10 Worst Moments In AEW History
It's not ALL Elite. Some of it is a total shambles...
At its best, AEW is transcendent professional wrestling; to reflect this, a sister list entitled ‘10 Best Moments In AEW History’ has been published under this author page recently.
That list, quite easily, could have exceeded 100 entries. This one could not, which underscores that AEW is a force for good in the modern pro wrestling scene - but, good God, has the promotion crapped the mattress one too many times.
AEW boasted from day one that it would encourage creative expression. This was necessary, for both the fans disillusioned with Vince McMahon’s wretched, oppressive creative, and the wrestlers who wished to escape Vince McMahon’s wretched, oppressive creative.
At times, AEW and Tony Khan reached the opposite extreme by allowing the top stars to do what they wanted - and allowing them to not do what they didn’t want to do. AEW at its worst feels like an unfocused mess - several different promotions existing under one banner, some great, some posing as great, some awful.
This list largely pulls from AEW’s worst creative days - obviously, the tragic passing of Mr. Brodie Lee is the darkest in company history - with one inescapable exception, of course…
10. QTV
QTV was a terrible idea.
A needlessly defensive parody of wrestling media - which, in wrestling, is invariably a sign that a promotion in fact is doing something wrong - the TMZ-themed stable was yet another vehicle with which to get QT Marshall over.
QTV did not get QT Marshall over.
Powerhouse Hobbs was attached to the group, which nearly ruined his career. QT helped him win the TNT title over Wardlow in early 2023. Instantly, Hobbs was just…in a faction, like virtually every other AEW prospect. A rubbish faction.
The aura was drained from Hobbs in one night. What in the absolute hell was a gigantic badass doing hanging around with a fake news crew? Why did, in a wrestling promotion, a fake news crew even exist?
Between the occupational gimmick and “Observe this, brother!” overtones, this was, on two levels, the very worst of 1995 smushed together.
The relationship spun from another core AEW problem: a too strict and too cute attempt at continuity. So what if QT brought Hobbs in?
QTV, a disaster in and of itself, was also emblematic of a deeper rot. Too often, veterans worm their way into Khan’s ear and buy some TV real estate.
As you’ll re-learn…
9. The Firing Of Anthony Henry
AEW, over its five year lifespan, has repeated virtually every mistake a major US cable company inevitably makes. This is an especially alarming trend, since Tony Khan has spoken on record, extensively, about the fate of WCW. He once said that the promotion acted as a How Not To Guide.
And yet, he allowed top stars too much in creative leeway. Mirroring WCW’s 1999 decline, Khan, perhaps swayed by the “cinema” gaining purchase in WWE, booked a sweeping melodramatic story between MJF and Adam Cole in 2023. He stole the competition’s homework with the invisible camera vignettes and goofball comedy.
Khan went too 2010s WWE in 2023 generally.
Stop-start pushes (Wardlow). The introduction of too many titles. Several names disappearing from TV with zero explanation.
The worst of this WWE-ification was the firing of Anthony Henry.
Out of action with a broken jaw, Henry was released from his contract in April 2024, and was seemingly only brought back as a result of public outcry. This was a sad loss for worker’s rights - yet another brutal reminder that AEW was just another ruthless outfit hardly intent on changing the world.
If it was probably naive to believe that AEW would be an unwavering force for good in 2019, that was definitely the case by 2024.
8. The Signing Of Ric Flair
This ultimately pointless signing was ugly, in and of itself, but it significantly impacted AEW’s reputation as the “babyface company”.
Tony Khan had just, earlier in that very month of October 2023, lashed out on Twitter at Vince McMahon’s “alleged misdeeds”. Vince deserves every breath of trash-talk aimed in his direction, certainly, but this tiresome attempt at Wednesday Night Wars rhetoric was rendered hypocritical and idiotic within weeks.
In parallel, WWE overtook AEW as the red-hot, fan-forward babyface promotion (whether earned or otherwise, that was the narrative). Flair’s signing depicted AEW as a poser of a promotion with no backbone. Ric Flair - who was only effective at Revolution 2024 as Sting’s moment eased the sickly feeling - of course acted like Ric Flair almost immediately.
On an episode of Rampage, and Flair of course played victim in the backlash, he asked any willing 18 year-old girl to meet him in his hotel room. He said he’d go as high as 28.
