10 Worst WWE Matches Ever (According To The Internet)

The Internet Wrestling Community swings the axe, and even sentimental favourites aren't safe.

Michael Cole Poop II: The Poopening
WWE

Negative content sells.

It's hardly pulling back the curtain at this point, but for the last ones to cross the line, the reason your online experience sometimes feels skewed in the direction of things that suck is that it generates everything that counts as currency in the contemporary age. It's not even a fresh concept for digital natives and beyond - press credibility stuttered and suffered decades before dial-up as those in charge of major publications spotted profitable patterns between when they stirred up anger over joy.

All of that's to say some people will relish this countdown of WWE's biggest stinkers, but if the balance and good cheer matter to you, fear not! We covered the positive version of this list first, highlighting the very best of the market leader shortly before a WrestleMania 39 card that might have added a couple of new entries to the countdown.

That featured a host of legendary performers at their dynamic and dazzling best, with a litany of classic moments flooding the minds and memories of everybody that watched the matches and rated them so favourably in the first place.

This, predictably, won't be quite as kind...

(The ranking, as with the original, will come from our friends at Cagematch...)

10. Miss WrestleMania Battle Royal (WrestleMania 25)

WrestleMania 25 Divas Santino Santina Marella
WWE.com

At WrestleMania 39 in 2023, Trish Stratus and Lita teamed with Becky Lynch in a high-profile six-women tag match that saw the latter pair win the Tag Team Championships en route to the event and the former turn heel on both to set up yet another Stadium showdown in the summer.

It's little surprise both Hall-Of-Famers thought better of working this in 2009, or that Lynch herself had left an industry she'd entered years earlier altogether. A grim vision of the state of things at the time, the Miss WrestleMania Battle Royale competitors entered without any individual recognition (thanks to the shameful decision to tack their entrances onto a useless Kid Rock medley), the winner was Santino Marella in drag, and several of the eliminations were missed and/or outright ignored by the commentary.

The anticipation of seeing former favourites Sunny, Molly Holly, Victoria and others were drained as they entered and emptied as the match trudged to its inevitably depressing conclusion.


9. Goldust Vs The Ultimate Warrior (In Your House 7: Good Friends, Better Enemies)

Ultimate Warrior Goldust
WWE

Even at his absolute worst creatively, Vince McMahon developed a reputation of being a promoter that over-delivered if wrestlers were injured or the card - as has always been identified on posters - was suddenly subject to change.

It was a weird crowd-pleasing quirk that seemed to be a holdover from the era when selling tickets and...actually trying could still be measured in the financial report, and McMahon appeared to thrive under the pressure of doing something preposterous to make up for the change in plans.

But not at In Your House 7: Good Friends, Better Enemies.

Ultimate Warrior was back to make the monster money he was earning, and ideally with pay-per-view buys rather than the comics stacking up in Vince McMahon's garage. Admittedly, the injury to Intercontinental Champion Goldust wasn't his fault, but he was more than happy to go along with the damning waste of time masquerading as a match instead.

They stalled, Ultimate Warrior smoked Marlena's cigar, sat in Goldust's director's chair, wore Goldust's usher's hat, threatened to wear (then tear) Goldust's robe, hit a few moves on the usher and that - whatever that was - was that.

Bad enough, (Warrior's had worse), but the decision to spend nearly eight minutes on all of that was wholly unacceptable and presumably what elevated it so high as one of the worst ever.


8. Sable Vs Tori (WrestleMania XV)

Sable Tori
WWE.com

This is no good.

A prominent programme even if the stakes were criminally low for a World Title match, Sable and Tori were at least saved doing of-the-time bikini/evening gown spots by virtue of the feud making it to WrestleMania. Introduced as a stalker of the Women's Champion, Tori was in fact a competent wrestler thought perfect to give one of the company's biggest stars something a little bit more credible bell-to-bell.

It might have been best left alone.

A lot worked against them on the night, with a short run-time colliding with Sable's growing disinterest in actually wrestling and, Tori's struggle to settle into the house style.

But all of that would be writing around was fundamentally a very poor match with a very lousy finish. To call it one of the worst matches in company history when some of the shoddiest developmental wrestling ever has been committed to television during NXT's televised era might scan as unfair, but the spotlight shining brightest is just as capable of burning with its glare.


