10 Worst Ever Wrestling Retirements

Don't call it a comeback.

matt hardy
WWE.com

Wrestling retirements are so rarely definitive, which may be why WWE chose not to overtly promote The Undertaker's WrestleMania 33 exit as such in the weeks leading up to his blockbuster clash with Roman Reigns.

Though the two were incapable of an iconic match to send the legendary performer home to Death Valley, both 'The Big Dog' and 'The Deadman' created an sizeable aura around themselves in the closing stretch of the show-closing encounter that seemed to signpost Undertaker's ultimate farewell.

Symbolically leaving his hat, coat and gloves behind to signify the goodbye, the message was loud and clear at the conclusion (if not during the performance), and the spectacle may be enhanced in the generations to come should Undertaker not decide to re-lace his boots for future WrestleMania paydays.

The return from retirement is a well-worn sales pitch in the wrestling industry, but it's just one of the tropes that harms what should be a hugely evocative plot point in the lifespan of a performer or character.

Like most stipulations, the consequence has been used and abused, which often creates little interest in a potentially career-threatening bout.

Picking through farce, falsehoods and fails, here are the 10 worst wrestling retirements.

10. Goldberg (WCW Sin)

Lex Luger Goldberg Buff Bagwell
WWE Network

In WCW's insane latter days, the concept of a stipulation being adhered to was unthinkable, but of all the possible angles to see full fruition, Bill Goldberg's storyline retirement actually stuck for real.

After a catastrophic heel turn and idiotic worked shoot babyface turn in the summer months of 2000, Goldberg became the sworn enemy of token villain authority figure Vince Russo.

Russo issued an ultimatum to big Bill - Lose, and you're gone. Challenging him to replicate his famed undefeated streak from less than two years ago when he was the biggest star in the industry, the lesser of two Vinces stumbled into a good idea for a change.

Goldberg was winning again and winning well, with a slim chance his aura may return as 2001 approached.

Then he lost to Buff Bagwell and Lex Luger and was forced out of the company forever.

The underwhelming end came during a lousy tag team match at January 2001's Sin pay-per-view, pitting the 'Totally Buffed' muscle-heads against Goldberg and his WCW 'Power Plant' trainer Sarge DeWayne Bruce.

Maced in the face by a planted fan, Goldberg was hammered with a steel chair by Lex before Bagwell hit his Blockbuster from Luger's shoulders for the victory.

In real life, Bill needed shoulder surgery, but before he could return, WCW folded. It ended up his actual WCW swansong.


9. Mick Foley (WWE No Way Out 2000)

Cactus Jack Triple H No Way Out 2000 Hell in a Cell
WWE.com

It would be sacrilegious to criticise the incredible Hell in a Cell match between Triple H and Cactus Jack, but the failure to honour a heavy consequence was almost as offensive.

Taking place at February 2000's No Way Out, the match was delicately placed before that year's WrestleMania following a gruelling street fight won by 'The Game' at January's Royal Rumble pay-per-view.

Foley promised to retire if he couldn't win the WWE Title, with the match sold on his one final reach for the fabled WrestleMania main event.

With the two brawling atop the cage with a flaming barbed wire 2x4, the finish eventually came when Foley plunged through the cage roof into the ring, crumpling in a heap in a collapsed portion of the ring.

Bidding emotional farewell to the crowd following his defeat, Foley shot the audience one last look before disappearing through the curtain dreams in tatters as the show went off the air.

Just weeks later, he strolled back through the same curtain and into the main event of WrestleMania after all, joining forces with Linda McMahon as part of the 'McMahon in every corner' main event. The evocative No Way Out conclusion had been for nought.


8. Matt Hardy (WWE Raw)

Lita Matt Hardy
wwe.com

WWE's message was loud and clear as defeat to Edge in an exciting ladder match forced Matt Hardy to leave Monday Night Raw for beleaguered B-show Smackdown following their emotional 2005 rivalry.

Despite 'The Rated-R Superstar' stealing his girlfriend in real life, then dismantling him in their first encounter at Summerslam two months prior, Matt was still unable to gain the conclusive and consequential victory over his hated foe.

The matches had followed Matt's public real-life firing from the company earlier in the year, as WWE showed little sympathy for the wronged party after he exposed Edge and Lita's nefarious romance on his personal website.

In real terms, the situation had accelerated Edge's ascent as a heel more than many thought possible, with crowds having a very real reason to despise the up-and-comer for the first time since his laboured 2004 turn.

