10 Unthinkable Masterminds Behind Legendary Wrestling Ideas

Vince McMahon came up with fewer legendary WWE ideas than you'd think - but #6 WILL surprise you...

Kevin Kelly Triple H Stephanie McMahon
WWE

The booker usually comes up with the ideas.

In a functional wrestling promotion that recognises the "talent" is called that for a reason, a booker will devise a framework for a storyline, arrive at the destination, determine who needs to get the heat or the comeback and when, and then allow the wrestlers to articulate their motivations. More often than not - unless a wrestler has played a devious political game - the person you see getting their hand raised has won because the booker said so.

The polluted landscape of the 21st century is shifting.

In WWE, Sami Zayn has made significant contributions to the acclaimed Bloodline saga. This is the norm in AEW, where wrestlers frequently pitch ideas and Tony Khan is receptive to them. He has his quirks, and is unable to comprehend that some of them have drawn earnest good-faith criticism - gloating about record ROH PPV buys means little when those shows benefitted from national cable TV exposure - but he values his talents. He has the self-awareness to realise that they have better ideas than he does sometimes.

Vince McMahon was derided for years for refusing to relinquish control - but he wasn't a daft awld tw*t all of the time...

10. Kevin Kelly Came Up With The Triple H & Stephanie McMahon Marriage Angle

Triple H Stephanie McMahon
WWE.com

A development that changed the course of Triple H's career and pro wrestling history as you know it.

In late 1999, Vince Russo left the then-WWF for WCW. His departure was sudden - he was not bound to a non-compete clause - and the WWF were left to tie up various in-motion plot threads. One such storyline was the relationship between Test and Stephanie McMahon; since wrestling is a never-ending soap opera with no happily ever after, a new twist was required. To buy time to think of it, the British Bulldog threw a trash can at Stephanie McMahon at Rebellion (presumably a different one in which Russo and Ed Ferrara's belongings were kept).

Russo's original idea, based on precedent, was probably "Stephanie, being a woman, was leading him on and she was going to leave him for someone in a better spot."

A company-wide email, unusually, was distributed to all staff. Kevin Kelly responded by suggesting (alongside his wife) that Steph, experiencing memory issues resulting from her head injury, actually forgot to whom she was betrothed, and it would be revealed that Triple H took advantage by wedding her in a backstage "quickie".

This idea was taken on, only made more rancid, as was the style at the time: the WWF actually went the "What would Russo do?" route, although it was Kelly's shoot idea.


9. Tiger Ali Singh Coined One Of The All-Time Great Catchphrases...

Tiger Ali Singh
WWE Network

A lot of people wished they were the Rock.

Where Austin was relatable, or at least his motivation was at the character's stratospheric peak, Rock was different. People aspired to be him, but in a different way; Austin was the guy who told the authority to f*ck off, while people lived through the Rock vicariously because his put-downs were sensational. He said the things you wished you had the panache to reel off in social situations - and with perfect timing.

His best bit, because it reduced his opponents to little nuggets of sh*t and cruelty can be funny sometimes, is when he would feign to ask them a question. He was always perfect at pretending to be sincere. He was never overly nice. He was disarming. And then, after he'd lured them in, he let them have it with "...it doesn't matter!"

Though the man didn't time it anywhere near as well, it was actually the long-forgotten Tiger Ali Singh who did the bit first, in one of those rotten segments in which he aimed to "prove" that Americans were disgusting pigs or whatever. When a woman he plucked from the audience was asked to eat something vile, he asked what her name was.

When she motioned to answer, Singh said "That's irrelevant, doesn't really matter."

Which segues into...


8. ...Which Is Strange, Since Conan O'Brien Came Up With One Of The Worst

The Rock WWE Funny Face
WWE.com

Right, so this doesn't exactly fit the theme, but if not legendary, this moment is certainly infamously bad, given the standard set elsewhere by the performer involved.

Amongst Simpsons fanatics, it is generally accepted that seasons 1-8 represent the peak of the show. Some even think that the decline began with 8, before the infamous season 9 "effort" 'The Principal and the Pauper'; episodes like 'The Secret War of Lisa Simpson' and 'The Canine Mutiny' are considered mawkish where real sentiment was once rare and well-earned. There are still great gags tucked in episodes all the way to season 13, after which the show is rubbish. The people who like "new Simpsons" are your "The Miz is the greatest Intercontinental champion of all time" types.

The most ardent Simpsons fans, your "wrestling peaked with the intricate holds of Dory Funk, Jr." types, insist that the show actually peaked when writer Conan O'Brien, credited with the immortal episodes 'Homer Goes To College' and 'Marge Vs. the Monorail', departed after the fourth season. His laser-precise satire of terrible TV tropes - "after all, I am the President of the United States" - elevated the Simpsons above everything else.

Which makes it all the more strange that he, indirectly, came up with the Rock's worst catchphrase; his intentionally stupid "Why don't you have a big, tall glass of shut-up juice" insult, which he'd say to those underneath him as a joke, found its way into the Rock's repertoire through writer Tommy Blacha, who left Late Night With Conan O'Brien to work for WWE in 1999.

