10 Ups And 12 Downs From WWE WrestleMania 34
Some great action, horrible booking punctuate Mania.
Wow, how do you rate this WrestleMania? Michael Cole said that “moments were made,” and while that’s true, not all of them were good.
If you were able to split this 'Mania in half and have the first four matches of the main card with the WWE Championship match stapled on, you’d have a pretty damn good PPV. Everything else was pedestrian (from an in-ring perspective) at best, awful at worst.
And since many WrestleManias are judged by their main events, it’s likely that WM 34 will not be remembered as highly as it could have. Brock Lesnar and Roman Reigns delivered a mechanical, video game-style match that included blood but lacked heart, and tacked on a swerve ending that made no sense whatsoever.
We found out who Braun Strowman’s partner was… and immediately wished we hadn’t. Seriously, was Michael Cole unable to compete or El Torito unavailable? Either would have been a huge upgrade over the decision we got.
However, WrestleMania did deliver huge on Ronda Rousey’s debut, and we got a few really good matches, so this year’s installment was not a total disappointment. But after racing out of the blocks at a great clip, the PPV stumbled massively in its second half. And when you’re watching a marathon of an event like a five-hour PPV (plus a two-hour kickoff show), the missteps are magnified.
So let’s find out what delivered and what got taken out with the trash.
Downs...
12. A ‘Prestigious’ Battle Royal?
Battle royals at WrestleMania are not uncommon. There was one as far back as WM 2 and again at IV. But the Andre the Giant Memorial Battle Royal, now in its fifth year, has become the ultimate kickoff show fodder.
And while that shouldn’t be a criticism – after all, a pointless battle royal on the main card would be, well, pointless – you’d think by now that WWE would figure out a way to do something to make it a little more meaningful.
Maybe offer a secondary title shot to the winner on the Raw or SmackDown after 'Mania? Or give them a chance to main event a PPV? Something, anything, to add stakes beyond the trophy. At the moment, the match itself is just time-filler, with one or two cute moments (Golden Truth’s mini-danceoff, “Delete” versus “10” chants and one other to be mentioned later).
This isn’t a huge negative, but more of a plea to look for ways to make it a positive.
11. ‘Dream Match’ Falls Short
The danger of calling something a “dream match” is that it suddenly has to live up to all the hype. If it does, then people feel relieved that it delivered. If not, people wonder what the hell happened.
AJ Styles and Shinsuke Nakamura had a solid, competitive match for the WWE Championship Sunday, but it was nowhere near the instant classic it was built up to be. The match was good, but never really clicked or fired on all cylinders.
Look at Johnny Gargano’s last two TakeOver matches for examples of contests that hit all the right notes. Hell, look at Charlotte Flair versus Asuka for a match on the 'Mania card that connected better.
Hopefully, with Nakamura turning heel afterward, the two will have a rematch that will live up to the expectations people had for a confrontation between them.
10. Jax/Bliss Match Drags On
Here’s an example of where a squash would have been acceptable.
Raw Women’s Champion Alexa Bliss had bullied Nia Jax and emotionally traumatized her, and this was Jax’s chance at revenge. She ultimately would get it, but it dragged on a bit too much. What was a 10-minute match should have been 3-4 tops. Bliss could have gouged the eyes and tried to gain an upper hand, but when Alexa kept taking over, it got a little much.
It’s not like they were running short on matches and needed to fill the time. With Jax slated to win already, she should have handled Bliss a little easier and sent her to defeat quicker. It wasn’t a horrible sin, but it definitely felt like something that could have been done better.
9. A Missed Opportunity
After all the chatter that 205 Live has become more about the wrestling, and following a 16-man tournament to crown a new Cruiserweight Champion, the lightweight division had an opportunity to showcase itself Sunday.
And while Cedric Alexander and Mustafa Ali had a perfectly serviceable TV match, they fell well short of delivering an eye-opening performance. Both men shook hands at the start of the match and acknowledged that it was WrestleMania, which raised the hope that they’d leave it all hanging in the ring.
Instead, they delivered a few highspots along with some mat-based wrestling. Again, there was nothing wrong with the match itself, but if it’s WrestleMania and you have a chance to shine in a title match – especially in a division that is defined by smaller, more agile wrestlers – then you would have expected a lot more from them.
