10 Ups & 4 Downs From NJPW Wrestle Kingdom 14

79-and-a-third stars in the Tokyo Dome, etc.

Tetsuya Naito KENTA
NJPW

New Japan Pro Wrestling's biggest show of the year, Wrestle Kingdom 14, dominated 2020's first major wrestling weekend.

A two-nighter for the first time in history, it attracted over 70,000 fans as Kazuchika Okada, Tetsuya Naito, Jay White, and Kota Ibushi contested another new concept: the Double Gold Dash tournament. The winner would walk away with both the IWGP Heavyweight and Intercontinental championships to their name. A divisive idea that split the fanbase prior to the event, though there were few complaints after the weekend had unfolded.

Elsewhere, WK14 saw Chris Jericho put an AEW World Championship shot on the line against the legendary Hiroshi Tanahashi, Hiromu Takahashi returning to his blitzkrieg best versus IWGP Junior Heavyweight kingpin Will Ospreay, Jushin Thunder Liger's last stand, Jon Moxley's overdue New Japan return, and a night two closing angle that brought more heat than an atomic bomb.

Wrestle Kingdom 14 is supposed to be the workrate show of the year. It is to be held to the highest in-ring standards, so this review (which combines both nights) will endeavour to do just that.

Get your "nine stars in the Toky Dome" jokes at the ready. Let's go...


Downs…

4. NJPW World’s Brief Collapse

NJPW World
NJPWWorld.com

It wasn't a major disruption, but NJPW World briefly sh*t the bed on Sunday morning.

The first problem arose as fans were gearing up for the main card. New Japan's streaming service died sometime between the pre-show and Wrestle Kingdom proper, sparking anxious twitches amongst the horde of viewers attempting to tune in as things were getting started. This resulted in a delay of only a few minutes, but it happened again shortly after Jushin Liger's second retirement bout, with the entire service collapsing for a good 5-10 minutes before recovering.

This would've been a lot worse had it happened during one of the evening's biggest matches, but it was still an issue. Granted, the servers were coping with increased volumes of traffic, but NJPW must have known this was coming, and it's disappointing that we're still experiencing interruptions like this in 2020.


3. This Isn’t Wrestle Kingdom

SANADA Taichi Zack Sabre Jr
NJPW

The biggest concern to arise when New Japan first announced Wrestle Kingdom 14 would be stretched across two days was that the lower-card that creeps into literally every other NJPW show would dilute their most special event of the year, as was the case early on night one.

The two eight-man tags were pointless. Other than Zack Sabre Jr. pinning BUSHI to avenge a recent Road To loss, they offered little narrative development. Both were functionally sound and relatively well performed, but they belong on Korakuen Hall undercards, not Wrestle Kingdom, and neither brought a significant angle to the table either.

Both were a waste of time that would have been filled much more satisfyingly by a singles match for someone like Shingo Takagi or Tomohiro Ishii. Those guys are two of the best in the world, yet New Japan could only accommodate them in inconsequential fart matches, even if Takagi left the weekend a NEVER Six-Man Champion. Him and Ishii could have wrestled each other, though! Imagine how class that would've been.

Let's hope that the eight-mans after left behind if the two-day concept continues in 2021.


2. New Japan’s Tag Malaise Continues

David Finlay Juice Robinson
NJPW

While neither of the matches were outright bad, Wrestle Kingdom 14's two nights did nothing to shake New Japan's two tag team divisions from their seemingly unending malaise.

Guerrillas of Destiny vs. FinJuice was a Guerrillas of Destiny match: slow, plodding, and heatless while Tama Tonga and Tanga Loa were on offence. It's a shame, really, as so much of G.O.D.'s act is great (from their legacy to their banging entrance track), but the bloom comes off the rose as soon as they hit the ring, and Juice Robinson and David Finlay's combined energy couldn't lift them. Still, at least it ended the Guerrillas' tedious 315-day reign. Perhaps the division can move forward now.

Roppongi 3K vs. Bullet Club's Taiji Ishimori and El Phantasmo was marginally better. Still, it brought little to the table outside of empty sugar-rush calories. The high spots were plentiful and the pacing fast, but you've seen a hundred matches like this before and ELP's over-the-top heeling continually veers into "too much" territory. This did little to elevate the Junior Heavyweight tag scene.

Gedo was a tag team specialist back in the day, so it's odd that he hasn't found a way to fix these divisions. Fans just have to accept that it's probably never going to happen at this point.