Flair, accused of sexual assault in 2002, resulting in WWE settling with Heidi Doyle out of court, was emblematic of AEW’s slide into the heel role.
7. The Booking Of The Women’s Division (General)
In 2024, AEW - without much in the way of achieving anything close to parity - made significant improvements to the women’s division.
Prior to that…
Peaks existed, yes, but in totality, the women’s division was a marginalised endeavour, an anti-passion project. It was impossible to escape the idea that AEW felt like they couldn’t not promote women’s wrestling for the sake of the optics.
The old excuses - the shallow free agent pool, the joshi talent being confined to Japan throughout the pandemic - became less convincing when AEW signed or developed top talent, only to maintain the one match per TV show policy.
Khan’s big mistake was in treating the women’s division like the men’s. In the men’s singles ranks, on TV, top stars would rarely face off one-on-one. Khan would rely on veterans, solid midcard hands and emerging prospects to lose to his pushed stars (think Dustin Rhodes, Jay Lethal and Wheeler YUTA respectively).
In the women’s division (and the one allocated 8+ minute match), instead of using his actual talents more frequently, Khan went for the name wrestler versus emerging prospect option week after week after week.
There exists now a graveyard of talents who were arbitrarily slotted into this “one to watch” role too infrequently for them to actually capitalise on it: Anna Jay, Red Velvet, Lady Frost, Abadon, Kiera Hogan, Tay Melo, Penelope Ford, Leyla Hirsch…
Some did better than others - Julia Hart was on the cusp before her injury - but the sheer amount of predictable TV matches with those on the losing side who went nowhere is staggering.
6. Matt Hardy’s Brush With Death
At All Out 2020, in a spot that should never have been approved, Matt Hardy and Sammy Guevara shimmied up a cherry picker and, with minimal space through which to manoeuvre, took an ill-advised, terrifying bump onto a table dressed up as a souvenir stand.
Everything about this was stupid. It was 2020, so nobody could buy merch for starters.
While the stunt had been rehearsed, the scope for error was vast - and an error was made. Hardy’s torso clipped the table; his head smashed against the concrete and, for a few horrifying moments, he was thought to be dead as his body turned purple.
The match continued, somehow. Hardy was “able” to move, somehow, but should not have been allowed. He won, because the Broken Rules (Last Man Standing) stipulation demanded it. Otherwise, he’d have to leave AEW.
Was…was this the priority?!
Reckless, stupid, mishandled: this was almost exactly what a black comedy satirising pro wrestling would look like.
Hardy actually claims that he didn’t in fact suffer a concussion, but something was obviously, badly wrong: he was hospitalised, and missed the next two months of action.
5. “December 18”
On December 18, 2019, the risible Dark Order and their profoundly unthreatening “creepers” drew fake blood from the throat of Matt Jackson, treated Kenny Omega like an underling, and, when attempting to punch Dustin Rhodes, missed by a good foot. These creepers, clad in black lycra, resembled the interpretive dancers in the most pretentious amateur play you’ve ever been forced to watch.
This atrocious, unacceptable scene could only be described as what wrestling must look like to the non-fans who think you think it’s real.
Widely and heavily panned, this angle almost single-handedly killed the idea of AEW as an alternative for the discerning fan.
This, you could argue, was the best thing that could have happened to the promotion. Tony Khan disbanded the old booking committee comprised of himself and the Elite, scrapped plans for their big Dark Order programme, and took the lead creatively, resulting in what might remain the outfit’s true peak: the build to Revolution 2020.
Or, alternatively, Tony Khan should have trusted his instincts all along - and then continued to trust his gut instead of listening to the various egomaniacs and carnies who would continue to get in the way…
4. The Revolution Bomb DUD
The big angle that concluded AEW Revolution 2021 was unfavourably compared to WWE Hell In A Cell 2019.
This wasn’t particularly fair; the rather key difference is that AEW attempted to do something cool and failed the execution, whereas WWE simply executed a terrible idea dismally.
Nonetheless, this was a complete embarrassment.
The Jon Moxley Vs. Kenny Omega Exploding Barbed Wire Death Match was very, very cool - the unexpected second explosion from Mox’s John Woo dropkick played beautifully with how those spots are “meant” to be distributed - even if the shower of sparks wasn’t quite as luminous as you’d hoped.
