10 Worst WWE Survivor Series EVER - According To Dave Meltzer

The bad old days.

the rock mankind survivor series 1998
WWE.com

At the conclusion of the final SmackDown Live! before Survivor Series 2017, the ever-changing card at last took solid shape with a final adjustment to the Women's Champion Vs Champion clash. In replacing Natalya with Charlotte against Raw's Alexa Bliss, the company completed the tightening up of just about every match since the first announcement of the Red Vs Blue concept a month ago.

It's potentially the greatest Survivor Series card ever. It's yet to follow through on all the promise of course, but on paper it appears stronger than just about any November supercard the organisation has ever presented. There have been some fine Series' over the years too, with a mix of superlative singles, tense tag and enchanting elimination matches all combining to deliver and delight.

These are not those shows.

Each event has of course been carefully assessed by Wrestling Observer gaffer Dave Meltzer, who dishes out stars to superstars...or doesn't, as is the case here. Averaged out and ranked by the ratings of every match on the card, these shows fall in line as the very worst iterations of a company classic. Few are without good cause, and some deserve every inch of the critical thrashing.

(NOTE: In the event of a tied rating, the most recent match gets preferential treatment. Wrestling evolves at a breakneck pace, and any older contest outperforming a contemporary equivalent is deserving of the elevated status)

10. Survivor Series 2013 (2.35)

Roman Reigns Survivor Series 2013
WWE

The 2013 edition of the Thanksgiving tradition found itself delivering nothing despite being on the cusp of everything.

The image above shows Roman Reigns celebrating as his team's sole survivor. He received a rapturous response, despite still being part of a heel Shield group that had spent much of the autumn terrorising beloved babyfaces Daniel Bryan and CM Punk. Imagine how chuffed Vince McMahon must have been to see his next Cena soaking up positivity at such an early stage? They couldn't miss with him...

And what of Bryan and Punk? The oppressed pair were shoehorned into a listless doubles feud with The Wyatt Family in an angle ostensibly crafted to shoo them both away from rancid title pictures fans clamoured for their involvement in.

Cena and Orton were holding the World and WWE Championships respectively at the time, a month before fighting each other in a mishandled unification of the straps. Their victories that night over Alberto Del Rio and The Big Show were serviced with angered groans from the crowd, perhaps giving McMahon more pause to consider the ascent of his next champion ahead of WrestleMania. Two guesses as to names who weren't on his agenda.


9. Survivor Series 1989 (2.31)

Demolition Jake Roberts Zeus Hulk Hogan
WWE

Though a two-star average for a late-1980s WWE pay-per-view is pretty good going for a Dave Meltzer rating, the 1989 Survivor Series rarely tiptoes in technical excellence thanks to succeeding in its dual purpose of promoting Hulk Hogan and The Ultimate Warrior as the biggest stars on the planet.

Having just about gotten Zeus out of his system as he prepared to enter a brand new decade, Vince McMahon had decided upon his WrestleMania babyface superclash, and used the elimination match layout to give fans lashings of both men to gage fan support a few months in advance.

The booking of each perhaps foreshadowed the direction of McMahon's gaze at the time. Ultimate Warrior was a dominant leviathan captaining his team to victory over a crumbling Heenan Family in the evening's topliner, all rampage and rage. Hogan meanwhile effectively squeaked past Ted Dibiase's team after questionable disqualification decisions saw Zeus and The Powers Of Pain auspiciously eliminated.

'The Hulkster's fight from underneath was as gripping as always, but his guts and determination suddenly didn't look on the level of his face-painted future foe.


8. Survivor Series 2000 (2.31)

Rikishi Survivor Series 2000
WWE

A year earlier, Rikishi borrowed The Rock's rental car and lay in wait for Stone Cold Steve Austin. 'The Rattlesnake' had been lured to the parking lot by Triple H, but was suddenly left exposed to the former Headshrinker's road rage. Mowing Austin down, Rikishi drove off into the night, hid away for a month or so, then reinvented himself as a dancing babyface on the main roster.

The revelations that explained all that absolute bullsh*t were drip-fed by a creative team clearly making it up as they went along in late-2000, such was the abject failure of the Samoan in a top spot. As 'mastermind', Triple H was effectively gifted the storyline, whilst Rikishi was sidelined off into a programme with the ever-giving Rock just to not make his demotion look so blindingly apparent.

Their match on this card was the best of the bunch, but it wasn't saying a lot. The Rock got the win because so he bloody should, but Rikishi got his heat back immediately in order to keep him 'hot' for one more main event the following month.

