5 Ups & 3 Downs From WWE SmackDown (11 Sept - Results & Review)

Sami Zayn won the WWE Title from CM Punk on a fiery night in Mexico City on SmackDown.

Sami Zayn WWE Title
WWE.com

Mexico City was left stunned when the referee's hand slapped the mat for a third time and ring announcer Mark Nash confirmed that Sami Zayn is the brand new WWE Champion during Friday's edition of SmackDown. Everyone from Johnny Gargano and Candice LeRae to Kevin Owens got involved in Zayn's bout with now-former champ CM Punk. It was chaos. Cats and dogs living together. Mass hysteria.

This show was promoted as "Championship Friday" by Michael Cole, but not everything felt as grandiose as bosses would've wanted it to. Indeed, Damian Priest's turn on R-Truth felt like something that needed to happen long before now. Meanwhile, Trick Williams just can't shake Baron Corbin no matter how hard he tries, and a grudge effort pitting Nikki Bella vs. Paige fell short as expected.

Back on the bright side, everyone will be talking about the top title change and what that means for a ridiculously jam-packed SmackDown main event scene. Randy Orton kept himself in the frame for a title shot earlier in the night, and Cody Rhodes will return to screens for a special sit-down interview next week. You just know Cody will be linked to the top belt whenever he's around, so stay tuned for more on that.

A surprisingly solid Women's Title match and that aforementioned headliner boosted SmackDown's prospects big style. WWE will now turn its gaze to Money In The Bank build, but they've got sheer mayhem unfolding thanks to Sami, KO, Punk, Gargano, Orton, Rhodes, Finn Bálor and Gunther. That's making SmackDown sing right now.

Here's all the yay and nay.


Downs...

3. Lame Duck Match & A Turn Without Emotion

Damian Priest R-Truth Turn
WWE.com

Damian Priest and R-Truth lost their AAA Tag Title match to The War Raiders, then Priest turned on Truth. This one was on the cards, so the title match was rudderless. No amount of samey backstage skits over the past couple of months was ever going to change that. At least Mexico City gave The Raiders more of a welcome than most live crowds would. Got to take your wins where you can find them, lads!

Sadly, the match never properly got going and there was never any threat of a title change. Post-bout, Priest's turn lacked any and all emotional weight too. It’s incredible how far Damian has slipped since the Judgment Day and World Champ days. Hopefully, he can rescue things going forwards, but a berth in AAA may be on tap for this big dude to see if he can turn the ship around.

He's gone from being one of WWE's most impressive new headliners to someone guffawing at Truth's antics behind the curtain. Now, he's back on his own again. That's a start, but it won't mean a darn thing unless Triple H actually has a plan for Priest. His babyface run, aside from teaming with Rhea Ripley, was a bit of a washout.

It remains to be seen if WWE's fanbase will get behind Truth as he looks for some revenge. The veteran can play a good underdog when he has to, but he might want to ask Chelsea Green for some tips heading into this one. On the other side, Damian has to up the menace if he wants to succeed as a heel. He could do worse than having a word with Gunther.


2. “Oh yeah, that’s how you do it!”

Nikki Bella Paige
WWE.com

You've got to question why Nikki Bella and Paige are even feuding in 2026. Like, what's the end goal here? Both are stalwarts/legends of the WWE mix, and both have been on comeback tours with varying levels of success. If the objective is to get either one more over with fans or line them up for a title shot in the longer term, then...why? There's no real clamour for that to happen, being brutally frank.

Here, Bella cheated to pin Paige by putting her feet on the ropes following an extended beatdown by the Brit babyface. There’s just nothing here, guys. Sorry, but there isn't. The feud has been sucking wind for a while, WWE has been on and off about even putting promos for it on TV, and this short match didn’t do much to inspire confidence. The whole exercise boiled down to pure time filler.

Not good time filler either.

Are we really going to keep going with this until Brie is back from her injury layoff and Paige can draft in a partner to take on the twins? Everyone might've fallen asleep long before that can happen, and it's hardly like Paige and a pal vs. The Bellas is a pulsating, can't miss thought anyway. Mexico City even seemed bummed out by the sudden stop finish on Friday night, and they were legitimately going nuts for practically everything WWE put in front of them.