1. Jay White’s Diminishing Returns

Kota Ibushi Jay White Gedo
NJPW

On his day, Jay White is one of the most effective heels in the business. His wonderful G1 Climax finals performance against Kota Ibushi is a perfect example of this, as his earned, well-placed f*ckery meshed perfectly with his opponent's indomitable babyface spirit to craft a minor Sports Entertainment masterpiece, and one of NJPW's most distinct 2019 matches.

It's a shame, then, that White is so inconsistent. One night, he's brilliant; the next, it's like 2018 all over again, and 'Switchblade' looks like he's still putting his villainous pieces together. This was the case at Wrestle Kingdom 14.

Wrestling Ibushi and Tetsuya Naito, White and manager Gedo brought chairs and brass knuckles into play, staged interruptions, downed referees, and played the numbers game, over, and over, and over, and over. By the end, it was hard to watch, almost compelling this reviewer (and many others on social media, it seems) to go and do something else with his time.

Both bouts were derailed by this lazy, uncreative shenanigans, which were executed with little flair or creativity. They were spammed in ways that hurt rather than helped the bouts. This was particularly problematic against Naito, where, given how long that bout felt, White's antics barely even felt necessary.

Heels cheat. That's fine, but this is NJPW. This is Wrestle Kingdom. Antics should inform the drama rather than nullify it, which is exactly what happened here.


Ups...

10. Don’t Sweat The Technique

Zack Sabre Jr SANADA
NJPW

Zack Sabre Jr. and SANADA clashed for what will hopefully be the last time in a while on night two, as the Suzuki-gun submission master put his RevPro British Heavyweight Championship on the line against a man who seemingly had his number heading into the event.

The grappling was as slick and fluid as you'd expect from these two. All quick exchanges and fast-moving counters, it felt like a rib on retiring referee Tiger Hattori (74 years old), who had to bust his *ss to keep up. Regardless, the brisk pace helped elevate the clash. It was a more exciting and engaging chess battle as a result and stylistically, it felt unique to everything else in the card, even if there are only so many times NJPW can go to this well. Fortunately, Sabre's victory guarantees something fresh is on the horizon for both.

Props to ZSJ for his understated character work here as well: his mini-freakouts whenever SANADA gained the upper hand took the whole package up a notch.


9. Kota The Killer

Kazuchika Okada Kota Ibushi
NJPW

Same fans may balk at Kota Ibushi's 0-2 record coming out of Wrestle Kingdom weekend, though it looks like this is the start of something new for the 'Golden Star.'

Ibushi entered a fugue state against both Kazuchika Okada and Jay White. A blank, expressionless mask adorned his face as his babyface spirit left his body. Brutality followed. The stiff, concussive blows he rained down on 'The Rain Maker' were particularly impactful. They came from a man seemingly out to murder rather than pin and though the White bout was sullied by overwrought f*ckery, the loss should only escalate Ibushi's descent into madness.

This is needed, as Kota's two losses push him further away from IWGP Heavyweight or Intercontinental contendership than he has been in a long time. A shift in character is necessary and by the looks of things, Wrestle Kingdom 14 will go down as the catalyst that turned Ibushi from pure wrestling force to straight-up murder machine, crippling all before him.

Look out for this as the year progresses: it is immediately one of 2020's most interesting arcs.


8. Anarchy In The USA

Jon Moxley Lance Archer
NJPW

While the idea that Juice Robinson can walk into an IWGP United States Title shot one night after Jon Moxley and Lance Archer had killed each other in a Texas Deathmatch was a little off, Wrestle Kingdom 14's US Championship offerings comprised of one great match, one decent-to-good match, and an absolutely blistering angle, making a positive whole.

Archer vs. Mox was the t*ts. This was two crazy, crazy bastards working a heated fight around plunder spots, rather than spamming the weaponry of the 10-count gimmick. Sure, there were plenty of knockout teases, but little slowdown. They made the most of their limited runtime with great moments like Archer literally Chokeslamming a young lion into Moxley's goddamn face, and the finish - a Death Rider off the apron through two tables - left big Lance bloodied, broken, and out for the count. What a war.

The following night's clash between Robinson and Mox wasn't as satisfying, particularly when considering the two bangers these guys wrestled in 2019. This was reflected in the surprisingly lacking crowd investment, though the post-match angle, in which furious murder grandpa Minoru Suzuki ripped off his tracksuit and sent Moxley to the shadow realm, more than salvaged it. This was an awesome challenge from MiSu after Mox DDT'd him in the build to the Archer match.


