10 WrestleMania Matches That Surpassed All Expectations

The times the fans got it wrong.

AJ Styles Shane McMahon
WWE.com

There's been plenty written over the years about the WrestleMania matches that failed to live up to their billing. If you've spent even five minutes reading about WWE history, then you know that Brock Lesnar and Goldberg went out on a whimper in 2004, and that Triple H and Randy Orton stunk the whole place up five years later.

But comparatively little is said about the matches that surpassed pre-show expectations; the ones that fans went into fearing the worst (or, at the very least, skeptical that things would work out on the night) only to be surprised by show-stealing performances they never in a million years saw coming.

To be fair, in a lot of cases, you can't really blame the fans for moderating their expectations in the run-up to the show. Many of the WrestleMania matches that have gone into the surprisingly good category have featured non (or sporadic) wrestlers, who have a somewhat sketchy reputation, like Mr T and Nicole 'Snooki' Polizzi.

On those few occasions that they have managed to leave us eating humble pie, however, we have to take our hat off and pat them on the back...

10. Big Show Vs. Floyd Mayweather (WrestleMania XXIV)

Floyd Mayweather
WWE.com

At best, fans viewed Floyd Mayweather's WrestleMania excursion against Big Show in 2008 as a necessary evil. If this is what it takes to get some mainstream eyes on the product, they thought, then so be it - let's just make it as brief and painless as possible.

For our money, WWE delivered on both those counts. At just over 10 minutes, this one was short enough that it didn't encroach on the ring time afforded to more interesting matches later on in the show (namely Undertaker against Edge in the main event).

As for its quality, it was actually a lot of fun. In the build-up, Mayweather was written off by some as a primadonna, but he wasn't afraid to take one or two bumps on the night itself, playing his role as an arrogant, in-over-his-head wrestling rookie to a tee.

Sure, it was never going to win any Wrestling Observer awards, but compared to the company's previous interdisciplinary efforts - Mr T versus Roddy Piper at WrestleMania II comes to mind - this one wasn't nearly as bad as it could have been.


9. Brock Lesnar Vs. Roman Reigns (WrestleMania 31)

Seth Rollins WrestleMania 31
WWE.com

If there's reason to be excited about WrestleMania 34's (presumed) go-home encounter, then this is it. Brock Lesnar and Roman Reigns have already contested a brilliant match on the Grandest Stage of Them All, and it came just three years ago in Santa Clara.

Of course, it should be conceded that much of what made this one such a thrilling spectacle was the fact that it was gate-crashed by a briefcase-wielding Seth Rollins at the death. His arrival saved what might otherwise have been a predictable finish.

But, even before then, this wasn't exactly going badly. Lesnar and The Big Dog were actually showing signs of chemistry in the ring, which many in the build-up were skeptical of, given how difficult the task of matching up two power-merchants can sometimes be.

For that, plus Seth's cash-in, WrestleMania 31's headline match has to go down as one that left the critics eating humble pie. Nearly everyone in the arena was getting ready to boo its finish, but they ended up leaving the stadium in high spirits.

Good job, gang.


8. Razor Ramon Vs. Shawn Michaels (WrestleMania X)

Razor Shawn WrestleMania X
WWE

While few fans went into WrestleManaia X expecting to see a bad match between Razor Ramon and Shawn Michaels - two of the best workers of mid-'90s WWE - the bout's third party was, at the time, an enormous unknown quantity.

In the record books, this was the second ladder match in WWE history, although for all intents and purposes it was essentially the first (the actual first, contested by HBK and Bret Hart, was filmed but released only on home video). In other words, few really knew what to expect. It sounded interesting, sure, but many other harebrained wrestling experiments have sounded interesting, only to be exposed as ridiculously convoluted the very second they are put into practice for real.

Given all of that, you have to give buckets of credit to the two men involved. Not only did they share the best match of the night (which is no small feat, given that Owen versus Bret was on the undercard), they even managed a rare five-star rating from Dave Meltzer - the first ever awarded to a WWF/E match.

And they weren't even wrestling in the Tokyo Dome.


7. Stone Cold Vs. The Rock (WrestleMania XIX)

Rock Austin WrestleMania XIX
WWE

Stone Cold Steve Austin, The Rock and low expectations don't normally go hand-in-hand, and - let's be very clear - there weren't many fans who piled into the Safeco Field for WrestleMania XIX anticipating a poor spectacle.

But there was good reason to suppose this one might fail to live up to the standard set by their previous encounters, the most obvious of them being that Austin, owing to a persistent neck injury, was clearly on his last legs as a performer.

Even if we weren't entirely clear on the fact that this would be the very last match he ever fought, it had been a long time since he had really put in a show-stealing performance (in terms of singles competition, you probably had to go back to his clash with Kurt Angle at SummerSlam '01).

Throw in the fact that The Rock was imminently set to depart to Hollywood full-time, and this one could - in a parallel universe - have ended up falling ever-so-slightly flat. But, thankfully, both of them dug super deep, and produced a match worthy of gracing any stage in the world.


6. Brock Lesnar Vs. Goldberg (WrestleMania 33)

Brock Lesnar Goldberg
WWE

Fans this time last year were skeptical about Brock Lesnar versus Goldberg, with good reason: the one other time these two had fought at WrestleMania - way back in 2004 - they conspired to put on one of the most lacklustre matches in the event's thirty-three year history.

The follow-up bout they shared at Survivor Series 2016, clocking in at just 86 seconds, was a big improvement - at least in terms of drama and reception - but there was still little evidence that they had any real chemistry in the ring (or that Goldberg, at 50, could still 'go' at all).