It’s a shame, because both men are really good, especially Alexander, whose match with Kota Ibushi lit up the 2016 Cruiserweight Classic.
8. Rumble Winners Fail
You’d think with a couple dozen writers on staff that someone would have noticed that WWE had booked both Royal Rumble match winners, who both are Japanese megastars, to lose their title matches at WrestleMania.
After so much was made about Asuka winning the first women’s Royal Rumble, she went and lost her title match (and her undefeated streak). Then, Shinsuke Nakamura lost his WWE Championship bout against AJ Styles, rendering his title shot useless as well.
It’s fine in one sense, as a Rumble win doesn’t guarantee the title, but when you have two winners and both lose like that? Come on. If you weren’t going to have one of them win, then book someone else to win the Rumble.
7. 'Taker Squashes Cena
In some perverse way, The Undertaker squashing John Cena in a matter of minutes has to be gratifying for many fans out there.
But as a wrestling fan who was looking forward to seeing a contest between two of the greatest performers in the past quarter-century, this writer can’t help but be disappointed. Cena spent weeks calling out 'Taker and begging him to meet him at WrestleMania for a match. He came out to face 'Taker, and when it looked like he wasn’t going to show, he left.
Then the Deadman emerged, stalked to the ring, and pummeled Cena. A zombie situp avoided Cena’s one offensive burst (the Five Knuckle Shuffle) and then a chokeslam and tombstone piledriver ended it. Undertaker’s entrance probably lasted longer than the match itself.
So instead of a competitive, epic confrontation between two legends we got an epic entrance and return, with a glorified squash stapled onto it.
6. A Big, Wagging Middle Finger
If you were a conspiracy theorist who believes that WWE not only doesn’t listen to its fans, but actively tries to spite them, you had to look no further than the United States Championship match at WrestleMania.
Four men vied for the title: champ Randy Orton, Jinder Mahal, Bobby Roode and Rusev. With thousands of people chanting “Rusev Day,” who do you think ate the pinfall? Yep. And who won, after a distraction? Yep.
Some will argue that Jinder draws huge heel heat, so this could be a good move, and even could set Rusev up for the chase. However, we just went through this last year, with Mahal as WWE Champion, which failed to move the needle. So that argument is wrong.
The match itself was nothing special, certainly nothing we haven’t seen on TV or a B-PPV before, which also was disappointing.
5. Another Streak Bites The Dust
What an insanely stupid decision.
For nearly three years, Asuka has not been pinned or submitted. It’s a streak that rivals all others in WWE history. The company played it up repeatedly for the past several months, leaving open the question of when she’d finally lose it. Conventional wisdom said she would enjoy a lengthy reign as champion before someone dethroned her, thus elevating that person.
Instead, Asuka lost her WrestleMania debut to Charlotte Flair in a phenomenal match (more on the bout itself later). The question here is: Why? Why in the blue hell would you end the streak here, and now?
Asuka winning the title and reigning as an undefeated champion would have been a great storyline, with challengers lining up until someone finally toppled her. Charlotte, who has accomplished more than any other female in WWE in recent history, didn’t need the win per sé. Losing a hard-fought match would have been fine for her.
The other question is: What happens next for Asuka?
4. Tag Title Joke
Remember how much WWE loves to make fun of WCW for David Arquette being their world champion, or Judy Bagwell as a WCW tag champion?
Keep that in mind every time the company replays this ultimate “putting smiles on faces” WrestleMania moment of having a 10-year-old kid plucked out of the audience to win the Raw Tag Team Championship with Braun Strowman.
After weeks of making you wonder just who Braun would pick as his tag team partner to face The Bar – A perennial loser? An NXT call-up? A returning superstar? – the company didn’t just make a make a left turn, they drove the car into the ditch. Strowman wandered through the crowd and picked a kid, brought him to the ring and had him stand on the apron.
Nicholas did tag in ever so briefly, only to tag out after five seconds so Braun could finish single-handedly squashing the tag champs.
At least Judy Bagwell mixed it up a bit.