10 Ups And 11 Downs From WWE Royal Rumble 2020

One great surprise winner, one predictable winner, one massive surprise return.

Well, the first Royal Rumble of the Roaring 2020s is under WWE’s belt, and what can you say about it?

The two Rumble matches both delivered some great moments, but they also produced some frustration in how they were scripted. One provided a fantastic, out-of-the-box winner, while the other gave us the preordained victor, just as everyone suspected/feared.

The men’s Rumble delivered a tremendous surprise entrant, one that won’t be topped anytime soon, unless “Stone Cold” Steve Austin enters, followed by Bret Hart. It also went a creative route with how it booked Brock Lesnar’s entry into the match at #1. Whether you liked it depends on the viewer, but that’s fine.

The women’s Rumble leaned heavily on NXT wrestlers, which was both good and bad. It also produced an eyeroll-inducing winner, as though John Cena returned and won because he needed to find a path to WrestleMania.

The rest of the PPV was a mixed bag, with some title matches clicking well, and others being forgettable affairs that defined clash of styles. Thankfully, this year’s edition was shorter than last year, which also helped.

Overall, this was a pretty good PPV, and well worth a watch. With that said, let’s get to it…


Downs...

11. Green’s Big Debut Fizzles

Alexa Bliss
WWE.com

So for weeks on NXT, Chelsea Green and Robert Stone have been backing out of her big in-ring debut, claiming they want something bigger and better.

Then on Sunday, they apparently got it, as Green entered the Royal Rumble at #16… and she was tossed just seconds into her run.

If Green is supposed to be a character who has an over-inflated sense of self-worth, then this sort of thing might work, but if she’s supposed to be serious in any way, backing out of your debut a bunch and then getting treated like a geek is a pretty bad sign.


10. Injured Ankle? What Injured Ankle?

Shorty G Sheamus
WWE.com

Wrestling injuries are part of every match storyline. You pick a body part and work on it throughout the bout, and sometimes it factors into the finish. And sometimes the injury is ignored at the finish.

There are times when it’s OK to dismiss the injured body part, but then there are times when you all but yell at the TV about the lack of continuity. The Sheamus/Shorty G match falls somewhere in between.

Gable (sorry, can’t solely call him by that dumb moniker) spent a decent amount of time stomping on Sheamus’ ankle and hooked in the anklelock numerous times, attacking the Celtic Warrior’s left ankle repeatedly. But seconds later, Sheamus nailed a Brogue Kick – planting on the injured ankle with no discernible effects – for the win.

It’s not like Sheamus doesn’t have an arsenal of other moves to finish a match: White Noise, Cloverleaf, Celtic Cross. He had to use the one move that required him to put all his body weight on the bad ankle and basically ignore the damage inflicted.

This isn’t some high crime, but it’s an annoyance, and sometimes we have to acknowledge those items.


9. Santina Returns

Santina Royal Rumble
WWE.com

Every time Royal Rumble season rolls around, the rumor mill starts flying about surprise entrants.

One name that popped up that brought a sense of dread was Santino Marella. It wasn’t because the master of the unibrow wasn’t entertaining as hell during his heyday. It was because the rumor was that he might perform as his “sister,” Santina Marella – the same “woman” who hilariously won the Miss WrestleMania battle royal at WM 25.

Sure enough, Vince McMahon got his side-splitting wish to see Marella enter in drag at #29, turning the end of the Rumble – a period where things should be at their most serious and tense – into a joke as Santina had a staredown with Beth Phoenix before hitting herself with the Cobra and eliminating herself.

Normally, humor is welcome in a Rumble, as comedy spots can really add to a match if done correctly. But Santina wasn’t a very funny character who overstayed her welcome last time she was around, and simply wasn’t done correctly.


8. Wasting Morrison’s Big Return

John Morrison Brock Lesnar
WWE.com

There were several gripes with the men’s Royal Rumble, and one of the biggest had to be how they just completely jobbed out John Morrison.

Morrison returned to WWE recently, and while you’d think they’d try to bill him as a top-level star, you’d be wrong. He’s partnered back up with Miz – because 2007 is in-style again, apparently. But the Rumble was even worse.

The Shaman of Sexy entered at #5, right in the middle of Brock Lesnar’s rampage, and he made short work of the former ECW Champion, tossing him in mere seconds. No near-elimination, no flashy ringwork, no offense, no nothing.

They could have had Santino Marella make his return here and just let Morrison sit the Rumble out if this was the best they had for him.