Oh, and as for Austin and 'The Game'? They went nearly half an hour before Stone Cold locked him in a car and dropped him from a crane for the finish/non-finish. It left nary a mark on Hunter when he returned two weeks later. And the less said about Undertaker's snakeskin trousers and his absolutely p*ss poor WWE Title clash with Kurt Angle, the better.


7. Survivor Series 1993 (2.13)

The Doinks Survivor Series 1993
WWE.com

Survivor Series 1993 really is worthy of Dave Meltzer's time all over again.

The opener is rich in drama and action, with Randy Savage's surprise emergence as Razor Ramon's fourth man generating the sort of reaction that makes it only more absurd that Vince McMahon wanted him as an announcer rather than a wrestler ASAP. They f**king love him out there, even when his red hot rivalry with Crush results in early elimination.

Elsewhere, Shawn Michaels is the dictionary definition of 'best case scenario' in replacing rape-indicted Jerry Lawler at the very last minute for a match with masked men against the tacitly fragile Hart Family. And yes, Lex Luger and Yokozuna's jingoistic nonsense blights the main event a little, but gripping sequences with Yoko and The Undertaker suggested a feud wholly unlike the cartoonish disaster eventually served up.

Alright, so the card may contain perhaps the worst WWE match of the 1990s, maybe ever. Big deal!

It truly can't be ignored. Bam Bam Bigelow, Bastion Booger and The Headshrinkers Vs Four Doinks is a Vince McMahon fever dream that immediately doubles as a viewer nightmare. Fatu and Samu are somehow cast as even stupider savages than normal, Booger is...well, as gross and useless as always, but poor Bam Bam has to try and wrestle around the chaos of half-eaten turkeys, toy scooters, gimmicked balloons and a literal banana skin. Oh, and Men On A Mission and The Bushwhackers because Doink didn't even show!

Even the clown didn't want to be anywhere near this.


6. Survivor Series 2008 (2.07)

Vladimir Kozlov
WWE.com

Though John Cena and Chris Jericho worked a passable main event and an Edge surprise comeback supplied a genuine thrill, Survivor Series 2008's uneven card was almost certainly given the short shrift from Dave Meltzer thanks to an abysmal Triple H/Vladimir Kozlov scuffle that should be played on giant screens in India as fair warning of what to expect when Hunter does his 'burly babyface vs husky foreigner' schtick on the December india tour.

It was unforgivably awful. Kozlov had been SmackDown's token dominant heel that summer, advancing from boring squashes over jobbers right up to boring victories over Jeff Hardy and The Undertaker. But 'The Game' was in refreshed form on the blue brand, even dragging an exciting encounter out of The Great Khali for his beloved belt at SummerSlam earlier that year.

Those with optimism were punished for their foolishness. The contest was supposed to be a triple threat including Hardy, but the 'Charismatic Enigma' was allegedly in rough nick before the match. The storyline was supposed to heavy-handedly imply that Jeff was battling demons, but a January twist revealed Matt Hardy (and definitely not nor never Christian...) had been decking him all along. Edge's return to steal the title in the match was literally too little and too late. Surprises are awesome, but that was a simple sacrifice to avoid having to suffer through the eventual end result.

Don't ever watch that match. Or do. But don't.


5. Survivor Series 1991 (1.97)

Survivor Series 1991 Hulk Hogan The Undertaker Ric Flair
WWE.com

Ric Flair played a major role in his first WWE pay-per-view, but like most of his supercard appearances during his maiden stint with the organisation, he wasn't permitted to be enough of 'The Nature Boy' to show company loyalists exactly why his arrival was such a big deal.

'Slick Ric' was at the centre of all the genuine drama on an otherwise tepid card. He inauspiciously survived in a star-laden opener after virtually every other competitor was counted out in a brawl, and an intervention on behalf of The Undertaker in the WWE Title clash cost natural rival Hulk Hogan his precious gold.

Unfortunately, the match that took place before his interference was absolutely diabolical. Hogan and 'The Deadman' worked at a snails pace and did almost nothing before a closing stretch finally gave fans something to cheer.

Elsewhere, the elimination matches were sacrificed in favour of promoting a 'This Tuesday In Texas' pay-per-view the following week. It was a particularly lousy tactic to announce Randy Savage and Jake Roberts' absence from the event as it started, rather than before the card. Their interviews to promote the Tuesday clash rubbed salt in an open wound.


4. Survivor Series 1997 (1.83)

Goldust Survivor Series 1997
WWE.com

There's a very, very, very controversial ending to this show you may have heard about before. But frankly, it's a good job Vince McMahon left the world with arguably the biggest talking point in company history as the show went off the air. The planned 'schmoz' Bret Hart assumed was taking place would have resulted in this card being the most-panned 'Big Four' event ever.

Despite the company being on the verge of incredible, history-making feats, it's astonishing how disparate the 1997 Survivor Series really is.

