10 Worst WWE Wrestlers Of 2021 (So Far)
The second half of 2021 needs to be better for these struggling WWE stars.
Everybody has their favourites.
Defending those faves against criticism comes easy when you love them, and there's nothing wrong with that. Wishing only the best for hard-working pro wrestlers isn't a bad thing, but good-hearted excuses only go so far. Being brutally honest, every single star on this list belongs here because they've had a largely awful first half of 2021.
So, who's to blame? WWE creative normally takes the brunt of it, and deservedly. The way those writers sling sh*t at the nearest wall or (worse) rely on some of the worst comedic material of all the times can be painful to watch, and it has done next to nothing for anyone involved.
Straight up though, some of your favourites have to shoulder a portion of responsibility, and they are going to pop up - it's unavoidable, but they're not here due to some mean-spirited attack. Nah, they're on a 'worst of' collection 'cause they're struggling badly on WWE's biggest TV shows, and it doesn't look like things will get better any time soon.
WWE's 2021 has had some big moments. For every memorable WrestleMania 37 showcase, Roman Reigns-led brilliance on SmackDown and Edge Royal Rumble win, there's been some serious nonsense to offset it...
10. Rhea Ripley
What the hell, man?!
That could very well be your immediate reaction upon seeing Rhea Ripley kick this misery parade off. After all, she's the reigning Raw Women's Champion and was absolutely superb for the bulk of her NXT run. "Was". Since jumping up to Monday nights, poor Rhea has been rethought as a childish annoyance.
One minute, she's literally thumbing her nose at Charlotte Flair. The next, she's barking and bolstering claims from those who believe that Vince McMahon doesn't get the grittier (by comparison) presentation that created cult-like loyalty at Full Sail University for years.
2021 hasn't been kind to Ripley despite her title win then.
The fact that one of WWE's only selling points for Rhea is to shout, "JUST 24 YEARS OLD" on entrance graphics says it all. Christ knows what they'll do once 11 October hits and Ripley turns 25. No, it's not a good sign that this is a main discussion point for her year.
9. Shayna Baszler
At least Rhea hasn't been demoted to teaming with Nia Jax or been simultaneously disgusted by and terrified of "stupid dolls". Shayna Baszler is another ex-NXT bad ass who has been reduced to a weekly joke by WWE's topsy turvy "we make movies" booking style.
A genuine ass-kicker has lost almost all of her aura, and that's sad.
Baszler had cracking matches aplenty during her NXT run, and she was always presented as a legitimately dangerous MMA fighter who could snap opponents like twigs. On Raw in 2021, the only thing snapping might be Shayna's sanity - she cannot be having a laugh when she's chewing out inanimate toys or pretending to be scared of Alexa Bliss.
Teaming with Jax has been a slog for Baszler as well, and that has only accelerated this year. One must question why they're still together outside the Women's Tag-Team Title picture anyway. Also, the less said about "Reggie", the better.
8. Nia Jax
Sadly, more Reginald chat is unavoidable.
The wine-serving hanger-on traded Carmella for giving Nia Jax the eye, and that led to perhaps the least-wanted WWE romance in a good while. Seeing Jax take her new man clothes shopping, or watching her defend him when he's costing her and Baszler matches, is arduous stuff.
No, Nia hasn't injured anyone like she seemed to do on the regular last year, but that doesn't mean her in-ring work has vastly improved. If anything, Jax appears to be going through the motions whenever she wrestles on Raw these days. There's just no good reason to sit through her matches or care about anything she does.
Nia has been squeezing the life out of her tag partner for well over a year now, and there doesn't appear to be any end in sight to that booking either. Jax remains one of the worst parts of a women's scene that desperately needs a rethink.
7. Baron Corbin
The then-'King' Corbin was in a Gauntlet bout to establish a new Universal Title challenger at the turn of the year. Since then, it's been all downhill for the former royal - he's even lost his crown to new 'King' Shinsuke Nakamura, and WWE seem content to pretend that Corbin is now totally broken.
It's been a rough six months.
Some fans may not dig it, but this fall from grace angle is the first time WWE has tried to do something interesting with Baron in 2021. It might not save his year. Feuds with Rey and Dominik Mysterio, an excursion over to Raw (for a heavily-promoted match opposite Drew McIntyre) and the current run with "Kingsuke" have all fallen a little flat.
Corbin is at his best when he has somebody like Roman Reigns to bounce off of. He's nowhere near as awful as some might claim, but arguing that is getting harder and harder the longer this spell of mediocre matches rolls on.
6. The Miz
Firstly, The Miz (and John Morrison) deserve a lot of praise for expertly guiding Bad Bunny through a surprisingly excellent tag showing at WrestleMania 37. The pressure was on there, and everybody pulled together to make sure the match was worthwhile.
What else has Miz done to equal or top that in 2021? Nothing.
The veteran even captured another WWE Title after cashing in Money In The Bank, but nobody really cared because he was blatantly only in that spot so Bobby Lashley could beat somebody not named Drew McIntyre and extend their feud. In other words, Mr. Miz was glorified collateral and third-wheeling to the extreme.