7. A Tale As Old As Time

KENTA Hirooki Goto
NJPW

As far as balancing great heel work with great wrestling goes, KENTA is the man Jay White should look to for inspiration.

Not that the former Hideo Itami is a better pure wrestler than 'Switchblade,' but he's a lot more adept at incorporating villainous shtick effectively and without hindering the flow of the match, hence why he's gotten over to such a degree in this promotion. Age is catching up to him, he's not as explosive as he used to be, and he'll never be the NOAH KENTA again, but it doesn't matter: KENTA has adapted. He's simultaneously a stiff old *ss-kicker and a cocky piece of trash, and it rules.

This match for a perfect clash of personalities with Hirooki Goto. New Japan's eternal bridesmaid he may be, but Goto is a valiant, honourable warrior with an unbreakable respect for pro-wrestling as a craft. Their ideologies couldn't be more different, and this was the story over their compelling, bruising NEVER Openweight Championship victory, in which Goto was victorious following a closing stretch so vicious it was impossible to watch without experiencing vicarious jaw pain.

Say what you will about Goto's positioning in the company, but the man delivers in big spots.


6. Next Up

KENTA Tetsuya Naito
NJPW

The complaints re: KENTA losing upwards into an IWGP Heavyweight Title match are worth discussing, but ultimately insignificant. KENTA made his own challenge. These arguments would hold more weight had the impending Tetsuya Naito clash not come about by the Bullet Club taking matters into his own hands, deciding to spoil the victorious double-champion's end-of-show celebration by kicking the tar out of him and literally sitting on his chest. In kayfabe, he made this challenge, not a booking team. It doesn't undo the win/loss mechanism at all.

On top of this, the beatdown was hotter than hell.

This thing drew incredible heat. KENTA was already established as one of New Japan's most over heels and those took him to a different level. Following on from the Katsuyori Shibata shenanigans, he's now the man NJPW fans most want to see slain by Naito's hand, and the promotion has established the money match for their next big pay-per-view - the New Beginning in Osaka-jo Hall.

Considering this, complaining almost seems pointless.


5. Liger Forever

Jushin Liger
NJPW

Jushin Thunder Liger drew the curtain on his in-ring career with two bouts that were about as good as anyone could have expected, as the masked legend bowed out in the most him way imaginable: by selflessly dropping two falls in sentimental opening bouts.

The first, pitting a host of figures from Liger's past (and, oddly, Ryusuke Taguchi) against each other in an eight-man tag, was loads of fun. That this match was going to succeed was evident from the moment Tatsuhito Takaiwa and Shinjiro Otani walked out wearing gruff, grumpy, expressions, and while there was a celebratory atmosphere in the end, it was a surprisingly stiff encounter. These old guys beat the snot out of each other.

Night two was ostensibly a Hiromu Takahashi vs. Liger singles match with Ryu Lee and Naoki Sano only on the action's fringes. Knowing it was Liger's last bout, it was one you never wanted to end, and it helped that him and Hiromu worked so fluidly with each other.

Thus ends one of the most legendary in-ring careers the sport will ever see. Liger's 35 years in the sport saw him craft a powerful legacy as few others have. It's one that'll never die, and one can only assume that there won't be a dry eye in the house by the time his New Year Dash retirement ceremony concludes.

Miss you already, boss.


4. Two Old Masters

Chris Jericho Hiroshi Tanahashi
NJPW

Chris Jericho vs. Hiroshi Tanahashi promised one of Wrestle Kingdom 14's most interesting outcomes, given the implications.

Victory would mean an AEW World Championship shot for the 'High-Flying Star.' Jericho brought the belt to the Tokyo Dome, the announcers put it over huge, and Tana fought like he wanted it. The stipulation not only added much-needed juice to a build that had tapered off after the first angle but bred hopes of an AEW/NJPW alliance, and these political implications added an extra layer of intrigue until eventually, and perhaps inevitably, Jericho put the icon away. For now, the working relationship must wait.

The bout itself was fabulous. This was two old masters of the craft ageing gracefully, squeezing as much life as possible from every single spot.

Jericho, the older of the two, has adapted perfectly. Flashes of the old him permeate his work but he plays the washed-up, brawling rockstar who still thinks he's the man perfectly. His in-ring character work is sublime, as is Tanahashi's, but their sharpness and coordination deserve a shout-out too: 'The Painmaker' crushing a flying Tana with a Codebreaker was so, so smooth.

