10 Ups And 14 Downs For WWE In 2015 (So Far)

5. Being Truth-ful

One of the worst things for a wrestler has to be realizing that he or she has peaked, that there is nowhere to go but down. Try as they might, but they will never reach that level again. That can very easily be said about R-Truth, whose best days are long behind him, and he€™s been reduced to €œcomic€ relief. Truth spent the early part of this year stealing and re-stealing the Intercontinental Championship from then-champ Bad News Barrett. No one thought he had a chance in the IC title ladder match at WrestleMania XXXI, and he lived up (down?) to those expectations. He had a memorable (for all the wrong reasons) moment in a match against Stardust when he opened a bag to reveal a bunch of plastic spiders. You see, Truth has a phobia of spiders, so he freaked out and was rolled up for the pin. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PS35wJJ4VPQ Oh, but it got worse. Shortly after winning the aforementioned King of the Ring tournament, Barrett lost to R-Truth, which led Truth to believe he suddenly was the new king of the WWE. He donned a bedsheet and started carrying a plunger to the ring. Truth must be entertaining someone, because it€™s not like fans are rallying around the plunger-wielding court jester.

4. Return Of The Goat

Daniel Bryan€™s latest career-threatening injury is a major downer for 2015, but it€™s his premature return to action that is drawing this criticism. Bryan had been shelved since May 2014, but he returned to action just ahead of the 2015 Royal Rumble and entered the match. It seemed like the storybook tale from 2013 was going to play out again. And then it didn€™t. WWE booked uber-fan favorite Bryan to enter the Rumble €“ in Philadelphia, no less €“ and then have him get eliminated midway through the match and have Roman Reigns win. Bryan€™s mere presence in the match was enough to overshadow everything else that happened. Unless Bryan won the Rumble, fans were going to crap all over it, and they did. Bryan then challenged Reigns for the #1 contender€™s spot at Fastlane, giving fans another glimmer of hope. That hope was then ripped away when Roman won the match. D-Bry got the consolation prize of competing in the Intercontinental Championship ladder match at WrestleMania, and while he won that bout, fans couldn€™t help but feel that it was a poor substitute for the title he never lost. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KJ3m9waPHkA Bryan€™s injury that forced him to surrender the IC title this spring was the latest chapter in a confusing and disappointing 2015 for the goat-faced warrior.

3. As The Kane Turns€ Or Doesn€™t

When Kane eventually goes into the WWE Hall of Fame, people will talk about his awe-inspiring debut, his numerous feuds and partnerships with his €œbrother,€ the Undertaker, his Team Hell No run with Daniel Bryan and his unhealthy obsession with Pete Rose. It would be best to forget the vast majority of his run as the Authority€™s Director of Operations. Despite this being a persona that has greatly diminished his standing as a monster (he€™s lost nearly 80% of his televised matches since 2014), Kane had a moment earlier this year where he looked like he was going to regain that fire€ and then it completely fizzled. With WWE World Heavyweight Champion Seth Rollins acting like a spoiled brat, Kane took exception and stood up to the champ, pointing out that he handed Rollins the Money in the Bank briefcase that allowed him to become champion. Kane threatened Rollins and attempted to leave the Authority, making it appear that he was on the verge of crusading against Rollins. Suddenly, Kane was interesting again, as fans were invested in him standing up for himself. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jQqYSeTg7pI But the Corporate Demon ultimately stayed put and still is a loyal foot soldier, still losing the vast majority of his matches. Maybe he€™ll finally turn his back on the Authority later this year, but it looks like the best opportunity has passed.

