10 Worst Booked WWE Champions Of 2020
In which WWE Creative turns its pots of gold into crocks of s**t.
Championships in WWE used to mean something. Mick Foley capped off the seminal Have A Nice Day with his first WWF Championship victory, Chris Jericho talked about staring at the belt in stupefied wonder in Undisputed, and in Hitman: My Real Life in the Cartoon World of Wrestling, Bret Hart movingly describes a broken down Dynamite Kid clutching the Tag Team Championship to his chest, having sacrificed his health for the respect the belt represented. Granted, nobody should consider Dynamite Kid a role model, but it still feels like something has been lost with how little titles in WWE mean nowadays.
This year alone has seen a slew of poorly booked championship runs that have done nothing for either the belt or the wrestler holding it. Winning one of the company's top prizes should be a milestone in any wrestler's career but WWE Creative has turned gold into lead all too often, its lacklustre booking dragging the company's champions down instead of elevating them.
To misbook one championship reign may be regarded as a misfortune. To misbook ten looks like WWE are trying to produce their own version of Springtime for Hitler.
10. The Street Profits (WWE RAW Tag Team Championship)
By the time the Street Profits swapped their RAW Tag Team championships for the SmackDown straps following the brand split, they'd held on to the belts for an impressive 223 days.
Unfortunately, that's the only thing about their reign that was impressive.
Things started off badly when they needed outside assistance from Kevin Owens in two successive matches to win and defend the belts, despite being babyfaces. After defending the straps at WrestleMania (cleanly this time) the Profits were handily beaten by the Viking Raiders which led to the utterly bizarre "Anything You Can Do, We Can Do Better" series (or, to give it another title, "A Series of Ridiculous Events").
What could have been a fun one-off skit was stretched way past its shelf life as the two teams spent more than a month competing in events such as basketball, bowling, axe-throwing... in short, anything except actually wrestling each other. This had the unfortunate side effect of making the Profits look like cowards, as it gave the impression they were happy to face the Raiders everywhere except in the ring after having their asses handed to them in the pairs' prior match.
The Profits would eventually get their win back, but by then the damage had been done. The Profits' RAW reign never really took off, but since switching to SmackDown, WWE have done a good job making the pair look strong and ready to find the smoke again.
9. Cesaro & Shinsuke Nakamura (WWE SmackDown Tag Team Championship)
It's no secret that Cesaro and Nakamura have never reached their full potential on the main roster. Whenever the pair have gotten within touching distance of one of Vince McMahon's fabled brass rings, WWE Creative yank it further into the distance like a dollar tied to a piece of string. That pattern continued with their aborted run as SmackDown tag champs.
After dethroning the New Day at Extreme Rules, the Kings of Swiss Style (sorry) proceeded to do... not much of anything, really. The most memorable moments in their reign were breaking up with former Artist Collective member Sami Zayn (whose run as Intercontinental Champion has been a genuine bright spot in WWE programming), and challenging the Street Profits to a champion vs. champion bout.
The latter occasion showed exactly where the Kings of Swing (again, sorry) ranked in WWE's priorities. Despite Cesaro rightly calling the Profits out for their lack of championship defences, WWE missed the chance to have the Profits lose and start a storyline where they regained their focus and came back strong, whilst simultaneously giving Cesaro and Nakamura a much-needed rub. Instead, the Profits won cleanly and C 'n' N (last one, we promise) finished their jobs as belt warmers by dropping the titles back to the New Day on a regular episode of SmackDown.
8. Alexa Bliss And Nikki Cross (WWE Women's Tag Team Championships)
Bliss and Cross made a strong start to their championship reign, dethroning the Kabuki Warriors at WrestleMania and defeating them again on SmackDown. Bliss made grand claims in the weeks that followed about raising the profile of the belts and bringing the women's tag division to prominence in WWE.
One look at the above image should tell you how that worked out.
Bliss and Cross' reign suffered from the same problems that have plagued the women's tag division from day one - a lack of believable challengers (Carmella & Dana Brooke? Really?) and the belts themselves being used as props to further whatever story WWE is telling at the time, rather than meaningful prizes in their own right. In Bliss and Cross' case, this meant their reign being brought to a premature end at the hands of the Golden Role Models as part of Sasha and Bayley's ongoing storyline (which would culminate in Bayley turning on Sasha after the duo lost the belts to Shayna Baszler and Nia Jax).
With the belts now very much in the background in favour of Nia throwing Lana through tables as part of the world's most bizarre push, the Women's Tag Team Championships remain the company's most vestigial titles.