These fears, however, were laid firmly to rest on the night itself. Not only did the duo succeed in blowing their previous effort out of the water, they even managed to better the show's other world title match between Randy Orton and Bray Wyatt - which, on paper, looked far more promising.

That's pretty good going for a spectacle that lasted fewer than five minutes. For the cynics out there, it was undeniable proof that you don't have to be a master of 10,000 holds to get an arena full of die-hards on its feet.


5. Hulk Hogan Vs. Vince McMahon (WrestleMania XIX)

Hulk Hogan Vince McMahon
WWE

Let's be honest, the build-up to Hulk Hogan against Vince McMahon at WrestleMania XIX wasn't exactly promising. In one promo, The Hulkster very nearly described himself as the "right gay in the right place at the wrong time".

Plus, look at how old these two were. Hogan was 49, many of his recent matches having been contested at a snail's pace, while Vince - a non-wrestler (albeit one with improbably large biceps) - was pushing 60. How much of a "Street Fight" was this really going to be?

Oh, how little faith we had in the chairman of the board. On the night, he proved that he could walk the walk as well as talk the talk, taking his body to places nobody thought possible in what turned out to be the most violent encounter of the entire show.

At 20 minutes, one could argue that the bout was a touch on the long side, but on only a couple of occasions did you really feel its length. Interferences from Roddy Piper and Vince's own personal referee ensured that there was plenty to hold your gaze, and that this mismatch was at least halfway believable.


4. Vince McMahon Vs. Shane McMahon (WrestleMania X-Seven)

Vince Shane McMahon WrestleMania X-Seven
WWE.com

What a huge feather in the cap of Vince McMahon it must be to have shared not just one, but three, reasonably good matches on the Grandest Stage of Them All (you imagine he brings that up over Thanksgiving dinner at least once a year).

The first of them, two years before he tussled with Hogan, came against his own flesh and blood at WrestleMania X-Seven, at which he fought son Shane McMahon - the heir apparent to his WWE kingdom - in a pulsating Street Fight.

What made this one great was how much of an exercise in catharsis it appeared to be. Not only did Shane, the same week he acquired WCW, manage to get another one over on his dad, even a previously catatonic Linda got in on the act by nailing him with a timely low blow.

Everything you could ask of a for-the-ages WrestleMania spectacle was there: melodrama, crazy spots, buckets of blood. It even ended with the youngster going over the veteran, even if it was the chairman who ended up getting the last laugh with victory in the subsequent Invasion angle.


3. Edge Vs. Mick Foley (WrestleMania 22)

edge mick foley
WWE.com

In the run-up to WrestleMania 22, two of the event's mooted encounters stood out as potential match of the night candidates: Triple H versus John Cena for the WWE Championship, and the triple threat World Heavyweight Title clash involving Rey Mysterio, Kurt Angle and Randy Orton.

And yet neither of those came away with the mantle. Instead, of was Edge versus Mick Foley - a bout that went on fourth - that ended up stealing the occasion, despite its featuring a part-timer who had barely competed in the previous five years.

This wasn't a complete surprise, to be fair: Foley, under the guise of Cactus Jack, had managed something similar alongside Randy Orton a couple of years earlier at Backlash - but that was then, and this was now.

You couldn't guarantee a repeat.

Besides which, the extremities they went to in this one were something nobody could really have anticipated. At one point, Edge speared his opponent through a flaming table (it's almost as though they were trying to whet our appetite for an ECW revival later on in the year).


2. Shawn Michaels Vs. Vince McMahon (WrestleMania 22)

Shawn Michaels Vince McMahon WrestleMania 22
WWE.com

The third and final time that Vince McMahon defied the odds on the Grandest Stage of Them All came in 2006, a match that he fought at the ripe old age of 60-years-old (his action figure-like biceps still no less impressive).

Like his previous two encounters, this one was less an exhibition in technical wrestling than it was an old-fashioned slobber-knocker, both men - having ostensibly hated each other for years (Bret Hart might have had something to say about that) - determined that their opponent would end the night in hospital.

Given that Vince had already performed this trick twice before, you might be tempted to conclude that expectations weren't surpassed here, but merely met. However, that ignores that this one was the best of his three 'Mania matches, taking things up another level from bouts one and two.

In truth, the WWE chairman has never looked better than when he was sharing the ring with Shawn Michaels, and considering that many went into this event irked at the fact that the Showstopper wasn't placed higher up the card, many were left eating their words.


1. AJ Styles Vs. Shane McMahon (WrestleMania 33)

AJ Styles Shane McMahon
WWE.com

The second WrestleMania 33 match to silence the critics was AJ Styles' clash with Shane McMahon, a bout that - in the build-up to the event - had been dismissed by many as a complete waste of the Phenomenal One's talents.

This assessment may well have been true. After all, if AJ was able to put on a match this good with a middle-aged part-timer, imagine what he could have produced in the ring with someone like Seth Rollins, or (since he wasn't injured after all) Daniel Bryan.

Overlooking the performance of the SmackDown Live commissioner seems kind of harsh, though. If you had never seen a WWE show before, you could have easily mistaken him for a full-time member of the roster. The guy did a freaking shooting star splash, for God's sake.

For many, this was the night's show-stealing encounter: one that helped get the Camping World Stadium on its feet ahead of the many disappointments to come later on in the show. Nobody really saw that coming, and huge credit must go to both men (along with whomever decided to throw them together).


Contributor