10 Ups & 4 Downs From AEW Collision (June 24)

CM Punk and Jay White again butt heads in another stellar outing for AEW Collision.

AEW Collision CM Punk Jay White
AEW

After a hugely impressive debut last week, AEW Collision is back for its second outing. Once again complete with CM Punk centre-stage, this sophomore offering had plenty of promise on paper, but how much did it deliver the goods in practice?

Much like last week, Punk found himself in the main event here, teaming with FTR and Ricky Starks to battle Jay White, Juice Robinson and the Gunns. Elsewhere, Christian Cage presented himself as the TNT Champion, Andrade El Idolo's burgeoning war with House of Black nicely ticked on, Tetsuya Naito was revealed as Sting and Darby Allin's partner for Forbidden Door, the Owen Hart Cup continued to shape up, and there was some slight character developments for Miro, Powerhouse Hobbs and the long-missed Scorpio Sky.

So, which elements of Collision knocked it out of the park, and which parts just ultimately fell flat? For the most part, it was another successful night for AEW's Saturday show, with Forbidden Door looming large on the imminent horizon. Still, it wasn't all sunshine and rainbows for Collision, for there were a few missteps amongst the string of positives to come out of this episode.

Saturday night's alright for fighting, indeed...


Downs...

4. A Slightly Laboured Opening Segment

AEW Collision Chris Jericho Minoru Suzuki
AEW

The second episode of AEW Collision kicked off with Fozzy's Judas blaring out across the Scotiabank Arena, with Chris Jericho and Minoru Suzuki making their way out to the ring. For these Suzuki Gods, they demanded an answer as to who Sting and Darby Allin's mystery partner would be for Forbidden Door.

Tetsuya Naito is the person who'll be going up against Jericho, Suzuki and Sammy Guevara at tonight's PPV, and that's a great, logical choice. Unfortunately, this segment felt a little muddled and overstayed its welcome somewhat.

Jericho as the whining, entitled heel was expected, but the Ocho's diatribe bordered on repetitive before Sting and Darby cut him off. For Suzuki, he looked like he didn't particularly know why he was there, bar to do a fun handshake spot with his tag partner.

Another issue with this segment, is that Tony Schiavone showed barely any fear whatsoever when Chris Jericho placed Floyd - his baseball bat - at Schiavone's throat and threated to rough him up. This is a Chis Jericho who is an eight-time World Champion, with a 33-year in-ring career, and who is positioned as a sinister villain capable of carrying out despicable acts.

In short, Schiavone should've been bricking himself. Instead, he acted unbothered and still managed to belt out a "It's Stiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiing!" once the Icon's music hit.

One particular positive of this segment, mind, was Darby Allin once again demonstrating an ever-improving game on the microphone. That's not to say Allin is MJF or anything, but he really starts to feel like he's finding his voice these days - which he again did here.


3. Muddled Mask Mess

AEW Collision Julia Hart
AEW

Firstly, Andrade El Idolo vs. Brody King was a belter of a match. The problem is, this is a second week in a row where the use of Andrade's mask has felt a little too daft.

Here, El Idolo put a temporary halt on his attack on Brody upon realising Julia Hart had dared to pick up the former La Sombra's mask. Yes, masks are of course sacred in the culture of lucha libre, but it feels a little off that the one-time NXT Champion would stop putting a beating on his opponent just because someone had touched the mask he wears for his entrance.

If this mask is so special to Andrade, logically it'd make sense to just leave it in the back if you're worried somebody might decide to pick it up for a closer look mid-match.

This admittedly is only a mild quibble, but it's the one slight negative of what has otherwise been a fantastic presentation of El Idolo across his two Collision outings so far.


2. The Cheap Route For Christian Cage

AEW Collision Luchasaurus Christian Cage
AEW

Christian Cage is a magnificent heel, a phenomenal talker, and someone who has shown time and time again how fantastic he is at garnering a desired reaction from a crowd. And while he did manage to get himself booed in his hometown of Toronto, Cage took an unnecessarily cheap route to get that.

By that, Cage took the path of ripping on the local sports teams.

Simply put, Christian is better than this. Going after the Toronto Maple Leafs and Toronto Raptors is the sort of low-hanging fruit that a lesser heel should use to get heat. Such easy fodder is better reserved for villains who don't have the confidence, presence or ability of Cage.

Was abusing the Leafs and Raptors effective? Yes. But this felt like a copout way to illicit a response, when Christian is skilled enough to steer clear of such clichés.


Ups...

1. The Pre-Titles Promos

AEW Collision Ricky Starks FTR CM Punk
AEW

Such a simple but effective thing, having AEW Collision serve up a couple of promos before the show's titles had even rolled, was fantastic.

