10 Ups And 12 Downs From WWE WrestleMania 34

3. Worst Main Event Ever?

roman reigns brock lesnar
WWE.com

Let’s play a game: Count the number of different wrestling moves and how many times they were used in the Brock Lesnar/Roman Reigns match.

- F-5: 6

- Spear: 4

- German suplex: 6

- Superman Punch: 3

- Belly-to-belly overhead suplex: 2

That seriously should cover 95% of the offensive moves in this slow, plodding, dull match. There was no heart, no energy to this match, until the very end, when a bloody Roman fired up and went for a spear, only to run into a sixth F-5 for the loss.

This was an awful, awful main event. Period. If you enjoyed this, Godspeed. The shock booking of Brock retaining couldn’t save it, and in many ways, made it worse.

If anything, WWE should have gone with the rumored idea of having Lesnar hit a quick F-5, Roman kicks out, hits a few spears and pins Brock for the Universal Championship. At least doing a Goldberg-esque match would have minimized the damage and made a statement.


2. Jumping The Shark

braun strowman kid
WWE.com

When Braun Strowman brought out his “partner” Brains Strowman on Raw, this column said it was too much and just too silly for someone like Braun, ill-fitting his character.

Sunday, WWE went full “jump the shark” mode, having the Monster Among Men go from a destructive force to a smiling babyface, plucking a child from the crowd to be his tag team partner.

Keep in mind that this is the same guy who threw Curt Hawkins through a wall last week as part of the ongoing punchline. This is the guy who has tipped over an ambulance and wreaked havoc on Raw, and now he’s smiling and hugging a kid from the audience.

Uggh. Uggh. UGGH. Just totally stupid booking.


1. What The Actual Hell?

Paul Heyman Brock Lesnar
WWE.com

Cynical fans and critics have been lamenting the inevitable coronation of Roman Reigns as champion once again, as everything for the past few months has been built around delivering us the ultimate WrestleMania moment: Roman slaying the unbeatable beast Brock Lesnar to win the WWE Universal Championship.

So we got the match, with the build pointing to Roman overcoming the odds and defeating Brock to send him back to the UFC. And then Reigns kicked out of five F-5s to deliver a series of spears… only to walk into a sixth F-5 that put the bloodied Samoan down for the three count.

Did Vince McMahon get cold feet again? Did someone tell him the fans would riot if Reigns won? Did Brock threaten to shoot on Roman?

As much as many have felt that Roman is being shoved down fans’ throats against their will, the thing that pisses us off even more is this stop-and-start push that never ends. Vince decides Roman is the guy, so he beats everyone and is built up to be super-strong. Then he cools on the idea of him being a top guy, but he still has to be kept strong and central to the show. Then he heats up again and runs roughshod again.

Vince, crap or get off the pot with Reigns. Either make him the unbeatable champion at the center of your company or not. But either way, make a decision and stick with it. This incessant back-and-forth makes the animosity even worse.

Now for the ups...


Ups...

10. Bray Is Woken?

matt hardy bray wyatt
WWE.com

The Andre the Giant Memorial Battle Royal was largely a huge disappointment, basically like any other dark match battle royal, until the very end.

With Mojo Rawley and Baron Corbin teaming up on Woken Matt Hardy, the lights suddenly went out, and Bray Wyatt returned. It was his first appearance since being plunged into the Lake of Reincarnation during the Ultimate Deletion match with Hardy two weeks ago.

Suddenly, Wyatt helped Hardy win the battle royal. Afterward, the two hugged and posed together, signifying an alliance of some sort. Naturally, this raises several questions about whether Wyatt has become “woken” or reincarnated or whatever as a result of his encounter with Matt.

Whatever the case, it provides a new direction for these two after WrestleMania, and if that means Bray will finally evolve a little, so be it. For now, we’ll give it an “up” just for popping the crowd.


9. Harper, Rowan Bludgeon Way To Tag Titles

bludgeon brothers
WWE.com

Conversely to The Undertaker/John Cena match, this is an example of when a squash can be useful.

The Bludgeon Brothers have been running roughshod over the tag division for some time now, but they had two well-established teams in their path: the Usos and the New Day. They collided at WrestleMania, and Harper & Rowan didn’t even look phased.

Even with Jimmy, Jey, Kofi Kingston and Big E ganging up on the two, the Bludgeon Brothers made short work of them, tearing through all four men (five, if you count Xavier Woods) and winning the SmackDown Tag Team Championship.

It was the kind of win that makes a statement, and puts the duo on top in strong fashion. You’ve got to wonder if someone like the Authors of Pain will get called up to compete with them in the coming months.


