10 Ways WWE Rebuilt NXT In 2017

A Spot Of D.I.Y

Johnny Gargano Tommaso Ciampa
WWE Network

Under-appreciated at the time, the San Antonio and Orlando TakeOver NXT Title matches between Bobby Roode and Shinsuke Nakamura were a masterclass in nuanced pro wrestling storytelling of old.

San Antonio saw Nakamura's bombast undone by Roode's less-than-'Glorious' guile and a title change most assumed further down the line. 'The King Of Strong Style' recklessly met his end against the wily veteran. By the time Orlando arrived, 'The King Of Strong Style's imminent WWE call-up should have sapped the bout of tension. Instead, a wiser challenger tried not to expose his previously wounded body part to the champion. Only in attempting a match-winning Kinshasa did he drop the pretence - and eventually the match - allowing Roode a inch-wide route to glory that he fortuitously followed.

Roode's stewardship was as short-lived as his predecessors - he lasted only two TakeOvers with the title before dropping the gold en route to a post-SummerSlam SmackDown Live! reunion with the rechristened 'Artist'. Signs of NXT's accelerated exit velocity since the 2016 Brand Extension, both landed on the main roster within a year of their developmental debuts in comparison with the teeth-gnashing tenures of Bayley, Finn Bálor and Samoa Joe before them.

No longer afforded robust roster reassurances, NXT was forced to creatively rethink the model that had crafted a golden age from 2014, lest 2017 become the worst year for the brand so far. Its success further confirmed the solid foundation underneath the developmental that disastrously remains absent from its bigger brother's bright lights.

10. Unstoppable

Asuka NXT Takeover Brooklyn
WWE

Resisting an understandable temptation to insist she say wrestling's time-honoured farewell before making crossing the void to the main roster, the company stared into the eyes of Asuka's incredible undefeated streak and thankfully didn't blink.

Her dominance at the start of the year was such that any defeat would have been charitable to a fault, but feuds with Nikki Cross and Ember Moon pushed the 'Empress Of Tomorrow' to her limits in intriguing new ways, even after she'd seemingly played and won the numbers game in multi-woman matches on Takeovers and television.

A Falls Count Anywhere clash with the SAnitY lunatic was amongst Full Sail's finest moments in 2017 thanks to the Champion unlocking her frenzied side against her equally ferocious foe. Cross had never cowered from the imposing titleholder in the preceding months, and literally threw herself into what would prove to be her only solo crack at the prize.

Asuka's TakeOver: Orlando foul was perhaps what afforded Ember Moon two shots - the Champion avoided Moon's devastating Eclipse finisher via nefarious means in their April meeting. Ember still couldn't beat her on her very best day, and TakeOver: Brooklyn 3 was most definitely that...


9. Steady As She Goes

Ember Moon NXT War Games
WWE

...but she was able to ascend the second 'The Empress Of Tomorrow' disappeared.

The NXT Women's Title may be the most prestigious prize underneath the WWE umbrella. A quick look at its lineage (and it's pleasingly quick) ranks it alongside New Japan Pro Wrestling's IWGP Heavyweight Title in terms of quantity and quality of reigns. Like the historic Japanese prize, the NXT strap has only changed hands six times since 2013. In much the same way the likes of AJ Styles and Kazuchika Okada were afforded lengthy reigns with the prize, the six women trusted with the honour of the holding gold on the developmental brand were arguably the best in their entire field as they did so.

Following victory in a pleasing TakeOver: WarGames Fatal Four Way, Ember Moon became the latest to join NXT's most elite club, and looks set to remain on top in the short-term at least following the sudden ascension of half her rivals to the main roster as part of Absolution and The Riott Squad.

The big singles contest NXT currently has to offer is unquestionably a battle between Moon and Mae Young Classic winner Kairi Sane, but the prior treatment of the title suggests this will be saved at very least for the TakeOver due the night before WrestleMania 34.


8. British Invasion

Mark Andrews Pete Dunne
WWE

There's often a backhanded swipe concealed in the praise often heaped upon NXT's product. In crediting Triple H as the driving force behind such a creatively satisfying product, fans draw a comparison to main roster calamities still shepherded by Vince McMahon.

It's unfair (and potentially untrue) to suggest McMahon won't have any interest in the goings on at Full Sail University, but its likely that he's got a closer eye on that than he does his UK Championship.

Looking every bit the billionaire's latest abandoned toy, the buzz from January's two-night tournament had diminished by summer thanks to a thoughtless lack of follow-up, and a set of tepid tapings from Norwich couldn't halt the concept's decline. Fortunately, nobody seemed to tell the talent.

NXT's penultimate episode of 2017 hosted a Pete Dunne/Tyler Bate match almost as good as their TakeOver: Chicago match-of-the-year candidate, whilst tag and singles matches scattered throughout the year featuring Dunne, Bate, Trent Seven, Mark Andrews et al usually stole whichever show fortunate enough to house them.