Ahead of their main event match-up, CM Punk, Ricky Starks and FTR spent 25 seconds firing shots at their opponents. For their part, Jay White, Juice Robinson and the Gunns then spent 30 seconds lambasting the babyfaces who they'd be facing later in the night.

This was great, this felt fresh, and it caught your attention right from the get-go. All eight men were energetic and spouted lines that felt entirely natural for their characters, complete with a nice smidge of classic pro wrestling cheese in terms of getting their own catchphrases in.

Concise and, most importantly, entertaining, this segment took less than one full minute to immediately get the Collision audience hyped for what lay ahead.

A fresh spin on the cliched screaming multi-man promo format of yesteryear, this was pitch perfect. More of this, please.


10. Naito Makes Perfect Sense

AEW Collision Tetsuya Naito
AEW

Following Darby Allin's ominous words on Dynamite about Chris Jericho having amassed lots of enemies over the years, some fans jumped to the conclusion that Bill Goldberg would be coming in to team with Darby and Sting at AEW x NJPW Forbidden Door.

Thankfully, that is not the case, as Tetsuya Naito is a far better fit for this role.

In Naito, AEW and NJPW have lined up a man who traded the IWGP Intercontinental Title with Jericho in 2018 and into 2019. Not just is there that history, though, for this role is the ideal landing spot for a Naito who at one point looked as if he may be entirely absent for a second Forbidden Door show.

While the Los Ingobernables de Japón leader isn't viewed as quite as big of a star these days as he was in prior years, he's still a significant name for New Japan Pro-Wrestling. Even more so, he would have been an extremely notable absentee - much like stablemate Shingo Takagi, who has been relegated to the Zero Hour pre-show - should AEW and NJPW have not found a spot for him on the Forbidden Door card.

Also, imagine in 2018, when Jericho and Naito were feuding, if you'd have said in five years time we'd see the two face off in a six-man match for a promotion launched by a billionaire and his son, where Naito would team with the then-retired Sting and a Darby Allin who was floating between promotions such as MLW, EVOLVE, Defy, and Progress...

Forbidden Door's trios bout should be a whole bunch of fun.


9. Slow But Steady

AEW Collision Scorpio Sky
AEW

With the launch of AEW Collision, the promise was that this would be a new platform to showcase some of the underserved talent of All Elite Wrestling. And in that regards, few have been as underserved in recent months (and longer!) as Miro and Scorpio Sky, and, to an extent, Powerhouse House.

In the case of Miro, he'd bafflingly wrestled just four matches in 2022, and he'd only competed twice in the 12 months prior to Collision's first episode. Where Sky is concerned, it's nearly a year since the AEW Original last wrestled; that coming on a July '22 Dynamite, where he lost the TNT Title to Wardlow.

Seeing Miro back in action and destroying Tony Nese last week was long overdue, and a follow-up pre-taped promo here was fine for what it was. There, we saw the Redeemer renounce his god, his gold, and his beautiful wife. It wasn't long, but this nicely returned Miro to the roots of what made him so compelling prior to his time spent in, as the Bulgarian Brute himself put it, "exile".

For Scorpio Sky, a short backstage interview had a confident, composed Scorp promise a reset of sorts, explaining how he was previously operating as a shadow of himself and couldn't handle the "big break" of his AEW success. Again, very brief, but very much solid in reintroducing Sky to AEW television.

With Powerhouse Hobbs, he picked up a squash victory over local talent Jeremy Prophet on this week's Collision, which is hopefully the start of establishing Hobbs as a brutal monster who spends his Saturday nights cracking skulls.

All of this has a feel of K.I.S.S. - as in, Keep It Simple, Stupid. Taking a slow, thought-out approach to making Miro, Scorpio and Powerhouse key Collision players should reap solid rewards down the line.


8. An Ideal Showcase Of THIS Tanahashi

AEW Collision Hiroshi Tanahashi
AEW

Yes, Hiroshi Tanahashi has clearly got completely knackered knees these days, and yes, his Collision match against Swerve Strickland was clearly not the same Tanahashi who wowed in legendary Wrestle Kingdom main events, but this Collision outing was an ideal showcase of this Tanahashi.

With a 24-year career of his intense, high-impact ring style under his belt, the 46-year-old Ace is obviously now feeling the wear and tear on his body. That's not to say that Tana doesn't still have a great match or two left in his locker before he eventually hangs up his boots, and maybe MJF is technically sound enough, smooth enough, giving enough, and charismatic enough to help deliver one such great match. Maybe.

While it wasn't always pretty, what we got on AEW Collision was a perfect example of what Hiroshi Tanahashi is in 2023. For those who've not seen Tanahashi for a few years, or even for those who may have never seen Tana in action, this was a performance that let you know that, both as a performer and as a character, Tanahashi is a veteran babyface with great fire and presence, but who is battling his own body as he chases the highs of the past.