7. Alexa Bliss Vs Bayley (Extreme Rules 2017)

Alexa Bliss Bayley
WWE.com

Alexa Bliss and Bayley featuring amongst some of the absolute disasters on this list might scan as grossly unfair, but what appears to have happened here is similar to how WWE itself managed the entire wretched storyline back in 2017.

A beyond-bad "Bayley: This Is Your Life" Raw segment hosted by Bliss was so hideous (and hideously received) that on the following week's episode, on-screen authority figure Kurt Angle was scripted to chastise on-screen perpetrator Alexa by an off-screen architect of all this sh*t Vince McMahon. That's sort of what's happened here.

The chemistry had always been decent between the two dating back to an excellent NXT television match in 2015, but the "Kendo Stick On A Pole" stipulation existed to try and bring out the anger in a Bayley character McMahon was destined to despise. She grabbed the weapon, couldn't use it and was quickly and easily despatched by a Raw Women's Champion that had taken her title in a similarly easy fashion.

A very, very bad time for the gimmick more than a very, very bad match, this was the contest most indicative of the core issues at the dark heart of WWE.


6. Jerry Lawler Vs Michael Cole (WrestleMania 27)

Jerry Lawler Michael Cole Steve Austin
WWE.com

Following Cody Rhodes' WrestleMania 39 defeat to Roman Reigns, picking on the result of a comedy midcard match over a decade earlier almost feels as petty as it does futile. But make no mistake - the outcome of this useless effort is one of the big reasons why this specifically earned the disdain of the online masses.

From screwing Jerry Lawler out of the WWE Championship in November 2010, Michael Cole had become a thorn in everybody's side, doubling and trebling down on 'The King' in particular on their own Road To WrestleMania. It was grating by design in order to give people the catharsis of a squash at the 'Show Of Shows'. WWE offered neither.

In one of the longest matches on the entire show, Cole and Lawler virtually went hold for hold with each other until the veteran finally scored vindication and a victory. Only, he didn't. The Anonymous General Manager reversed the decision just to force two rematches that redefined diminished returns.

And Michael Cole will be back later!


5. Gran Metalik, Kalisto & Lince Dorado Vs Lars Sullivan (Super ShowDown 2019)

Lars Sullivan Super ShowDown
WWE

A complete mess of a handicap match, this was low on botches, flubs or the sort of moments of in-ring madness that used to confine contests to the bin in...less kind times.

Downvoted almost definitely because of how utterly nonsensical it was, the match is reflective of the wider audience's dissolution with the obvious meddling Vince McMahon more than the individual performance levels of the performers themselves.

Not that this was a mat classic, but even if Gran Metalik, Kalisto and Lince Dorado had had the night of their lives and/or Lars Sullivan had his best multi-man this side of the TakeOver: New Orleans ladder match, this was still going to fall apart.

Set against a bored and confused crowd creating an eerie pin-drop silence in Saudi Arabia, the Lucha House Party men were dominated individually and as a group before cheating to get an advantage, losing by disqualification and having their attempt to run away thwarted by the new monster.

It was pitiful stuff made worse by the vibe, and forced through a rematch where Sullivan sustained an injury that derailed his career and expedited his WWE departure.


4. Braun Strowman Vs Tyson Fury (Crown Jewel 2019)

WWE Crown Jewel 2019 Braun Strowman Tyson Fury
WWE.com

An awful exhibition of what can just happen now thanks to the absurd money flowing through the industry, Tyson Fury Vs Braun Strowman was just artless trash fought for sacks of cash.

The World Champion boxer towered over that many performers that 'The Monster Among Men' was one of the only logical opponents, but a nothing-happening encounter at Crown Jewel 2019 would have been the worst match of the year had another abomination occurred in the country earlier that year. More on that momentarily.

Weirdly, for a match that had wisely been promoted as a prize fight, the whole thing had an even more pantomime quality than a standard wrestling match. The babyface/heel dynamic was never well fleshed out considering the typical stakes of a celebrity encounter, and Braun getting any type of rub/reward looked redundant in the build, let alone the match. Bam Bam Bigelow/Lawrence Taylor this wasn’t.

After several perplexingly uneventful minutes, boxer Fury landed a knockout blow, but worker Braun was counted out instead of pinned. Then with the decision rendered, he hit his running powerslam finish after the bell. Boring uncommitted parity, like everything else about the feud.