This spelled disaster for Matt, who was made to look incompetent at every stage of the rivalry right to the last. The bad guys won, and won and won.

Trapped in the ropes by his former fiancee, he was forced to watch as Edge claimed his 'Money in the Bank' briefcase hanging from the ceiling, banishing Hardy from their lives and into Smackdown midcard obscurity.


7. Ric Flair (WCW Nitro)

Vince Russo Ric Flair David Flair
WWE Network

One of the ugliest on-screen moments of Vince Russo's detestable reign as WCW head writer came in the summer of 2000 when his character was to strip Ric Flair of his dignity and his career at the same time.

Having won a match with his career on the line the night before, Flair took the ex-WWE writer to task for the hateful abduction of his son David during an early segment on that evening's edition of Monday Nitro.

As things so often did under Russo's pen, it escalated rather quickly into an impromptu handicap retirement hair vs hair match between Vince, David and Ric.

Flair's family (including a young Charlotte and the late Reid) sat ringside, which only added to the uncomfortable scenes when 'The Nature Boy' was beaten down in a four-minute match that concluded when his oldest daughter Megan threw in the towel as Russo pathetically smashed him in the head with a miniature Statue of Liberty ornament.

With Reid, Megan, Ashley (Charlotte) and even his wife Beth held back by Russo goons, the pair shaved Flair bald as he lay unconscious and banished from WCW. They then turned on Reid, shaving his head too until Ric could recover.

It was a deeply uncomfortable moment that was typically undersold. The show moved immediately on to the next match, stifling the intense emotion of the heartbreaking scene.


6. Terry Funk (WrestleFest - 50 Years Of Funk 1997)

Funk Hart
WWE.com

Barry Blaustein's excellent 1999 'Beyond the Mat' documentary focused a sizeable portion on Terry Funk and the then-53-year old veteran's decision to retire in a match against highly respected WWE Champion Bret Hart at a show paying tribute to both Terry and brother Dory as well as father Dory Snr.

So revered was Funk within the industry that the September 1997 Amarillo show featured a host of performers from both WWE and ECW, often working against one another despite the heated 'Monday Night Wars' drawing lines in the sand between numerous talents at the time.

His main event match against 'The Hitman' was a poor effort from both, with much attention stolen by referee and documentary cult favourite Dennis Stamp after he threw a tantrum with his supposed best friend Terry about not being booked on the show.

It would be enough to consider it an understated ending to a storied career, but predictably it wasn't even that.

Funk was accepting independent dates just weeks later, and even made a return to WWE television that December, just a month on from Bret's acrimonious November exit from the organisation.

Terry has worked countless retirement matches since, most recently losing a match to Jerry 'The King' Lawler by disqualification for USA Championship Wrestling in Tennessee.


5. Hulk Hogan (WCW Bash At The Beach 2000)

Hulk Hogan Jeff Jarrett Bash at the Beach 2000
WWE.com

So toxic that it became the subject of a lawsuit, the all-too-real war of words between Hulk Hogan and Vince Russo during July 2000's Bash at the Beach pay-per-view came to embody the enormous failure the former WWE head writer had been in Atlanta.

The story began as yet another of his insipid 'worked shoot' angles, but morphed into something much worse as the night progressed.

Set to do battle over the WCW World Heavyweight Title, Hulk Hogan and Jeff Jarrett instead commenced the supposedly big angle, with 'Double J' laying down in the ring for Hogan to defeat him at Russo's behest.

Hulk did so, but lambasted his boss on the microphone, suggesting that WCW was 'the shape it was in because of bullsh*t like this'.

As commentators talked about 'going off script', Hogan took the World Title and left.

Russo returned later in the night to explain how he'd spent all day trying to deal with Hogan's politics and was pushed to breaking point. He ended his scathing diatribe with a final message to Hulk - 'You big bald son of a b*tch, kiss my ass'.

According to Hulk (and his defamation lawsuit), Russo went way beyond the pale in his promo. Ironically, he did promise fans that they'd 'never see that piece of sh*t (Hogan) again'. It ended up being true.


4. Goldberg/Brock Lesnar (WWE WrestleMania 20)

Wrestlemania 20 Brock Lesnar Bill Godberg
WWE.com

Now little more than an exorcised demon for both men, the anticlimactic Bill Goldberg/Brock Lesnar WrestleMania 20 clash was an ugly farewell to mainstream professional wrestling for both men.