Being the younger, brasher, cocksure prick heel who has no time for legends and icons, the MJF character is the perfect foil for present-day Tanahashi, as time catches up with the man who for so long carried New Japan Pro-Wrestling on his back.


7. Andrade Vs. House Of Black Nicely Progresses

AEW Collision Andrade El Idolo Brody King Buddy Matthews
AEW

Last week, the returning Andrade El Idolo toppled Buddy Matthews in an absolute war, and this week it was Matthews' House of Black stablemate Brody King who went up against El Idolo. And again, we got another absolute war.

For nearly 13 minutes, Andrade and King beat the utter tar out of one another. Snug doesn't even come close when describing the shots laid in between these two... before Buddy Matthews ran in and attacked El Idolo to cause the DQ.

It wasn't just Matthews who had a presence on Collision, though, for Malakai Black showed up on video wall as Buddy and Brody put a beating on the former La Sombra. Of course, ghis continues to build towards Andrade having to seek out back-up in his burgeoning war with House of Black.

Andrade vs. King itself is more than worthy of an Up. To add extra oomph to this, AEW nicely progressed towards what will surely be a La Facción Ingobernable vs. House of Black rivalry, which would certainly be a welcome way to bring Rush back to AEW programming.


6. The TNT Title Finally Feels Like A Big Deal Again

AEW Collision Luchasaurus Christian Cage
AEW

He may have received a Down for taking the cheap heat route, but Christian Cage is already the best thing to happen to the TNT Title for what feels like an eternity. And the best thing is, Christian isn't even the TNT Champion.

For the past year, the TNT Title has so often felt like an unfortunate afterthought.

During that time, the belt has bounced from Scorpio Sky, to Wardlow, to Samoa Joe, to Darby Allin, to Samoa Joe, to Wardlow, to Powerhouse Hobbs, and to Wardlow, before now being held by Luchasaurus.

The War Dog's initial TNT Title run certainly had moments of promise, but all of those other reigns with the gold have fell flat, with the TNT Championship being viewed as the least important, least prestigious belt in AEW. Now though, there's hope again...

Christian parading around with the TNT Title as if he's a proud papa showing off his baby, already positions the TNT Championship in a fresh, much-needed light. By this title being such a big deal to Cage, that likewise makes the audience perceive the belt to be a big deal.

Of course, it also helps that Christian has the hulking presence of Luchasaurus looming in the background to back up the sh*t-talking done by Cage, and this formula should work wonders for AEW and the TNT Title should the promotion allow this schtick to stick for the foreseeable future.


5. The Men's Owen Hart Cup Feels Important

AEW Collision Satoshi Kojima
AEW

This isn't to say that the Owen Hart Cup Tournament didn't feel like a big deal last year, but this week's AEW Collision did a particularly great job of making the men's Owen feel hugely important.

In one short video package, AEW made the men's Owen Hart Cup feel like the biggest thing in the world to those involved in it. Here, we got comments from Satoshi Kojima, CM Punk, Roderick Strong, Samoa Joe, Dustin Rhodes, Powerhouse Hobbs, Juice Robinson, and Ricky Starks - all of whom put over their opponents, put over the tournament, and portrayed a sense of genuine desire at wanting to win the Owen.

So often, we've seen tournaments where they feel run-of-the-mill and with low stakes. Not here. Instead, all eight male competitors did their very best to make the audience appreciate how seriously they're taking this and how hard they're going to fight to win this tourney.

On the other side of the fence, the women's Owen Hart Cup doesn't feel particularly heated up just yet. That said, Collision did see Willow Nightingale cement herself a spot in the tournament semi-finals...


4. Willow Continues To Thrive As The Endearing Babyface

AEW Collision Willow Nightingale
AEW

Willow Nightingale, man...

Is there a more enjoyable, authentic babyface in pro wrestling right now? Likely not.

Seeing Willow getting to shine in the AEW spotlight lately, has been phenomenal for those who've kept an eye on Nightingale's career over the years. The New Yorker is one of those special talents who just makes you feel good about watching professional wrestling. Willow makes it fun, makes it a little daft, makes it accessible to all, but still puts on a hell of a game face when it's time to get to work.

Not just is the Nightingale character one of the most enjoyable presences in present-day wrestling, but the 29-year-old is also a mighty fine in-ring worker, too. While it seemed Willow may be more of an ROH-based talent at one point in time, her capturing of the NJPW Strong Women's Championship has seen her become a more featured player on AEW programming - and AEW programming is all the better for that.

Here on Collision, Willow once again put on a brilliant babyface performance, besting Nyla Rose - who very much held up her side of the bargain and was the perfect villain - to seal herself a spot in the Owen semis.