That inspired Bunny bout was the exception, not the rule. The Miz featured in one of 2021's worst matches; WWE's zombie nonsense at WrestleMania Backlash' killed any hopes of a follow-up cracker with Damian Priest, for example. Also, the "comedy spots" he's doing right now, including being wheelchair-bound and squirting water, are seriously tedious.
5. Bayley
Bayley's inclusion might be another shocker for some.
2020 belonged to Bayley. She ruled SmackDown as Women's Champion for most of the year, and her friendship-turned-sour story with Sasha Banks was one of the best angles WWE put on. In fact, one would go so far as to say that Bayley and Sasha carried the product on their backs at times during those early Performance Center tapings.
In 2021... not so much. WWE ditched serious Bayley and decided to go all wacky - she adopted a zany TV host persona, debuted her woeful 'Ding Dong, Hello' chat segment in January and then embarked on a quest to prove that Bianca Belair is overrated by laughing. Yes, laughing. Then laughing some more.
Bayley and Belair are currently poised to wrestle their third pay-per-view clash in succession at Money in the Bank. It's rather damning that they're treading water despite working inside Hell In A Cell and setting up other stipulation bouts like the forthcoming "I Quit" match.
4. Carmella
Spare a thought for poor old 'Mella.
Last October, Carmella was reborn as an "Untouchable" villainess who promised to rule the SmackDown women's division and look good doing it. She was a Diva throwback with promise, and all looked rosy for her. Then, WWE lost interest and 'Mella's push totally stalled.
Put it this way: Carmella went from challenging Sasha Banks for the top prizes at Royal Rumble to teaming with Billy Kay as an "odd couple" duo at WrestleMania 37. Since then, she has been used sparingly and started trading wins and losses with Liv Morgan. That's not a great spot for somebody with ambition.
WWE's general lack of interest has rubbed off on Carmella's ring performances too. She was dynamic and invested heading into the Rumble showdown with Sasha, but recent bouts with Morgan, Bianca Belair and Ruby Riott have been uninspired and rather lifeless.
Things do not look great now that Eva Marie is on telly doing the old Diva bit herself.
3. Jeff Hardy
It's rather sad to report that the once-exciting daredevil vibes of Jeff Hardy have evaporated. In their place stands a midcard legend who can barely buy a win - is this really how Hardy wants to do things for the rest of his active career? Sure, he'll be making good money, but come on.
He can offer way more than this.
This year, Jeff has done jobs for AJ Styles, Sheamus, The Miz, Jinder Mahal, Mustafa Ali, John Morrison and Veer (see the latest Main Event for that) on TV. In addition, his mini-feud with Cedric Alexander spewed up the old retirement chestnut for no good reason, and it didn't actually lead to anything of note.
There's a marked difference between enhancing younger talents by putting them over in proper, fleshed-out feuds and doing random jobs on Raw for the sake of it. Sadly, that's all WWE has in mind for Hardy at the moment, and it sucks.
2. Elias
Who wants to walk with Elias? Nobody. Jog on, pal.
Jaxson Ryker was nearly here instead, but it's still early days for his singles run. Meanwhile, Elias has been knocking around for years without any sign of upwards mobility. He's been heel, he's been babyface, he's been heel, he's been babyface - you get the picture, and Elias is now heel again.
Elias' pre-match singsong interruption spots are terribly played out, his matches are average at best and WWE never seem sure what to do with him. Teaming the guy with Ryker reeked of sheer hope from the creative team that they'd make something good of the gig. When they didn't, Jax and Eli split for an undercard feud few give a rat's ass about.
Raw's resident songsmith was once somebody who seemed like a main eventer in waiting. Now, rather than mixing it with guys like John Cena and The Undertaker, Elias is fumbling around and failing to convince as a lower-card baddie.
1. Mace/T-Bar
Yuck.
This is a joint effort between ex-RETRIBUTION members Mace and T-Bar. Together, the artists formerly known as Dominik Dijakovic and Dio Maddin have sucked wind as a tag team on Monday nights since re-debuting (still with their faction gimmicks) on the 12 April episode.
WWE tried unmasking the pair, but weirdly decided to keep their RETRIBUTION names and outfits largely intact. To date, matches against everyone from Drew McIntyre, Braun Strowman and Lucha House Party have been unconvincing, and it must've been troublesome to the pair that they were jobbing in handicap efforts anyway.
They're going nowhere fast.
How long will WWE keep this pain train on the tracks before cutting their losses and either reverting T-Bar back to Dijakovic on NXT or trying something fresh with them as singles on Raw and SmackDown? This post-Retribution run is almost worse than being in that crappy faction was, which is unthinkable.
For more WWE, check out 10 Things We Learned From Mick Foley On Stone Cold’s Broken Skull Sessions Podcast and 18 Things You Probably Missed From WWE SmackDown (July 2)!