Post-match, Bella shouted: "Oh yeah, that's how you do it". Do what? Work a mediocre match in a mediocre feud that's struggling to convince?


1. We’re Going “Fight Forever” With This?!

Baron Corbin Trick Williams Lil Yachty
WWE.com

Sunday Night's Main Event should've been an endpoint for this rivalry.

On SmackDown, Trick Williams came out for a promo about his United States Title win at SNME. There was no Lil Yachty, but he was dragged to ringside by Baron Corbin. Why? Well, apparently we must run with this rivalry forevermore. Honestly, Trick winning the belt again was the time to move on from Corbin, but here we are still doing it. No amount of Trick Willy magic on the mic can justify going with yet another match between these guys.

Baron got some good heat, being fair, but surely everyone is bored of this now. “We’re not done”, said Corbin after he'd blasted Williams with a kendo stick from behind on the stage. That’s what we’re all afraid of, sir. Listen, Baron put in some shift in Atlanta last weekend, and he carried Yachty to a passable 5-minute 'wrestler vs. manager' showdown, but there was no need to keep him in the title scene on this week's show. None at all.

If anything, people would've been hoping to see Trick move on to something else, but his looming inclusion in things at Money In The Bank means WWE booking remains frozen for now. Unless the latest Williams vs. Corbin bout is a qualifier for the ladder match, then forget it. Does anyone actually want to see them lock horns for that United States gold one more time?!

The sooner Yachty splits from Williams the better too. It's time folks. It's high time.


Ups...

5. Decent ‘Champ On Notice’ Address

Randy Orton
WWE.com

Randy Orton kicked off the show with a basic promo talking about how Cody Rhodes couldn’t pull the trigger at SNME because “he’s a good man and no killer”. Then, he put the winner of the WWE Title main event on notice by saying he’d have an RKO waiting for them. This was all rather straightforward, but the live crowd was buzzed to see Randy and he did have a point to make.

He was keeping himself in the title mix here, which is smart.

Also, Orton fed the thought that Cody is about to turn heel and show a different side to his personality. That's been implied for a while now, but the superhero-style babyface just can't bring himself to be downright evil. When he snaps, he'll snap hard, and that could be a special moment for the 'American Nightmare'. It'd also bring a wry smile across the lips of Randy, or terrify him. That's up for debate, and so is how the writers should play with the iconic heel's own character once Rhodes goes off the deep end.

For the time being, having Orton ominously threaten that he'd be coming for either CM Punk or Sami Zayn was a neat way to open up the night. He didn't stop by to deliver on that RKO once Zayn shockingly won the belt later on, but WWE can put that moment on ice. Who knew we could have so many successful tweeners knocking around the headline scene without it feeling awkward?! Guys like Randy and Sami are smashing their characterisation these days.


4. Ricky’s Going Nowhere, But This Was Fun!

Rey Fenix Ricky Saints
WWE.com

Rey Fenix defended his AAA Cruiserweight Title vs. Ricky Saints in a fabulously zippy opener.

Saints is treading water on the main roster big time and has been for a while, but he’s still really good between the ropes and worked as a challenger in this sort of setting. Some AAA infusion worked for Mexico City’s wrestling daft faithful, and Fenix was typically smooth out there himself. This wasn't going to be some 30-minute stunner by any means, but it had its place on "Championship Friday", that's for sure.

Some reading/watching might've missed every bit of it, but the pair had actually done some build for this online and in non-televised skits aired on WWE.com and social media. Unfortunately, we didn't really get to see them line anything up on SmackDown proper, but the important thing was that the match clicked. Good news incoming: It did. This was like a teaser of more to come between these guys.

For proof of that, just check out the promo segment that aired deeper into the episode. Ricky initially called Fenix "the better man" and put his hand out for Rey to shake. After that, he walked away and blindsided the masked man before insinuating that things aren't over by a long shot between them. If that means another match is on the schedule, then sign this writer up!

Fenix probably has next to no chance of getting on a mainline WWE PLE whilst AAA Cruiser Champ, but Saints going to AAA or running it back on a future episode of SmackDown sounds pretty fun.


