10 Ways AEW Has Revolutionised Pro Wrestling
The fuse for change.
All Elite Wrestling isn't a perfect professional wrestling company.
The win/loss rankings hold up to scrutiny, but this is mostly from an estimate, and perhaps generously so. The definition of a "quality" win is hazy, and that it is limited to a top five doesn't necessarily tell us what we haven't learned by paying attention to the top programmes. It's a nice visual reminder that puts over the otherwise elusive "league" aspect we were promised in the original TNT press release. It's limited to the presentation of the company; wrestling is wrestling and grudges and trash-talk will always drive it, but AEW could and perhaps should use the win/loss rankings as a narrative device. A traceable dip in form might compel a desperate, fading wrestler to turn heel, for instance. That real sports feel is missing, not that there isn't enough to differentiate AEW as a real alternative.
The Women's division continues to not warrant the Elite descriptor. The lack of focus is most damning; limited to one segment a week, most weeks, it's incredibly difficult for an act to build momentum. There's an almost patronising your-turn quality to it confounded by a further stop/start issue brought on by scheduling of the talent's diaries.
It is not, however, far away, through restoration as much as revolution...
10. Reinventing The Style Of TV Wrestling
TV wrestling in WWE is, through in-house policy and its schedule, often pedestrian, formulaic fare.
There's a about a million road agents working from the same style guide; the format is repetitive, the action withheld most often to account for the bloated schedule. It's a necessary measure to preserve the bodies of the roster, but while pragmatism and morality is nice, it does not satiate banger lust. NXT is the outlier to this, obviously - the best matches on Wednesday are exhilarating, outstanding - but even then, the style is regulated. There are more tropes than genres.
In AEW, MJF works a very overt, old-school heel style, defiantly so; he is less interested in the back-and-forth than drawing the closest approximation of old school heat. The Lucha Brothers have incorporated a style of lucha so authentic that it repels some for not adhering to Americanised referee counts. In the TV match of the year, Kenny Omega and PAC deftly adapted the long, main event puro epic to American TV by abandoning the slow-build and integrating familiar US heat spots. There's a sense of fun that pervades the midcard, too, creating a sense of levity not seen on TV in forever.
Irony, comedy, bangers, trios: AEW has expanded the language of TV wrestling, and in 2020 in particular, has transcended it.
9. Episodic Storytelling
AEW books storylines in such a way that avoids the incessant need for physical interaction through telling honest-to-goodness pro wrestling stories.
This is a marked and welcome departure to the post-match brawl, the endless rematches, the tacked-on stipulation sequels. So often, the match graphic supersedes the story. Conflict emerges. The match is made.
Then what?
Trash-talk. Brawls. Tropes, like contract signings, pull-aparts. And that is about it; there is no theme to the story, no absorbing, episodic quality. Matches breed matches, more matches, often twice in the very same week.
Per the parameters of the storyline, MJF and Cody touched just once before the famous lashing segment: at Full Gear, when MJF first turned. Beyond that, Wardlow - one of several ancillary characters in AEW, bodyguards, managers, stable heavies - put the beating on Cody. Those ancillary characters, banished by the big-time over the years, serve a distinct, dramatic purpose: they delay and enrich the big fight.
The Elite, bar the shoving and one #1 contendership four-way match, only truly exploded at the same event, Revolution, the tensions behind which were so fraught precisely because the internal desire to lash out was suppressed on television as part of a storyline in which the mutual sportsmanship became untenable.
Chris Jericho tends to get more physical in his programmes - he's a bully with a stable, and so it's in-character for him to weaken his opponents - but can tell a fantastic story with beats and dialogue that compels the public to pay for it.
8. The Clean Wins Only Policy
Where, as outlined in the introduction, the revolution narrative is closer to restoration, AEW's enforcement of a clean wins-only policy is genuinely radical for a mainstream North American promotion. It shouldn't be, but it is.
Fans haven't reacted earnestly to babyfaces and heels in decades. Interference no longer feels like a grave transgression; it's a hollow plot device with which to prolong a feud or "protect" a performer, the speech markers of course denoting irony. What once deprived fans of hope now deprives them of meaning. Nothing matters; it's all pretext to the next thing that doesn't matter to enable and sustain the churn.
Chris Jericho will humiliate himself to get a babyface over. He allowed Jake Hager to cradle him in his arms, like a comically deceased leading lady, and he was still a legitimate World Champion because the Inner Circle beatdown inevitably followed the clean win.