Lesnar had decided mere weeks earlier that the grind of the WWE schedule was no longer for him, and was to try his hand at a career in the NFL.

Similarly frustrated, Goldberg had experienced the worst of the company's internal politics, with several programmes doing far more harm than good in maintaining the wicked star aura he had amassed during several successful years with WCW. Coming to the end of his one year contract, he was also set to depart following the battle.

Seemingly unbeknownst to the performers until they hit the ring, the Madison Square Garden crowd was tuned into both stories, and refused to give either man a shred of respect as they worked a boring resthold contest in lieu of the impactful power matches they would later produce.

It was a sad end to both tenures, but a particularly jarring way for Lesnar to exit an organisation he had absolutely ripped through with such dynamism during a minuscule two years on the main roster.


3. Kevin Nash (WCW Superbrawl Revenge)

Kevin Nash Scott Steiner
WWE Network

Like Bill Goldberg a month earlier, Kevin Nash's final night in WCW started with a storyline and ended with the real life collapse of a multi-million dollar organisation.

Having feuded with just about everybody else (and each other) multiple times before the complete closure of the company in March 2001, Kevin Nash and Scott Steiner engaged in an awful unannounced 2-out-of-3 falls 'Loser Leaves WCW' match to main event the last ever Superbrawl pay-per-view in February.

Ric Flair's 'Magnificent Seven' stable had already worked on chasing out several top babyfaces such as Goldberg and Sid Vicious presumably for a big payoff in the future, but fantasy became reality as the heroes really never did return to save the day.

The match was the usual farce, with the 2-out-of-3 stipulation added after Nash clocked Steiner with the title belt to win in 17 seconds.

Tied at 1-1 following a Steiner lead pipe shot after three minutes, Ric Flair interfered with a steel chair ten minutes later and allowed 'Big Poppa Pump' to lock on the Steiner Recliner for the victory.

Nash was gone from WCW. But just over a month later, everybody was.


2. Bret Hart (WCW Nitro)

Bret Hart Kevin Nash
WWE Network

The legendary Bret Hart would work his last 'proper' match during the main event of a January 2000 edition of Nitro, but was unaware at the time it would mark his actual retirement from the art-form he was a master of.

Less than a month after taking the kick to the head from Bill Goldberg that would signal the end of his career, Hart continued to work, attempting to shake off the post-concussion syndrome he wasn't aware he had.

Having already taken a beating from WCW commissioner Terry Funk in a hardcore match the previous week on Thunder, World Champion Hart was made to face nWo comrade Kevin Nash as part of 'The Funker's efforts to divide and conquer the unit.

The match was predictably dire, with Hart looking visibly punch drunk for reasons that would become obvious when his condition were confirmed.

The match went to a non-finish as things broke down with typical Nitro main event hullabaloo, and 'The Hitman' would vacate his World Title shortly before the January Souled Out pay-per-view event when the severity of the injury became apparent.

Unable even once more to be 'The Best There Is, Best There Was and Best There Ever Will Be', it marked just about the saddest possible end to his abysmal WCW run.


1. Ric Flair (WCW Halloween Havoc 1994)

Hulk Hogan Ric Flair Mr T
WWE Network

The darkest chapter in WCW's often abhorrent treatment of their finest ever performer, Ric Flair's retirement match loss to Hulk Hogan at Halloween Havoc 1994 was an utter embarrassment.

The October steel cage match was originally intended to be a deciding contest between the two, with the company doubling their typical buyrates for their first encounter at July's Bash at the Beach and drawing monster ratings for their Clash of the Champions rematch the following month.

In truth though, Hogan had never looked troubled by Flair in the feud. His loss at the Clash was via count-out following an extended figure four leglock and high heel shoe attack from Sensuous Sherri.

Nonetheless, the rubber match was booked with with Hogan ally Mr T as referee and both men's careers on the line.

Despite copious abuse from Sherri, Flair and a masked assailant that had been attacking Hogan for weeks, 'The Hulkster' was still easily victorious.

Retiring 'The Nature Boy' alongside a handcuffed and previously assaulted Mr T, WCW didn't even show Ric's emotional departure.

He was hastily ushered to the back while Hogan celebrated with ringsider Muhammed Ali, then unmasked his new enemy as former best friend Brutus Beefcake to commence their ludicrous build to December's Starrcade '94.


In this post: 
Matt Hardy
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.