8. Women Turn In Better Effort

becky lynch sasha banks
WWE.com

Some will disagree, but the Women’s Battle Royal offered a better showing than their male counterparts.

The biggest reason for the higher marks was the presence of alliances and some continuity throughout. Right out of the gate, the NXT women (Kairi Sane, Dakota Kai, Peyton Royce, etc.) teamed up to attack the main roster superstars and worked together. They held Sonya Deville down so Bianca Belair could hit a 450 splash on her. That teamwork gave way to the Riott Squad working together, which gave way to Sasha Banks and Bayley teaming up to toss all three women.

And then, Bayley and Sasha’s simmering rivalry boiled over when Bayley turned a handshake into an elimination. And then, just to rub it in more, Naomi revealed that she hadn’t been tossed yet and made short work of the Huggable One to claim the crown. (Although we could have dealt without that moment, as Bayley’s win would have finally showed her overcoming her naivety instead of being tossed like a goof.)

The match just had way more continuity and flow, which made it easier to follow and more enjoyable. However, there still should be some sort of prize or stakes added to it going forward, as was suggested for the Andre battle royal.


7. A Callback Entrance

charlotte flair wrestlemania 34
WWE.com

The last time WrestleMania was in the Superdome four years ago, Charlotte Flair made her debut.

Of course, no one recognized her, as she, Sasha Banks and Alexa Bliss were part of Triple H’s entourage, removing his king’s gear before he headed to the ring.

Sunday, Charlotte began her entrance by sitting on a throne, bathed in golden lights while “Also sprach Zarathustra” (her father’s original entrance music) blared. Three soldiers assisted her and removed her ring robe, much in the way that Charlotte, Sasha and Alexa helped Triple H four years ago.

It was a pretty striking visual and a really nice callback to WM XXX.


6. Rousey Unpolished, But Effective

ronda rousey stephanie mcmahon
WWE.com

For her first professional wrestling match, we’ll have to give Ronda Rousey better than passing marks.

Rousey made her in-ring debut at WrestleMania 34, teaming with Kurt Angle to take down Triple H and Stephanie McMahon. Rowdy Ronda mixed in MMA strikes, some judo takedowns and a couple wrestling moves, hitting a hurricanrana on Triple H and deadlifting him for a Samoan Drop (which Steph saved him from).

Ronda slammed Stephanie around a bit and repeatedly went for her patented armbar, finally locking it in on Hunter and then on McMahon. The second one ended the match.

As a first match, you have to consider it a success. But you also have to acknowledge that there’s a steep learning curve in wrestling, and not every match can have this level of protection. Rousey will have her work cut out for her, but she showed enough promise and has more than enough natural talent that she could be extremely successful going forward.


5. Nakamura Turns Heel

shinsuke nakamura aj styles
WWE.com

After a somewhat disappointing WWE Championship match, Shinsuke Nakamura went to present the title to champ AJ Styles and knelt in a subservient manner.

Just as this writer prepared to write a “down” about it, Nakamura delivered a low blow and proceeded to batter Styles with kicks, finally hitting a Kinshasa on the floor to lay AJ out. It was the kind of heel turn fans didn’t see coming, and it was exactly what was needed after that bout.

A respect feud is great, and it can produce great results. But Shinsuke as a villain certainly could open some interesting doors going forward.


4. IC Title Bout Gets Things Rolling

Finn Balor Seth Rollins The Miz
WWE.com

Sunday’s Intercontinental Championship triple threat match won’t go down rivaling the Ricky “The Dragon” Steamboat and “Macho Man” Randy Savage classic from WrestleMania III, but it definitely served its purpose as the opening bout of WM 34.

The match between champion The Miz, Finn Bálor and Seth Rollins was fast-paced and high-octane, which is what you want out of an opening contest. You had multiple finisher attempts, broken up by another wrestler, counters, rollups… everything you’d expect.

In the end, it was Rollins hitting curbstomps on Finn and Miz after a Coup de Grace on Miz to secure the Architect’s first IC title. We can debate whether that was the right call, but in the end, it was a pretty good match that didn’t have any down moments.


Contributor
Contributor

Scott is a former journalist and longtime wrestling fan who was smart enough to abandon WCW during the Monday Night Wars the same time as the Radicalz. He fondly remembers watching WrestleMania III, IV, V and VI and Saturday Night's Main Event, came back to wrestling during the Attitude Era, and has been a consumer of sports entertainment since then. He's written for WhatCulture since 2014, establishing the Ups and Downs articles for WWE Raw and WWE PPVs/PLEs and composing pieces on a variety of topics.