7. Breezango (NXT Tag Team Championship)
Poor Breezango. Tyler Breeze and Fandango have spent a combined twenty four years in WWE (14 for Fandango, 10 for Breeze), and this August they finally won their first title. To clarify, that doesn't mean their first title as a tag team - we mean it's the first time either of the pair have held gold in their entire WWE careers.
There was so much history to be discussed here - video packages detailing the trials and tribulations each has faced in their WWE tenure. How Fandango went from being an overnight sensation to an afterthought in the first half of 2013, how Tyler Breeze was left for dead in 2016 for the apparently unpardonable sin of leaving a SmackDown taping early, and how the pair have struggled and clawed their way back to relevance in the years since.
But that wasn't to be. Instead, less than two months into their reign Breezango dropped the belts in an attempt to put heat on Pat McAfee's newly formed stable. Not only was this disappointing, it was entirely unnecessary - McAfee is such an excellent heel his stable does not need the belts to get heat, at least at this stage in its lifespan. It would have meant so much more if NXT had taken the time to build Breezango up as great champions before switching the belts to McAfee and friends, but WWE hot-shotted the titles on a regular episode of NXT.
(As an aside, remember when the NXT Tag Titles were the talk of the industry and had enough clout to main event a PPV? How the mighty have fallen...)
6. Randy Orton (WWE Championship)
"What was the point in that?!"
That was the reaction held by many a WWE viewer when Drew McIntyre avenged his Hell in a Cell loss to Randy Orton on RAW, ending the Legend Killer's title run a mere three weeks after it started. Not exactly a reign of terror, more like a drizzle of piss from WWE's ever-flaccid booking committee.
We love Drew McIntyre, and his match with Roman Reigns at Survivor Series was an absolute belter, but Randy Orton deserved better than a three-week fling with the title. He was the best heel in the company during the summer, outshining even the great work done by Sasha and Bayley as his revived "Legend Killer" gimmick visibly re-energised and re-motivated the Viper into putting on his best performances in years.
WWE should have capitalised on Randy's momentum by giving him the belt at SummerSlam and then booked Drew to go over him at Hell in a Cell. Switching the title on RAW smacked of WWE realising they had booked themselves into a corner over the Reigns/McIntyre match at Survivor Series, and the end result was Randy getting his legs cut off during one of his best-ever years.
It's not often we feel sorry for Randy Orton, but such is the state of WWE Creative these days - even the golden geese are getting their wings plucked.
5. Apollo Crews (WWE United States Championship)
Back in June, Apollo stated in an interview with TalkSport that his character hadn't exactly connected with the fans. "There's no reason for them to really like me," was his stunningly honest admission of how poorly he'd been booked during his time in WWE.
Unfortunately, five months and one US Title run later, little has changed.
Apollo's time as US Champion was blighted by his feud with the Hurt Business. Losing to the 47 year old MVP in a non-title match didn't exactly do Apollo any favours, but the most baffling bit of booking was still to come. MVP used this victory to proclaim himself the real champion, and debuted a new design for the United States Championship. After Apollo got his win back (following a Covid-enforced absence), he then chose to keep the belt his nemesis created over the original championship.
This made no sense. Why would you keep the belt your enemy made? Sting didn't keep the nWo spray paint on the WCW title, and Vince McMahon didn't carry on with Steve Austin's smoking skull belt when the latter was dethroned as champion.
Apollo legitimizing MVP's redesign of the belt made him look foolish, and submitting to Bobby Lashley twice in a row to end his feud with the Hurt Business made him look weak. Small wonder Apollo has been lost in the shuffle since then.
4. The Fiend/Bray Wyatt (WWE Universal Championship)
We're not sure what the worst thing about The Fiend's time as Universal Champion was: the way he lost the belt or that he ever held it in the first place.
Let's discuss the second point first. This writer is a big fan of Bray Wyatt's "children's entertainer possessed by a malevolent clown demon" character, and the fact that Wyatt got such a ridiculous persona over to the extent he did is testament to his storytelling skills. Unfortunately, the powers that be at WWE couldn't leave well enough alone and decided to fast-track The Fiend to the Universal Championship.
This made no sense - The Fiend is (apparently) the supernatural embodiment of the bitterness and rage felt by Bray over his ultimately disappointing first run in McMahon's company. Going after the belt was a totally unnecessary diversion for the character and one that transformed him from the most unique wrestler in the business into a generic title-chasing heel, albeit one with a penchant for mood lighting and aggressive chiropractic care.
Taking the belt off Wyatt was undoubtedly the right call but the way WWE went about it left much to be desired. Booked to face Goldberg at Super Showdown, Goldberg channeled 2010-era Cena and convinced WWE to have him overcome the Fiend to send the kids home happy (because that worked out so well for the Nexus). The match stunk out the joint, with Goldberg squashing the previously invincible Fiend in three minutes because that's all Goldberg is capable of these days (or any day, for that matter).