So what has been discovered here is that one of the worst wrestlers of all time came up with one of the Rock's worst catchphrases, where one of the funniest men of all time came up with his worst.


7. Jon Moxley Wanted To Squash CM Punk

CM Punk Jon Moxley
AEW

Jon Moxley is one of very few wrestlers you can be certain isn't a d*ckhead - either that, or he's an even better worker than you thought. This is a man who adores his wife, refuses to indulge in the petty bullsh*t of social media, and is enchanted by the concept of libraries.

He is over as a babyface because he scans as the complete opposite of a ruthless, soulless pro wrestling carny.

It might surprise you, then, to learn that he campaigned to squash CM Punk on free television before dropping the Interim World title to him at All Out 2022. Did Mox sense that Punk's volatility backstage was set to explode, and that he might not find an opportunity to get his win back "down the road"?

Did he leverage Punk's love of playing the hometown hero and pitch a story that would see Punk redeem himself in Chicago by getting a win out of him first?

Or did he just express to management that he was a star on Punk's level, and as such needed a win to keep his heat after the fact?

In any event, it was a smart political play, and as revealed by Dave Meltzer of the Wrestling Observer, it was Mox's idea that Punk "eventually" agreed to.


6. Who Came Up With The Attitude Era Logo?

WWF Scratch Logo
WWE.com

The WWF Attitude Era logo that debuted in 1998 was iconic.

Cool in a way that is hard to describe - as if the polished nature of the WWF itself was literally disintegrating, complete with a black metal-adjacent font - it literally symbolised that the new World Wrestling Federation was a new beast. It's so iconic, in fact, that every new logo is a spiritual sequel to it. Much like WWE TV to this day, with its long show-opening promos, invisible camera and authority figures setting up impromptu matches on the night, the new logo is a cleaner version of what came before.

You'd expect WWE to have tasked its creative services department with designing a new logo to better fit the new stylistic direction, but it was actually Vince McMahon himself; after the ratings disasters of the Berlin and South Africa editions of Monday Night Raw, he threw a fit and decided everything needed to change. This is how Vince Russo crept into creative, and this is how the logo changed: Vince decided the old one was precisely that, a reminder that the WWE was passé.

As revealed by Mike Sempervive of the Wrestling Observer, Vince scratched something close to the logo that was implemented several months later - only, because of course, with a pair of testicles underneath it. This new WWF had balls, damn it!

He was talked down from that idea, but it was felt the logo he had drawn, impulsively, was a strong reflection of the new "attitude" direction.


5. Scott Hall Credited Himself With Crow Sting

Sting AEW
AEW

Sting has been so incredible in AEW that Tony Khan has usurped Paul Heyman as the booker who can best accentuate the positives of talents with certain limitations. Sting can no longer wrestle a very good singles match of any significant length, but the "Sting party match" is so creative and wildly entertaining that it doesn't matter: at 63, Sting casts a spell of pure wrestling magic like few others.

The paint-job helps. With the genius of his modern match layout, carefully structured to flatter him, he looks ageless. His presence and mastery of body language is enhanced by that killer, immortal look. He can't be Surfer Sting anymore - that look is synonymous with his explosive babyface work - but no matter. Crow Sting is eternal.

It was, per his own re-telling of the story, Scott Hall's idea. In coming up with it, Hall didn't merely transform Sting's career; he added decades to it.

When changing together backstage, Hall - an expert pro wrestling mind who knew where the business needed to go in the mid 1990s - asked if Sting was still wearing the "happy guy" tights and if he'd seen the 1994 film. "I ain't telling you to rip off 'Taker," Hall claims he said on 83 Weeks, "but rip off 'Taker".


4. Vince Russo Was Actually Good Once

Vince Russo WCW
WWE.com

Opinion on Vince Russo is naturally divided; he's either a genius capable of bringing on monster TV ratings to this day, if only the cowards at AEW or WWE would hire him, or a complete moron who was successful for a year but set the business back decades.

Even his most loyal supporters shrug at accusations that he was a nonsensical misogynist; if anything, to them, that is a cause for celebration. Wrestling is about wrestling; it's about twists, t*ts, and slut-shaming. They often argue that Russo had an idea for every wrestler on the roster, as if that isn't the bare minimum, but few, on either side of the debate, would confuse Russo for an astute, elegant writer who plotted compelling stories over the long-term.

The events of Survivor Series 1998 prove otherwise. The Deadly Game tournament was his masterpiece; something of which Gedo or Bill Watts would have been proud.

Russo, faced with several challenging problems, nailed them all.

The tournament-long ruse was so intricate that Steve Austin was no mug for failing to recognise it. His babyface appeal was preserved, and, since he was nowhere near his peak, it was an ingenious idea to book the Rock to win by aligning with the Corporation; Russo built a megastar heel act and the WrestleMania XV main event in one shockingly unpredictable night. Not only that: by framing Mick Foley with the Screwjob finish when it was still an effective source of heat, Russo mapped out the intervening period between Survivor Series and 'Mania too.