These were dual triumphs; Jericho remained a serious proposition, and his stable resonated as nasty for the sake of it d*ckheads. Darby Allin isn't "protected". He isn't a talent that AEW might one day do something with; he's a talent they definitely will do something with, but his story must be paved with the resolve and spirit that got him over, not the contrivance that keeps him ticking along into mundane nothingness. There's a gravity to AEW's overarching narrative policy. It isn't hazy, manipulative, and it doesn't result in a single tier that bleeds into itself.
Wins and losses don't just impact the rankings.
7. The Youth Movement
MJF is 23 years old. Jungle Boy is 22. Marq Quen is 25. Isiah Kassidy is 22. Darby Allin is 27. Marko Stunt is 23. Warts and all, each have brought a fresh, totally motivated energy badly lacking in mainstream pro wrestling.
AEW's youth movement is a risk that has manifested in as much failure as success - the prodigious Jungle Boy improves weekly, while Private Party are in their awkward adolescent phase - and the lighter schedule is not conducive to talent development. But AEW talents are encouraged to supplement their experience on the independent circuit - which, incidentally, is an honourable mention because AEW are not actively destroying it - and it's far preferable to the WWE way.
WWE typically signs talent near or in their prime years, benches or actually uses them in NXT, and then, when they're ready to make real money, they are overexposed to the most attentive audience and, through the rotting mechanisms of the main roster, are not effectively promoted to more casual fans. There's no real arc to experience, no journey to reward fan investment. It is a bloated roster of prime, name acts bleeding into itself to chronically normal effect.
In the perfect outcome, AEW fans will watch Jungle Boy mature into his next form, in the years to come, intensely, emotionally bonded to his journey.
6. The Old Guard
Vince McMahon doesn't like to present old people on television.
He has to, at times, because he struggles to create new stars under 40, but their age isn't emphasised. The opposite is true; the Undertaker dyes his hair, Goldberg is presented as invulnerable, and the stars of the retro reunion shows are eerily preserved in amber, grotesquely reduced to their old aesthetic and often, a single catchphrase. The amusing irony, given WWE's woes in attracting young fans, is that Vince does this under the belief that it would age his product and render it unfashionable.
AEW has no such concerns, welcoming a horde of ageing, legendary figures to further draw its personality as a pro wrestling company. Jim Ross, warts and all, is an authoritative, wise presence; Arn Anderson likewise is a beloved, he-talks-you-f*cking-listen figure; Tony Schiavone is wholesome, avuncular nostalgia; Dustin Rhodes is so respected and sympathetic that he is the perfect, grizzled babyface with which to get heels over; Jake Roberts, as sinister as all hell, exudes badass vibes just by surviving his experience.
It's effective and quite touching, on a per-individual basis, and it's also very savvy; AEW has a vibrant atmosphere around it, because the product is less than a year old, but the old guard collectively lend it a certain, rooted gravitas.
5. Advanced Equality
There used to be a prerequisite for making it in North American mainstream pro wrestling. A wrestler had to have the correct body, the correct look, the correct persona - "correct" being a byword for "mandated".
This does not apply in AEW.
Nyla Rose is a history-making transgender performer who plays the hoss role excellently when in opposition to smaller, gutsy athletes who know exactly how to sell for her raw power. It shouldn't be, but promoting her so openly and with such conviction marks a real paradigm shift.
Marko Stunt is an anti-mainstream performer getting over in a rapidly-shifting mainstream. He is tiny, but has adapted his style so that he relies on his teammates to execute his offence, nimbly filling the psychological gap. Ditto Orange Cassidy, whose ironic, wholly unique ring style, alien to the mainstream, has seen him become one of its fastest-rising stars. Several pushed, profiled performers are not native English speakers (Fénix, Pentagon Jr., Riho). Their work transcends mandated overly verbose scripts, rendering them useless, as if they ever served one.
Traditional body types and antiquated notions of realism - inherently farcical, given the essence and very definition of pro wrestling - no longer apply.
4. The Listening Company
WWE does not listen to its fans.
This a blanket criticism, one substantiated to the point of parody. The harsh reality however is that WWE does listen - Goldberg is far superior a ratings draw relative to The Fiend, which explains the booking of Super ShowDown - but nowhere near enough. Daniel Bryan's journey to superstardom made for a compelling narrative, but only in retrospect. Fans vocally rejected Roman Reigns, for years, the span of which saw WWE's viewership gradually erode by half. Vince McMahon continues to persist with the positioning of King Corbin, when all ratings data indicates he should not, because Vince McMahon likes him. Similar mistakes were made by a TNA rampant with nepotism when it once held a tentative footing in the market.
