10 Worst WWE Wrestlers Of 2021
Carmella probably isn't the only WWE star who wants to hide their face!
2021 was the year WWE got back in front of fans and on the road.
The weirdness of 2020's 'pandemic era', and the ThunderDome video wall that came with it, washed away as though nothing had happened. Sadly the same can't be said for familiar issues that have plagued the promotion for years.
Character development is often lacking, there's a tedious (and lazy) over-reliance on so-called comedy to sell major matches that should be heated, and almost everyone not-named Roman Reigns or Brock Lesnar yo-yos up and down the card; maintaining momentum for its wrestlers isn't a WWE strong suit.
Some fared worse than others though. There are some seriously good pieces of talent on this roster that just...didn't get going in 2021. A few sucked and fumbled their way through matches and promos alike generally, but most of the crew here were given no chance to succeed in the face of horrendous booking and ideas so flimsy they'd blow away in the wind.
Behold the worst of the worst when it comes to the past 12 months or so. Here's hoping 2022 brings better things for these guys...
10. Jeff Hardy
A surprising start? Maybe.
Jeff Hardy might still play before some of the bigger live crowd pops on WWE programming, but he's been handled horribly and had some real stinkers this year. Indeed, matches against Cedric Alexander, Jinder Mahal, Karrion Kross and more were mediocre at best.
That's the best word to use when summing up Jeff's 2021, being honest. The less said about a stab at the bogus 24/7 Title, the better too - that was totally rejected by fans, and forced a scrambled rethink that...led to Hardy jobbing in the United States Title division instead. Yeah, hardly an upgrade there.
Most recently, Jeff also left a WWE house show mid-match. Fans are still waiting on an update, and it could be a routine injury issue, but some are worried that his all-too-familiar personal demons have reared their ugly head again.
At least his classic 'No More Words' entrance theme is back, eh?
9. Carmella
As the tagline for this piece suggests, Carmella might want to dig out her old mask and give everyone else on the list a turn. That'd spare their blushes and might just protect them from some of the so-so booking she's had to endure. No, "The Most Beautiful Woman In All Of WWE" didn't have a lot to shout about until later on in the year.
She's currently one half of the Women's Tag Champs alongside Queen Zelina, but that title win was a rare moment of shine for 'Mella. The loudmouth, screeching blonde has teamed with the released Billie Kay, flopped as a challenger for Bianca Belair, been ousted from the challenger slot by Becky Lynch at SummerSlam and more.
Carmella has just been making up the numbers, and her sparkly, protective mask gimmick was a complete afterthought for WWE's creative team too. They blatantly didn't really care about that one, and it was quietly dropped.
Roll on next year.
8. Braun Strowman
This one was almost a joint effort between Braun and Shane McMahon.
Their WrestleMania season feud was a reminder of what happens when WWE suddenly decides to spice things up with unwanted character lore. Did anybody really need to know (or care to know) that Strowman was a bit of a thicko at school, for example?
Also, what was up with WWE pretending that Braun was bullied during his youth? That didn't fit his unstoppable wrecking ball presentation, and it actually made him sound like a put-upon whiner after years of using his own physical size to dominate.
None of Strowman's matches, from the boring bout with Elias at Fastlane to McMahon at 'Mania and a WWE Title tilt, satisfied. Before being released in June, big Braun was going through the motions big time. The company had also clearly been running out of solid ideas for the 'Monster Among Men' since his hasty Universal Title push ended.
7. The Miz
Yes, Mr. Dancing With The Stars is here. No, it doesn't feel great to include somebody as talented as The Miz on a list of the year's worst, but...his 2021 was a bit sh*t. There's no getting away from it - it was, and it's amazing that he managed to bag a brief reign as WWE Champion again during such a second-rate year.
Try and wrap your head round this: Miz helped carry Bad Bunny to a watchable tag at 'Mania 37, and held the WWE Title. Those positives were totally destroyed by that zombie garbage at WrestleMania Backlash, his wheelchair stint that included endless "drip stick" nonsense, and pretty much everything else.
Granted, Miz was absent for a few months here or there, but he weirdly sucked energy from Raw whenever he was around by leaning on goofy comedy or having bang average matches. Maybe this emerging feud with Edge will rekindle his fortunes.
Mr. Miz badly needs that.
6. Elias
Hello, he is Elias and he is doing bugger all of note.
WWE's resident music man had been a utility player for years. That's why he suddenly re-assumed the henchman role for Shane O-Mac during McMahon's feud with Braun Strowman, and it's why he was tasked with getting ex-Forgotten Son Jaxson Ryker over in a going-nowhere tag.