The elimination matches are uniformly awful. One after another, each eight-man sh*tshow drags along to virtual silence at the sight of illogical teams and recklessly booked battles. Elsewhere, a Kane/Mankind brawl is a passable debut for 'The Big Red Machine' and Steve Austin's four minute decimation of Owen Hart only highlighted how not ready he was to return to action.

The biggest offender is the woeful Team Canada/Team USA clash. Phil Lafon is the only actual Canadian along with two Americans and a Brit, whilst the patriotic opposition is made up of Vader, an antagonistic Marc Mero, newcomer Steve Blackman and a disinterested and injured Goldust. Nobody seemed to give a f*ck, least of all the wrestlers themselves.


3. Survivor Series 1998 (1.68)

Undertaker rock survivor series 1998
WWE.com

Vince Russo's magnum opus suffers the indignity of a pitiful average rating more for how much needed cramming in to make his narrative fantasy a reality.

Survivor Series 1998's 14-Man WWE Title tournament required the rattling through of an entire first round bracket in under half an hour, with even less afforded to the quarter and semi-finals.

It was a necessary evil on the night, with almost every contest woven somehow into the incredible backdoor ascent of The Rock alongside tacit assistance of Vince and Shane McMahon. Up front, the Chairman feigned support for the gullible Mankind, but his interest in the lovable lunatic was merely to ensure he had his main event patsy.

Foley was used and abused in the tournament, working as an inadvertent hired gun against Stone Cold Steve Austin in a contest that revealed Shane McMahon's shocking allegiance with his father in the grandest of twists. The vengeful 'Rattlesnake's post-show fury against the 'Great One' foreshadowed the first of three spectacular WrestleMania battles between the two bastions of WWE's mainstream reawakening.

WWE, such as it is, can rarely produce bottle episodes of their TV shows, but Survivor Series is as close as they ever came. Logical progression, incredible shocks and high drama. The in-ring quality was a justified casualty.


2. Survivor Series 1999 (1.61)

Triple H Big Show The Rock  Survivor Series 1999
WWE.com

Steve Austin wasn't half p*ssed off when he returned to television nearly a year after Rikishi mowed him down in the car park of Detroit's Joe Louis Arena before he could main event Survivor Series 1999. If he'd seen the rest of the broadcast instead of being carted off in an ambulance, he'd probably have bought the dancing Samoan an appreciative pint.

Aside from the bait and switch main event (that itself was an absolute stinker), the rest of the card doesn't remotely try and galvanise support from a crowd ordinarily head over heels with the company's output.

White hot on television, WWE was tacitly trapped between creative regimes following the recent exit of Vince Russo and Ed Ferrara and it tended to show itself on pay-per-view around the time. Unforgiven, No Mercy, Survivor Series and Armageddon were all risible before the company sprang back to life and hit home-runs nearly every month in 2000.

The undercard may be one of the most haphazard talent arrangements in company history. Only Kurt Angle's debut victory over Shawn Stasiak warrants rewatch to revel in the birthing of one of Vince McMahon's finest creations, but the elimination matches on the show are uniformly dreadful. Even Chris Jericho, desperate for acceptance in his new surroundings, couldn't get much from Intercontinental Champion Chyna.


1. Survivor Series 1994 (1.43)

Bret Hart Bob Backlund Survivor Series 1994
WWE

Bret Hart's never been the luckiest.

The poor b*stard entered in an creditable display in his choice WWE Title match with Bob Backlund, but it was lost in the middle of an uneven pay-per-view that unfortunately indulged in the worst vestiges of Vince McMahon's mid-1990s cartoonish leanings.

Ever the professional, Bret somehow managed to sell the intense pain of an ice age spent in Backlund's brutal Crossface Chicken Wing whilst mother Helen Hart dithered over throwing in the towel at the behest of his rotten brother Owen. It was lush sports entertainment drama, but Meltzer's ** rating ruthlessly derides the inaction in the final third.

Following a red hot opener that saw the demise of Shawn Michaels and Diesel's relationship in preparation for their own WrestleMania title match build, the card either side of Backlund/Bret was a Day-Glo disaster.

Jerry Lawler and Doink's comedy bout featuring miniature doppelgängers of themselves reached Sid-levels of drizzling sh*t. Lex Luger was again just a flexing loser in his latest failure against Ted Dibiase's corporate crew, whilst the Undertaker's casket clash with Yokozuna was only marginally less stupider than their Royal Rumble disaster-piece earlier that year. Attempting to interfere, Jeff Jarrett took an almighty kick from ringside enforcer Chuck Norris. 'Double J' really can survive anything the wrestling business throws at him.


Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.