3. Women’s Title Match Makes The Best Of It

Nia Jax Chelsea Green
WWE.com

Chelsea Green vs. Nia Jax was a nice underdog ride for the champ. The live crowd in Mexico City was firmly behind Green, even more so because of the flag-based ring attire both women wore, and Chels worked well as someone physically overmatched. It’d be lovely if WWE could move on from this quickly, unlike Trick vs. Corbin in the US Title scene, but it was perfectly fine for what it was.

This writer has to be honest about something else: The match was way better than he thought it’d be going in. That's slightly awkward after weeks of eye rolling in these pages about how Nia sucked as a challenger for Green. You've got to be able to hold your hand up when you're wrong - there was a real threat of a title change here, if only because people are waiting on Tiffany Stratton’s seemingly inevitable turn, but it’s a net positive that Green retained.

Sure, there was some spotty logic with the mask stuff (Chelsea was supposed to be in deep trouble and potentially be stripped of her belt if the mask slipped off?), and the finish wasn’t as tidy as it could’ve been, but we got there. We got there. Score this one down as a shining example of how Green prioritises character work over pure in-ring acumen. Nia's usual slow as hell beatdown work didn't feel out of place on this occasion either, which is worth saying.

These women came up with something that never dropped below watchable and was actually one of SmackDown's brightest moments. Both deserve credit for that considering the suspect build.


2. Top Targeting Of The Respective Injuries

Sami Zayn CM Punk
WWE.com

Cast your minds back to CM Punk's title defence vs. Kevin Owens on the 21 August episode of SmackDown. There, the-then WWE Champ Punk sold a sore knee like his rent was due. Go back even further than that, and a knackered Punk was struggling to stay in the game against Roman Reigns at WrestleMania 42. Selling has become such a crucial component of CM's game in 2026.

On Friday, he was at it again. Punk re-injured his knee early in the WWE Title match vs. Sami Zayn, so the challenger targeted it. Later, Punk gave as good as he was getting by going after Sami’s already injured hand. Walking wounded vs. walking wounded was a good way to go with this main event. It gave each man a focal point throughout, and actually sold prior matches/injuries instead of just pressing the reset button on health like this was an exhibition in WWE 2K26.

Anyone watching these men do their thing should feel the weight of the road and hard fought matches coming back to haunt them. That's the whole point. These WWE stars are doing things most mortals simply couldn't, and that needs to come across each and every time they're inside the ring. Kudos to Punk and Zayn for making sure to sell how worn down they are by everything that's been going on this year.

Arguably, SmackDown's ad interruptions didn't let these injuries breathe as much as hardcore fans would like, but the pair did work around that before the fiery finish.


1. Sami Wins Amidst Sheer Chaos

CM Punk Sami Zayn Kevin Owens
WWE.com

And what a wild finish it was.

Johnny Gargano and Candice LeRae tried to help Sami, mainly because Gargano wanted to be first in line for a title shot as promised. Then, once that plot failed, Kevin Owens ran out but accidentally hit Punk with the belt when he was going for Zayn (Kev wasn't too gutted by that and managed a smirk). One low blow to KO and a Helluva Kick to Punk later and Sami was WWE Champion all over again. Nobody saw that one coming, let's be honest.

All going well, this title reign should last a little longer than the last one, but that was brilliant chaos to close us out and it again sold how competitive the main event pack is around this place. WWE might want to slow down a little on the title changes lest people start to think this is WCW Nitro and Thunder though! OK, maybe not. We don't have Vince Russo running around the place to yell: 'IT'S A SWERVE, BRO', so all is right with the world.

Seriously, that mayhem-filled closing stretch on SmackDown was reminiscent of the best from the 'Attitude Era'. To continue flinging compliments WWE's way, get this: Sami came out looking every bit as opportunistic as peak 'Rated-R Superstar' Edge, and now he's the one who goes from hunter to hunted in one of the busiest title pictures one can remember for a long, long time.

Sami's champ all over again, a steaming mad Punk is out for revenge, and there's a lengthy list of hungry challengers in-waiting. Owens, Gargano, Gunther, Finn Bálor, Randy Orton and Cody Rhodes are all in the spotlight too. It's great.

What did you think of this week's WWE SmackDown? For more wrestling, check out 12 Wrestlers Who Looked COMPLETELY Out Of Place In Other Promotions and 11 Legendarily BAD Wrestling Runs (With One ICONIC Moment)!


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.