10 Ways WWE Booked CM Punk’s Career All Wrong

If they hadn't screwed it up, he'd still be there.

As 2014 comes to a close, this will mark the first full calendar year that is in the post-CM Punk era of World Wrestling Entertainment. Much has already been said regarding the gamut of emotions fans have regarding this occurrence, so in order to possibly take a look at the post-Punk saga in a refreshed light, let's consider ten ways that WWE creative botched the career of the "Straight Edge Superstar." Punk's no longer on television, so. let's consider ways in which WWE could've presented Punk in a light that would've allowed for him to not become frustrated with his (and the company's) direction and forced his hand in leaving. CM Punk was easily one of the most intriguing WWE superstars on multiple levels during his eight-year run. As an in-ring performer he was a dependably entertaining and absolutely bankable main eventer. As a media personality he was highly engaging and a modern icon on-the-rise for WWE, a progressive man for a progressive age. However, there were key moments that WWE missed out on that could have added to Punk's marketability both in and out of the ring, that a) would've kept him on the roster and b) in an era where WWE's marketing plans have so drastically changed, allowed them to enhance a likely cornerstone of those initiatives.

10. CM Punk Should've Eliminated Batista At The 2014 Royal Rumble

Let's be honest here. Even if anyone knew how awesome Dave Batista's acting performance was going to be in Guardians of the Galaxy, there's still absolutely no reason why he needed to win the Royal Rumble and main event Wrestlemania in a three-way dance with Daniel Bryan and Randy Orton. Instead, what could've been a more intriguing storyline (that would've played well in the media) is if Punk had eliminated Batista, then dropped a "pipe bomb" on him the next night on Raw, and challenged him to a match at Wrestlemania. Punk using the actual logic of "why should this guy just get to come back and main event Wrestlemania" would be intriguing. Also, possibly getting an in-ring promo with Vince McMahon, Paul Heyman and CM Punk with Vince recreating his role from the Attitude Era (with Heyman as a pompous legal advocate for WWE claiming that Punk potentially put WWE "in breach of contract" by eliminating Batista) would've been fun. A storyline allowing Punk to play "babyface Steve Austin" is something that WWE could've banked on in 2014, and in everything from assisting Dean Ambrose to filling a spot on the card that would've involved that ill-fated feud Chris Jericho had with Bray Wyatt, setting Punk up for a major main-event run could've been accomplished with Batista's elimination.

9. CM Punk Should've Defeated Johnny Nitro For The ECW Championship At Vengeance 2007

Who knows if one of the key factors in Chris Benoit's demise was the idea that he was going to be defeated by CM Punk for the ECW Championship in the finals of the tournament for the vacated championship on June 24, 2007. At the show that Benoit "no showed," the then-(ubeknownst to anyone) deceased wrestler's replacement was Johnny Nitro, who won the championship. This set off a series of matches in which Punk himself was not exactly proud, matches that did not need to occur. Punk being able to have intriguing matches with veteran WWE performers in ECW like Kane, The Big Show and Mark Henry could've made for compelling television.

8. Kevin Nash Didn't Need To "Stick The Winner"

In August 2011, CM Punk returned to WWE after having engaged in the "Summer of Punk" storyline that involved him leaving from Chicago's Money In The Bank Pay-Per-View with the WWE Championship and without a WWE contract. Punk and "interim" champion John Cena fought to determine one "true" WWE Champion and after Punk won, he received a jack knife powerbomb from Kevin Nash, allowing Money in the Bank briefcase holder Alberto del Rio to cash in said briefcase and win the WWE Championship. In a promo the following evening on Raw, Nash claimed that Triple H told him to "stick the winner" of the WWE Championship match. Of course, Punk uncorked one of the finest promos of his career on Nash, which led to Nash challenging Punk to a match, a match where Nash was replaced by Triple H at 2011's WWE Night of Champions. The fact that the CM Punk/Kevin Nash feud ended with Triple H biting the bullet himself and faces Kevin Nash in a "Sledgehammers and Ladders" match at TLC 2011 says everything. Punk making Nash look old and irrelevant in a storyline (that was utterly nonsensical) was ultimately a waste of CM Punk's time and energy, and didn't need to occur.

