wrapped in bacon wrapped in wrestling listicles wrapped in tin foil wrapped in seaweed wrapped in gak.