10 Ups And 14 Downs For WWE In 2015 (So Far)

Great highs on the horizon, but rough roads ahead.

So, how is WWE World Heavyweight Champion Roman Reigns doing fending off challengers? Is Intercontinental Champion Daniel Bryan tearing up the midcard? What about the company€™s prestigious 2015 King of the Ring King Barrett? If looking back at the first six months of 2015 has taught wrestling fans anything, it€™s that plans rarely turn out exactly how you envision them. When WWE entered 2015, Roman Reigns was the heir apparent, a man who would win the Royal Rumble right off the bat and presumably build up to a heroic conquering of the Beast, Brock Lesnar, at WrestleMania XXXI to capture the WWE World Heavyweight Championship. But that and several other plans have been tossed aside as the first half of the year has worn on, whether due to injuries, fan reaction or just the whims of those in charge. Not all of these changes have been bad, but this year so far has been a pretty disappointing one on multiple fronts. Conversely, there are some things that have happened in 2015 that should give WWE fans reason to rejoice, much of which stems from a glimpse of the future. It has to be not unlike 1996 when you had relatively new WWF superstars Steve Austin, Hunter Hearst Helmsley, The Rock and Mankind hanging out just a step (or two) below established stars Bret Hart, Shawn Michaels and the Undertaker. There are some exciting things on the horizon for WWE. With all of that said, let€™s take a collective look back at the first half of 2015 in WWE. While some context is provided from last year and some storylines have advanced in the two-plus weeks since June 30, this list attempts to stay within those first six months of the year. So let€™s find out what spiked the ratings and what tanked viewership. Let€™s get to it€


Downs...

14. Tag Team Injuries

This is one item that is beyond WWE€™s control, but that doesn€™t make it any less frustrating or detrimental to the product. On paper, WWE should have a vibrant tag team division, with numerous duos vying for the WWE Tag Team Championships. In reality, however, some of the company€™s most viable teams have been shelved due to injuries. The biggest blow came at WrestleMania XXXI this spring when Jey Uso dislocated his shoulder, knocking WWE€™s best tag team out of action for about six months. The Usos held tag team gold for much of 2014 and had been the backbone of the division. More recently, Tyson Kidd went down with a serious neck injury, disbanding his partnership with Cesaro. The former tag champs weren€™t in the title picture at the time, but they were a reliable duo that could always carry a solid match. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UbEUGA8q6nU The injury bug also hit Erick Rowan, who had just reunited with Luke Harper and looked to be building up as a bruising team, complete with a new tandem finisher, The Way (the Dudley Boys€™ 3D).

13. A Royal Dud

When WWE reinstated the King of the Ring tournament this spring, longtime fans couldn€™t be blamed if they were optimistic. After all, the tournament helped launch superstars such as Kurt Angle, Edge, Brock Lesnar and Billy Gunn (whoops!) to the next level. Recent attempts had flopped (Sheamus, William Regal), but if WWE did this right, it could provide a platform for a wrestler. By now, we all know that the KOTR tournament has served one purpose: to allow R-Truth to dress like a court jester and pretend he€™s the king because he defeated the tournament winner, King Barrett. The former Bad News Barrett has gotten zero mileage out of winning King of the Ring, and it€™s doubtful that WWE is suddenly going to have him go on a royal winning tear. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b7OkJFg5qyA It really is a shame to see that the King of the Ring tournament, which could have been a perfect annual WWE Network exclusive, is being played solely for comedy. There€™s always a slight chance WWE wakes up and changes course, but don€™t hold your breath.

12. For The Low, Low Price Of€ Free!

If you managed to hold off on ordering the WWE Network for WrestleMania, you have had ample opportunities to sample the company€™s on-demand system. The proverbial basket that WWE put all its eggs into has been offered as a free trial every month since then (April through July). Without checking, it€™s safe to say there has to be a way to use different e-mail addresses and accounts to get multiple free months. WWE also has seemingly given up on any kind of a long-term commitment, allowing people to subscribe for a month, cancel and then renew later. You have to imagine if the Network was doing well with subscriptions, they wouldn€™t be offering free months repeatedly, just encouraging people to sign up and not miss must-see action. WWE reported 1.3 million subscribers at the end of March, but it hasn€™t been determined yet if all the free months have led to an uptick in viewership. If it hasn€™t, then what next?

11. Fall Of The Soviet Empire

When 2015 began, Rusev and Lana were in the midst of a reign of terror over the WWE midcard. The Bulgarian Brute had defeated everyone a step below the main event and was poised to make a splash at a higher level. Obviously, Rusev was going to have to lose a match at some point, but what has transpired during the first half of 2015 has not been something to remember. After defeating John Cena to defend the United States Championship at WWE Fastlane, Rusev went on to lose three straight PPV matches to Cena, including the title at WrestleMania XXXI. He also lost Lana as his valet (to Dolph Ziggler) and injured his foot, putting him on the shelf for more than a month. He€™s gone from an unstoppable foreign monster to a forlorn man pining for one blonde (Lana) while he has another (Summer Rae) on his arm. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xGNfvg4yHFM As for Lana, she had been portrayed as a smart, beautiful, villainous woman who once stood toe-to-toe with the Rock on the mic. Suddenly, she has turned into a smiling sidekick to Ziggler, kissing Dolph, accompanying him to ringside and little else. She can hopefully reclaim her status as a leading lady in WWE with some smart writing in the second half. Being Ziggler€™s arm candy can€™t be her ceiling.