If the worst case scenario for the title (and entire league) in 2018 is a rotating spot on the developmental brand, early evidence at least suggests the whole project won't have been a complete waste of time and resources.


7. Surprise Surprise

Velveteen Dream Aleister Black
WWE.com

In 2015, the WWE Network presented Breaking Ground as an exclusive behind-the-scenes look at the life of an aspiring superstar as they navigated through NXT's parochial grind and the Performance Center's rigorous routines.

The series still provided insight into the competitive drive instilled in the talent even on the lowest rungs. It highlighted how the TakeOver events weren't just necessary storyline checkpoints in the model of WWE's monthly supershow system, but in fact crucial motivational tools in ensuring talent don't become complacent big fish in the company's tiniest pond.

Then-Women's Champion Bayley and soon-to-be-called-up Tyler Breeze both spoke of the importance of making every TakeOver show somehow or another, and what a slight it was to be overlooked. With the talent revolving door spinning faster than ever in 2017, anticipation dwindled for the events until the select recipients utilised the premium exposure to make themselves the new talking points.

Peyton Royce, Billie Kay, Nikki Cross and Ruby Riot exhibited individual excellence in multi-woman matches with Asuka on the shows, whilst Andrade 'Cien' Almas' down-and-up year on the cards exquisitely represented the character's chequered journey to the top.

Aleister Black remains the most obvious candidate to dethrone the Mexican Champion, but he too required the star-making night he experienced alongside Patrick Clark's Velveteen Dream persona during November's WarGames match. If either man ever receives their own Network Documentary treatment, it will be that incredible encounter dwelled upon as the night they took their biggest steps to superstardom.


6. Mixing Up The Mains

Authors of Pain, Johnny Gargano, Tomasso Ciampa
WWE.com

In keeping with the preservation of TakeOver as the company's most protected enterprise, card formats this year were experimented with in order to place greater importance on the matches with the most emotional heft. Such logic is long lost on a main roster allergic to the tiniest of changes, but every shift elevated the beneficiaries without remotely burying the allegedly relegated parties.

TakeOver: Chicago was one of the year's most underrated cards almost entirely because of this. Hideo Itami was something of a lost cause by May, but had value enough to enter a short programme with Bobby Roode for the NXT Title. Still a brand where talent makes titles rather than the other way around, their match was the semi-main to the rip-snorting blowoff ladder match between the Authors Of Pain and #DIY that came in-built with a devastating post-match twist.

Asuka and Ember Moon's semi-main spot at TakeOver: Brooklyn 3 mirrored the placement afforded to Sasha Banks/Bayley and Bayley/Asuka in 2015 and 2016 respectively, and lived up to the lofty standards set by both. And TakeOver: WarGames couldn't not be headlined by its eponymous stipulation, but the layout keenly favoured Andrade 'Cien' Almas' low key yet memorable heel title win.


5. Auteurs Of Pain

authors of pain nxt
WWE Network

If any magic still exists in the art of a professional wrestling match today, its in the ability to harness any form of disbelief suspension over more than just a move-trading finisher sprint or the command for a 'This Is Awesome' chant you could set your watch to.

Alongside the agents of their major matches through to their opponents and even Paul Ellering stationed ringside, The Authors Of Pain deserve tremendous credit for making their killer unit one of the few to generate that perfect response.

It was only a year ago that a clunky Dusty Rhodes Tag Team Classic finale victory had worrying echoes of WWE's every-monster-gets-a-push philosophy, but their initially unwelcome interruption in #DIY's transcendent rivalry with The Revival shortly afterwards triggered one of the most satisfying runs for any act this year.

Bully heels when they lifted the titles from Tommaso Ciampa and Johnny Gargano at TakeOver: San Antonio, the pair looked believably unstoppable in a series of fabulous defences until coming up against SAnitY in a chaotically underrated brawl at August's TakeOver: Brooklyn 3. Spirited and short on cliches, the war was a coming-of-age moment for Akam and Rezar even in defeat. Defacto babyfaces in the exhilarating WarGames revival, the pair have taken the most organic route to anti-heroism and ironically now represent yet another new frontier for developmental doubles.


4. Latin Lover

Zelina Vega Andrade Cien Almas
WWE.com

Andrade 'Cien' Almas hero-to-zero and back again story probably wasn't one the company had in mind to tell when he debuted in a mishandled victory over Tye Dillinger at June 2016's TakeOver: The End, but the former 'La Sombra's losing streak following a creative acknowledgment of his first failed run was a typically astute reimagining of the talented former CMLL Universal Champion.

Almas was still examining the lights as late as April this year, with his loss to the debuting Aleister Black infamously inspiring ignorance from the uncharacteristically uninterested TakeOver: Orlando crowd. Perhaps the bulk of the audience's distraction with a "We Are Awesome/Shut The F*ck Up" chant duel helped them forget his fate that night, but his August return to the TakeOver rotation was immune to eradication.

His spectacular Brooklyn 3 opener with Johnny Gargano was an electric back-and-forth battle anchored by 'Johnny Wrestling's still-broken heart (more on that later) and Almas' new sidekick Zelina Vega's willingness to pounce on the weakness.