Luckily (?) for them, Brock Lesnar and Cain Valesquez had an equally p*ss poor match on the same show, and the whole crew were stuck in the country while Vince McMahon allegedly squabbled with the paymasters over money, so little gets said about this experiment five years later. Luckily for us, the internet never forgets.


3. The Undertaker Vs Goldberg (Super ShowDown 2019)

The Undertaker Goldberg
WWE.com

A triumphantly terrible encounter for those that might not be the biggest fans of both men and anybody that abhors WWE’s ongoing deal with the Saudi Arabia Sports Authority, the main event of Super ShowDown 2019 was a sobering and legacy-tarnishing display from men thought big enough stars to get away with the basics.

”Get away with” and “basics” might not seem like terms tied to a match befitting of such a monster payday for the company, but the first few Saudi Arabia shows in particular were just that - big (old) stars for the people paying the tab, required to go through the hits or a rough approximation of them.

This was simply a rough approximation of a wrestling match.

A sweltering Goldberg cracked his head open early, resulting in a dangerous display that nearly turned Undertaker’s ‘Deadman’ gimmick from work to shoot when a Jackhammer went badly wrong and folded him in half like one of those snakes him and Big Show used to murder in the desert.

As their iconic status slipped further and further from view, so too did the match. Undertaker wrapped the godawful botchfest up with a chokeslam, and even that was more about them getting the hell out of the ring in one piece rather than sending the fans home happy. That was lost in the first few minutes, and ‘Taker’s furious face told a better story after the fall than anything that had happened bell-to-bell.


2. Ariel & Kevin Thorn Vs Kelly Kelly & Mike Knox (December To Dismember)

Shelly Martinez Kelly Kelly December to Dismember 2006
WWE.com

The overall in-ring quality of professional wrestling at present is in a strange state of flux.

Between WWE and AEW, fans of mainstream North American pro wrestling can expect at a minimum between one and three matches per week that exceed almost everything over the last century in terms of in-ring athleticism, innovation and wild physical feats. As with all sports and sports-adjacent pursuits, the performance bar is only ever raised higher as old standards are put to the sword by newer, faster, riskier and stronger displays. Meanwhile, on NXT and sometimes Rampage, Dark and Dark: Elevation, rookies or inexperienced hands make their mistakes on a far bigger stage and highlight just why there's nothing quite like experience in something as skilled as pro wrestling.

The watermark has risen to the point where a match like Ariel & Kevin Thorn Vs Kelly Kelly & Mike Knox would simply not happen on Raw, SmackDown or Dynamite. It's bad, but unremarkably so, and seems included here because it's the worst thing on an all-time worst show. That counts for a lot, but watch it back - two women that hadn't been in the industry all that long with partners that didn't exactly have rich histories of their own made for an amateur hour performance worked earnestly if with almost no redeeming features.

WWE TV matches are rarely this shoddy, but they're often more boring. Plenty would argue that the former is preferable.


1. John Cena Vs Michael Cole (Monday Night Raw, June 4th 2012)

Michael Cole John Cena
WWE.com

A wretched exhibition of WWE's grim culture Then, Now, Forever, Together, Michael Cole and John Cena's protracted bullying/"comedy" match was the worst of the worst of the worst and Cagematch gatekeepers and the wider online wrestling fanbase were right to designate it as such.

When WWE's at its worst, it barely resembles a wrestling organisation.

When WWE's at its worst, there's not a star alive capable of elevating the material or raising the sinking ship.

And when WWE's at its worst, it seems as though fans are forced to endure an unholy amount of it, in keeping with the more-is-always-more philosophy espoused by its leader.

This wasn't even the payoff to Michael Cole's own reign of terror as WWE's heel announcer. That had happened almost a full year earlier, allowing Cole to phase it back in a project that took so long it rendered the original idea more hassle than it was worth. And even when he was a heel, 'The Champ' was one of the few wrestlers the villainous voice openly adored anyway.

Cena picked Cole on random Raw when offered any match he wanted from then-GM John Laurinaitis, beat Lord Tensai to get it, then physically abused the commentator for five and a half minutes that felt like twice as many hours. WWE's audience-of-one problem had never been more pronounced.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.