3. The Greatest Commentary Team In The Game?

AEW Collision Nigel McGuinness Kevin Kelly
AEW

In regards to AEW, Kevin Kelly and Nigel McGuinness have only been an on-air partnership for two episodes of TV, but already this pairing is shaping up to be one of the best in the business.

Of course, Kelly and McGuinness have worked together before, doing an excellent job for Ring of Honor back in the day. For those who didn't particularly pay too much attention to ROH, though, this may appear like an entirely new commentary pairing.

Most importantly, this duo bring a uniqueness to AEW Collision where it pertains to the commentary seen elsewhere across Dynamite and Rampage. This isn't a knock on the announce teams for those shows, but Kelly and McGuinness are enthusiastic without being over-the-top, are informative without overloading the audience, and have a general tone and calmness to them that it means more when they do get animated.

For your writer, Ian Riccaboni and Caprice Coleman are the A-team in professional wrestling commentary these days, but Kelly and McGuinness could well soon be challenging for that crown.


2. Addressing The Elephant In The Room

AEW Collision CM Punk
AEW

If Collision was a WWE show, one of two things would've happened during the main event. Either the commentary team would've spouted lines about Bizarro Land, or the negative reaction to CM Punk would've been completely ignored by those calling the action.

What AEW did, though, was have Kevin Kelly and Nigel McGuinness address the elephant in the room.

To be fair, AEW has never shied away from listening to its audience, and this was yet another example of this. In WWE, the company has its own narrative it forever wants to deliver, which in turn means they at times will blindly ignore the response of their crowds if said fans aren't reacting in the desired way. Thankfully, AEW is a very different beast when it comes to this topic.

AEW would've looked utterly foolish if it didn't acknowledge that CM Punk received a hugely split opinion from those at Toronto's Scotiabank Arena. Likewise, Punk himself did a great job in playing into the boos and negative sentiment being rained down upon him by certain sections of the Scotiabank crowd.


1. Another Main Event Marvel For Collision

AEW Collision CM Punk Jay White
AEW

Its obviously early doors, but AEW Collision is two for two in delivering stellar main event matches.

We may not have had any further movement towards the inevitable CM Punk vs. Samoa Joe rivalry - don't worry, it's coming - but Collision's closing eight-man bout was a whole lot of fun and helped continue to position Jay White as a major player in AEW.

Some have rightly questioned how the Switchblade has been used since formally becoming #AllElite earlier in the year, but Collision seems to have arrived at just the right time for White. Here, he picked up the win for his team, hitting the Blade Runner on Ricky Starks to pick up the 1-2-3. For any heel to secure the win in a match featuring the recently-returned CM Punk, that's a huge deal. And much like Joe, it seems inevitable that we'll be getting a Punk and White singles contest in the not-so-distant future.

After losing last week, this win was a much-needed one for Jay and Juice, and Rock Hard's erratic intensity continues to be a highlight of whatever show he's on. Likewise, the Gunns are proving to be another AEW highlight, with their cool as all hell entrance amassing quite the buzz online.

Most importantly, the victory here did far more good for the heels than it did damage to the babyface foursome. Taking the pinfall doesn't particularly harm Ricky Starks, and Absolute may well get some semblance of revenge by dumping Juice Robinson out of the Owen Hart Cup Tournament. And speaking of Absolute, seeing the Stroke Daddy standing alongside CM Punk and FTR just felt, well, right. If this is the roots of a genuine faction we've got on our hands, consider your writer very much here for it.


Senior Writer
Senior Writer

Once described as the Swiss Army Knife of WhatCulture, Andrew can usually be found writing, editing, or presenting on a wide range of topics. As a lifelong wrestling fan, horror obsessive, and comic book nerd, he's been covering those topics professionally as far back as 2010. In addition to his current WhatCulture role of Senior Content Producer and Presenter, Andrew previously spent nearly a decade as Online Editor and Lead Writer for the world's longest-running genre publication, Starburst Magazine, and his work has also been featured on BBC, TechRadar, Tom's Guide, WhatToWatch, Sportkskeeda, and various other outlets, in addition to being a Rotten Tomatoes-approved film critic. Between his main day job, his role as lead panel host of Wales Comic Con, and his gig as a pre-match host for Wrexham AFC games, Andrew has also carried out a hugely varied amount of interviews, from the likes of Robert Englund and Eli Roth to Kevin Smith and the Russo Brothers, to Kevin Conroy and Frank Miller, to Bret Hart and Sting, to Mickey Thomas, Joey Jones, Phil Parkinson, and Brian Flynn, to many, many more. Where his beloved Wrexham AFC is concerned, Andrew is a long-standing season ticket holder and an FSA Award-winner for his time co-hosting the Fearless in Devotion podcast.