AEW listens. This is revolutionary for an industry monopolised by the unilateral whims of Vince McMahon.
The Nightmare Collective was a nepotistic, amateurish stable incongruous to AEW's presentation. The experiment on principle was not bad - it's necessary, in a controlled and staid wider landscape - but it failed, miserably, and so it was sh*t-canned.
Too many Dynamite matches went too long, exposing green talent, and to the detriment of promos, vignettes and world-building. AEW refined its TV formula to incorporate all of that, in 2020, resulting in the sensational top-to-bottom Revolution build.
They listened. They listened also to a decades-long plea of...
3. Creative Freedom
The odd complaint has surfaced - talk of handcuffs coming out, etc. - but tellingly, those talents aren't on television.
The inference is that those who got over were permitted to get over using their own creative agency. Darby Allin is a true maximise-your-minutes performer who needs all of 30 seconds to get over as a unique and compelling personality and build his programmes with his own haunting, black-and-white short films, the eerie tone of which artfully conveys the level of danger his opponents imminently face. Sammy Guevara's vlogging is used to facilitate comedy spots; Hangman Page gets over even with his own banter title graphics, in a fantastic touch; the EVPs, obviously, are in control of their own storylines, which after some not insignificant flaws have now incorporated Being The Elite's excellent episodic quality into the traditional, serious TV context.
The promos are penned by the those who cut them, not a hack ex-TV writer, allowing Chris Jericho and MJF to get over huge as piss-funny d*ckheads, Cody as an articulate, impassioned pure babyface, Britt Baker as a wonderfully aloof "role model".
AEW insisted, over and over, that it was a wrestling promotion run by wrestlers, and they recognise and encourage the independence of the contractors.
2. LEGITIMATE Competition
AEW's original TV deal with TNT was already the best secured by a non-WWE company since the death of WCW.
TNT paid Dynamite's costs and allocated a split of the advertisement revenue to AEW, and this was evident in the presentation; the pyro and glamorous production values gave the show that elusive and vital big-time feel missing from the alternative in decades, elevating it, at least visually, to the realm of competition.
Dave Meltzer reported that the goal was to secure from TNT a rights fee in a renewed deal to ensure profitability, and Wrestling Twitter whispers persisted that the illusion of the aesthetic belied AEW's financial position, which was more precarious than it first appeared. AEW were comprehensively outbid for top target Marty Scurll, substantiating the idea that continued success in the key demo was pivotal to the company's long-term success.
And then TNT renegotiated the deal in January, and paid AEW a substantial rights fee, which seemed to accelerate the company's fortunes. Buoyed by the news, Dynamite hit a critically-acclaimed stride in 2020 as everything fell rapidly, thrillingly, into place. Action figure deals were finalised. Promoted free agent signings are imminent; more are heavily rumoured to follow. Eyes emojis respond to every request for a video game. Attendances remain strong; pay-per-views are selling out or are all but selling out.
This is as real as pro wrestling gets: AEW is legitimate mainstream competition, pacing itself through the marathon with a self-sustaining stamina.
1. Getting Stipulations Over
Stipulations meant nothing in mainstream pro wrestling for a long, long time.
Through excess and diminished aura, the Hell In A Cell match has lost its prestige. There is an inorganic quality to its scheduling, and the modern version pales to the - yes - blood and guts of yore. The Steel Cage match is a logic-devoid ratings grab. WWE continues to excel at Ladder matches, but they are no longer the star vehicle that saw Shawn Michaels, Edge and Jeff Hardy literally ascend to stardom. Generally, the gimmick match is obligatory. The build is rarely organic; it's just something WWE does, whether it aligns with the intensity of or interest in a programme, when the singles match has already happened. It's a hollow if not unexciting ratings facilitator booked by a calendar.
The next time AEW promotes a Lights Out match, it will be anticipated with a certain, uneasy dread. Jon Moxley Vs. Kenny Omega was a pulsating, frightening spectacle - all the more impressive, given how much more of it was worked than met the eye - so much so that the stip, initially received as a strange, antiquated territory throwback, now feels genuinely dangerous, as a violent pro wrestling match should.
AEW taught WWE a lesson with its first-ever Steel Cage match, which got over huge in one night. It was built as a match Cody had to survive, not wrestle, and was worked as if there were no escape from the challenge. He had to fight, smart and hard, and climbed only to take the ultimate risk.
No escape, no cowardice, no bullsh*t - all meaning.