7. An Overall Bland Rumble

Naomi Bianca Belair
WWE.com

You’ll see on the positive side, there were several “ups” about the women’s Royal Rumble match. However, it really was a bland match overall.

Think about this: two women eliminated 16 of the 29 wrestlers. Four tossed 23. No one else eliminated more than one, with Liv Morgan and Lana tossing each other, and Santina (uggh) eliminating herself. So aside from the few standouts mentioned later, not a hell of a lot happened in this Rumble.

This is the kind of Rumble that will have a couple moments replayed, but it won’t be remembered as anything special by any means. There was a ton of dead weight and several extended periods of nothing notable happening.

The best Rumbles have an ongoing story or theme throughout, or several interesting mini-matches/moments during the bout. This was lacking in that. Still, let’s reserve the right to revisit this later and re-evaluate, but after first viewing, meh.


6. Brock Smash Goes Too Long

Brock Lesnar Royal Rumble 2020
WWE.com

It wouldn’t have done any good to have Brock Lesnar come out at #1 and get tossed by #2. But having him eliminate 13 straight men like they were a bunch of 98-pound wimps was ridiculous.

The point was made after six or seven guys, and the joke was beaten into the ground once we got past #10. And yet, it went on until Drew McIntyre entered at #16, more than halfway through the Royal Rumble.

Had Drew come out at something like #11, it would have worked really well, but it just got silly going another 10 minutes. Of course, your mileage may vary. Some will really like the way it was done.


5. Wasting Two NXT Guys

Brock Lesnar Keith Lee
WWE.com

You get the feeling that the main roster writers and producers just don’t get it with NXT.

Keith Lee made a great entrance into the Royal Rumble at #13 and immediately went toe-to-toe with Brock Lesnar. For a moment, it looked like he might be the guy to get some shine and take it to the Beast.

Then Braun Strowman entered at #14, and you would think we’d get a three-way battle of the hosses. But instead, Braun and Lee fought on the ropes, and Brock tossed both of them for his final eliminations of the night. LAME.

Later on, Matt Riddle made his Rumble debut, kicked off his flops and attacked Drew McIntyre. Seconds later, everyone’s least favorite troll King Corbin tossed Riddle. Worse, Corbin was unceremoniously bounced a minute later by McIntyre. So what the hell was the point of Corbin eliminating Riddle so quickly if he was going to be sacrificed shortly thereafter.

It’s stuff like that that makes you want guys like Lee and Riddle to stay in NXT rather than be misused on the main roster.


4. Main Roster Failings

Bianca Belair
WWE.com

It says a lot about the state of the women’s rosters on Raw and SmackDown when you look at this year’s Royal Rumble figures.

There were 29 eliminations during the Rumble, with one of them (Santina Marella) eliminating “herself.” Of the remaining 28, only 10 came from main roster superstars (seven of which came from two: Alexa Bliss and Charlotte Flair). The remaining 18 were the product of NXT wrestlers, who also comprised nearly half the field of competitors.

That means the main roster women are so depleted that they could barely fill half the slots for a 30-woman Rumble, and aside from two of them, they could barely eliminate a soul.

That’s pretty damn embarrassing, quite frankly.


3. Evans, Bayley Just Don’t Click

bayley lacey evans
WWE.com

You have to appreciate how hard WWE is trying to get Lacey Evans over as a babyface challenger against dastardly heel Bayley, but man, if there ever needed to be an example of going against typecasting, this is it.

Bayley already is a failure as a heel, as she just doesn’t seem to be able to decide whether she’s a sniveling, cowering villain or a vicious mean girl. Evans is relying on people being mean to her 7-year-old daughter (who apparently is being home-schooled since she shows up at every TV match now) to get sympathy heat. That and repeatedly saluting because she used to be a Marine.

And while Lacey has a great personal story and shows flashes of talent, she’s clearly still not ready to be competing for a major title on a major show. Just because she looks like a champ doesn’t mean she should be one just yet. And the more WWE throws her out there to flail away and lose title matches, the worse it’s gonna be for her.

As for Bayley, someone needs to sit her down and work with her on what kind of heel she is. It just doesn’t seem to work.


Contributor
Contributor

Scott is a former journalist and longtime wrestling fan who was smart enough to abandon WCW during the Monday Night Wars the same time as the Radicalz. He fondly remembers watching WrestleMania III, IV, V and VI and Saturday Night's Main Event, came back to wrestling during the Attitude Era, and has been a consumer of sports entertainment since then. He's written for WhatCulture since 2014, establishing the Ups and Downs articles for WWE Raw and WWE PPVs/PLEs and composing pieces on a variety of topics.