Speaking of pointless reigns that ended badly...
3. Rhea Ripley (NXT Women's Championship)
Eight months on, we're still not sure what Rhea Ripley's NXT title run was supposed to accomplish.
When Rhea dethroned the seemingly insurmountable Shayna Baszler, the crowd (remember those?) were electric, blowing the roof off the arena in celebration of Ripley's accomplishment. Anyone watching would have thought WWE had found the next superstar to carry NXT's stellar women's division through 2020. Three months later, that superstar was left whimpering in the ring after tapping out in the biggest match of her career.
It cannot be overstated just how badly this hurt Rhea's momentum. The badass Nightmare was reduced to a weepy mess on the Grandest Stage of Them All, her aura shattered as months of character development went swirling down the drain. This wasn't like Ripley's recent loss to Io Shirai (arguably WWE's best champion of 2020), where the Nightmare looked like an absolute warrior even in defeat. Ripley's loss to Charlotte left her looking hopelessly out of her depth, another NXT call-up who couldn't handle the big time as McMahon continued his bizarre fetish for burying the black and gold brand at any given opportunity.
Unfortunately, Charlotte's subsequent title reign didn't exactly justify Rhea's WrestleMania sacrifice...
2. Charlotte (NXT Women's Championship)
Charlotte Flair was given an impossible job when WWE booked her as NXT champion.
With NXT taking a weekly hammering from AEW, Vince McMahon saw Charlotte as the weapon that could turn the tide in the ratings war. Unfortunately, that proved to be too tall an order for the Horsewoman as Tony Kahn's upstart promotion continued trouncing the black and yellow brand during her time as champ.
To be clear, the blame for Charlotte's failure to increase NXT's ratings lies solely at the feet of WWE's head honchos, not Charlotte herself. Firstly, due to the way modern WWE builds (or hasn't built) stars, there is no one star big enough to single-handedly reverse NXT's fortunes. Even Roman Reigns alone couldn't provide the necessary boost - he'd need another star on the level of McIntyre or Orton to come with him for NXT to have a shot at toppling AEW.
Secondly, if WWE intended Charlotte to be a special attraction for NXT they shot themselves in the foot by regularly booking her to appear on RAW and SmackDown on top of her NXT appearances. Why would anyone tune in to watch NXT for their Charlotte fix when they had already seen her on RAW, and would likely see her again on SmackDown? Not to mention the fact that Charlotte's moonlighting turned the fanbase against her and made the NXT title look like nothing more than a prop she dragged along with her while continuing her business on the main roster.
The way Charlotte dropped the title - "losing" a triple threat match when Io Shirai pinned the hapless Rhea Ripley - simply enforced the notion that Charlotte was a cut above the NXT roster, and that the NXT title had always been beneath her. A champion should always elevate the belt, but WWE's booking of Charlotte did the exact opposite.
1. Asuka (WWE RAW Women's Championship)
If there's ever been a sign that the roomful of monkeys that is WWE Creative needs culling, it's that they've managed to screw up the title reign of one of 2020's most over performers twice.
Asuka's first stint with the RAW belt started well, with her tearful embrace of Becky Lynch and celebrations with Kairi Sane providing some of the best feel-good moments of the year. Unfortunately, those feelings dissipated whenever Asuka stepped into the ring as her undoubted talent ran up against WWE's maddening booking. Her two matches against Nia Jax were decided by a double count-out and a fast-count, and successive non-title losses against Charlotte made the Empress look every bit the paper champion.
Frankly, the ridiculous manner in which Asuka lost the belt to Sasha was only fitting given how WWE had contrived to make her look like a joke at every turn during her reign. (Yes, we know she eventually beat Charlotte but the moment was spoiled by the commentary repeatedly hammering home that Charlotte was carrying an injury. Can't have people thinking your babyface champion can win in a fair fight, right Vince?)
Asuka's strong SummerSlam performance made it look like she'd turned a corner, but since winning the belt she's been lost in the shuffle. Left off two of the past four PPVs and without a credible challenger to sink her teeth into, the RAW Women's Champion has taken a back seat to the feud between Nia "No Vax" Jax and Lana, of all people. It is beyond frustrating that WWE keeps shining the spotlight on two of its lesser talents when Asuka and Shayna Baszler have been sharing the ring together during this interminable story, and hopefully WWE salvage something from this mess and give Asuka's reign the feud it deserves with a brutal, epic war against the Queen of Spades.
*Sigh*. Who are we kidding? Get ready for Lana vs. Nia Jax at WrestleMania 37, folks!