7. CM Punk & The Straight Edge Society Vs. John Cena & The Rock At Wrestlemania 27 Should've Happened

The Undertaker's No Holds Barred match versus Triple H should've main evented Wrestlemania 27 (and Hell in a Cell between the two with Shawn Michaels shoud've main evented Wrestlemania 28). Of course, as a semi main event, John Cena calling on The Rock to assist him in fending off the then likely-unstoppable Straight Edge Society would've made sense. Punk terrorizing WWE during all of 2010, and say - after losing Serena, Joey Mercury and Luke Gallows from the group and being traded to Raw - recruiting The Big Show as his Straight Edge Society partner-in-crime after spouting straight edge propaganda as an announcer on Raw for a few months as a commentator. The Big Show and Punk taunting Cena, and maybe causing him to lose his WWE Championship to The Miz (causing the feud to escalate into high gear) would've been cool. Then, Cena calling on the one man he knew who was more charismatic, engaging and worth following than CM Punk to team with him at Wrestlemania would've made for great television.

6. Why Was CM Punk The Leader Of The Nexus?

After losing control of the Straight Edge Society, when CM Punk was traded to Raw in October, by December he was the head of a reformed Nexus. The point of reforming the Nexus ultimately was to create the heat to kick-start the feud between Punk and Orton that led into their match at Wrestlemania 28. In 2014 terms the fact that CM Punk, Bray Wyatt, Curtis Axel, Mason Ryan and David Otunga were at one time in the same stable is entertaining, in 2010/2011, that really wasn't very entertaining at all. Insofar as a way for the gaining in cool Punk to remain a devious heel, Punk attempting to force Justin Gabriel and Heath Slater to beat each other with kendo sticks (after Wade Barrett was exiled to Smackdown and leading The Corre) it made sense. But anything that wasn't the Straight Edge Society or CM Punk being in The Miz's main event position in 2011 actually feels in retrospect like a complete waste of time.

5. CM Punk Never Ate A CM Punk Ice Cream Bar On Monday Night Raw

Sure, after the initial 2011 "pipe bomb" promo, we were treated to CM Punk wearing a tee shirt that portrayed him on an ice cream bar, but, wow. WWE really missed out on a huge branding opportunity by NOT having CM Punk himself walk out on Raw when he returned to the show after a week hiatus eating his own ice cream bar (maybe even throwing a few more from a box into the crowd), wearing the WWE Championship, and generally looking pleased with himself. Yes, CM Punk was a merchandise-selling machine for WWE.Punk ice-cream bars being thrown out by Punk at televised events (while WWE worked to find a retail producer and distributor) would've been awesome. Think CM Punk Ice Cream Bars (along with other old school wrestlers, too) wouldn't have sold for a year or two? It's entirely possible that they could have done just that. Insofar as finding a brand that already has an ice cream contract within a set percentage of arenas that would handle production of a "WWE Ice Cream Bar" property, it's entirely possible that multiple corporations would fight for that contract. A case of money being left on the table for certain.

4. CM Punk Deserved To Lose The World Heavyweight Championship In The Ring In 2008

CM Punk was assaulted by The Legacy at Unforgiven 2008, allowing Chris Jericho the opportunity to enter the Scramble Match and become the World Heavyweight Champion. In being punted in the head by Randy Orton, Punk's meteoric rise to popularity was stunted, and the underdog babyface (that Punk then was) had to live to fight a few more days on his eventual road to championship glory. In being one of the moments when WWE didn't quite understand the unsinkable nature of Punk's rise to fame, keeping him removed from the main event picture did more harm than good. Had Punk entered said match, and maybe lost to soon-to-be top heel Jericho, the ability for the two to possibly engage in a big money feud would've existed. Of course, Punk and Jericho would tangle four years later in 2012, but a 2008 payoff match to a great feud certainly could've been something special, too.