Indeed, the addition of Vega to Almas' act was the kayfabe and real-life turning point for Andrade after oh so many setbacks. Imbibing him with much needed confidence and the excuse to steal the early wins that would reverse his curse, 'Cien's stock exponentially to the point where his TakeOver: WarGames NXT Title victory was more plausible shock than unpleasant surprise.


3. Twists And Turns

Adam Cole NXT TakeOVer
WWE.com

When John Cena was shuffled into a front row seat for the NXT Title Ladder Match between Neville and Bo Dallas in February 2014, the intention was to manufacture an implied sense of importance in the developmental brand's first live main event.

In the end, the match spoke for itself, but the company persisted with the 'stars-in-the-crowd' trope as an intriguing way to pepper shows with an exciting potential vision of future talents soon to debut. It became an alternative to traditional methods of introducing talents, but in rapid time became just as formulaic.

The growing stoicism to the device was partly what made Adam Cole's TakeOver: Brooklyn 3 debut so scintillating. Joining Kyle O'Reilly and Bobby Fish in a post-match assault on new NXT Champion Drew McIntyre after the duo had already laid waist to new Tag Champions SAnitY earlier in the night, Cole skipped the pleasantries to aggressively insert himself at the top of the card in shocking cliffhanger conclusion.

It was the second time NXT had gone out on such a shock this year, and was almost as effective as a similarly brutal assault that took place at the climax of TakeOver: Chicago. Almost...


2. The Greatest Story Ever Told?

Ciampa, Gargano
WWE.com

Tommaso Ciampa and Johnny Gargano were little more than a makeshift unit when they debuted together on NXT in a Dusty Rhodes Tag Team Classic 2015 first round clash, but within two years the eventually-christened #DIY had improved, inspired and imploded. It was a uniquely transparent arc audiences were included on throughout, but every peak and valley came still came served with a side of surprise.

As a doubles act, their pair came into their own midway through 2016 as the landscape-shifting rivalry between American Alpha and The Revival reached its apex. Victory over Scott Dawson and Dash Wilder just before they became NXT's first ever two-time Tag Team Champions at Jordan and Gable's expense earned them a title shot at TakeOver: Brooklyn 2. They'd lose a breathless encounter, but their seated unity that night matched the same tortured embrace they'd share after fighting each other in the 2016 Cruiserweight Classic. Then, Gargano was the better man, but a targeted assault on his knee had cost them the belts in Brooklyn. On both occasions, Ciampa's dejection simmered but didn't boil over.

It virtually disappeared at the climax of TakeOver: Toronto's last chance title shot and the 2016 WWE/NXT match of the year. Dethroning Dash and Dawson in gloriously dramatic fashion, there was little need for further concern until the pair lost the belts to The Authors Of Pain at January's San Antonio supershow, and subsequent rematches in both Chicago and as part of 2017's finest contest in an Orlando triple threat with the fearsome titleholders and The Revival.

The once-tempered fire in Ciampa's eyes engulfed him as set their union ablaze. He snapped on the heartbreakingly sympathetic Gargano in grisly fashion following their Chi-town defeat. Injury has since prevented further conflict, but the distress simply won't dissipate. Tommaso symbolically sat alongside his decimated former partner during the Chicago sh*t-kicking, whilst Gargano awkwardly shuffled away from a #DIY t-shirt tossed at him by Zelina Vega in August. Costing him defeat that night as a reminder of all he'd suffered and what he'd lost, the cursed apparel had had the team's final resting place adorned on it all along. 'Do It Yourself - Nobody Will Do It For You'.

Like the Steve Austin/Bret Hart rivalry it mirrors in transcendence, it has been one unapologetic stunner after another.


1. Keep On Keeping On

Drew McIntyre
WWE.com

The choppiest waters NXT ever has to navigate through are not waves generated by the brand's own tumult. The winds of change that blow through WWE's main roster with scatty regularity are at a moment's notice prone to do damage to the Orlando group, but the brand bosses are card-sharp enough to have five aces up their sleeves at all times.

Just tracking the journey of the NXT Title over the past few years paints the neatest picture of how durable the brand remains. Kevin Owens' last act as an NXT star was losing conclusively to new Champion Finn Bálor, who in turn proudly carried the gold until his abdication several months later to Samoa Joe. From Joe leaving for Raw to Shinsuke Nakamura and Bobby Roode departing for SmackDown Live! up to and possibly including Drew McIntyre at TakeOver: Brooklyn 3, the belt itself has been the final step towards main roster prominence exactly as it should be.

Drew's own loss at TakeOver: WarGames was extenuated by the injury he suffered late on, but his time in Full Sail was perhaps destined to be short regardless. Adam Cole and Aleister Black seem earmarked for TakeOver topliners, as the reshuffled main event scene finally takes shape. Its to NXT's eternal credit that new avenues such as these are so consistently discovered.


In this post: 
NXT DIY
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.