Honestly, some of the matches those lads had with RK-Bro and New Day showed they had zero value as a team; if duos can't have good bouts with those squads, then they're f*cked. Once WWE had lost interest in the experiment, they had Elias split from Ryker and feuded them briefly before attempting to repackage Eli.
He's been largely absent since then, and that's why some may think it's harsh popping him on here. Nah! Elias was awful for a good seven months of the year before disappearing from screens. That's long enough to bag a place amongst the worst of 2021.
5. Jinder Mahal/Shanky
What happened to Jinder Mahal? Imagine being WWE Champion in 2017 and then dying a slow, agonising four year death as an act until finally topping it off with some rap in 2021. That's been Jinder's fate - his biggest moment, an angle with former running buddy Drew McIntyre, didn't even reference their shared history in 3MB.
Crazy.
There was next-to-no point in feuding the pair if their past wasn't going to be properly explored. Instead, WWE had Mahal hide behind the towering Shanky and Veer for a spell, then lose in less than five minutes at SummerSlam. His entire return has been a miserable failure, and it hasn't even helped others.
Shanky looks like a tool by acting like WWE's latest giant idiot, and Veer has moved on to something else that already seems to be fizzling out before it even gets started. Christ, Jinder used to be a serious heel! Those days are over.
4. Happy Corbin/Madcap Moss
Early signs for Baron Corbin's change from 'King' to jackpot-winning lucky git were promising. His first few promos as Happy Corbin had a bit of spark, and the guy genuinely seemed to be enjoying the chance to finally move away from playing faux-royalty.
Then, Madcap Moss came along and erm...yeah.
Now, here's the truth: Happy and Madcap are supposed to be a double helping of cringe. Moss' jokes are meant to annoy fans and put heat on the team, but the pair's 'Happy Talk' segments are too long and never have much direction. Lately, they've been feuding with Drew McIntyre and Jeff Hardy for some reason.
None of it appears to be going anywhere, and that's just sad. It's not cool that there's eye-rolling aplenty whenever these dudes show up, but not because fans enjoy hating them. They're quickly developing the worst kind of heat - that "go away" heat.
3. Reggie
Did you know: Reggie can do plenty of flips and used to be involved with Cirque du Soleil. No? Well, you must've been skimming through episodes of Raw and missed the fact that WWE mentioned this every bloody week for months on end. Seriously, being acrobatic is the guy's only notable trait.
He went from backing up Carmella to falling for Nia Jax, and literally just got done dominating the peripheral 24/7 Title division from July-November. WWE might not want to admit this, but nobody really cared about his escape-artist routines opposite R-Truth, Akira Tozawa and a whole host of other undercard workers.
They were interminable.
The longest-reigning 24/7 Champ (112 days uninterrupted) has been phased out lately. This mercy-killing is a blessing for Raw, but it could only be a matter of time before Reg shows back up as a manager or ends Dana Brooke's own joke title reign.
2. Nia Jax
You had to know she'd be included.
Nia Jax was Shayna Baszler's tag-team partner for far too long (the pair teamed up between August 2020-September 2021), and that union held the 'Queen Of Spades' back terribly. Worse, Nia's singles efforts against everyone from Alexa Bliss and Rhea Ripley to Charlotte Flair were either awkward or sloppy.
The 30 August Raw match with Charlotte, in particular, was a complete mess. That'd end up being one of Jax' final performances for WWE - the company released her in November mid-sabbatical. Fingers crossed Nia's mental health is on the mend (that was the reported reason for her break), but there's no getting away from the fact that her in-work was often poor.
2021 was yet another year of reckless-looking spots and sequences for the former Raw Women's Champion, and you'd have to go some to find many fans who consistently enjoyed her matches. Nia, however, wasn't this year's worst WWE worker...
1. Eva Marie
...SURPRISE! Or, y'know, not.
Eva Marie returned to WWE screens via vignettes in May 2021. Eventually, she made her in-person debut (for this second stint, at least) on the 14 June Raw and was immediately aligned with Doudrop. That team was never built to last, and the alliance had abruptly ended by SummerSlam.
On that pay-per-view, Marie lost to Alexa Bliss in a three-four minute stall-fest that somehow felt like it lasted three hours. Being brutally honest, whether she was in there with Doudrop, Bliss, Asuka, Naomi or anybody else accomplished, Eva always looked out her depth as a worker. She's never really had the fundamentals down, and even looked difficult to carry.
It's hard to name even one Marie match that was even slightly entertaining too. She's never had it as a pro wrestler, and probably never will. Has there ever been a less-skilled worker with this much spotlight before?
Which other WWE stars had a dreadful 2021? For more wrestling, check out WWE 2K22: 10 Things 2K Must Get Right and 10 Things We Learned From Jeff Hardy On Stone Cold’s Broken Skull Podcast!