Rock needed that feud with Foley to get over as a true heel, and 'Mania XV was the most successful PPV ever to that point.


3. Who Opened The Forbidden Door?

Kenny Omega
AEW

While it may not seem unthinkable, since Kenny Omega forged a unique path to super stardom and never seemed content to work one fixed style or dedicate himself to one wrestling promotion, or one booker's vision, his relationship with New Japan Pro Wrestling had deteriorated badly by the time he left in January 2019.

He was paid less, significantly so, than his role should have dictated. He revealed on the short-lived 'Wrestlers On The Road Ordering Room Service' YouTube series that "for about a year and a half", he was the lowest paid guy on the roster. His monthly cheque from ProWrestlingTees cleared his earnings the month that he worked Kazuchika Okada at Wrestle Kingdom 11.

Moreover, in the weeks ahead of Wrestle Kingdom 13, Omega was blocked from the telling his story with Hiroshi Tanahashi the way he had intended. He was unhappy, and this was reciprocated by NJPW; the Young Bucks, Cody, and Hangman Page had announced the formation of US competitor All Elite Wrestling on Being The Elite with the Tokyo Dome as the backdrop.

It was nonetheless Kenny Omega's idea to collaborate with Impact Wrestling during his run as the 'Belt Collector' across 2021, and, per Rocky Romero, it was Omega who pitched to bring in NJPW's KENTA at Beach Break. KENTA was US-based, was working a programme with Jon Moxley for the IWGP US title on Strong, and Omega spotted an opportunity to open the door ajar.

The ripple effect of Omega's idea has drastically informed professional wrestling for the better; more AEW Vs. NJPW matches were promoted on Dynamite, the seminal Forbidden Door pay-per-view was promoted in June last year, and, as so often happens in wrestling, the trend caught on elsewhere. NJPW's collaboration with Pro Wrestling NOAH has already yielded spectacular results.


2. The Elite Helped Shape Britt Baker's Character

Britt Baker
AEW

This one is unthinkable because the rumour mill suggests that, as soon as AEW formed, the Elite fell out and pursued their own creative interests to the detriment of a product that sometimes felt disjointed.

The Elite wanted to lose a rather silly supernatural-leaning programme with the Dark Order as Cody Rhodes sought to bring back the halcyon days of 1980s territory in parallel. AEW stated all along that the range of the promotion was its core appeal, but it felt like two different companies between Full Gear and the end of 2019, particularly when the Elite continued to interact. The idea that Cody was tormented by MJF and a Dark Order creeper at the same time just wasn't convincing (or particularly compelling).

The booking committee that comprised Tony Khan, Cody, Kenny Omega and the Young Bucks was disbanded by Khan across the 2019 holiday season. Demonstrably, they didn't collaborate effectively.

Except they did, after the fact; when Dr. Britt Baker was struggling to connect as a babyface, because holding two jobs was almost too impressive a thing for a babyface to do, it was Omega's idea to turn her heel. The incredible "I'm seeing a lot of confusion on these chubby Whataburger faces" line delivered in February 2020 was Cody's idea.

Baker used these suggestions and soon shaped the character herself to a remarkable extent; she is the success story of an uneven women's division to this day.

The idea that the Elite couldn't collaborate, and that they had zero input after January 2020, is incorrect.


1. Turns Out The WWE Creative Process Wasn't Always A Failure

Chris Jericho Vince McMahon
WWE

The cynical - and all too often correct - take is that, for much of the 21st century, the WWE creative process was entirely dysfunctional.

The crux of it was as follows:

1) The wrestlers, the artists, had next to no input nor agency, particularly if they weren't top stars. Even then, the most protected talents had to wade through a lot of complete b*llocks.

2) An overstaffed crew of creative writers were responsible for generating ideas, and they were hacks imported from areas of "real" TV (at which they had failed) who learned quickly not to pitch anything that Vince McMahon wasn't predisposed to liking.

3) Vince would hack their work to death and rewrite thee show to his liking regardless.

So basically, the people who couldn't voice the ideas of talent (because they weren't the talent) were responsible for coming up with deliberately sh*tty ideas, that were rarely accepted, to protect the roles that the wrestlers had a better grasp of.

The process actually worked once to incredible effect.

The Money In The Bank ladder match was Chris Jericho's idea; he recognised that a lot of great upper midcard talents had nothing to do at WrestleMania 21, and suggested a singles variation of the tag team ladder wars beloved by fans. He took this to writer Brian Gewirtz, who came up with the stakes: the winner was entitled to a World title match over the next 365 days at their convenience.

Jericho and Gewirtz took the idea to Vince, who liked it but suggested a prop, because of course he did. This however made sense: the briefcase scanned as a prize worth holding, symbolising Edge's threat as the next man to break into the main event bracket.

When things happened the way they were meant to happen, great things happened.

Astonishing.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!