3. CM Punk Didn't Wrestle Colt Cabana For The WWE Championship At An Indy Wrestling Event

OK. On July 23, 2011, CM Punk showed up at an All American Wrestling event in Berwyn, Illinois. It's an absolute shame that Monday Night Raw on July 25, 2011 didn't open with CM Punk wrestling Colt Cabana for the WWE Championship at that event. Punk's "pipebomb" promo involved Punk stating that he'd take the WWE Championship to his one-time home Ring of Honor, where his buddy (and ex-WWE employee) Colt Cabana worked. The idea of Punk saying that he wanted to do something with Colt Cabana "that WWE was too stupid to do" and offer his buddy Cabana a shot at the WWE Championship in front of 200 people in a VFW hall would've been amazing. Currently, WWE's entire talent development gameplan involves plundering independent promotions not-so dissimilar to AAW. Possibly setting up a friendly relationship with the independent ranks in 2011 could've accelerated the wild shift of the landscape in WWE's developmental-to-TV ranks in 2014.

2. CM Punk Deserved To Defeat The Rock

OK. The fact that CM Punk never defeated The Rock is unfortunate. Though he was at the time the WWE Champion, Punk was used by WWE as a warm-up heel for The Rock before wrestling John Cena, ostensibly making Punk little more than Jake "The Snake" Roberts warming up a big name heel before wrestling Hulk Hogan in the 1980s. No disrespect to the WWE Hall of Famer, but CM Punk was the longest-reigning WWE Champion of the modern era, and slotting him as a solid number two player behind John Cena seems a bit absurd. Being champion for sixteen months means that you're something of a draw and a presence. Maybe Punk pinning The Rock (but The Shield attacking "The People's Champ" before the match to weaken him) would have been an easier way to book the match while at the same time maintaining a significant amount of CM Punk's credibility. The fact that CM Punk lost twice to The Rock and once to John Cena and still maintained enough interest in himself to make him a top-notch opponent for The Undertaker is impressive. If Punk had a victory over John Cena too, he'd have been much more impressive in the role of challenging The Undertaker's streak, too.

1. CM Punk Should've Ended The Undertaker's Streak

OK. There was a perfect storm that could've created the perfect story that would've allowed WWE the chance to defeat (and retire) The Undertaker at Wrestlemania 29 versus CM Punk. However, in ending "The Streak" one year later with Brock Lesnar, WWE may now be in the situation where they've had to take too much creative license with their storytelling (while also potentially damaging a box office draw in the process) in order to do what could've naturally been done with CM Punk at Wrestlemania 29. In the midst of the telling of the Punk/Undertaker story, Paul Bearer passed away. "Bearer's ashes" in an urn were then at-play in the storyline, and when CM Punk dumped Paul Bearer's ashes on The Undertaker, it was such a visceral and powerful moment that had The Undertaker lost, it's entirely possible that people would've been surprised, but not to the level that 'taker being beaten by a part-timer in Brock Lesnar who hadn't actively been a WWE participant in six months beating him caused. Pairing Punk's heat with real-life drama could've made The Undertaker's loss at Wrestlemania a lot easier to handle. Mabe even having Lesnar wrestle Punk at Wrestlemania as a "new Undertaker" type of character would've been exciting. This leading to the possibility of Punk wrestling the ACTUAL *new Undertaker* in Bray Wyatt in San Francsico at Wrestlemania 32 would've been highly compelling for certain.

Contributor
Contributor

Besides having been an independent professional wrestling manager for a decade, Marcus Dowling is a Washington, DC-based writer who has contributed to a plethora of online and print magazines and newspapers writing about music and popular culture over the past 15 years.