One of Jericho's best bouts since leaving WWE, this was up there with the Kenny Omega and Tetsuya Naito bouts. Here's to more Old Man Jericho in NJPW.


3. Welcome Back, Hiromu

Hiromu Takahashi
NJPW

You'd have never have known Hiromu Takahashi had just returned from a broken neck, watching the way him and Will Ospreay flung themselves around at Wrestle Kingdom 14.

Their match was outstanding. In the build-up, a cocky Ospreay had expressed his desire to take the Junior Heavyweight division to a level on par with his bigger, beefier counterparts in 2020, handwaving Takahashi's chances in the process. This was pertinent to the story. Ospreay brought this attitude into the bout, attacking Hiromu's neck and adopting straight-up heel work, softening him up for the Stormbreaker. This meant the disgusting Hidden Blade spot and ensuing near-fall had everyone biting, the match having long since escalated into explosive, kinetic craziness.

Takahashi re-established himself as one of the best in the world here. A top five wrestler before he went away, his astounding superstar charisma, colourful personality, and lunatic wrestling style erupted in beautiful, brutal cloudbursts. His triumph would go down as the night's most cathartic if not for stablemate Tetsuya Naito.

While these narrative points are the bout's most important takeaways, it'd be remiss not to mention the level of technique on display. That balletic Sasuke Special counter sequence would have looked awful in the hands of literally any other pair of wrestlers in the world. Here, not only did it look great, but it made sense in the context of a scripted fight as well. These guys killed it (and themselves) throughout.


2. The Beauty In Brutality

Kazuchika Okada Kota Ibushi
NJPW

Kazuchika Okada is a wrestling god, within kayfabe and outwith it.

The ease with which this man crafts mesmerising in-ring epics with such impossibly dramatic closing stretches isn't fair. It just isn't fair. His slow-building escalations and incremental increase in intensity, in which the slower opening phases are just as important as the big match-ending bombs, mark him as one of the sport's greatest ever storytellers, and this was on full display at Wrestle Kingdom 14.

Kota Ibushi entered a similarly excellent performance on night one, driven first by determination, then destruction after entering his murder trance. The essence of the 'Golden Star' changed before our eyes in this match. Overcome by the will to maim and win, he couldn't undo the wrestling god, and now, the switch-flipping moment and violence he rained upon the 'Rain Maker' (so intense the referee had to interrupt out of concern for Okada's health) may now become him.

Kota's old wrestling sole fell in a dazzling IWGP Heavyweight Championship match. Simultaneously beautiful and ugly, its heart-in-mouth moments felt like the artform's pinnacle.

Until night two...


1. Tetsuya Two Belts

Tetsuya Naito
NJPW

Tetsuya Naito failed at Wrestle Kingdom 8. Spectacularly. Booted from the main event spot in favour of the Intercontinental Championship match, his bout with IWGP Heavyweight kingpin Kazuchika Okada ended in defeat for the 'Stardust Genius' and his floundering babyface persona. He wasn't ready. He crashed and burned.

The same thing happened at Wrestle Kingdom 12. In what was supposed to be Naito's redemptive arc, Naito forgot what he had become. In one fatal moment he dropped the 'Ingobernable' tapped back into the 'Stardust Genius,' and left all that brought him back to the dance behind. He wanted to feel the crowd's roar behind him, their energy in his veins, and it cost him. He went for the Stardust Press.

And he lost.

But not this time.

Finally, at Wrestle Kingdom 14, Naito ascended. His arc was capped in as well-crafted a big-time wrestling match as you'll ever see, fighting for his life against a dominant wrestling god. Okada was going to Okada. Naito knew this. He knew his greatest foe was going to destroy his knee, he knew he was going to have to rise to the challenge, he knew he was going to have to fight for his life. And he did.

2020 may not produce another spot as dramatic as WK14's Stardust Press. Time slowed down. Mouths fell agape.

And Naito mailed it.

One last surge of energy coursed through his body. He was fuelled by past failures, by the past seven years, by destiny, by the burning desire to slay the wrestling god and claim his scalp, and he rode all of it to victory. One last Destino took him to immortality.

This was flawless professional wrestling. Words cannot do it justice.

Watch Kazuchika Okada vs. Tetsuya Naito.


Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.