2. A Big Miz-Take

At the end of 2014, one of the best storylines going was the relationship between the Miz and Damien Sandow, who had taken months of impersonating other wrestlers and famous people and segued into becoming the Miz€™s stunt double, Damien Mizdow. Miz berated his stunt double, who€™s mirror act became so amusing that fans couldn€™t help but cheer him. The story€™s ending was as clear as day, and for once, it was something that every fan wanted to see, predictable or not: Damien grows tired of being Miz€™s whipping boy, stands up to him, beats him silly and sets out on his own. Miz finally gets his comeuppance, and Sandow cashes in on his newfound popularity. Of course, none of that happened. In a shocking display of sheer stupidity, WWE managed to swerve everyone. Mizdow stood up to Miz at WrestleMania in the battle royal, finally turning on Miz and eliminating him. Damien almost won the event, but despite losing, he had taken that first huge step in declaring his independence. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=t5yBku6MV6g But instead of setting out on his own, Mizdow battled Miz over the rights to the €œMiz brand,€ meaning that Damien was trying to own the rights to Miz€™s character instead of establishing his own. Mizdow then got double-crossed by Summer Rae (which led nowhere) and now he is impersonating Randy Savage as Macho Mandow and hasn€™t been seen on Raw or Smackdown for nearly two months. Of all the bad decisions and mistakes made this year, this one might hurt the worst, if only because this was a no-brainer of a storyline that was working, evolving naturally and was building to a logical conclusion €“ and they screwed it up.

1. Roman Wasn€™t Built In A Day

Let€™s be clear here: Roman Reigns is incredibly talented and has the ability to be a world champion. And there€™s nothing that says it can€™t be soon. But it also has to be something that fans are going to at least somewhat buy and the writers are going to commit to. Unfortunately, Reigns€™ pre-planned ascension to the top was derailed by a variety of factors. Reigns was sidelined for much of the fall of 2014 with a hernia, and his return a month before the 2015 Royal Rumble pretty much jumpstarted his rapid ascent. The entire thing felt forced on fans, as he had been out of action for nearly three months and was immediately inserted into the title picture. Worse, Daniel Bryan returned to action for the Rumble as well, which meant fans had a rooting interest. When Bryan was eliminated early on, fans turned on the match €“ and eventual winner Roman Reigns. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SRFWb4Ia3r0 The massive backlash was bad enough, but having Roman deliver promos where he uttered lines such as €œsniveling, suck-up sellout full of sufferin€™ succotash€ was even worse. Reigns then was booked to battle Bryan for the #1 contender€™s spot, which didn€™t help win over any D-Bry fans. At WrestleMania XXXI, Reigns took the pinfall when Seth Rollins cashed in his Money in the Bank briefcase in the WWE World Heavyweight Championship match. Since Mania, Reigns has been dialed way back, losing a #1 contender€™s match, a fatal fourway title match and the Money in the Bank ladder match. It€™s almost as if WWE is taking him back to formula so the company can build him back up. Hopefully WWE has learned from its missteps and doesn€™t repeat them and try to force-feed Reigns on fans. But you also have to hope fans will check their cynicism a little.

Ups...

10. Grabbing The Brass Ring (Club)

As 2014 wound down, WWE did something that turned out to be wise in retrospect: It took two under-utilized talents and paired them together as a tag team. Sometimes, this random pairing can be disastrous. Other times, it can work magnificently. In the case of Cesaro and Tyson Kidd, it definitely was the latter. The duo wasn€™t doing very much on their own and quickly became enough of a force to capture the WWE Tag Team Championships at Fastlane. They successfully defended their titles at WrestleMania before losing the straps at Extreme Rules. During that time, they became a fairly popular team on the strength of their in-ring performances, which included a lot of great tandem offense. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=goA6l8PtqV8 Although they have been out of the tag title picture for some time, the team still was a welcome part of the division until Kidd went down with a serious neck injury last month (during a match with Samoa Joe), which will keep him out of action for a year. As for Cesaro, after doing nothing of note for a bit, he stepped up and answered John Cena€™s United States Championship challenge on the last day of the first half of the year, delivering what was bordering on a match of the year. While it€™s a shame (and borderline tragedy) to see Kidd go down like this and break up the team, the silver lining has to be the possibility that Cesaro could finally get a singles push. Maybe.