10. Imitation Is Not The Sincerest Form Of Flattery

Every once in a while, WWE seems to stumble upon gold and is able to turn it into something totally priceless. Other times, they trip over a gem and manage to muddy it up. That€™s what has happened with Curtis Axel and Damien Sandow, better known today as Axelmania and Macho Mandow. Sandow€™s story is well-known and will be recounted later, as he finally broke free of the Miz but still thinks that impersonating others is the way to go. WWE had an opportunity to make a star out of that angle and blew it big time. Axel, by comparison, was the hapless guy who was attacked coming down the entrance ramp at the Royal Rumble and never technically entered the match. That didn€™t stop him from claiming that he had the all-time record for longest Rumble and should be going to WrestleMania. He started chanting Axelmania, and fans actually responded. For the first time in eons, Axel was somewhat interesting. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DHsuWP7q-mQ But instead of building off of that, WWE chose to have Axel become delusional and start aping Hulk Hogan€™s act, right down to the mustache and shirt-ripping gimmick. Sandow then took on Savage€™s persona, giving us the Mega Powers 2.0. It€™s not funny, not entertaining and is doing absolutely nothing to help either man, as they haven€™t had a match on Raw or Smackdown in nearly two months.

9. Tough To Watch

WWE€™s latest incarnation of Tough Enough just got started last month and still has plenty of programming to go, and while more episodes have aired, this list is only considering stuff that happened before July 1. That would mean the first two episodes of Tough Enough qualify. The weird hybrid style of the show €“ large parts are recorded, but the judging portion is live €“ is disjointed and doesn€™t work. The judges €“ Hulk Hogan, Daniel Bryan and Paige €“ apparently only see what we see on TV, which is vastly different than every other incarnation, where the trainers are the judges. As far as we know, trainers Billy Gunn, Booker T and Lita have no input in who the bottom performers are. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I-B_qKpxSWc Then there€™s the host. Chris Jericho is awesome at almost everything he does. And he does his best in this situation, but unlike €œStone Cold€ Steve Austin before him, Jericho is only there to keep the show on track, not to confront the contestants or grill them about the business. One of the best parts about the 2011 edition of Tough Enough was Austin tearing into the contestants. Lastly, leaving the voting solely to the fans via Twitter is a kiss of death. Watch ZZ make it to the finals because fans find him €œfunny.€

8. AJ Lee Retires

The Divas division has been one of the true low points in WWE this year, and one big contributing factor has to be having its most popular member depart suddenly. AJ Lee€™s early April retirement meant that one of the most interesting, dynamic and capable female performers on the roster was gone, leaving a void that hasn€™t been filled since. AJ on top of the division meant energetic, entertaining promos and competent matches. Whether she was influenced by her husband or just naturally had the same spark, AJ wasn€™t afraid to speak her mind, dropping the infamous €œPipe Bombshell€ on Raw and calling out Stephanie McMahon on Twitter. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QoYYRRGND6Q In her defense, AJ had accomplished everything she possibly could in WWE: three-time Divas champ, former GM and a major focus of WWE programming. There really wasn€™t much left for her to do other than collect title reigns and put on solid matches with upcoming NXT women like Charlotte and Sasha Banks.

7. Randy Orton€™s Stop/Start Routine

If the first half of the year is any indication, 2015 is not going to be the Year of Orton. In fact, Randy Orton has spent almost as much time away from WWE television as he has on it. Orton was written out of storylines in November 2014 and didn€™t return until WWE Fastlane, missing January and most of February. He battled the Authority and defeated Seth Rollins at WrestleMania XXXI, but he lost title matches at Extreme Rules and Payback and failed to capture the Money in the Bank briefcase. Orton disappeared after Payback for two weeks and again after MITB, only returning last week. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tsbvZd0UG2Y These gaps, which amount to about 11 of the first 26 weeks of the year, prevent Orton from gaining traction. He might be slotted in top matches when he€™s around, but you get the feeling Orton isn€™t factoring into WWE€™s long-term plans, just filling in as a top guy. It would be nice to see a long-term story arc involving the Viper€ and hopefully not a four-month feud with Sheamus.

6. Bella Twins€™ Inexplicable Dominance

For every comment that Nikki Bella has vastly improved her ringwork, there should be a follow-up question: Is Nikki better than Natalya? Paige? Naomi? Most of the NXT women€™s roster? That€™s not meant to demean Nikki. It€™s great that she takes more pride in her performance, but it€™s not like she€™s become one of the better wrestlers on the roster. She€™s just become more passable. But the real problem here is how the Bellas have been booked, switching almost weekly between faces and heels. If they had been consistently booked as heels, then Nikki€™s reign would be a little more bearable. Instead, the twins€™ act seems to be more about keeping them at the top of the division rather than building convincing characters for fans to get invested in. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VQ2NF3asSaY What we have is a Divas€™ champ and her sister who fans don€™t know week to week whether they should boo or cheer. This also doesn€™t help their opponents, and thus the entire division suffers.

Contributor
Contributor

Scott is a former journalist and longtime wrestling fan who was smart enough to abandon WCW during the Monday Night Wars the same time as the Radicalz. He fondly remembers watching WrestleMania III, IV, V and VI and Saturday Night's Main Event, came back to wrestling during the Attitude Era, and has been a consumer of sports entertainment since then. He's written for WhatCulture since 2014, establishing the Ups and Downs articles for WWE Raw and WWE PPVs/PLEs and composing pieces on a variety of topics.