However, in the post-match, when the ring was meant to explode with Jon Moxley trapped within it, an absolutely pathetic sparkler display faintly rose from each ring post. Poor Eddie Kingston, making the heroic save, had to sell it.
AEW actually salvaged the whole thing with a very funny edition of Dynamite - “69 me, Don!” - but AEW strove for FMW here, and instead plummeted to LOLTNA.
A punchline of an angle, no matter how well it was handled, it underscored that AEW, sadly, is never too far away from stupid. Significant trust was lost that night.
3. Chris Jericho, And The Reaction At Worlds End
Over the 2023 holiday season, on Twitter, Chris Jericho got into a slanging match with Stephen P. New: a lawyer who buys commercial space on Jim Cornette’s podcast. Chris claimed, as Brawl Out surfaced yet again on Twitter, that he’d never signed an NDA in his life.
Then, journalist Nick Hausman responded: what about the NDAs you make other people sign?
While no direct allegation was made, Kylie Rae - a super-promising babyface who disappeared from AEW almost as quickly as she was signed - responded with a heart emoji to a tweet alluding to Jericho’s rumoured sexual misconduct.
Dots were connected.
AEW promoted Worlds End (sic) on December 30. Jericho was jeered and pelted with chants of “NDA!”. In the post-show press conference, Tony Khan - who had to know this was coming, but chose to wear a stupid hat regardless - hardly backed his man. Khan did not definitively state that Jericho has never been the subject of a complaint pertaining to his behaviour.
This event was ugly in the extreme, and yet, Jericho was rewarded with his mandatory TV time. He even, under the guise of his awful meta character, took the piss by naming a terrible talking segment precisely that.
Jericho has tanked his legacy and prevents AEW from recapturing the “feeling”. This would be karmic, were it not for the fact that he’s still making millions.
Also, his ‘Learning Tree’ gimmick is so bad that it’s almost working out in his favour: some are already starting to forget what actually prompted the backlash.
2. Tony Khan’s General Fecklessness
Khan, a great booker when he asserts control, is too often guilty of just letting people do sh*t - and what’s worse is that he knows in his bones that it is sh*t.
He let Matt Hardy debut under his ‘BROKEN’ persona in March 2020 and, after hipster critics were aghast at the teleportation stuff, almost immediately regretted it. And yet, by 2023, Khan had forgotten what the podcasters said because Hardy was doing cinematic matches in which the Hardy Compound magically turned into nighttime. Presumably, Hardy got in Khan’s ear. Khan is at once the easily persuaded star-struck fan and an old message boarder who wants to be liked by the “sickos”.
That’s how he arrives at booking the Continental Classic and approving hacking angles on the same episode of Dynamite.
That’s how Dax Harwood, by being placated with endless long matches, cooled off so much since 2022.
That’s how the sports league is too often polluted with supernatural hokum.
Matt Hardy generally was allowed to do any awld sh*te for the longest time, doing his level best to drag down AEW’s invincible streak of 2021.
It’s not just Hardy. Khan will let Chris Jericho do what Chris Jericho wants to do. Khan will also wait until an untenable situation erupts before even approaching doling out some punishment.
On the subject of which…
1. Brawl Out
‘Brawl Out’ unfolded on September 4, 2022.
On December 25, 2023 - a full 477 days later - people were still talking about it. Not that you need reminding, but December 25 is Christmas day. After Chris Jericho brought it all back up, a lot of people spent December 25 re-litigating the events of Brawl Out, and Jesus Christ: the fighting soldiers took that day off to play football during the first World War!
That about says it all. The sheer amount of time that people spent discussing the events of the All Out 2022 press conference underscores the extent to which it was a distraction from the fiction.
Did, as virtually the entire locker room believed, CM Punk heavily intimate to Tony Khan that he didn’t want to see Colt Cabana around the place anymore?
It almost doesn’t matter how it all started at this point.
The fact is that Tony Khan buried his hand in the sand and woefully mismanaged a situation that was destined to erupt. CM Punk, in an unprovoked rant, buried the Elite and set the company on fire after Hangman Page brought up the accusation on TV a few months prior.
A dire enough set of circumstances to begin with, none of this was remotely helped by two key factors: the real-life feud between Punk and the Elite was far more compelling than anything Tony Khan could hope to book on TV, and - through a steady series of leaks and Sports Illustrated interviews and yet another backstage fight a year later - it was AEW’s longest-running programme.
AEW has never quite felt the same since.