9. New Life For The New Day

Similar to the team they defeated for the WWE Tag Team Championships, the New Day was directionless heading into 2015 and basically on life support. Then, the trio started doing something interesting: They got more positive. At first it was subtle, but within a few months, it became clear that New Day was taking its positive message to the hilt so that it was obvious that they were anything but sincere. This new New Day was clearly phony, and it worked. Within a short period, the group captured the tag titles, breathing new life into the team. It wasn€™t quite the Nation of Domination that had been speculated last summer, but this heel faction was entertaining and talented€ and then they lost their tag titles to the Prime Time Players last month. (As of this writing, Battleground hasn€™t taken place, so it€™s unclear if this was just a temporary diversion for the tag titles.) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xlBTowpS8gA Regardless, New Day was floundering when the year started and has managed to gain traction, so much so that they get a good reaction from fans and are a pretty entertaining part of Raw. That€™s a reason to stay positive.

8. Honoring The American Dream

The untimely death of Dusty Rhodes hit the WWE family extremely hard. The American Dream was a big part of NXT€™s growth and development, and his passing reverberated throughout the developmental territory, as well as through the main roster, where two of his sons €“ Goldust and Stardust €“ currently perform. What saved this tragedy and turned it into triumph was how WWE managed to put together various specials and tributes to Rhodes. There was the retrospective on his career and the first-hand recollections of interactions with the Dream. These pieces offered a fitting tribute to a legend in the business, and it showed WWE paying proper respect to Dusty. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9py4aMK3aIU Rhodes€™ death is terrible on many levels, but it also set the bar for how WWE should treat its legends, not just when they pass, but while they€™re here. The Network specials for the Ultimate Warrior last year were incredible as well, but why should WWE wait until it€™s too late?

7. Unhinged, But Not Forgotten

It would be very easy to list this as a €œdown€ for the first six months of the year if not for the last two months. Heading into 2015, Dean Ambrose had gone from a surprise ultra-hot face to a guy jobbing to holograms and exploding TVs and looking fairly lost in the midcard. But WWE seemingly realized that Ambrose regularly gets one of the biggest explosions from the crowd when he comes out €“ and that Roman Reigns needed to draw some good vibes from his lone BFF on the roster €“ so the Lunatic Fringe found himself thrust to the top of the card in a two-month feud with WWE World Heavyweight Champion Seth Rollins. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6EEq1ukyCFA And while Ambrose failed to capture the title and has since seen his push throttled down, the fact that WWE realized that Ambrose is capable and that fans reacted positively to it has to bode well €“ provided WWE brass was paying attention. Therein lies the challenge. Still, Ambrose getting a couple PPV main events was a welcome sight. Let€™s hope it translates into an honest storyline and push sometime soon rather than being just another guy. Call this cautiously optimistic.

6. Network Specials

Beyond the programs honoring Dusty Rhodes, WWE Network really is coming into its own with programming, giving fans more than just an extensive library of PPVs, Raw, Nitro and Saturday Night€™s Main Event to lure them. During the first half of 2015, WWE has aired three wrestling specials, in addition to its periodic NXT: Takeover events €“ King of the Ring, Elimination Chamber and Beast in the East. These WWE specials were met with various degrees of success, but each has its charm and is an indication that WWE is planning to use the Network more often to entice fans to purchase the subscription-based service. While KOTR was a hastily convened, one-hour program, it basically tested the waters for two future Network exclusives: Elimination Chamber and Beast in the East. The Chamber was a last-minute PPV, a Sunday house show turned into a full-blown major event, bringing back a well-known gimmick match that has been bypassed earlier this year. Likewise, Beast in the East was a Tokyo house show that featured a Brock Lesnar squash and an NXT Championship match. (Although it took place after the June 30 deadline for this column, it was announced in June and matches were known then too.) Both showed what the Network can be for WWE: an opportunity for fans to catch some exclusive, quality, in-ring action. It will be interesting to see if WWE will toss out a few more of these types of events as 2015 rolls on.

Contributor
Contributor

Scott is a former journalist and longtime wrestling fan who was smart enough to abandon WCW during the Monday Night Wars the same time as the Radicalz. He fondly remembers watching WrestleMania III, IV, V and VI and Saturday Night's Main Event, came back to wrestling during the Attitude Era, and has been a consumer of sports entertainment since then. He's written for WhatCulture since 2014, establishing the Ups and Downs articles for WWE Raw and WWE PPVs/PLEs and composing pieces on a variety of topics.